rd MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF · 4 Agenda Item No. 53. 1 (a) Confirmation of the Minutes of the 52nd Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 19th February, 2014

1

MINUTES OF THE 53rd MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF

HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 17th DECEMBER, 2014 AT NEW DELHI.

Present

1. Dr.Ramjee Singh - President

2. Dr.Arun Bhasme - Vice-President

3. Dr.Prasobh Kumar K.C. - Member

4. Dr.Manilal S. - ”

5. Dr.G.Nirmal - ”

6. Dr.M.K.Sahani - ”

7. Dr.Kulwant Singh - ”

8. Dr.Narayan Debnath - ”

9. Dr.A.P.Verma - ”

10. Dr. Vinod Kumar - ”

11. Dr. N.Srinivasa Rao - ”

12. Dr.Ramesh Chandra Dogra - ”

13. Dr.Pankaj Kumar Sharma - ”

14. Dr.Birendra Bahadur Singh - ”

15. Dr.M.R.Srivatsan - ”

16. Dr.N.Radha - ”

17. Dr.K.K.Juneja - ”

18. Dr.Shyamal Kumar Mukherjee- ”

19. Dr.Rakesh Singh - ”

20. Dr.S.K.Nanda - ”

21. Dr.R.K.Manchanda - ”

22. Dr.A.K.Seth - ”

23. Dr.S.M.Singh - ”

24. Dr.A.L.Patil - ”

25. Dr.S.M.Desarda - ”

26. Dr.Ravi M.Nair - ”

27. Dr.L.K.Nanda - ”

28. Dr.Dias Dominic Savio - ”

29. Dr.Chandan Kumar Das - ”

30. Dr.(Mrs.) K.S.Desarda - ”

31. Dr.V.R.Kawishwar - ”

32. Dr.Bhosale R.N. - ”

33. Dr. Tejinder Pal Singh - ”

34. Dr.Mohammad Zakharia - ”

35. Dr.(Mrs.)Ayesha Ali - ”

36. Dr.Girish S.Patel - ”

37. Dr.Pawan H.Dongre - ”

38. Dr.Ghanshyam D.Raval - ”

39. Dr.Pinakin N.Trivedi - ”

40. Dr.P.K.Satapathy - ”

2

41. Dr.Parul J.Patel - ”

42. Dr.G.Kannan - ”

43. Dr.B.T.Rudresh - ”

44. Dr.Mrinal Kanti Sarkar - ”

45. Dr.Bhakt Vatsal - ”

46. Dr.Vinod Kumar Vimal - ”

47. Dr.K.L.Babu - ”

48. Dr.Rajat Chattopadhyay - ”

49. Dr.Bilab Kumar Kundu - ”

50. Dr.Rajesh Sharma - ”

Dr.Lalit Verma - Secretary

Not Present

1. Dr.G.P.Hahnemann - Member

2. Dr.Teli Hotu Comdir - ”

The Central Council received Shri Shripad Yesso Naik, Minister of State, (I/C),, Ministry of

AYUSH, Govt. of India and Shri Nilanjan Sanyal, Secretary, Ministry of AYUSH, Govt. of

India . Both the dignitaries offered their respects to Dr.Samul Hahnemman, Founder of

Homoeopathy by placing garlands on his Statue Shri Sanyal, Secretary called upon the Council

to review its work through failures and achievements of the 40 years of its constitution and also

assured to extend his co-operation to the Council in looking into introduction of P.G.Courses in

remaining (UG) subjects and also in respect of other administrative pending matters. The

Hon’ble Minister of State Shri Naik, congtrulated the members and officials of the Council on

completion of 40 years of the constitution of the Council and also recalled the responsibilities on

all concerned due Department of AYUSH being declared as a Ministry and he sought co-

operation from the Council in achieving the required standards of education and practice during

his tenure. Hon’ble Minister assured the President, Vice-President and members that he will call

for a meeting of all concerned in the Ministry to discuss the pending matters listed in the letter

handed over to him by the President C.C.H..

The President and Vice-President extended a warm welcome to both the dignitaries i.e. the

Hon’ble Minister of State and Secretary in Ministry of AYUSH.

After the Hon’ble Minister and Secretary, Ministry of AYUSH left the auditorium, the meeting

of Central Councils started.

Dr.A.K.Seth, Member also left the meeting at this stage.

3

All the Officers and staff were present when the Hon’ble Minister and Secretary, Ministry of

AYUSH were there. However, later on to assist the Secretary, Inspector, Asstt.Secretaries,

Office Supdtds. and a few other staff of the Council remain present throughout the meeting.

The Secretary introduced the newly elected members namely, Dr.K.L.Babu, Dr.G.Kannan,

Dr.Vinod Kumar Vimal, Dr.Rajat Chattopadhyay, Dr.Rakesh Singh, Dr.Biplab Kumar Kundu,

Dr.Shyamal Mukerjee, Dr.Bhakt Vatsal, Dr. Virender Bahadur Singh and Dr. Rajesh Sharma.

He also informed that Dr.A.P.Verma has been re-elected as a member. All the new members

were greeted by the Council.

The Secretary further informed that Dr.N.V.Sugathan, Dr.P.C.Dave, Dr.Naresh Arora, Dr.Saidul

Islam and Dr.Ramakrishna Ghosh Mondal have ceased to be the members. The Council put on

record the appreciation in respect of their contributions.

The Secretary also informed that the Central Govt. has cancelled the election in the State of

Gujarat in which Dr.J.K.Patel and Dr.Bharolia Jadvjibhai Muljibhai were declared elected as

such their membership was over. However, Dr.J.K.Patel has moved to the High Court, Delhi

wherein he was allowed to caste his vote in the elections of President and Vice-President. The

Office of the Council has requested the Ministry for a clarification about continuation of

membership of Dr.Amiya Goswami but no reply has yet been received, therefore, the meeting

notice has not been issued to him. The Ministry has also issued notification which show

ceasation of membership of Dr.Amiya Goswami who also filed a petition in High Court of Delhi

wherein he was allowed to caste his vote in the elections of President and Vice-President. The

Office of the Council has requested the Ministry for a clarification about continuation of

membership of Dr.J.K.Patel but no reply has yet been received, therefore, the meeting notice has

not been issued to him. Dr.Jose Issac has been a member under an order of Hon’ble High Court

of Kerala at Ernakulum and this Council has received no communication either from the High

Court or from the Govt. in respect of Dr.Jose Issac but in a meeting with the Director (who was

the Returning Officer in the election fo President and Vice-President) the matter was discussed

and he hinted that Dr.Jose Issac has been substituted with Dr.K.L.Babu as all the College are

under Kerala University of Health Sciences. However, when the office of the Council requested

the Ministry to confirm about the membership continuity of Dr.Jose Issac no reply has been

received and for that reason meeting notice was not issued to Dr.Jose Issac. Dr.Jose Issac has

filed a new case in said High Court at Ernakulam.

The Secretary informed the Council about the message of Dr.G.P.Hahnemann that being unwell

he would not be to able to attend the meeting.

The Council took up the Agenda item wise.

4

Agenda Item No. 53. 1

(a) Confirmation of the Minutes of the 52nd

Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held

on 19th

February, 2014 at New Delhi.

(b) Corrigendum to the Minutes of the 52nd

meeting of Central Council of

Homoeopathy held on 19th

February, 2014 at New Delhi.

The Central Council confirmed the minutes including the Corrigendum as circulated.

Agenda Item No. 53.2

Action taken in respect of the Minutes of the 52th Meeting of the Central Council of

Homoeopathy held on 19th February, 2014 at New Delhi.

The Central Council noted Action Taken Report in respect of decisions contained in the minutes

of its last meeting held on 19.2.2014.


Draft Annual Report of Central Council of Homoeopathy for the year 2013-14.

The Central Council approved the Annual Report.

Agenda item No. 53.4

Annual Accounts of the Central Council---Audit report of DGACR for the year 2013-

2014.

The Central Council taken a note of Audit Report/Certificate of DGACR in respect of 2013-14,

and approved the reply furnished by the office.


Consideration of RE for the year 2014-15 and BE for the year 2015-16 respectively under

Plan & Non – Plan.

The Central Council agreed with the Revised Estimates and Budget Estimates under Plan and

Non-Plan for the years 2014-15 and 2015-16 respectively.

5


Ministry’s letter No.V.27021/10/94/HD(Pt.)-CCH dated October, 2013 regarding

recognition of GPF. Scheme of CCH in the Schedule of Provider Fund Act, 1925-reg.

The Central Council noted the notification dated 8.10.2014 of Ministry of Finance, Govt. of

India regarding applicability of provisions of Provident Funds Act, 1925 (except Section 6A) to

the Provident Fund established for the benefit of the employees of Central Council of

Homoeopathy.


Amendments to Homoeopathy Central Council Act, 1973.

The Central Council discussed the matter at length and by majority it ratified the decision of the

Executive Committee. Note of Dr. R. K. Manchanda, Member is enclosed in this matter.


Ministry’s letter No.A.11019/25/2014-EC/CCIM Election dated 23.6.2014 regarding

minutes of meeting held on 16.6.2014 (in Ministry) to simplify the process of C.C.H.

elections.

The Central Council considered the matter at length and it decided that the existing system of

election may continue without any amendment in Election Rules.


(a) Ministry’s letter no. R13040/93/2014-HD(Tech) dated 11th September, 2014 regarding

Protection of Fundamental Rights, Article-21 of Indian Constitution (protection of life and

Personal Liberty) by concealing of Homoeo. Medicine name by Homoeo. Practitioners.

(b) Grievance dated 31, July, 2012 received from Ms. Prini, Maharshtra regarding

Transparency, accountability and responsibility in Homoeopathic doctors profession.

The Central Council discussed the matter and decided that a registered Homoeopathic

practitioners shall provide the prescription to the patients atleast if demanded by the patient or by

close relatives of the patient. An amendment to said effect is required in Code of Ethics

Regulations.

6


Ministry’s letter No.R.14013/9/2014-HD (Tech.) dated 31.03.2014 regarding amendments to

Homoeopathy (P.G. Degree Course) Regulations, 1989.

The Central Council discussed the matter at length and it ratified the decisions of its Executive

Committee.


Amendment to Degree Course Regulations.

The Central Council had long discussions in the matter. Some members opined to have one

paper of theory only in examination in Pharmacy subject, and to have maximum 13 years as the

permissible duration of the course.

It was decided that the office will write to Medical Council of India and Central Council of

Indian Medicine to know whether these councils have prescribed any maximum duration of

Degree Courses coming within their respective domain; and further the President assured that

he will discuss with concerned authority in the Ministry as to whether said minor changes

can be done at this late stage in the already submitted amendments or not. With the said

discussions, the amendments were approved.


(a) Ministry’s letter No.R.13040/124/2013- HE (Tech.) dated 9th June,2014 regarding

HCC (MSR) Regulations, 2013.

(b) Ministry’s letter No. R-13040/10/2011-HD(Tech) dated 25.07.2014 regarding

implementation of provisions of Homoeopathy Central Council (MSR) Regulations,

2013.

The Central Council discussed the matter at length and it decided that in sub-regulation (2) of

regulation 3 of HCC (MSR) Regulations if a College is having all required facilities in its

attached Homoeopathic Hospital including operation theatre and labor room and facilities for all

types of patients including the post operative cases then such a college need not be forced to

again execute MoU with a hospital of Modern Medicine additionally and subject to this the

amendments proposed so far by the Education Committee have been agreed to.

7


Amendments proposed in Homoeopathy Central Council (Inspectors and Visitors)

Regulation, 1982.

The Central Council agreed with the recommendation of the Sub-Committee (constituted by the

Executive Committee) for amendments proposed in Inspectors and Visitors Regulations and the

same may be forwarded to Ministry for sanction.

However, regarding taking disciplinary action or putting penalty against an Inspector or a Visitor

as proposed, MCI and CCIM may be requested as how whether these Council deal with such

situation and whether they have prescribed any disciplinary action/penalty.


Requests received under Section 12 A of HCC Act for Higher Courses.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken on the various request for starting new/higher

courses. In cases from where required information has not come the same may be brought to the

notice of Central Govt.


Requests received under Section 12 A of HCC Act for increase in intake capacity.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken on the various requests for increase in the

intake capacity. In cases from where required information has not come the same may be

brought to the notice of Central Govt.


Requests received under Section 12 A of HCC Act for opening of New Homoeopathic

Medical Colleges.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken on the various requests for new college. In

cases from where required information has not come the same may be brought to the notice of

Central Govt.

8


The Proforma for Reporting of Inspection to be carried out in view of references received

from Ministry under Section 13(2) of HCC Act, 1973.

The Central Council approved the revised proforma for submission of report of inspection which

is enclosed.


Approval of P.G Examiners for M.D (Hom.) Courses in respect of different Universities.

The Central Council considered letter dated 26.11.2014 of Dr.L.K.Nanda, Member and decided

to allow the request of the Principal of A.C.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bhubneshwar for

engaging Guides in respect of students admitted in batch 2011-12 as per provisions of

Homoeopathy(Post Graduate Degree Course) Regulations (as amended upto 2001).


Consideration of Reports of Inspections of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken in the matter.


Ministry’s letter No.R. 13040/93/2008-HD(Tech.) dated 03.09.2013 regarding inclusion of

BHMS and M.D. (Hom) degree qualification s awarded by West Bengal University of

Health Sciences, Kolkata in Second Schedule of HCC Act, 1973.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee in the matter, and

noted the issue of notification dated 10.11.2014.


Ministry’s letter No. R-13040/40/2012-HD(Tech.) dated 03.07.2014 regarding inclusion of

M.D. (Hom.) qualification awarded by Shivaji University, Kolhapur in Second Schedule of

H.C.C. Act, 1973.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee in the matter.

9


Ministry’s letter No. R-13040/83/2010-HD (Tech.) dated 06.03.2014 regarding inclusion of

BHMS degree qualification awarded by Kumaun University, Rudrapur, Nainital,

Uttrakhand in the Second Schedule of H.C.C. Act, 1973.



(a) Ministry’s letter No. R-13040/10/2011-HD(Tech.) dated 12.12.2013 regarding

inclusion of qualification in Second Schedule of H.C.C. Act, 1973.

(b) Ministry’s letter No. R-13040/17/2006-HD dated 17.12.2013 regarding inclusion of

qualification in Second Schedule.



Ministry’s letter no.R.13015/22/2006-HD(Tech.) dated 16.9.2014 regarding inclusion of

M.D.(Hom) Degree qualification awarded by Dr.B.R. Ambedkar University, Agra in the

Second Schedule to H.C.C. Act.



Ministry’s letter No. R-13040/105/2014-HD(Tech) dated 30.06.2014 regarding inclusion of

M.D.(Hom.) qualification awarded by Homoeopathy University, Jaipur in Second Schedule

of H.C.C. Act, 1973.



Ministry’s letter No. R-13040/49/2009-HD(Tech) dated 12.02.2014 regarding inclusion of

M.D.(Hom.) qualification awarded by Bharati Vidyapeeth University, Pune in Second

Schedule in H.C.C. Act, 1973.


10


(a) Appointment of Asstt. Secretary (Admn & Regn)

(b) Appointment of the post of Office Superintendent on Adhoc Basis

(c) Appointment of Sh. Anil Kumar, UDC.

The Central Council noted the appointment of Shri K.K.Gupta on the post of

Asstt.Secretary(Admn.& Regist.) on adhoc basis. It also noted the appointment of Smt.Anil Rani

Malik, on the post of Office Supdt. on adhoc basis. The Council further noted the promotion of

Shri Anil Kumar on the post of UDC.


Letter No.MCI-Academic/2014/32725 dated 23-09-2014 of MCI, & Minutes of Academic

Committee meeting held on 13.05.2014 and minutes of the meeting of the Executive

Committee of MCI held on 21.08.2014.

The Central Council noted the contents of letter of Medical Council of India.


Ministry’s O.M. No. Z.28015/14/2013-P& C[AYUSH] dated 02.04.2014 regarding Action

Taken on 62nd Report of the Department Related Parliamentary Standing Committee on

Personnel, Public Grievances, Law and Justice on the Status of Woman Government

Employees, Service Conditions, Protection against exploitation, Employees, Service

Conditions, Protection against exploitation, Employees, Service Conditions, Protection

against exploitation, Employees, Service Conditions, Protection against exploitation,

Incentives and other related issues.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.


Appointment of Chartered Accountant in Contract basis

The Central Council noted that M/s.Sanjay Jain and Company, Chartered Accountant has been

engaged on contractual basis.

11


Letter No. 7-1/2013-CGHS/C&P/Part/3409 dated 09.07.2014 regarding Extension of

C.G.H.S. facilities to the retired employees of Statutory/Autonomous Bodies, whose serving

employees are already covered under C.G.H.S. regarding.

The Central Council agreed with the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.


inabaMQak‚ ibahar rajya haoimayaaopOiqak icaik%saa baaoD-‚ pTnaa sao p`aPt p~

idnaa^Mk 17º07º2014 maoM JaarKND rajya ko ]%tI-Na Ca~aoM ka inabaMQana krnao ko

sambanQa maoM.



EaI ftoh isaMh‚ saovaainavaR<a‚ p`var EaoNaI ilaipk ka p~ idnaa^Mk 01º08º2014–jaao ik

pirYad\ maoM daobaara kaya- krnao ko saMbaMQa maoM hO.

The Central Council approved the contractual appointment of Shri Fateh Singh.


Ministry’s letter No.R.13040/45/2010-HD(Tech.) dated 07.05.2013 regarding inclusion of

BHMS Degree qualification awarded by Pt. B.D. Sharma University of Health Sciences,

Rohtak in Second Schedule of H.C.C. Act, 1973.



Charging of inspection fees from Nagpur College of Homoeopathy and Hospital, Nagpur.



Letter No.MUHS/UDC/FCFL/05/A865/2014 dated 10.07.2014 and letter No.

MUHS/UDC/PFL/09/E-04/1093/2014 dated 04.09.2014 received from MUHS Nashik

regarding allow the conduct of U.G. and/or P.G. level courses or any other courses in

Homoeopathy meant for Homoeopathic doctors which have been notified by the Central

Council of Homoeopathy in the Official Gazette.

The Central Council considered the matter and it decided to take a serious view for not allowing

the University to conduct such courses which are not prescribed by the Central Council.

12

However, before taking any action legal opinion from the Councils advocate in this regard may

be taken.


(a) Ministry’s letter No.R.13040/39/2011-HD(Tech.) dated 27.7.2011 regarding MJC

No.1201 of 2011 (Saran Homoeopathic Medical College Vs. the Union of India and

Ors.)

(b) Ministry’s letter No.R.13040/39/2011-HD(Tech.) dated 26.7.2013 regarding MJC

No.1201 of 2011 (Saran Homoeopathic Medical College, Saran(Bihar).

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by the Executive Committee. It also took the

congnizence of Ministry’s letter NO.R.13040/39/2011-HD (Tech.) dated 11.11.2014 and

Councils reply vide letter No. 15-14/2011-CCH(104-16)/24635 dated 28.11.2014.


Ministry’s letter No.Z.28015/109/2014-P&C dated 1.9.2014 regarding submission of

declaration of assets and liabilities by the Public servants for each year and placing the

same in public domain on the websites of Ministries/Departments.

The Central Council agreed with the decision of Executive Committee for asking Councils

Officials and staff to file declaration, information or return as the case may be regarding assets

and liabilities with him/her in accordance to Ministry’s letter made applicable mutatis mutandis

on them. However, such information and documents may not be placed on Councils website till

clarity is given by the Central Govt. (in view of news items published in the newspaper namely

Hindustan Times dated 12.12.2014


Letter no.41212/12/2013/H& FW D dated 01.02.2014 received from Govt. of Kerala

regarding two and half year D.Pharm Course in Pharmacy (Homoeopathy) in the Govt.

Homoeopathic Medical College, Thiruvananthapuram and Kozhikode.

The Central Council noted the Court order.


(a) Ministry’s letter No. R.13040/92/2008(HD-Tech) dated 19.05.2014 regarding

National Board of Examinations in Homoeopathy.

(b) Ministry’s letter No. R.13040/92/2008(HD-Tech) dated 05.06.2014 & 03.07.2014

regarding National Board of Examinations in Homoeopathy.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by P.G.Education Committee in the matter.

13


Creation of posts of Accounts Officer and Law Officer in CCH.

The Central Council decided to take up the matter again with the Central Govt. for sanction of

additional posts for which a proposal has been already submitted to Ministry.


Formats for Books review submitted by Dr. M.K.Sahani, Chairman, Education Committee.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by Literature Committee in the matter.


Letter dated 02.03.2014 received from Dr. Manish Bhatia from Jaipur, alongwith 8 copies

of the book “Lectures on Organon of Medicine Vol. I” for review.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by Literature Committee in the matter.


Ministry’s letter No. Z.28015/14/2013-P&C [AYUSH] dated 24.12.2013 regarding

Reservation for persons with disabilities revised forms for Disability- regarding.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by Executive Committee in the matter.


An endorsement Letter No. R-13040/27/2011-HD(Tech.) dated 13.05.2014 received from

Director, Government of India, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Department of

AYUSH regarding inclusion of names of doctors registered in State Register of Nagaland.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by Registration Committee in the matter.


Payment above Rs. 50,000/-

(a) Bill No. 723 dated 31.01.2014 for Rs. 51,480/- received from M/s. Gupta

Photostat for photocopy Charges in respect of Central Council Agenda.

(b) Bill/Invoice No. CCH/29/04/2014/092/01 dated 03.04.2014 regarding payment of

Rs. 2,35,248/- for the month of March, 2014 M/s. Aim Consultant Pvt. Ltd.

(c) Bill/Invoice No. CCH/30/05/2014/15/01 dated 02.05.2014 regarding payment of

Rs. 2,39,482/- for the month of April, 2014 M/s. Aim Consultant Pvt. Ltd.

(d) Bill in respect of M/s. Aim Consultant Pvt. Ltd. (for providing manpower)

14

i) For the month of May,2014 - Rs. 2,52,745/-

ii) For the month of July, 2014 - Rs. 2,59,083/-

(e) Bill/invoice No. CCH/34/09/2014/038 dated 03.09.2014 regarding Bill of Rs.

2,41,023/- for the month of August, 2014 M/s. Aim Consultant Pvt. Ltd.

(f) Payment of Rs., 55294/- to M/s.Kendriya Bhandar for purchase of stationary.

(g) Bill No. 3/4/W/37/17 dated 04.06.2014 of Rs. 93,59,250/- for payment for

printing

charges of Central Register in the Official Gazette dated 22/28.02.2014.

(h) Letter dated 31.07.2014 from Inspection Officer regarding payment of Audit

Fees.

(i) Bill No. 48/14 dated 25.07.2014 Rs. 1,23,000/- received from Controller of

Publication, Civil Line, Delhi- 110 054 regarding printing charges of amendment

to Homoeopathic practitioners (Professional Conduct Etiquette and Code of

Ethics) regulations, 1982.

(j) Bill dated 29.07.2014 received from Advocate Shri Kundan Mishra regarding

Gyanjot Trust L.P.A. No. 1630/12 from 07.01.2014 onwards till end of litigation

i.e. on 01.05.2014. Rs. 1,80,000/-

(k) Letter dated 19.08.2014 from Advocate Shri Kundan Mishra regarding fee

structure and other charges in the S.L.P. No. 12735-12736/2014 in the Hon’ble

Supreme Court.

The Central Council sanctioned expost facto about the following payments :-

1. Bill No.723 dated 31.1.2014 for M/s. Gupta Photostat - Rs.51,480/-

for photocopy charges in respect of CCH Agenda.

2. Bill in respect of M/s. Aim Consultant Pvt. Ltd.

(for providing manpower)

i) For the month of March, 2014 - Rs.2,33,450/-

ii) For the month of April, 2014 - Rs.2,30,167/-

iii) For the month of May, 2014 - Rs.2,52,745/-

iv) For the month of June, 2014 - Rs.2,40,937/

v) For the month of July, 2014 - Rs.2,59,083/-

vi) For the month of August, 2014 - Rs. 2,38,776/-

vii) For the month of September, 2014 - Rs.2,23,202/-

viii) For the month of October, 2014 - Rs. 2,15,689/-

3. Payment to M/s. Kendriya Bhandar for purchase of - Rs.55,294/-.

Stationary

4. Letter dated 31.7.2014 from Inspection Officer regarding - Rs.59,125/-

payment of Audit Fees.

5. Advertisement expenses DAVP - Rs.4,72,012/-

6. Leave encashment of Sh.V.P. Singh, Ex-UDC - Rs.3,92,470/-

15

7. Gratuity of Sh. V.P. Singh, Ex-UDC - Rs.6,47,576/-

8. Pension Strengthening - Rs.17,00,000/-

9. Legal Expenses (Sh. Kundan Mishra, Advocate) - Rs.57,500/-

10. TA advance to Dr. Shoukath Ali P.K., Inspector - Rs.70,000/-

11. Legal Expenses (Sh. Sunil Narula, Advocate) - Rs.60,500/-

12. Leave encashment of Sh. Fateh Singh, Ex-UDC - Rs.3,95,800/-

13. Gratuity of Sh. Fateh Singh, Ex-UDC - Rs.6,53,070/-

14. Controller publication Printing expenses - Rs. 1,20,900/-

The Central Council sanctioned the following payments :-

1. Bill No.3/4/W/37/17 dated 4.6.2014 of for payment of - Rs.93,59,250/-

printing charges of CRH in the Official Gazette dated

22-28.2.2014.

2. Bill No.48/14 dated 25.7.2014 of Controller of publication, - Rs.1,23,000/-

Civil Line, Delhi-110054 regarding printing charges of

amendment to Homoeopathic Practitioners (Professional

Conduct Etiquette and Code of Ethics) Regulations, 1982.

3. Bill dated 29.7.2014 of Advocate Shri Kundan Mishra reg.- Rs.1,80,000/-

Gyanjot Trust L.P.A. No.1630/12 from 7.1.2014 onwards

till end of litigation i.e. on 1.5.22014.


Letter dated 27.8.2014 received from Md. Zaheer regarding re-joining in III BHMS

class.

The Central Council as a special case allowed the request of Md. Zaheer for rejoining in III-

BHMS in LBS Homoeopathic Medical College, Bhopal for completing the course as per

provisions of Homoeopathy (Degree Course) Regulations, 1983 (as amended upto 2005).

16


Ministry’s letter No. Z.28015/72/2014-P&C (AYUSH) dated 13th May, 2014 regarding

Padma Awards, namely Padma Vibhushan, Padma Bhushan and Padma Shri to be

announced on the occasion of Republic Day-2015.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by Executive Committee in the matter.


Advertisement of Public Notice and payment thereof – regarding.

The Central Council granted expost facto sanction of Rs. 472012/- which was paid to DAVP

and it noted the Publication of “Public Notice” in daily newspaper throughout the Country.


Workshops organised from April 2014 to December 2014.

The Central Council noted the reports of various workshops.


jftLVªkj mRrj izns”k cksMZ ls izkIr i= i=kad 422 ,p- ,e-ch-@275

¼Vh-lh-½ fnukad 12-02-2014 MkW- gsseyrk dh ch-,p-,e-,l-

vgZrk tkyh gksus ds fo’k; esaA The Central Council noted the action taken on the recommendations/decisions of

Registration Committee in the matter.


jftLVªkj jktLFkku cksMZ }kjk Hksts x, Ukkeksa dk fujLr djus

rFkk mu ukeksa dks dsUnzh; iathdk ls Hkh gVk, tkus ds lac/k

esaA The Central Council decided not to take the names of Dr.Namrata Verma and Dr.Neha

Yadav in Central Register on the basis of their registration with Rajasthan Board.


17

jftLVªkj mRrj izns”k cksMZ }kjk Hksts x, Ukkeksa dk fujLr djus


esaA The Central Council decided not to take the names of Dr. Nihirka Kokne, Dr. Dharmender

Kumar Pateland it also noted the action taken for removal of names from the Central Register

in respect of Dr. Vishwavarty Pathak, Dr.Vijay Prakash, Dr.Ashish Shankar, Dr.Mani Kumar

Denanath Pandey, Dr.Baljit Singh, Dr. Mohd. Mukim and Dr.Rajesh Kumar Jain on the basis

of their UP Registration.


jftLVªkj e/; izns”k ifj’kn~ }kjk Hksts x, Ukkeksa dk fujLr djus


esaA The Central Council decided that the office may ensure that the names reflected in the

Agenda Item are not taken in to Central Register or if taken are removed from the Central

Register on the basis of Madhya Pradesh Registration.


jftLVªkj NRrhlx< ifj’kn~ }kjk Hksts x, Ukkeksa dk fujLr djus rFkk

mu ukeksa dks dsUnzh; iathdk ls Hkh gVk, tkus ds lac/k esaA The Central Council decided that the names of persons in the Agenda Note may be removed

from the Central Register on the basis of registration with Chhatisgarh Council.


MkW vuq:n oekZ] lnL;] lh0lh0,p0 }kjk izkIr i= fnukWd “kwU; esa gksE;ksiSFkh ds fodkl ds eqn~nsa dk jktuhfrd nyksa }kjk pqukoh /kks’k.kki= esa “kkfey djus gsrq A The Central Council decided not to take any action in the matter as it does not come in its

jurisdiction.


Minutes of the 163rd Meeting of the Executive Committee of Central Council of

Homoeopathy held on 23.04.2014 at New Delhi.

18

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee which have not

been discussed elsewhere.


Minutes of the Meeting of the Education Committee of Central Council of

Homoeopathy held on 02.05.2014 at Bhubaneswar.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Education Committee which have not



Minutes of the Meeting of the Liaison Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy

held on 12.05.2014 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Liaison Committee which have not



Minutes of the Meeting of the P.G. Education Committee of Central Council of

Homoeopathy Held on 23.05.2014 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the P.G.Education Committee which have

not been discussed elsewhere.


Minutes of the 164th Meeting of the Executive Committee of Central Council of





Minutes of the Meeting of the Literature Committee of Central Council of


The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Literature Committee which have



Minutes of the Meeting of the Committee concerning Excellence in Education of

Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 27.05.2014 at New Delhi.

19

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Excellence in Education Committee

which have not been discussed elsewhere.



held on 20.06.2014 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Liaison Committee which have not



Minutes of the Meeting of the Registration Committee of Central Council of


The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Registration Committee which have








Minutes of the Meeting of the Editorial Board for Publication of Journal, of Central

Council of Homoeopathy held on 08.07.2014 a New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Editorial Board which have not been

discussed elsewhere.



held on 01.08.2014 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Liasion Committee which have not



Minutes of the Meeting of the Finance Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy

held on 21.08.2014 at New Delhi

20

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Finance Committee which have not



dsUnzh; gksE;ksiSFkh ifj’kn~ dh jktHkk’kk ¼fgUnh½ lfefr

dh cSBd fnukad

27-08-2014] ubZ fnYyh d¢ dk;Zo`r A

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Rajbhasha (Hindi) Committee.







Minutes of the Meeting of the Office Functioning Review Committee of the Central

Council of Homoeopathy held on 16.09.2014 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Office Functioning Review

Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.







21






Minutes of the Meeting of the Regulations committee of Central Council of


The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Regulations Committee which have




Homoeopathy held on 03.12.2014 at Kanyakumari.














22

Proceedings and recommendations of the Workshop of Regulations of State

Boards/Council’s of Homoeopathy held on January 30th, 2014 under the aegis of CCH.

The Central Council agreed with the recommendation/decision of Executive Committee in

the matter.


Mail letter dated 19th June, 2014 received from Dr.Jose Issac, Member, Education

Committee regarding MOU with Super Speciality Hospital.

The Central Council deferred the matter to its next meeting

Any other item with the permission of the Chair.

1. The President informed the Central Council about the contents of Ministry’s (two) letter

No.R.13015/12/2005-Vig. Dated 14.8.2014 and another letter No.C..31013/04/2014-

Vig.(AYUSH) dated 11.9.2014 and Appeal dated 16.12.2014 of Dr.Lalit Verma

(addressed to Central Council of Homoeopathy) and the matter was discussed. The

Central Council accepted the appeal of Dr.Lalit Verma and decided to treat the charge

sheet dated 14.8.2014 withdrawn.

2. The Central Council decided that the requests of Dr. Sarvepalli Radhakrishanan Ayurved

University, Jodhpur and Dr.Hari Singh Gour Vishvidalaya Sagar if are received in terms

of Section 13 (2) of Homoeopathy Central Council Act for inclusion of BHMS Degree in

Second Schedule further, than the same may be examined and placed in the next meeting

of Executive Committee.

3. The Central Council decided to consult the Ministry as to whether the seal of Govt. of

India can be used in the identity cards of the members of C.C.H..

4. The Central Council decided that the Ministry may be impressed upon to include one

member of CCH in the State Mission Governing Body in each State to be coopted in the

state concerned from where such a member comes.

5. The Central Council decided to refer the Case Taking Proforma proposed by Dr.Biplab

Kundu to Education Committee for the purposes of consideration.

23

6. The Central Council decided that all Homoeopathic Medical Colleges may involve

themselves in respect of Public Health initiatives with support of the Government, and all

Colleges may also consider to submit Research project to C.C.R.H. under the of Extra

Mural Research Schemes which will be evaluated by the concerned authorities of

C.C.R.H.. Such steps will enable the colleges to consolidate their clinical work and

Research initiatives.

7. Minutes of the Meeting of the Editorial Board for Publication of Journal (of Central

Council of Homoeopathy) held on 16.12.2014 at New Delhi, were ratified.

Meeting ended with a vote of thanks to the Chair.

(Dr.Lalit Verma)

Secretary

Attested

(Dr.Ramjee Singh)

President

“A”

23.12.14

24

EXTRACT TAKEN FROM THE MINUTES OF THE 53rd MEETING OF THE

CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 17th DECEMBER, 2014 AT

NEW DELHI.


Payment above Rs. 50,000/-

(a) Bill No. 723 dated 31.01.2014 for Rs. 51,480/- received from M/s. Gupta Photostat

for photocopy Charges in respect of Central Council Agenda.

(b) Bill/Invoice No. CCH/29/04/2014/092/01 dated 03.04.2014 regarding payment of Rs.

2,35,248/- for the month of March, 2014 M/s. Aim Consultant Pvt. Ltd.

(c) Bill/Invoice No. CCH/30/05/2014/15/01 dated 02.05.2014 regarding payment of Rs.

2,39,482/- for the month of April, 2014 M/s. Aim Consultant Pvt. Ltd.

(d) Bill in respect of M/s. Aim Consultant Pvt. Ltd. (for providing manpower)

i) For the month of May,2014 - Rs. 2,52,745/-

ii) For the month of July, 2014 - Rs. 2,59,083/-

(e) Bill/invoice No. CCH/34/09/2014/038 dated 03.09.2014 regarding Bill of Rs.

2,41,023/- for the month of August, 2014 M/s. Aim Consultant Pvt. Ltd.

(f) Payment of Rs., 55294/- to M/s.Kendriya Bhandar for purchase of stationary.

(g) Bill No. 3/4/W/37/17 dated 04.06.2014 of Rs. 93,59,250/- for payment for printing

charges of Central Register in the Official Gazette dated 22/28.02.2014.

(h) Letter dated 31.07.2014 from Inspection Officer regarding payment of Audit Fees.

(i) Bill No. 48/14 dated 25.07.2014 Rs. 1,23,000/- received from Controller of

Publication, Civil Line, Delhi- 110 054 regarding printing charges of amendment to

Homoeopathic practitioners (Professional Conduct Etiquette and Code of Ethics)

regulations, 1982.

(j) Bill dated 29.07.2014 received from Advocate Shri Kundan Mishra regarding

Gyanjot Trust L.P.A. No. 1630/12 from 07.01.2014 onwards till end of litigation

i.e. on 01.05.2014. Rs. 1,80,000/-

(k) Letter dated 19.08.2014 from Advocate Shri Kundan Mishra regarding fee

structure and other charges in the S.L.P. No. 12735-12736/2014 in the Hon’ble

Supreme Court.

The Central Council sanctioned expost facto about the following payments :-

15. Bill No.723 dated 31.1.2014 for M/s. Gupta Photostat - Rs.51,480/-

for photocopy charges in respect of CCH Agenda.

16. Bill in respect of M/s. Aim Consultant Pvt. Ltd.

(for providing manpower)

i) For the month of March, 2014 - Rs.2,33,450/-

ii) For the month of April, 2014 - Rs.2,30,167/-

iii) For the month of May, 2014 - Rs.2,52,745/-

iv) For the month of June, 2014 - Rs.2,40,937/

25

v) For the month of July, 2014 - Rs.2,59,083/-

vi) For the month of August, 2014 - Rs. 2,38,776/-

vii) For the month of September, 2014 - Rs.2,23,202/-

viii) For the month of October, 2014 - Rs. 2,15,689/-

ix) Payment to M/s. Kendriya Bhandar for purchase of - Rs.55,294/-.

Stationary

x) Letter dated 31.7.2014 from Inspection Officer regarding - Rs.59,125/-

payment of Audit Fees.

xi) Advertisement expenses DAVP - Rs.4,72,012/-

xii) Leave encashment of Sh.V.P. Singh, Ex-UDC - Rs.3,92,470/-

xiii) Gratuity of Sh. V.P. Singh, Ex-UDC - Rs.6,47,576/-

xiv) Pension Strengthening - Rs.17,00,000/-

xv) Legal Expenses (Sh. Kundan Mishra, Advocate) - Rs.57,500/-

xvi) TA advance to Dr. Shoukath Ali P.K., Inspector - Rs.70,000/-

xvii) Legal Expenses (Sh. Sunil Narula, Advocate) - Rs.60,500/-

xviii) Leave encashment of Sh. Fateh Singh, Ex-UDC - Rs.3,95,800/-

xix) Gratuity of Sh. Fateh Singh, Ex-UDC - Rs.6,53,070/-

xx) Controller publication Printing expenses - Rs. 1,20,900/-

The Central Council sanctioned the following payments :-

1. Bill No.3/4/W/37/17 dated 4.6.2014 of for payment of - Rs.93,59,250/-

printing charges of CRH in the Official Gazette dated

22-28.2.2014.

2. Bill No.48/14 dated 25.7.2014 of Controller of publication, - Rs.1,23,000/-

Civil Line, Delhi-110054 regarding printing charges of

amendment to Homoeopathic Practitioners (Professional

Conduct Etiquette and Code of Ethics) Regulations, 1982.

3. Bill dated 29.7.2014 of Advocate Shri Kundan Mishra reg.- Rs.1,80,000/-

Gyanjot Trust L.P.A. No.1630/12 from 7.1.2014 onwards

till end of litigation i.e. on 1.5.22014.

*****

26

‘kc’ 3/2/15

Documents

rd MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF · 4 Agenda Item No. 53. 1 (a) Confirmation of the Minutes of the 52nd Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 19th February, 2014