View
0
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
��� ���� ��� ��������� �� ���� ����� ������ ����
)���� ����� �� ��� ���( ������� ��� ∗∗∗∗
��� ���� ����∗∗∗∗∗∗∗∗
����� �������� �� � �� ���� ����� �� ������� �������� ! ��"��� �� #��$ %�&�� '�
#(� �$)� #*��+,"- '��� '���� .�/$� �� 0.���1� �� #2�3 .��� ����$� '���3�� #�/ '��� -
�����4� ����- �(- �3������� .��/56 .8���� ���$-0 9/& 8�� �� � #�� � �� 9�:3� '��� '��;3#�� <�- <�� ��� =�>?! %��@�� .<����� �� �)A�B5 ��� �� � �� '�8�� �� <�� � ������5 <���5 '�
�3�- '��6��� =��� �2C�D5 E�$"! � . 8�� �� ���(3 ���F3 ����� � %��GH� ,�@?! � ��I:! #(�3JJJ��FJJ�$�5� �#�� <�- <�� ��� '� .�3/�3 8�� K��� ��� �� '��� L '�F3 M�2-� ���)5 I�3 � �$�+�
3�� �� � 3 #�������� 9/� N�� �� .��/56 #��- �)A�B5 ��� �� ����- �(- O@��5 K���5 �� .��#(� � �3���'��� ��+�� P#+�� ���& ,�@?! � ��I:! � ����� ��/5 .���1� �� #2�3 �(36 ����$�'�
8�� �� <�� ��� �� <�56 #���»�$�5� ���F3'� «�5 ��� S�- �� <��� �A/>5 T$ ,5�-�$-��: ����3����0 �$U '�V+ '�����0 ����� <��� '��:$ ���+0 �$5��I�� W�2!�� � ����� �3 X���� .»��� �A/>5« ���
���� �»#(�3����3���� ����$� '����« �5���� �� <��� %Y/>5 ���� �� #������ .�$�5� ���F3 '��@��CX���- �)� �� ,5�- �������� N�5 E� ZA�& �� 00 #�� <�- ����� ��5�� � %G5�)! .
���� ����
0.��� �#(����$� '���0 �$�5� ���F3 0������� �������� ! 0.���1��������� N�5 0'�.
� ������ ���:�/�/�� � ������� ��� �����:��/�/��
∗
������� ���� !"# ������$� %�&"'"()�* +,�- �./��� dboostani@mail.uk.ac.ir ∗∗ �� !"# ������$� ������� �� �./�������* �(,$%�+�) a_mohammadpur@yahoo.com
�( �����
0)� �1�&��� ���2�$ �� ��3 45�6� ! ",,7� ",2� 8�)9 ������� ! �.()"*�!� �� ",,7� 0' $� ��� :� ��/';;;,* <;;;(� !� =;;;�� ! > ��,?(� 8",#
/@* ��(� ���A$� 45�6� =�� B� � .�& +- ��D�� 45�6� �+E�& F*�(& 8���� +���� G,H(� �� ��/' �.()" ��H� IEJ 0��� B� K�5� B� �L,1 0' +-�* ����2 ! ��2��
%����� =,* <*�!�)"?N �� "�2� B� G�� (83�P�(Q� R��+,N ��0��$� 8�)� 8�;;; �� +�+�& K&�-��- .* 9S�$� =,�) "*"�� �$� B�T B� �Q� %����� ��,?(� 8",# 8�)
* 9��/' �� �"�?# ���EP�U& 00E&�� B�T �� V�!0E&�� ! ,?(� �$�(- �$�(-$� W�" 4�X!� . �/)!VN ! 8"H� 4�,*�� 9�YP �(W! �"�?#8� Z��2 =�� ��
$� S"�$� �� .�"Q�!� �* 4�EP�U& =�� +�� R@* 0' �D�A B��,)� ! 8"H� 8�) -
)[!� 8�4�\]� ��2�(-� ! 0�"H� %�&BA 0* ���� �� 0' $� +- ��D�� 0����"#^ +,� �* $� �+_�� 0EP�U& =�� �YP 9$� +- ���(& `��E�& 4�,J" �2"* a�U*� ��
[!� ! 8",?L� �"b�!� B� ��L�$�0�"H� =��� �$�(- 0(,&B 8B�$B�* ! �$�"* 0* 8��� ���(E& %�,& �� ��,?(� 8",# 0* \?� B�",- "�- S��+& "?N %�B�&A R���
c,&� �"Q�!� "* �(�\& ! ���,(* 8",$�L� 0* ! 0�2��"N %�"�2�d 0EP�U& 6� e�J�& B�+*�� $� ��'Y& 0E&�� ��"� %�,& �� .,&� �"Q�!�c G������N �� 8��,(* G,)�L& B� �Q�
[!� ! 8",?L�B�* ! ",?L� 9f�� 8�(E& 0* ! ��* �L,' �$�(- e�J�& �� +�+N �g��� B� �$�"* ���&»",#�� ��"� "H� 0Ui�« $� .,�� ���L& K*�i& 0Ui� �� c,&� ���L&ck
1- Emic 2- Etic
"* li6& %��* "m�� �#V�! "* ! ��* ���\]� 0�!� c� n�$�$� 0' $� ! l,i6� ���& "&�A 0* �.�% 0U$�! ! ����2 �EJ�& B����� +,'�� +(& (Neuman, 2006: P 449).
� �*[!� o�@�$�(-� "H��&B 0,0(�8� 9�(p�) 0EP�U& =,�$� �+_�� =,*�� "H� 0*� 0 ��� 8"H� a+& ! �"*�(* ! ��* ��6&�%A `+) = 0� �g�&BA 0�"H�9 0Q�*"H��0B�$8 ��
�"2 qU$ $� .
( !� "#$%&�
?&^& 0P;�$�"* ��� & =��;R��� 0r $� %A 0EP�U$�"* ���& "?N %�B�&A� 0s ! f��;��� ��� B�;(� �* t�\;& >;��2 IP�@ .s ! +����;?� 0��; ���A 0* \
��#,"8 &�+((' .��\& 0* 0��� �*� L?��� �����N��� [!�$�(-� ',L� [!� !!� `u2 "* ��'Y& ",?L� ! f�� 9 ��L�$� ���&�4�\]� �"Q�"#�[!� ! 0��$�(-� v�'�
(�\&� � 9%A "*��"#�g+,cd"�?* 9 � � ! S�?T���8 �E�,GYN�"8 �6�,�� 1�\(�$� !� $� .,�"#�g+�� =,,\� c���� \� B�,,������ ���� �� ��L�$� ���& =� ?L�,"8 $�
\� %A �� 0';,, B� $� 4��\� =�_�� c;,@J I;, G�� �;���"8 gw� �*;, 9Z�2 4��� 0��� �* 9�&�;��w�� &;*�� �!+6; ���X�& c;E, �& �;,������ %�+�& �� �; 9K*�i
\�;,,���&�� =,c2 ���� \�,,$� ���& =;� �� ��L�;��� ���;���� ]�;��\� $�; �� 0' \� %A;,,� =;X "* n��+�;���,x�� =;� # !; ��w*�!� ! �);Q�& %���X 0\- K*�i�& <� $�(cf. Neuman, 2006: Blaikie, 2007) . ��6& =�� a�T 0EP�U& =�� +�� R$"N$� �U& ���& ��"� 0r 0EP)R���%�B�&A (��#,"8 ?(�,�� %�"�2� 0* \?� �� ��2
N,g���B�* ! �(E& 9f�� 0��.s ��2 %�&�"� &�+((' .�� I,_�� 9n���?&, ! 4�r���� l
1- Ideographic 2- Nomothetic
� ",$�L���� 0P�i& 0* \?� ��"� =#,"8 ?(�,�� 0�5 8B�$��b-A �w��?& 8�)B y��D� =�"�B��(E& ! 0�?8 ()o� B� ��L�$� �* ���A n�$�$� ! 4!�L�& 8�"b�!�
"�YN",?L� 9����(E& 8"&� 0*�z& 0* 0*"D� �(E� �$� 0*"D� "&� 0* \?� ��?��,��B�N",W +�B !.(cf. Crotty, 1998; Patton, 2002; Denzin and Lincoln, 2005; Silverman,
2005)
'( ��#� (��)��
�_� `+)� �� 0EP�U& =� 8",?L� �"b�!� o�@�� �* � $� %A %!�� B� �.� �* 0r )!��&� �"Q,c (�� e�J�& 0*#,"8 ?(�,�� �B��"{* 0EP�U& ���& 0E&�� �� .=�+*-
!� %!+* 0' �(E&� �"Q�!� ���)�"Q8 "H�8 N,/,J" ! =,(�\& +- 0�2�$ 4�� %A "*� � =,,\� 0g��� ! ���A�\� �,,=g�)� 4�",,7� =�� 0* \?� %!",* B� �x��)|,�� �"b�!�( 9
&?^�� 0P#,"8 ?(�,�� \?� B�T �� �� %�"�2� 0* R��� ",?L� ! }���� %�B�&A 0EP�U& ���& "?N ��� ��"X�B��"{* e�J�& =�� 0* ���A "H� 0Ui� B� ! .* 0 <��"- 9 !u�
A" ! 4u&�E� 9�)"�?* ���� ! �)+(,� 8�)+&�,N w��� =#,"8 ?(�,�� ��H� �� ����� 0* ���A ���(E&�/' "+ . ���(E& 8B�$B�* l,i6� =�� ��_� `+) 8�"b�!� =,(s �*
��#,"8 ?(�,�� "?N%� *�,���$"� "�--,$� %�"�2� 0* \?� B�" .
* (+���, -��� �
9������� ��E*� ".�� �* %A t�\��� ! ,?(� Z��2 �� 8�+E�& ��2�� 4�EP�U&$� +- ��D�� ��/' �� 8����X� ! �.()" .�� ���! =�� �* 6� e�J�& Z��2
�& ��-� "�B ���& +(s 0* ��(� 0P�i& =�� �� �$�"*��-:
8+$�)~��� ( 0(,&B ���D/��� <*�!�� �./��� "?N ! "�2� %��)8 *��� "�-,K 0* l,i6�$� 0�2��"N .����� ��&A8 �� �� R)!VN��� �D/��� B� "L��Q/� %�, ��� K -
+�� .�N �� li6&�EP�U& %�� _��,L�� Ui&E� � 0* ��2��� =,$� 0D, 0' $� +�� �D/��� +_���w# �* %��(� »& t�\���,-B�&A Kg�?& �� "?N ! "�2� %�� y�(���YN��� "
$�« +���* IP�@& u&�' . e��D& ���/�� �D/��� B� +_���* t�\��� 0* \?� %�, =� B� "?N ! "�2��+(�-�� \z& [".� 9�u$� �#+ .&,2� �� \z& [".� %�w* %�"�, R
(p�) ! ��* %�"?N B�, =~�� �D/��� +_��� %� 0�-��+�*� [B�&A��$�(/��!� 9� !+&�"����� 8���� 98 +���* \z& [".�9 P�T ��� � 0'��D/��� �� \?� =� %� 0�-�
�&BA �����)�./� �/�� ��* +_��. �L$�� � !� %�".)~��� (+P�! [".�����L_� =� 0���$!� <*�!� 0* \?� ��
�$�"* %�"?N ! %�"�2� �"'+��. �0���)8 ��N R)!VN =,���/� & %�/�� 0' +)�+P�! [".����"�2� 0* \?� =� ��"?N ! +���� "?N $!� 0'� "�2� $!� 0'
L(& 9+����� $� .(p�), =�0��* 0' ��� %�/� �), 4!�L� %��+N ! %����& [".� =(E&����8 7�& ! ���+� ���!,��& "� ��* 0'+P�! [".� 4!�L� ��& =��"# ��-� R
\)Y&� � 0* $���A��"� =,+P�! 0s") 0' ��\)Y& =� 0���$!� <*�!� 0* \?� +(-�* "�L(& [".� %�"�2� ! %�"?N�"�8 +����.
/@*� B��0���)8 �N c,����& R� )��LW8 9~��� (�,$�"* 0* w� %����� [".�~� ���� N 0P�$,�$!� %�&�"� �@& >(� �*$� 0�2��"N IP .����& %�/� �� 0' +)�
&,.��,�$!� �* %��"& i��& =� * "?N ! "�2�,$� %��B B� "�/ .��LW8 $� +i�E&_" 9�5�$�"& ��H��"- ! �)��$�(& <"�8 �"*8 & G)�" %��"&� [".� ! ��!A
� 0* \?� %��"&�+N =�� �� �� 9 +^,�P��B�* ! +,$� ����& FJ! + .(p�),=
�w���6� qU$ R,����X� qU$ ! 4u8 �$�N�#��w� �* %��%A i��& RN �), %�&�"�$!�� ��* �"�) "?N ! "�2� .5���� �$�N 0'�#��"* %�8 ���,�$!� 0� "?N ! "�2�
�"' 0g���� +��;B� +(���\ : 0* �$�N�� c,;L1�� B��K�$ 94���i��� IEJ 9��.��8 !*��5�\&� �����2 9�)� F� 9%5�?�) ! %��$!� ��/,?(� B���(-A 9�� ��!�B� +�X 0*
H(� ! ��!�B� 0* t�*"& 4uQ/& !, �����2 G. � ! +T�&� %�".)~��� (�,$�"* 0* w� �D/��� [".�� ! "�2� 4"-�E& 0* \?� %�
0�2��"N ��!�B� B� K\X "?N+�� .�0���)8 ��N R)!VN =,���/� �./��� �� 0'�)8 -, B�" !Q-wN ����� -,& %�/� +- ��D�� B�"� �����2 0' +)��)8 �D/���� 0* \?� %�
�D/����L(& [".� %��"�8 � 0*�=4"-�E& 0��#0�-�� �)+�� .7�&,�)"8 �^], "* ��Y#"�D/��� [".��B� +(���\� %� :i\1 9 �����2 [".�� ������� �6� 9 �����2, ! �+N 4u
�P!� 9�+N K7- 9���&�;�)8 -B��� ��&8 ��&�" !8 ?(� !, .��� %�ii6&�n�� +N�+� �$!� ! 4"-�E&� EX�! �� "?N ! "�2�,������ � ���m��8 &�N �� 0' +(����
7�,,-".� 4�"� -B�� !� $� +&A ���! 0*. �' ��1 0*� �$ ! �� 4�EP�U& f"�/& 0�!�R)!VN "�)8 �2��� � �� 0'� B�T =� +- ��D����W 0' $� =$�(- [!� �* �\P� v�'�(Q� 9,N c,���EUi& ��1 0* ! R� 0*
$�"*� * <*�!�,n��+�� ! 0�2��"N >(� !� = )�&,D($ [".� � 0�-��+��. (s, =��EP�U&� -B�� 45�6� 0s"#�� ��,?(� ! ��� %�/� ��+��9 v�' x�� 0* �&�� 9%��*
?L� ! I/' 0* ���X," "�A�)+(8 +��B�*�/� N !,�)+&�8 ��\� %A+�� .� 0' �� %A B�� =" 9�)"�?* !�'!+(' 0* R)!VNA�N ! �)+(,�)+&�8 KQ-#,"8 * t�\���, 0�\P� 9>(� !� =
Q� �*,?L� "* 0,& %�"?N "��B��"N9 &��Q� +����,+((' K� �)��'8 N,/,+-�* = .
� �*�& "H� 0* ���! =����2 4�EP�U& 0' +$�� *,"�/8 <*�!� Z��2��?(�,�� [!� B� ��L�$� �*$�(-� ',L� +- ��D��+�� .� ���& Z��2 =� 0* %���
'� R)!VN,w(1 )~��� ( %��(� 6�»%��"& %+- 0���B :)�,"H� ��&B 0,0(�8 ��Z��2 &,-�N %�� ��#"#� !� ?(��«i6� 9,�"5 l�2 )���� ( %��(� 6�» 0*
%�"?N "1�2 :' 0EP�U&,L� �)�"\)��8 ?(�,�� ��' !L1��� %��B0"T >'�* ���8« 9a�$�) 0EP�U&3 )���� ( %��(� �*»4!�L��)8 �"&� 0��$� `"�& ! %B 4�*�@��� �� �)
P�"�$�, a�$ �� ����~«��' 0EP�U& 94 )���~( %��(� 6� 9»UE� ����,�u� ?(�,�� :���& 0EP�U&8 �D/���� �./��� %�«P� 0EP�U& 9� ' !,f"5 )���� ( %��(� 6�»?(�,
?���N !,+�!"�- K8 �D/��� ���%����� %�«�) 0EP�U& 9�"�?'�* ! %"�$! 96 ��*�� )���� (»?' 0s� ���,& G�#,0�@/& ��"�)8 ������� ��?'� 0' "#B�WAg�+��
+(�?) ���!�B�« 9 !$�"*� P� $!"� !7 %��(� �*»�)�.P�8 P�E,���?� � ��N�.($ %�������8« ���� ��-� .P�U& =��[!� B� ��L�$� �* n��+�� 0' 4�E �$�(-
+- ��D�� �L,'Ri� K2�+� 0* 9+��)�\- 9��,?(� 8�) !� =,* <*�!� ! 9��,?(� 8�) �"' �E$ ! 0�2��"N "_�E& 0E&�� �� �"& ! %B >(�0�5 ���! +�� ���2�$ �g�(E& 8�)
+��- %��"& ! %��B ��,?(�. [!� o�@�� �* "J�T 0EP�U&L,' �$�(- �� %�"?N �g�(E& ��H� "�?* 0* �!�! ! �
>(� 0* �'�� =,(s 0��/�+��B�* +(�A" G� ! "�2� >(� B� ���A f�� 0* �*�,�$�
1- Richard Ekins 2- Yvonne Lafferty 3- Sandra Haswell 4- N. S. Carr 5- Dianne. Eley & David. Kirk 6- Belinda. Hewitt; Mark. Western; Janenn Baxter 7- K. S. Lee & S. G. Trost
&;*�"X IP�@; a�T =,T �� 9���� ����2 4�EP�U& �* �_�2 �-!� ! 8"H� 8�)�&2�� 4�EP�U& �2"* 8�"* ��,?(� <*�!� �g�(E& ! �L,' ��E*� 0* 0��� �* +���� ��
0\(���Q,+-�* 0�-�� ��.
.( ��/0� 1������
4!�L� 0* 0��� �* L?� 8�)� � v�r [!� !� ��������N�$�"* �� 9�L,r ! � 8�) B� 94�,J" %�&BA ! =�!+� �� 8"H� y�s��s B� ��L�$� 8�� 0* �L,r
��"@�$� �� �&��L& y�s���s �& ��L�$� l,i6� 45��$ �� a��$ ��- .y�s��s
&��L& �U\�"& G) 0* G,)�L& 0���D& � $�G� ! G,)�L& "* 0r 0EP�U& ���& +�� 8�) +��,N ".�+�) 0* ���(E& <\�"& ! GD?(& ��H� |� �P�X �� �� ���A ! ���� wr"��
�& +)�(cf.Maxwell,2004; Schutt, 2004; Ritchie & Lewis, 2005) . l,i6� ��0E&�� �"b�!� B� "J�T �� 8",?L� �$�(- L��"#",?�� ������� y�s��s =�!+� 8�"*
$� +- ��L�$� �&��L&. ������� ���"#",?L� �"b�!� %��(� 0* $�"* =�� �� ��_� �"b�!�� 0r $� +i�E&
* 0��� �*$ w,� ! %�?�� ,)�& %��* �u2 0v,��� 9������� ,EX�! %��* a� ",;?& %��� ";;,,7� ��;;D�� �;;� ! 4�;;,EX�! }�� 8�";;* Z�;;2 [!� ! ���(;;/,N �;;��A �� �";;r
(cf.Neuman,2006, 2007; Blaikie,2007) . 0;��#") �g�;�� F;�"& ! F\(& 0r �D�A B� %�;?�� }�� 9>;N 9$� %�?�� %��) ������� 4�,EX�! �� ",,7� ! B�$ ! 2�$ B� �;)
;$� G;�& ��,;?* �;��A %�";r ����(E& �.��.s ! 4�,EX�! �� ",,7� 94�,EX�! . =;�� B���� �* 90�-Y# B� =,���;X +X� ���?�� 0�2�$"* ��&� 0*�z& 0* ������� 4�,EX�! 0b(�� 0* 0
R,N =,,E� a�T �� n��g�� ! ��* +- %+- ��� �YP 9+(�?) ! a��;- %��� �g�.P� %���
�;X�! 8�"* ��; ;���� 4�,E; ;7� w;,� ! ���; ;$� ! ",,; �";r F;J! �;��A �� 8��b� . =;��X�!; a";�(r ! I/r K*�X ��(� 0� 4�,E +(�;?,�9 �;& n�";_ 0;b�* ",;?L� ! }�� +;(����
+��-(cf. Glaser,1967, 1978,1998, 2001) .��!� =�0' �"Q "*�"* �� %�?�� P�_� "*%�?�� ",?L� ! }�� +(�A" �� 4�,EX�! 0r $� �!�* =�� "* ���� +,r^� <,6& P�_� �)
�& ����(E& ! 0�2�$ 9 "&B!� �#+�B au2 �� ! +��-. �Y;P9 0;� G;� ! }�� �;6� �;�(�?��;%� �* 9���� ,�)� 4�,EX�! B� �);-� 8���� 0b;?) w,� 8�+E�& a�b . 9";H� =�� B�
�@;/& ! +;T�! ,EX�! |� �* 0� �&9 !";*!� %�#�;��# ! �+;E�& 4�;,EX�! �;* 0;b�* G,�;?)(cf. Lincoln and Guba, 1985; Guba, 1991; Guba and Lincoln, 2005) .
(p�), = S�$� "* �� ��2 %�&�",N 8�,�� B� ��"& }�� ! ",?L� 0r �D�A B� 9�"b�!� =���& Kb- "&B!� �#+�B ������� "�?* ��* "�?* 0* 0�?*�! +- +,P�� ���E& 9�",# ! ��
�& ����(E& %A %!�� ��-;;+ .R)!VN =�� �� 8�";b�!� �* $� +- �E$ 0����"#",;?L�B�$B�* 0*8 g�(E&� ��#,"8 ?(�,�� �R�� *� ��;$ "?N %�B�&A, ;- "�;- %��;$", B�"
� %�/� ! 0�2��"N+) � 0'� �)+;&�,N B� �;r�� 0;s %�#+((' '��/& =8 4�";,,7� =;���& �*��B�� ! }�� ��Us �� ���A 9+���� +((r.
2( �����34 +���,
�g�(E& 8B�$B�* l,i6� =�� `+) 0b(�� 0* 0��� �*��#,"8 ?(�,�� $� �YP 9[!�,r �$�(-[!� %��(� 0* �L��"& l,i6� [!� ! �P�W �$�(-8��.�1 ��D�� 8�"*
"H� [!� ! l,i6� 4�,����&B 0,0(�8 wD� ����6� ! 0, ��� K$� +- y�@��� �).
1- Ethnography
��"& 0�,$! 0* �E,\1 ������� <,6& |� �� ��"& 0EP�U& B� $� 4��\� 8��.�[!� ! �)��w*� ! ������� ���E& 0* %���* 0r ���)<,6& �� ��"� ,P�E �E,\1 8�)�"r �+,N $� . li6& 9l,i6� [!� =�� ��i�?& ��1 0*,G ���& %�+,& ! <,6& ��
�& r��/& 0EP�U&+(r(cf. Brewer, 1998; Fetterman, 1998; Schutt, 2004; Berg,
2006)
"#$( �% �&��'(� ) ���*��%����
r��/& "L� ?,* �� 0EP�U& =�� %�#+((rR��� B� %��$",*� ��$ Sur "?N %�B�&A ��� K,b/� B�",- "�-+�� .R��� 0EP�U& ! y�@��� 0* %��$",*� ��$ Sur "?N %�B�&A
$� 0�"# 4��_ K,P� +(s : 0�"H� ! +���� ��"X �$�?T ��!� �� +-� ��6P B� ���A Kb- %��!� =�� �� �" �,P!� ��) +�+i�E& %�?b��� K,\X B� ���B��"N�& �",#
(Erikson, 1968:P 128) .��) +(�A" ! G,��� 8�$ 0* �� %��� 9 �!� =�� �� �*���w#(;R) ���);& ��+;� & 0r +(r;D�� 0* "D(;�& �#+�B 8�"* ���+�E� �� ��-
(Ibid,P 155) .R��� B� !"# =�� 0b(�� ".�� 0�T"& |� �� ��,�6� ��6P B� %�B�&A+���� ��"X �P�i��� .i��� ".�� �-B�&A <,6& 0* �-B�&A <,6& |� B� a�) �)�./��� R,N
�./��� ! ( 0L,m! ��H� &+2 ! ��r ��B�* 0* ���%���b,* !"# �. r��/& y�@��� 8�"* +(�+) 8",# 0���� [!� B� %�#+((r1 $� +- ��L�$�. ��
� 8�)�"\)�� %�,&0��#=��N 0r 8�(cf. Patton, 2002) 9$� �"r �"U& 0* �"\)�� !�B� +(���\� 0' +- 0�"# ��r: ~� 0����e�(� "zr�+T �* 8",#2 B� �,- =�� �� 0r
%��$",*�R��� ! [�!"N ! [B�&A 0��#���s �T��� 8�)�#V�! �* ���B�&A 4!�L�& 8�)
1 - Purposive Sampling 2 - Maximum Variation Sampling
) 8����X� �.��N ! ��,�6� ,EJ! ��6P B� ;������� (0���� "zr�+T �� +- 8",#* 0�-�� �� e�(�+-�.�� 0�����"* 0P��# 8",#1 R��� B� �,- =�� �� 0r +,$"N %�B�&A
r +-;& 0;r��/* +((r;N 0r 8+E;& %�&�",;;& �� 0P�i;L;1� �_�2 ���;s ���� eu; 0r;$� �? .� ��;����$� �* ;& B� ��L;E,-� ��;� e�\;"H8 & ��;� ���;� ��+E;���;0 �)�;��,G#;,"8 +- .� S�$� "*�= &;E, 9��& 0r ���&B;�� =�� 0* li6;$"* 0D,; 0r +
/,* ��D��;�& "�;0\T� ! ��,�2� �� 8"�/,* 4��u1� 9 +)�/& !8 ��� n�"_ ! ���Y#�& IX��& �� 4��u1� 8�!A�"# li6& P�T =�� �� 9$� ��\X 4��u1� ��"b� +(r
(cf.Gubrium and Holstein,1997, 2001; Kval and Brinkman, 2009) .
+#$( � ),��� �'�- . )��/01 231 )� 4 5�678�
R)!VN ��0����.� ��"& 8�)9 0(,&B 0�"H� 0g��� ��[!� B� �L,1 B� 8� �� �) ��� 8�!A�"#�& ��L�$� 4��u1� ! �)B� +(���\� 0r ��- :0\T��& 9��r��/& +)�/& -
�$�"* ! B�* ! 0��,� 2�$ 8�)8��($� 8�)(cf. Esterberg, 2002; Schutt, 2004;
Punch, 2005; Hammersly and Atkinson, 2007). ��� l,i6� �� ����& 8�)[!� B� ��L�$� �* "J�T 8�!A�"# B�* 0\T��& ! ��r��/& +)�/& 9��BA +)�/& 8�)
+-+��.
0(,&B 0�"H� [!� B� "J�T R)!VN �� 8�2 ;b� 0r� [!� B��)8 �6�, ��� K�)8 L,r $� �; �6� ��, ��� K$� +- ��L�$� �) .0(,&B 0�"H� a�$ �� 8�d���
S!"�-� ! �w,�# <$��3 9 �* y��r ��/���0(,&B 0�"H� I/r8�4 �"E& ���� 0E&�� 0*
1 - Snowball Sampling 2 - Grounded theory 3- Glaser & Strauss. 4 - Discovery of Grounded Theory
"# ��"X %�!�" a�\i�$� ���& ! +- .0(,&B 0�"H� 9+�+i�E& S!"�-� ! �w,�# 8�|� $� [!�; ��� B� 0r $� ���"i� �)* 0r �� 0$+* ������� R)!VN B� GH(& ��1;
�&�& +,P�� 0�"H� 9+�A +(r.(cf.Glaser & Strauss, 1967, 1998, 2001) [!� ��0(,&B 0�"H��� 98�;;F ��� K,�6� 98�!A);0�"H� ! ��& $� 0* n5���T� 0r 8� �* 9+�A
+���� �b��w� t�\��� ".�+b� .i6&;;H� �* l;;0�".�� R,N 8��-�;;��� e!"- 90 9+(r B�T �* n�6,�"� �& e!"- 0EP�U& B� 8� (r+ �& B��� ! * 0�"H� 0r +)� 0 ��� 0�,$! �)
��- l�2 ! �"' ���m(cf. Strauss & Corbin, 1998; Corbin & Strauss, 2008) ."H��&B 0,0(�8 ����8 0�@/&�)8 +���8 B �"- 0*�$� ":
~ � ��� "* �(�\&& 8�)$� �(�9 ��� B� �&� +)�/& 8�) q,J�� ! =�!+� �� w,� 8��& ��L�$� G,)�L&+(r.
� � $� �g�"i�$� �-!�.
� � 0�"H� 8�"* �-!��g�&BA 0�"H� 0� ! $� 8B�$.
� � (�\&;& 8"$ |� "* �;*+r KT�"; ��� 8+();i& |� 0g��� 0* 0r $�;?) 0P�; 0��&+&�D��.
� � ��� +&A $+* 0�"H�$�)+&�,N ! 4u&�E� 9<��"- +E* 0$ 8�.
� � 0�"H�0�_�T $� ��,EX�& ! |,�"#�g+��.
� � � �� ������ ,�*�X �2�- 90�"H� �*��B�� ��,E&^$� 0EP�U& ���& ��"� <$�� +,�.
U& ��;,r 4�EP�;\& �L;(�� H� "*;&B 0�";0(,�� 98�;F 6� ! 8�!A;�; ��� K,);0* � -
) ��1;D�� %�&w�;�& �;� -;N 0* �� ��;��+,;� R;H;�"� &;?; ��� �� "i�);�r �; |(r; +((cf. Glaser & Strauss, 1967; 2001; Corbin and Strauss, 2008) . |,(b�
F�� 8�"* ��L�$� ���& +�� ��� 8�!Al,�� 0\T��& 9�)1 $� . l,�� �L,r 0\T��& �,- �*);;;0(,&B 0�"H� 8����� �$�(� ��,?* 98� . a"�(r li6& 9l,�� 0\T��& ��
��� 2�$ 8!� 8"�/,*���� �) .$� +- ��� �� 8�.�L# |� 90\T��& FX�! �� .�"H� [!� ,)�&� 0(,&B ��� ! ��,�6� ��w*� a"�(r ! 8"�YN `�UE�� =,(s 8� �� �)
�& y�D�� +(r .(cf. Charmaz, 2006)F�� ��H(& 0* ��� 8�!A0$ B� �) |,(b�\T��&=��N 8���(/,N l,�� 0(cf.Patton, 2002) +&A K�� 0* ��L�$� "�B �,�"� 0* . ��
$� 8�"* ��r B�WA0P�i& ! G,)�L& 0* �*����$�",W ���.�L# 0\T��& �"b�!� B� �)2 +- ��L�$� .0P�i& ! G,)�L& 0b(�� B� +E* �"b�!� B� ��L�$� �* +�+- ��b-A 0,P!� 8�)
0\T��& �&��� 8��()��39 0P�i&" �� G,)�L& ! �)A+��"# 8",.,N 0\T��& +(� . "&� =��0���� 8��$�� ���& ��D�� w,� 8"H� 8",# 0(,&B 0�"H� [!� ,)�& �* ! ��- 8�
���� 8���B 8��#B�$ .0\T��& ��r t�U2 0b(�� B� >N* �) 00P�i& ! G,)�L& 0�,$! �)$ 9"# Kb-�" =�� ! �T�"1 B�* 45�AT"& �� +(�8"H� e�\-� ��4 �� 0&��� . ��
0�T"& =��9 B� ���+���$� B�* �\T��&5 +&A K�� 0* ��L�$�. �"b�!� �� �$�$� ,P�E0(,&B 0�"H� ��� K,�6� ! 0�wD� �B�T �� 8��& ��D�� �)��- .|,(b� ��L�$� ���& 8�)
�& �)�"b�!� "��$ B� %A w���� ���* �"b�!� =�� ����- . ��_� ���2�$ ��� K,�6� �)0(,&B 0�"H� ��$� 8��Y#+r ��,- 0$ 8�(\& "* 8� :~� 9B�* 8��Y#+r6 � � 8��Y#+r
8��6&7 � � �*�@��� 8��Y#+r8 (cf.Corbin and Strauss, 2008).
1 - In-depth Interview 2 - Informal Conversation Interview 3 - General Interview Guide 4 - Theoretical Saturation 5 - Standardized Open – Ended Interview 6 - Open Coding 7 - Axial Coding 8 - Selective Coding
�& �u1� ��,�6� +(�A" 0* ! $� B�* 8��Y#+r 90�T"& =,P!� 9%A �1 0r ��-P!� G,)�L&,(�\& +�� 45�i& >{$ ! 0� ���$�(- 9���A "* 0�,�2 9 +- %�-��E*� ! �)
��� ���& I/r �) ��-. $� 8��6& 8��Y#+r 90�T"& =,&!� .�� " FX�!A a���� +(�0P�i& 0* �) ���A Z��2 S�$� "* ".�+Q�)0P�i& "�B�)(��Y#+' 98 »8��6&« +,&��
�& 0P�i& ��6& a�T �� 8��Y#+r �"�B 9��-�& 4��_ 8� & 0r �",#0P�i qU$ �� �� �)0�,�2�& <\�"& G) 0* ��E*� ! �)�B�$(cf.Strauss and Corbin, 1998: 123) . =,&�$
$� �*�@��� 8��Y#+r 98��Y#+r 0�T"& .0s��{b� +(�A" 8��Y#+r e�� =�� ! 8B�$0P�i& R�5�N 0�"H� l�2 �� �� �) $� . K&�E� 0D,�� �� "H� ���& �.s��{b�
K,�6��� �* "#�& ����* �B� �b� ! +�A $� ��r KT�"& =�"����-� . �� +��* li6& ���0P�i& =,* +��,N +����* �� �B��"{* l�E� 0* ! ��- �"W �) R�5�N �� ���A 90��� �� �) �"' 0s��{b� G)�* 9����+ +(r ��"@�$� �� 0�"H� n������ ! . �� |� ���- a!+� ��
0��� R@*�@/& +(�A" =�� �) $� +-.
9#$(��(�6� ��2��:
������ ,�*�X ��,E& 0* %+,$� 8�"*1 )g�!� ! ��\��� a��E&� i6� ��,�' 4�i�( B� 9?* ! `��E�& |,(b� 0$,B� +(���\� 0' +&A K�� 0* ��L�$� ��$"& ��:
a!�: a"�('������ <$�� �*����\��� �2(cf. Patton, 2002; Silverman, 2005;
Kval and Brinckman, 2009) :� ���r��/& B� 9[!� = �� +- 0�$��2 %�#+((r0���r 8�)6_ ���& �� ! �"r �*��B�� �� ��+()� "H� %A .
1 - Trustworthiness 2 - Member Check
�!� :0?��i&��,�6� 8�)1 :� ��� ��� 0* 9[!� =2�$ �� +��"# e��� ��2 8�) ��� �* 0�"H� 8+(*��"# �*��B�� ! 0?��i& ��2 8�).
��$ :� B� ��L�$�,�& |,(b8w2 :� ���&B =,0(,&B 0�"H� ��r �� ��@�& +(s 90( 98����L& 98��Y#+r I��@& KT�"& "*+(�-�� 4��H� 45�i& ��"@�$� ! 8B�$.
5(��6��)
$�'��/& 0r $� =�� l,i6� =�� ��_� a� IP�@& >(� 0* \?� %�#+(('� 0* � %�-��2 %�*B»$!� )IP�@& >(� B�(« �� 0��.s#,"8 &���E& 9+(('� ()o� 9
R('N ! �),� +&��R(' =�"* �)8 %A$� 0��.s �)� �' ��1 0*� 8+(*+r 0�T"& �� 9B�*k� ���L&)�B ��0P�i& " ( �P�X �� 0' +�+- ��"@�$�� +(�"# ��"X +�� 0P�i& .
��B� +���* 4��\� +�� 45�i& = :+��B�*�/�#�� 9+(&��w*� t�\��� 9,"8 ��8 ()o� 9�!�$ <*,�)��/ ! a�8 ��D()8 %��$!� !"# . 0�T"& �� +�� 0��# �(N 45�i& =��
��"@�$� 0* �/(�w# 8+(*+r0�?) 0P�i& |� �$�$� ! 8��6& 0P�i& 0r +- "D(&�& K&�- �� l,i6���- . 0�?) 0P�i& � �$�"* =�� �g��� 8��6&»�� ��,?(� 8",#
0��/�+��B�*« $� .�/� 0' $� "'o 0* �B50P�i& ! G,)�L& �2"* =,* 8�7P 0* 0* 8�)$�;[!� "H� 0Ui� B� +&A (,&B 0�"H� �$�(-;0���+� 8��"�� 8� .,*��'; ! =-�; S!"�)k��� ( B�&��s !)k��� (/�"1�2;' %�; �"* �� 0' +��; �2"* ����& 8��,?
& G,)�L&; "�5�* �6U$ �� �� ! 0�� ��' 0* +�� 0P�i& +,P�� �� $� =Q�&; 0P�i);6& ! 0�?;& 8��;& +(s �� c� �* $� =Q�;� 0P�i;� 8���� +�;P 0*�/; 8�7
1 - Analytical Comparison 2 - Auditing
+-�*(cf. Charmaz, 2006; Corbin and Strauss, 2008) . ���- a!+� ��)~( G,)�L&0�?) 0P�i& ! +�� 45�i& 90,P!� 0' au2 �� �"2� �6�,K1 0\T��& ��"@�$� �)
+-$� +- 0g��� 9+�� .* �B50(,&B 0�"H� �� K,�6� +T�! 0' $� "'o 0 `u2"* 98�[!�0(,&B 0�"H� �� K,�6� +T�! 0Q�* �?,� �" 9l,i6� `��E�& 8�) ��,)�L& 8�
0���� %��"� �� 0' +(�?)0���� "* �(�\& 8"H� 8",# ���& ��"� B� +(�+) 8",# +,$� 8"H� e�\-� 0* 0\T��&+�� .
����4 7��8)::( <�)�0� �=��%� ->�����!) �%��� � =
��%�� <�)�0� �%��� ���? �%���
��!) ������� ���� � ����� ��� ������ ��� ��� ����� �� !� "#$ �
%� ���&' ��'�����( )����� * �+������ ��� ,������ ������ )- . � �/0��� 12� - ����� )- ....
�45���6��
@#�A B
/8 � �C���D��
���!
38
����� �7���8� �� ����� ������ %8#9:� ;5�����2� �<=�- ��� �.�> ������ �
- ?5�@...
�2��A�� �����
"#0�B4� ��C� "#:2� � - ' � "�CD ��2 E "#�:2� �� �2#�42$ �C�
�F� #'� �2 E
���5�G�� ���H )�&0 ����&' "I- �8����� ��� �%��'J��K L��%� �-� 6� "�=/0��� 12�
,�#= M��-
"=-� N���� � � � - ' �4�)/0��� 12�( ��� ��=QR$ �#' ��$ ����=-� L- ' #' �$
���!2 ���4���=-� L- '
45�i& B� |� ") 0* ����2� 0* "�B ���(N �& 0�2��"N 0�?) 0P�i& >{$ ! 0��#-
��-.
1 - Microanalysis
"#;( �&�*�����
,�r G,)�L& B� �b� �/�+��B�* +- S�\�X� w�+,# B� 0r $� R)!VN =�� �� 8+$� ./�+��B�* 8!;�� R(r 0��#") `"E& �� �; ���?�& ��-� %A e�� !� 0* ! +���
�& +(r. %+�� �� �B�+�� �� �/�+��B�* ���� ,�r�T ($ 0r %�+& K\X�& ! ��$ 8�)�!� �� �&� 9$� ($ q,J�� ! ",?L�B�* 0* �!+6& 8���B� � 9+�+ �/�+��B�* ,)�&
�& ",,7�+(r .�& >bE(& ".�+b� �� R(r ! 0/�+�� �!� =�� ��� 9+��-^ ����� ! +,� -�� +)��@� �����r ($ ���J �* ".�� �)�"b���)9w�+,# ~��� :Z�� .( ��
0\T��& au2�)8 ��,� ! +- ��D�� l,wD� I��@& KT�"& w��6� ! 0, ��� K "z'� 9�)'��/&� %�#+((' +�+N ���& �»$!�� "�2�1« +�+N =�� �* ��2 8",#�� %�w,& !
�& \6_ T�� ��,2&B5 ! 0�"�YN �� %A 9+��"r� �#+�B�& +(��� .� B��= �� ���A 9!��� �� 8���B +T?(� 8",#, 0*�z& 0* %A B� ! �"r �/�+��B�* ��2 ���c "�(�
$�$�� #+�B� ��2 "&B!��& ���+��"' . ����r��/& =�� B� �b� �� 0' $� %�#+((r��(s Z��2 =,& =��#�+:
»���� �� ���2 Z�2 4���i��� 8"$ |� ���2 =& . B!� %5� 0.* G�* �?r "#���� G(b� �+,N =,i� ���2 �� 9$�G(r �!�* G��� .�&$!� =# )IP�@& >(� B� (�* 9 +�& �2 �P! 9���� ��i��� �� =�� 0�"/,N ���* G) nu&�r ! 0-�* G) y�2 nu&�r 0���
0/*« .
d�X� 3اين -!,R��� <$�� n�i�& ��' 0* 0\T��& ���& %�B�&A�& �L�� ! �P 9+-,��� =Q� %��;(� �;* 0;P�i& =»IP�@& >(� B� $!� «���w.��& =��-.
�& ,�)� ��2 <$�� =,i� 0* %+,$� ! 0*"D� 0* ���� ���& +�+N ���& �� ! +)��$!� ! ���� �����2 �� ��T �/�+��B�* =�� 9$� ��r �/�+��B�* |� a�T �� �6*R
$� 0�"# 4��_ G) .�& 8! 9a�z& 8�"*+��# : »�& G�!��& S�� G) �* �D�!�G,��2 .�& Rb�r =& ���@* |�r =& B� !� "#� G(r
>b�"* �� .�& G) ���!� ���& ! �+N0���� ��,2 ! +(�!�« . r��/& 0r $� >(� !� 0U*�� %+- 8��� 9�/�+��B�* =�� +&�,N ��-� %A 0* +((r
�&+(r .�$�(/��!� G�� B� =�"# |�r �* =,(p�) 9����9 y�s��s �)��!� ! 8�)�& RP�s 0* �� >(� !� t�\��� "* Gr�T+/r:
»y�s��s��A 8"$ 0� �� �) +�5�\X �& 0* 8�)0)�\�-� G) nu&�r ! +�� . [�L2 0.&��* �r %�"�� �- .�"H� 0r ��* 8�"� �"r 4�\]� �� +�!" .+i� �+X =��� �T!�
�"r �� ��r =�� 0r -��« . �^� �* t�\��� 4�!"J "* +,'0�,�2 B� �b� IP�@& >($� !"# =�� 8�) .
=�� �� +,�T�& ��*+��# : »& �E$ =&� RP��E� +T �� �� 8w,s ") G(r]G)+* ��D��[$!� 9 ) >(� B�
IP�@&( RP��E� +T �� G) %!� �P! G-�* 0�-�+� 0r ��+� ��,P� =& "H� 0* G)« . r��/&+((r� $� �"r %��(� w,� 8".�� :»!� nu_� $)IP�@& >(�( 0�-�+���� 9�-�*���@* S�� ����!!«.
+#; ( ��<= ��>- ���� �
r��/& 9��r ��1 0* �()o 8",#�� 9+���� t�\��� IP�@& >(� �* 0r ���#+((r� 8���B,0�7/& B� �b� ��,?(� %���L# ! +���� w+�� 8�)� �& y�?6& ���A��- . =��
�g�?& ��,�6� ��6P B� ,EJ!� & 8�"*r��/�& ��D�� %�#+((r =�� B� �b� �+(r�& �"- =,(s �� ��2 �()o 8",#�� %�#+((r r��/&+)�:
«�& a�7/& n�EX�! !� ��A "b��"r 0*"D� 0r ���2 =& 90(r . 8�"* ��"r �E$ a�7/& !� ��A "b n�EX�! 4���6�&� �� %�s 9��(r ���Y.* �� �)��r =�� n�EX�! 4���6�&�
�&@* 0r 90(r0&��"* 0s ��" 9�(r "b �)���& 8� 9%!",* 8"* [�)�* 98w�"* �)��2��*��� `"T a�7/& !� ��A "b n�EX�! 9�(r "b G��B G) �* 0r ���)�& 0(r« .
r��/&+((r� �& �"- =,(s Sur �� �� ��2 �()o 8",#�� w,� 8".��+)� : »�� �� 4"$?,� �$� .�&0.�� 8�� 0� 9Sur "$ 8��8 . ��" 9��"X�"$ �"* B!"&�
��"X�"$ �"*« . r��/& 9+(�?) ",#�� �()o ��6P B� 0b(�� "* !u� 9Kg�?& =�� �* ",#�� �%�#+((r
\6_ 0r +���� ��"X 8"�?* ! �* |� ������ ��!� ��6& ,?(� �)!"# 8�) . 0*"- 0*�z& 0* ���A a�$ ! =$ G) �%��$!� !"# ! Sur �* ".�� 4��\� K�� �U��
�&+���Y#"]� ���A K*�i�& R(r ! R(r "* 0r +(r .� ��� Z��2 =�Q� '��/& B�(s %�#+((',& =��#�+ :
»\6_=,�) 8!� "�/,* G���$!� ! =& 8�)�)w,s =�� ! "�2� 9$�)« .�� :»v�� 0p* 8"b�Y.* Sur 0.�+�) 8�"* 9 "�2� ���& �� "�/,* 9�)� G��"r %u �& 9+� ...
!��& F�� G) �0(,�) %�- �6* =-« .
9#; (�� )� ?)�� � �0�< �&-
��s�� !"# 8���� 9��- ���� �(,E& !"# =,* �_�2 8���� 8�.P� |� 0r ���&B�& ,E\� 0*+��- .0\T��& K,�6�r��/& 8�) $!� +�+N ",#�� 0r ���#+((r
)IP�@& >(�( �& %�/� +(�?) %��$!� !"# "�?* �� 0r +)��$ub�) ! 8�"* 9�) $!� +�+N �* %+- ",#��)IP�@& >(�( �& ��"X ��/ 6� n���,T� ! +- l��/�-
+�",# .r��/& B� �2"** %�#+((r0 0�) ��-� %�/���$!� %�,& �� +�+N =�� %+- ",#�&+((r :
»0p* =,*�& ���A �* =& 0r ���) B� 9��"#d�� 9+_��d�� %�-+_��] $!� =�-��B� IP�@& >(� [$� ����« 9�� �»0p* +_�� �D(N =,(s a�\�� 0$�+& =�� 8�)
0p* �(E� 9=$ =�� 8�� �P! 9+(�?) ���)��r* ��,2 9��$ Sur 8�), =�� a�\�� "�/+(�?) ��r« .
r��/& =�"# ��"X 8��D() ��/ ���� ���A 8�"* ���)"�?* =,(s �� %�#+((r��� �"�) 0* !"# B� ,E\� ��� .r��/& B� �b� ! ��*�X� ,EJ! %�#+((r
�$ur G) ! %��$!� �!A��/��);�& q,J�� 0��# =�� �� R+)� : »0p* �)]$!� =�-�� 8!� )IP�@& >(�( [�& ����& ��,2+()� . a�\X ��,2 �(E�
�& ���! ��r %��(� 0* �� =�� ! +����+(��� .�& $!� =& 0#)IP�@& >(� ( 9����8��+� ��« .
r��/&�& ",?L� =,(s 8".�� +((r+(r : »0�?/� G) R,N �� ! =&�& I�"E� G��G,(r .�& =& }�2 9��� �� ��B !� �b� G#
�& G) !� �8��+� 9�b� �� "$ ���& G(& 0#��� �� G�B« .
@#; (*� �/�� A��1 �
�& �u1� �1�\��� e�� %A 0* +(&��w*� t�\��� 0P�i&� l�"1 B� 0r ��-8�!�( B� �b-
� ! =L�� �(E� B!� 8�)� �"�) =L�� Z�2 ��1 0* ! �"�(��*�& ���& K_�T K��- .
r��/& +_�� K�s%����"* �* ���A +_�� � 0�\P� 9+(�-�� �"�) =L�� %�#+((r %�-+(�-�� �r�"�-� ,bP�& .K��*�& �&���r��/& 8�) 8���� ! 0�"/,N e�� B� %�#+((r
�\��� 4���b&� G�, Kz&��* �����* ! �$�b� 98���"* . [B�&A %�&B�$ `"1 B� 0s"#� +- e�(�& 0$�+& 0* �"�) =L�� %��!A [�!"N !9 r��/& 0�) �P!%�#+((r 0\T��&
+(�-�� �"�) =L�� ! �& 0$�+& 0* ��2 �* �� %A +- a���� ,��(�& 0* 0��� %!+*-
+���!A .r��/&r�& %�,* n��T�"_ %�#+(("r 9G�, K,\X B� �\��� 8�)�"r��r 0r +��$� ��* %�-"H� ���& "�/,* �����* ! >b� . ��w*� =�� �$�$� 8�)�"r��r B� �b�
r��/& 8�"* �1�\��� =��� 9%�#+((r»%��� ���-« %�/�$!� �* t�\��� 8��"X"* !)IP�@& >(� (��* :
»0p* "zr�+���� K��*�& �& Sur 8�) .1 =,�) 0$�+& 0�) ���- [�)�* "�/,* 9 ���&%�« �� 9�»0p* ��L�$� K��*�& B� t�\��� 8��"X"* 8�"* �)�& +((r« .
K�� 8��BA ! +��"# t�\��� 8��"X"* �� K,�?� ! F�"?� ���* n���?& 0�,$! =������ �"�) 0* 8"�/,* :
»�$!� 0* %��� ���- 8�"* K��*�& 0)IP�@& >(� B�( �-�* 0�-�� K��*�& 9 0.��T�� "�« .
�& w,� �" ������� �.��N �2�- 0�,$! =�� 9�1�\��� �"r��r "* !u�+-�*9 %�(sr��/& B� �b� 0r�& %�#+((r+��# : »�& `"1 nuz&"�2� 0* ���2 �& !� R���*�& ���- 9 +* ���- Sur ��,2 9 � ���« .
2"*;;;r��/& B� �b� 0r �����* l�"1 B� %�#+((r =L�� �\��� 4���b&� B� ��& y�?6& �"�)0(�w) ! ��-�& ��L�$� 9���+�"* �� G) 8�+((r . �� "�/,* [!� =��
���� �"*��r ���- 8�)�� .�& q,J�� 0��# =�� ���& =�� �� +,�T+)� : »%�b& 8�"*�& 0r ���- 8�)0(�w) ,) 9s Kz& ��� ��P�T 0� 9%� 9 ��+� G) 8�
�* �&�7,N 0�*;;;;;0.�� K��*�& 0* ������& 8� %!� ! +(�$"]"�2� [�& a�\X 0#� 90��2�& R�* 0r !� ��7,N 9�"r y��� 90$��& �«.
0HTu& K*�X 45�6� 9%+- ����� 8�)+&�,N B� �b� %��(� 0* �"�) =L�� �� 8���r��/& ��,?(� 8",#$� �"r ��D�� %�#+((r .# ��L�$� ! �!�! B� K\X �"�?
��!+6& IP�@& >(� �* t�\��� 8��"X"* 9�1�\��� ��w*� =�� B� ���b& ! ���&B 8�)-�� �_�2 .= =�� B� ��L�$���!+6& B� 8�!A aui�$� 90�$�r ���b& ! ���&B 8�)
0HTu& K*�X ��" ! ! $� �"r +,P��B�* �� 8+�+� �#+�B 8�.P� ! ��� �" 0* 8��& "H� 0*�+X� +$� ��w*� =�� B� ��L�$� ��!+6& �� �� w,� [�!"N ! [B�&A 4�&
$� ��\� �/.)�� %�+(s .G�, +)�/&>b� ! �) =L�� l�"1 B� �?(� }"6& 8�)�� +�+/� 0* "D(& ! +- �_��2 9 �"�)8",#�& ��,?(� 8�)��- . "&� =��
8+�+� 8�� ���& l�2 >(� !� =,* <*�!� ��+(r .
B#; (C��) �*�����
0\T��& K,�6�r��/& =,* <*�!� 0r ��� %�/� �)%�/���$!� �* %�#+((r ) >(�IP�@&($��Y# ! ��X�& n��+�� 9 .r��/& B� �b� ��(� �+_�� 8+� ��1 0* %�#+((r
��* ��!�B� �� t�\��� �!�+� .a�X Ki�$� <*�!� 8��+��N�� +��& "�B 8�).
»]<*�!� =�� [��� ��!� ��,2�� � .��,2+(�?) �) 0' �& �E$ �� �� <*�!� =�� +((r�+- %��,/N �P! G�-�� �� "b =,�) G) =& +���� 0.� "�� "2A«.
»+- $!� 0.�� �b� �* � +E* 9��* =& �* a�$!� R,b�«. r��/& B� �b� S!",$�$!� �* t�\��� 0r $� ���#+((r R)IP�@& >(� B�( ��
�& ��X�&+��� .r��/& =���& a5+�$� =,(s <*�!� =�� %��* ��X�& ���& �� +((r-
+(r : »�& !� =,�) %5� "#� 9G/* ��bs =& ?,� �@/& %5� G#]��!�B� 8�"* [
G/* "�5�* =�� B� ! G��@* G���* G) +��- �� G/* "��r =�� B� 0(b�& ��" G(r y�@���« . (�A ������� ,EX�& ! ��7- ��) %��\� �@/& S!",$ + B� �b� �� [�
�& ���5�R�$!� �* ��!�B� �� t�\��� �!�+� B� F��& 0r +��� )IP�@& >(�( �&��- .r��/& "��$ ! S!",$ ! +���� �)�#A ��Y# %��!� �� ��2 =�"# ��"X B� %�#+((r
�& +�� R@* 0r +(��� +(�A ����) 45�6� B� 8�[u� !"# �� %�- B!"&� 8�)$���A . =,(s ��r��/& 0�?�B 0*"D� �U��"-�& GbT %�#+((r ���� 0* 0r +(r
R(r ! +(�B $� ��6& +(�A �/�+��B�* +(�A 45�6� 0* 0��� �* �� ��2 ��E 8�)�#+�B �����+()� ��D�� %�- .
�;;; 8��+��N�� �� ���w$ 0* Ri� 9=,"1 B� �b� �(b- %��,N 9�� K&��� "* !u���� <*�!� .& B� �b�r��/�& ��* =�� �� %�#+((r+��# :
»+- $!� 0.�� �b� �* � +E* 9��* =& �* a�$!� R,b�« . r��/& 8�"* ,EJ! =�� +�� +&�,N$� 8V��"�$� ",,7� 9 +((r . ��L�� =�� B� >N
0,_�� R���$!� 0* 8!�& +((r Kz& 0* 0�*�i& 0r +(r :
» �r ") 0* +E* 0* =�� B�]G���$!� B� [r�& 0�& %�/�* G$� 9 ��Y.* %�-��r"$ G# %�s�& �& ��r"$ !����!� "�2� 0r G�!� ��Y#« .
r��/& B� �b� +�+N 0* %�#+((r* 8� 0 ���»5�r $!� �.��#)IP�@& >(� B�(« �& ��-�+(r :
»%�/�$!� 0* 5�r |� Kz& 9+(-�* ��,�_ ��,2 0#� %��$!� F�� ) >(� ��H(&IP�@& (& �.��+((r .�& ¡�� 0/,�)+((r .�&�� a�& %!� ! =& a�& =�� 0# . 0&��� =&
�$!� ��i,� B� �b� R)IP�@& >(� B�( �"r ¡�� [�i,� B� �b� =)�",N �* ��« .
E( �� � F����GA�#@
� ���$�"* =9� 0P�i& 0�?)»��,?(� 8",# �� +��B�*�0��/1« ! ��W�� K_�T� �� +�� 0P�i& �(N �,r"�$ .E� ��,,� =�E& 0* 0�?) 0P�i& =,�)��8 Z�2
w#�B �"- 0* 0�?) 0P�i& R(�$� +- 0��� ": IP� :��w���� �' !� ") +����* ! +-�*�g�(E& "H� B� %�Q&� +T �� �� 45�i& B� c�
+)� R-�N. y :�6� 4�+X,�� ��(� ! +-�* 0�-���_�� 0P�i& c,L� +-�\� ��$ !. � :��!�" 0*� � �� ���)8 P!�,�$ B� 08 '��/&'�� ���& ! +- ��"Q� %�#+((', +
+-�* 0�"# ��"X. � :"��\1 %�,E� 0\T��&+-�* +- `�UE& %A �$ 0* n��+�� �).
1- +��B�* 3�! 0s"#� 0*�z& 0* G) 9�/�'"� �� G) ! 9 +�� 0P�i& c, B�&��s "H� B� 9$� 0�"# ��"X "H�+& 0�?) 0P�i& �)����(*��' 9,S!"�-� ! =)���� (� �-!� ��6P B��0' ���+� ¢��" � Ri� +����* ���L& c� � �� +;�� 0;P�i& c ;,� w� �;L
! 9 �"'� ��'"� �� +�� 0P�i& c,� 0�?) 0P�i& �,�!� ��' 0* w .
� S�$� "*�"z'� 90P�i& =��$�N %���#R��� 8B�",- B�&A+�+N ���& ��� » $!�)IP�@& >(�(« �,- 0*K?� B� 4!�L�& 8��)8 N,/, =/�+��,�"r K�� ! + �+� . ��+E�
r��/& B� 8���B[B�� `u2"* %�#+((r B�&A ! �)������ 8�)�.()" 9� �T !� ��i���8 ��2 IP�@& >(� 0* \?� ��($ K�� B� 8+�+� �i�� ! �"'A0�-�� %+�� .
B�&A `u2"* ! �P�� ��,?* 8B"1 0* �* ���2"* ! \6_ 0' ����& ��($ 8�)IP�@& >(� ,��(�& �2"* 8���� ! 0��# �*�� ��Q- 0* �� �i�� �"� ! �Xu2� 8�)
�& 9+('%�/�$!� ���& �� ���A )IP�@& >(� B� ��H(&( 0* ! �"' \6_ ��T�� 0*+���* Z��2 =�� �� +�+� 0*"D� a�\�� .%��)0\T��& %��& �� 0' ��1 0* w,� 8�
�,*"D� %�#+((' '��/& 9$� +- %��(� T�"_ ! q�"/� �� ��2 ��@- 4 ���� w,� �*��B�� �� %A ����& 8��,?* �� ! �"' �g���B�*+�� . +�+� ��,?(� 4�,*"D�
0' $� ��* ��+- ! E$! %�(s 8���� ��"� =�� B� �2"* 8�) �����2 �# ��Tr��/&%�#+((r90�$��2�� �� 0�$��2 9 +&A ��(r +�+N =�� �* w,�+�� . B� 8��+E��N�$ - %���#y�s��s +i� 0*�)8 ������� .()" !� 0E&�� "* G'�T ��($�"N�0�2 ! +��
G�& �� IP�@& >(� �* t�\��� =�-�� 0r =�� "� �,- 0* I��@& 8�) ! 0�-�+(N 8�!"J �#+�B +�+� �,- |� %��(� 0* �� %A %�+& "�� ��?L�,B�� ! "�*�� 0�"�YN ! �"'-
+�� . �);�%B a+& 0' 0��#&,0(�8 ���-� �& %�/� c���D() ��/ +)�8 �$!� !"#�
�Q� �"- B��x�� <� &B,0(�"* B�$8 ��* t�\��� ��D,$� >(� !� =. ����D() ��/ =8 * ��,�$!� !"# =� * 0s ! %!�� 0s,�� B� %!"8 $! 0(&�� 0$�+&,E� �� R��� ! 0�-
� ��,?(� ! �?(�+ ��"X ���A S"�$� �� 8+��& +)� .�� 9%�,& =��0��$� ��1 0* ! �) 9Z�2 ���!� ���)�&,� "* w�+N =�& =&�� +�+(�B . +�+� F*�(& =,(s �* ��+�&� ��
R(' ! R���1�\��� ��w*� 9� +�� ��$ �� <*�!� ��(� 0� 9+& T�� ! "���B�$9 0Q�*4��H� 9�)��/a"�(' 9�)��� ! �),���2�$ 4�+8 �,(� 0�*�i& Z��2 �� 0E&�� � �*� =
+N�� �� +,& KX�+T 0* w�+��$� . �b� %��(� 0* 9 �"�) =L�� �(E� 9+�+� �1�\��� ��w*�83�P�(b� B�83�P�(b� �* 0?��i& �� %A ,�)� �� 0* 0r �1�\��� ! ����u1� 8�) 8�)
�� %A �2"* 9".�� �1�\��� »�&w���r 83�P�(b�1« +,&�� =,* <*�!� �� �".- a�6� 9+��%�?��r��/& =,* �� =�� �� ! �)$� ��!A ���! 0* IP�@& >(� ! %�#+((r . "z'�
'��/&� B� %�#+(('�3�P�(Q� =8 &��� ! +���* �����2"*� �.�$��)8 ��L�$� ���&3�P�(Q� 0* w�D& ���A8�)�� *�!� 9�����* %�s,=9 $�& R@N !,i� ��* .� B� ���A� =
�"* ��(� 0� ��w*�8 ��"X"*8 ���t�\ 9+�+� 4�,*"D� 8�"* 8"�?* ! �"* 0Q�*8 �?'�N������� �.� �) !�� ��2 ,& ��L�$� w�+��"' . �!�! 0(,&B +�+� �1�\��� ��w*� =��
4�,*"D� 98B�D& �?(� <*�!� 8�� %��(� 6� %�+& 0/�+�� �� 0' ���Q& 0*" ! ���W 0/,�) ���T 9+(& 0U$�!� �& G)�" �� $� ,EX�!�B�$. �()o 8��
r��/& $!� +�+N �* ",#�� �%�#+((rIP�@& >(� B�0�7/& B� +(rA 9 8�) ! �?(� ! $� ��,?(� =,* ��r��/& B� 0�$� =��%�#+((r9 \6_ ,?(� �)!"# 8�)���� ��!� ��6& .Kb- ���* %A B� �-�� 4u&�E� ! 4�"bL� =�� ��!� ��/ 8",#
$ur G) ! %��$!� !"# 8��D()� �)�& -� 0r � ��2 0*�� 0* 0* ����! �� !"# 8�����& !"# 4���H��� ! ���� B� ,E\�+(r.
d� ��' ¢3�P�(Q�� �&w(Charisma Technology) K£�*�& ¢3�P�(Q� 0* e���� ¢�"* 0' $� �TuU_�
�& ��' 0*1 ¢���� 0' �!�,3�P�(Q� 4���Q&� B� ���(�& I�N 9�����* 9=L�� K&�- �Q, ���;_ 4���Q&� 9 ���' ����� !�$� ¢" .
N,�"- +�� +&��" ! <A��)+(8 +- �6*9 (&�+��B�* 0* ��/� �� ��#,"8 ?(�,�� '��/&�"# %�#+(('�+ .+��B�*�/��8 � 0'�($ ! 0�-Y# 0* `�UE& ". �)
�,?9 ()" 0* `�UE& 0Q�*¤�)8 ����� ��!�& !8 a��6& ��2 0' $�)B"&����� .()" 0��-� ! %+-� $� .��+��B�* =�/� B�&A ���)8 ��(� ������ !�
�"* ! 0�"# 4��_8 +\� 0EP�U& ���& !"#� 0* K ���� ¤()" �"2 8��,?* �� !+J ����&� ¤()"$� +- .+��B�*�/� �� ��#,"8 ?(�,�� n��+D& ��2 �"-� < !
"A��)+(8 ��#,"8 ?(�,�� P��B�* ��,+N ! �"' +�W KQ- 0* �6* ���& +,�$�"� !� ! /N ��8 0(6_�)8 T 0* 0E&��,& 0&��� ��2 4��+)� .
�� ��, 9��'Y& 4u&�E� 0D�(E� #��,"8 ��8 ()o� '��/&%�#+(('9 +(&��w*�E� P��$ ! %+-,,7� ! =,,�� 9<*�!� "#,"8 ?(�,�� �/&'� n�&��� 9%�#+(('
$,�N�� 9a����+9 #+�B au2 �� ! ��* awPw�& !� 5� 0* "&B!�� n��"Q& 4!�L�& K+��B�*�/� &���- .N,�"- +&��N 9��'Y& 4u&�E� ! <,�+���� R� $ <*�!�, ! a� �*4�\] * ��,$� "?N ! "�2� >(� !� = . �6* ���& 8�)+&�,N ! 4u&�E� 9<��"-
0P�i& ��6& a�T ��������N a+& |� �P�X �� 0�?)) ���- a+&~ ( +- G,$"� 0r +��� lU(&��� e�� =#,"8 ?(�,�� +��B�*�0��/9 !� B�� �"Q&�*� &� !, c ���& ��"�0EP�U&9 ��� 0*�/' ",$� +- +.
شانه پسران نسبت به يبازاند يتيجنس يريگجهت ):1(شماره يانهيمدل زم
دختران
فشار
هنجاري گروه
دوستي
درگيري
فضاي ذهني
روابط
سيالارتباط
ابزارمند
بازانديشي
گيري جهت
جنسيتي
T 0EP�U&",?L� �"b�!� 8",#��r 0* �* "J� B� 0r $� 0�-�� �E$ ������� ���"#�"- 0* ",#�� "?N %�B�&A R��� �"b�!�� +(�A" 9< /�� 8�)+&�,N ! 4u&�E�#,"8
?(�,�� �B��"{* %�"�2� 0* \?� %�"?N .[!� B� ��L�$� �* ��$�� =�� �� ! �L,r �$�(-0(,&B 0�"H� ��w*�0�"H� 98�X�& 8� }�� B� |,�"#�g+�� ! ���"i�$� 9Z�2 9��,E
'��/&((';;;P�@& >(� 0* \?� %�#+;;+- ��� $+* I . FX�! �� 0�"H� =��'��/& G� ! �*��B�� y��B�*�� B� %�#+(('#,"8 ?(�,�� $� ��* ���A ��2 . ��
[!� lU(& S�$� "* li6& 9�D(��$� 9��"@�$� 8�"* 8��w*� ��(� �L,r �$�(- 98+(* 0� S�bE�� !)!���# 0��#!� K,w�+8 ( %��� :� a�T �� 0EP�U& %�+,& �� 0r $� 8w,s %A$� ��* .
� ��-D���
� ¥�+\� 98+$�)~���(9 » �./��� �� "?N ! "�2� %���D/��� <*�!� �$�"*K,*��� "�- 8�)«9 �@:5
��@�L ,����� �"-I 9/@� <�;�3�� ���� .[ 9G/- �!�� .�_.~~�� ~~�.
� �����A 9w�+,# )~���( 9»���3��5 '��5�� « 9)�]u] =?6&(wr"& "/� 9a!� ¦�s 9%�"�� 9. � �")B 9�L$��� �J�+�6& 98+*��� ")�1+,�T 9$!� t�/�)~���(9 » "�- =�+P�! [".� �$�"*
%�"?N ! %�"�2� 0���$!� <*�!� 0* \?� %��L_�«9 ��� <��/3�1 �5�$@D+ . [ ��$ a�$~� .�_ :���� ��~.
� �J"&uW 98��LW)~���(9 »[B�� ! <*�!��"�� %����� ������� 8�)��«9 %�)A�B5 �5�$@D+
.�3�/� .[ � !�9 %��?*�� .�_ :�� ��. � +,D& 9+T�&� "7_� ��� 9S+i&� �i�+�6& 98B��- �$�\�)~���(9 »0E&�� ! %����� 9 �����2 -
8"�YN«9 .�3�/� %�)A�B5 �5�$@D+9 [� !�9 �?*��%�9 �_ :�����.
� Berg, B. (2006), “ Qualitative Research Methods for the Social
Science”s, New York: Allyn and Becon.
� Blaikie, N. (2007), “Approaches to Social Inquiry”, London: Polity
Press.
� Brewer, J. (1998), “Ethnography”, London: Open University Press.
� Carr, N. S. (2001), “Gendered Holiday Behavior: A Case Study of
University Students”. In: S. Colyer and K. James, ANZALS: Leisure
futures, leisure cultures. 3rd Women in Leisure International Conference,
Fremantel, (). 5-6 July, 2001.
� Charmaz, K. (2006), “Grounding Grounded Theory: A Practical Guide
Through Qualitative Analysis”, London: Sage Publication.
� Corbin, J. and A. Strauss, (2008), “Basics of Qualitative Research”,
Third Edition, London: Sage Publications.
� Crotty, M. (1998), “The Foundations of Social Research: Meaning and
Perspective in the Research Process”, London: Sage Publication.
� Denzin, N. and Y. Lincoln. (2005), “The Sage Handbook of Qualitative
Research”, London: Sage Publication Ltd.
� Ekins, Richard, (1997), “Male Femaling: A Grounded Theory
Approach to Cross-Dressing and Sex-Changing: Grounded Approach to Cross-dressing and Sex-changing”, Rutledge Press.
� Eley, Diann and Kirk, David (2004), “Gender and Citizenship
Potential in Adolescent Students”. In: Katsikitis, Mary, Proceedings of
the 39th Annual Australian Psychological Society Conference. The 39th
Annual Australian Psychological Society Conference: Psychological
Science in Action, Melbourne, Victoria, (94-98). 29 September - 3
October, 2004.
� Esterberg, K. G. (2002), “Qualitative Research Methods and Process”,
Second Edition, London: Open University Press.
� Fetterman, David M.(1998), “Ethnography Step by Step”, Second
Edition. London: Sage Publications.
� Gabrium Jaber, and Holestein, James.(1997), “The New Language of
Qualitative Research”, London: Sage Publications Ltd.
� Gabrium, Jaber F. and James A. Holstein, (2001), “Handbook of
Interview Research”, London, Sage Publication.
� Glaser, B. and Anselm Strauss.(1967), “Discovery of Grounded Theory”,
Transaction Publishers, U.S. Publisher.
� Glaser, B. (1978), “Theoretical Sensitivity”, Sociology Press.
� Glaser, B. (1998), “Doing Grounded Theory: Issues and Discussions”,
Sociology Press.
� Glaser, B. (2001), “The Grounded Theory Perspective:
Conceptualization Contrasted With Description”, Sociology Press.
� Guba, E. G. and Y. S. Lincoln (2005), “Paradigmatic Controversies,
Contradictions, and Emerging Confluences”, In N. K. Denzin & Y. S.
Lincoln (Eds.), “Handbook of qualitative research” (3rd ed., pp. 191–
215). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
� Guba, E. G. (1991), “Paradigm Dialog”, Newbury Park, CA, Sage.
� Hammersley, M. and P. Atkinson (2007), “Ethnography: Principles in
Practice”, Second Edition, New York: Rutledge Press.
� Haswell, Sandra (2002), “Male-Female Differences and Media Consumption in Australia's Wartime Election of 2001”. In:
International Conference on Social Sciences, Hawaii, (). 11-15 June,
2002.
� Hewitt, Belinda, Western, Mark and Baxter, Janeen (2006), “Who
Decides? The Social Characteristics of Who Initiates Marital Separation”. Journal of Marriage and Family, 68 5: 1165-1177.
� Kvale, Steinar and Svend Brinkmann, (2009), “InterViews: Learning the
Craft of Qualitative Research Interviewing”, Second Editions, Sage
Publications.
� Lafferty, Yvonne (2007-08), “For the Boys: A Qualitative Study of
Women's Gender Strategies and Emotional Labour in Professional Boxing”, PhD Thesis, School of Social Science, the University of
Queensland.
� Lee, K. S. and Trost, S. G. (2006), “Physical Activity Patterns of
Singaporean Adolescents”. Pediatric Exercise Science, 18 4: 400-414.
� Lincoln, Y. S., and E. G. Guba, (1985). Naturalistic inquiry, Thousand
Oaks, CA: Sage.
� Maxwell, J. (2004), “Qualitative Research Design: An Interactive
Approache”, Second Edition, London: Sage Publications.
� Neuman, L. (2006). “Social Research Methods: Quantitative and
Qualitative Approaches”, Third Edition. London: Allyn and Bacon.
� Neuman, L. (2007), “Basics of Social Research: Qualitative and
Quantitative Approaches”, Second Edition, Allyn & Bacon.
� Patton, M. (2001). “Qualitative Research & Evaluation Methods”,
London: Sage Publication Ltd.
� Punch, Keith, (2004), “Introduction to Social Research; Quantitative
and Qualitative Approaches”, London: Sage Publications Ltd. � Ritchie, J. and J. Lewis,(2005), “Qualitative Research Practice: A Guide
for Social Science Students and Researchers”, London: Sage
Publication
� Silverman, D. (2005). “Doing Qualitative Research”, London: Sage
Publication.
� Schutt, R. (2004). “Investigating the Social World: the Process and
Practice of Research”, Fourth Edition. London: Pine Forge Press.
� Strauss, Anselm and Juliet Corbin, (1998), “Basics of Qualitative
Research”, Second Edition, London: Sage Publications.
Recommended