12
1 10 SIe[1?:>sl'ddns 10d .S~U!'e1~SUO:>S.l0~:>!P~l~UO:> 'dld!~lnm S'd:>~J U'd~O ~! pue "d~'dldmo:> dN S! ~! 'S'd:>ue~SU! [1?:>!~:>~ld 1[1? ~Somre uI .m'dlq01d ~ln:>HJ!p 'dlOm pU~ 'dlOm ~ ~U! -mo:>'dq S! SlOSS'd:>01d01:>!m UO ~u!lnp'dq:>s Uo!~:>n1~Sur o~ aA!~!SUaS aq ~SnUI laInpatps poo~ V .SUO~1;}1U1SU~ P~;}Vld~.J,dS~UaUIal!nbal re!~'eds asaq~ q~!/t\ SUO!~;)nl~SU! ll'e;) aA\ .[f1I] la~snI;) ~Ua~S!SUO;) 'e o~ padd'eUI aq ~SnUI sasn pu'e SUO!~!U!Jap S~! 'SUo!.'aal ~u!Inpaq;)s SS01;)'e aA!I S! anreA 'e uaq/t\ 'pUo;)as .[f;I '9 '~] SUOS'eal a;)U'eUI -10Jlad 10J 10 SSaU~;)al10;) 10J laq~!a 'sla~SnI;) ;)!J!;)ads Uo S}{Ut!q A10UIaUI SSa;);)'e ~SnUI SUO!~;)nl~SU! Sa10~SpU'e sPt!°I aUIOS '~Sl!..!1 .Sa;)lnoS o/t\~ UIO.IJ as!l'e S~UaUIal!nb -al asaqJ, .S~UaUIal!nbal re!~t!ds ;)!J!;)ads aAt!q Saln~ -;)a~!q;)l'e It!!~t!ds Uo SUO!~;)nl~SU! aUIOS 'UO!~!PP'e UJ .alnSSald la~S!~al U! aSt!al;)U! pU'e 'UO!~Ua~UO;) a;)lnoSal UO!~'e;)!U -nUIUIO;) reUO!~!ppt! 'sAt!Iap UO!~'e;)!UnUIUIO;) Al'eSSa;)aUUn UIO.IJ ~sOI aq ut!;) saI;)A;) 'pal!Sap U'eq~ At!/t\'e laq~'eJ a;)U'e~ -S!P JO ~!Un aUO paInpaq;)s S! UO!~;)nl~SU! re;)!~!l;) 'e J! ~nH .~sOI S! aI;)A;) auo Aluo 'pal!Sap U'eq~ la~'eI aI;)A;) auo paIn -paq;)s S! UO!~;)nl~SU! re;)!~!l;) t! JI .a~~S!UI re10dUIa~ llt!UIS t! U'eq~ AI~SO;)a10UI AIrelaua~ S! a~~S!UI re!~t!ds llt!UIS t! asnt!;)aq '~u!Inpaq;)S re10dUIa~ U'eq~ UIaIq01d ~In;) -HJ!P a10UI t! Apt!alre S! JIas~! Aq ~u!Inpatps It!!~'edS .jJO. -apt!l~ S!q~ JO aIdurnxa ut! S/t\oqS I al~!..!1 .A~!re;)°I pU'e UIS!IaIrel'ed uaa/t\~aq jJOapt!l~ lad01d aq~ pU'e~SlapUn o~ St!q lalnpaq;)s aq~ 'SUO!S!;)ap ~U!Uo!~!~d a~UI OJ, .UIaIq01d re10dUIa~ 'e pU'e UIalq01d re!~t!ds t! q~oq SaUIO;)aq ~u!Inpaq;)s UO!~;)nl~S -U! 'snqJ, .Sa;)lnoSal ~U!~ndUIO;) aq~ SS01;)~ SUO!~;)nl~S -U! UO!~!~l'ed o~ S'eq laInpaq;)s UO!~;)nl~SU! aq~ 'Saln~;)a~ -!q;)lt! asaq~ UO .sAt!Iap JO saI;)A;) a10UI 10 auo In;)U! Ut!;) Sa;)lnoSal ~U'e~S!P uaa/t\~aq UO!~t!;)!UnUIUI°:) .sa;)lnoS -al ~U!~ndUIO;) l!aq~ a~nq!l~S!P ~'eq~ Saln~;)a~!q;)lt! al'e Saln~;)a~!q;)lt! It!!~t!dS .[~I] sda'II pU'e '[~~] S10SSa;) -old P!lD '[f1~] /t\1:111 'sM1'IA pala~snI;) apnI;)U! Saln~ -;)a~!q;)lt! It!!~t!ds JO saldurnx3 .pa~t!;)!IdUIO;) a10UI UaAa S! ~u!Inpaq;)S Uo!~;)nJ~SU! 'Saln~;)a~!q;)l~ I'e!~~ds uO .sU!ds la~S!~al JO laqUInu a~l'eI t! o~ ~u!pt!aI ~noq~!/t\ alq!SSOd S'e d'II tpnUI S'e ~!OId -xa /t\oqaUIOs ~SnUI lalnpaq;)s UO!~;)nl~SU! aq~ 'saInpatps poo~ a~t!laUa~ OJ, .alnSSald la~S!.'aal laq~!q put! Sa~Ut!l aA!I la~U01 aAt!q OSre (d'IV UIs!IaIrel'ed IaAaI UO!~;)nl~S -U! a10UI asodxa ~t!q~ sa;)uanbas apo:) .alnSSald la~S! -~al put! UIS!Iallt!l~d al'e sanss! Alt!UI!ld o/t\~ aq~ 'SM1'IA UO!~on po.l~uI I .;}.Ln1~1~'1{:>.lV MI7A p;}.L'd1Snl:> V Uo s'dnb~u'1{:>'d1 6u~lnp'd'1{:>s puv 1U'dm -u6~ssv 1.LV-'d'1{1-Jo-'d1V1S .l'dao % n Jo 1U'dm'dao.ldm~ uv puV ' .lOSS'd:>O.ld mvH 'd'1{1 Jo .l'dlnp'd'1{:>s 'dm~1-'d:>vds 6u~1S~ -X'd 'd'1{1 .l'dao % 19 Jo 1U'dm'dao.ldm~ 'd:>uvuuof.l'dd 'd6v.l'dav uv U~V1qo 01 'dlqv s~ 6u~lnp'd'1{:>s 1U'd6.l'daUO{) .1U'dmu6~ssv .l'd1Snl:> P'dU~UU'd1'dP'd.ld 'l{1~m SUO~1:>n.l1SU~ ;}.LV 'I{:>~'1{m 'SUO~1 -:>n.l1SU~ P'd:>vld'd.ld 01 'dnp S1U~V.l1SUO:> SV 11'dm sv 'UO~1 -vz~m~u~m UO~1v:>~unmmo:> puV '6u~:>uvlvq pv01 'ms~I'd11v -.lvd sv 'I{:>ns S1U~V.l1SUO:> IVUO~1~PV.l1 'dlpuv'1{ fi11njss'd:>:>ns 01 'dlqv s~ 1l .'dU~'1{:>vw MI7A p'd.l'd1snl:> v puv .lOSS'd:>O.ld mvH 'd'1{1 :S'd.ln1:>'d1~'1{:>.lV Iv~1Vds om1 01 6u~lnp'd'1{:>s 1U'd6.l'da -Uo:> P'd~lddv 'dav'1{ 'dM .s:>~1s:t.ln'd'1{ 1U'd.l'd1T~p 6u~d01'da'dp -0:> puV S1U~V.l1SUO:> 'dld~nnm 6u~lpuv'1{ Jo m'dlqo.ld 'd'1{1 s'd.if~ldm~s 6u~lnp'd'1{:>s 1U'd6.l'daUO:> ' .l'd'1{10 'I{:>V'd 'l{1~m 1:>V.l'd1 -U~ 01 'd:>VJ.l'd1U~ 'dUO filuo PUV1S.l'dpun 01 p'd'dU puV 1U'dP -u'dd'dpu~ 'd.lV s'dssvd 11v 'dsnv:>'dEI .S1U~V.l1SUO:> 1UV1.LOd -W~ 'd'1{1 11v S'd.ifS~1VS 1V'1{1 'dlnp'd'1{:>s v 'd:>npo.ld UV:J .l'dln -p'd'1{:Js 1U'd6.l'daUO:J 'd'1{1 'S1U~W1SUO:J 1uva'dl'd.l 'd'1{111v SS;}.Lp -pv 1V'1{1 s'dssvd Jo S'd:t.l'dS V 6u~filddv fiEI .S'd:>U'd.l'dJ'd.ld 'dS'd'1{1 6U~fij~pom fiq S'd1V.l'ddo ssvd V .s1°1s 'dm~1 puv 'd:Jvds 'dld~nnm .lOJ S'd:>u;}.L'dJ'd.ld sv 11'dm sv 'S'd:>u;}.L'dJ;}.Ld s1~ Jo 'd:>U'dp.ifUO:> 'd'1{1 ss;}.Ldx'd 01 ssvd v smo11v 'd:>VJ.l'd1 -U~ 'd'1{1 'PV'd1SU~ :'d1nI0sqv 10U 'd.lV S'd:>U;}.L'dJ;}.Ld .UO~1 -:In.l1SU~ 'I{:JV'd .lOJ 'd:Ju;}.l;}J;}.Ld IV.lOdw;}1 puv Iv~1Vds s;}p~a -O.ld 1V'1{1 'd:JVf.l'd1U~ uowmo:> "dldm~s V ;}.Lv'1{s s;}ssvd 'd'1{.L .1U~V.l1SUO:> .l0 W;}lqO.ld .lvln:J~1.Lvd V S;}SS'd.lppV 1V'1{1 :>~1 -s:t.ln;}1{ V 6u~1U'dm'dldm~ 1{:>V'd 's'dssvd 1U;}pu'dd'dpu~ Jo p'dSodwo:J S~ .l;}lnp'd1{:Js 1U'd6.l'daUO:> V .S'd.ln1:J;}1~1{:>.lV IV~1 -vds Uo 6u~lnp'd1{:>s UO~1:>n.l1SU~ puV 1U'dmu6~ssv .l'd1Snl:> .lOJ :y.lOm;}WV4 IV.l;}u'd6 v s~ 6u~lnp;}'1{:>s 1U;}6.l;}aUO{) ':J.:>~.I':J.sqv npa.':j.!w.SJI..'J~J@{ u~w~s 'UOSUaMSS'0.'Ja!p ":j.I~M} A.'J%uqJa.L Jo a':j.n':j.!':j.suI s':j.':j.asnqJ~ss~W aq.'JU!S~l~WV U~W~S 'UOSUaMS au~qs 'u!ddnd o.'Ja!G 'aa'I la':j.I~M Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

Convergent scheduling - Microarchitecture, 2002. (MICRO-35). …hpc.isti.cnr.it/~diego/papers/micro_2002.pdf · 2014. 9. 10. · -uedepu! Jo pesodwo:> S! Jelnpeq:>s ~Ue~JeAUO:> V

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 1

    10 SIe[1?:>sl'ddns 10d .S~U!'e1~SUO:> S.l0~:>!P~l~UO:> 'dld!~lnm

    S'd:>~J U'd~O ~! pue "d~'dldmo:> dN S! ~! 'S'd:>ue~SU! [1?:>!~:>~ld1[1? ~Somre uI .m'dlq01d ~ln:>HJ!p 'dlOm pU~ 'dlOm ~ ~U!

    -mo:>'dq S! SlOSS'd:>01d01:>!m UO ~u!lnp'dq:>s Uo!~:>n1~Sur

    o~ aA!~!SUaS aq ~SnUI laInpatps poo~ V .SUO~1;}1U1SU~

    P~;}Vld~.J,d S~UaUIal!nbal re!~'eds asaq~ q~!/t\ SUO!~;)nl~SU!ll'e;) aA\ .[f1I] la~snI;) ~Ua~S!SUO;) 'e o~ padd'eUI aq ~SnUI

    sasn pu'e SUO!~!U!Jap S~! 'SUo!.'aal ~u!Inpaq;)s SS01;)'e aA!I

    S! anreA 'e uaq/t\ 'pUo;)as .[f;I '9 '~] SUOS'eal a;)U'eUI

    -10Jlad 10J 10 SSaU~;)al10;) 10J laq~!a 'sla~SnI;) ;)!J!;)ads

    Uo S}{Ut!q A10UIaUI SSa;);)'e ~SnUI SUO!~;)nl~SU! Sa10~S pU'e

    sPt!°I aUIOS '~Sl!..!1 .Sa;)lnoS o/t\~ UIO.IJ as!l'e S~UaUIal!nb

    -al asaqJ, .S~UaUIal!nbal re!~t!ds ;)!J!;)ads aAt!q Saln~

    -;)a~!q;)l'e It!!~t!ds Uo SUO!~;)nl~SU! aUIOS 'UO!~!PP'e UJ

    .alnSSald

    la~S!~al U! aSt!al;)U! pU'e 'UO!~Ua~UO;) a;)lnoSal UO!~'e;)!U

    -nUIUIO;) reUO!~!ppt! 'sAt!Iap UO!~'e;)!UnUIUIO;) Al'eSSa;)aUUn

    UIO.IJ ~sOI aq ut!;) saI;)A;) 'pal!Sap U'eq~ At!/t\'e laq~'eJ a;)U'e~

    -S!P JO ~!Un aUO paInpaq;)s S! UO!~;)nl~SU! re;)!~!l;) 'e J! ~nH

    .~sOI S! aI;)A;) auo Aluo 'pal!Sap U'eq~ la~'eI aI;)A;) auo paIn

    -paq;)s S! UO!~;)nl~SU! re;)!~!l;) t! JI .a~~S!UI re10dUIa~

    llt!UIS t! U'eq~ AI~SO;) a10UI AIrelaua~ S! a~~S!UI re!~t!ds

    llt!UIS t! asnt!;)aq '~u!Inpaq;)S re10dUIa~ U'eq~ UIaIq01d ~In;)

    -HJ!P a10UI t! Apt!alre S! JIas~! Aq ~u!Inpatps It!!~'edS .jJO.

    -apt!l~ S!q~ JO aIdurnxa ut! S/t\oqS I al~!..!1 .A~!re;)°I pU'e

    UIS!IaIrel'ed uaa/t\~aq jJOapt!l~ lad01d aq~ pU'e~SlapUn o~

    St!q lalnpaq;)s aq~ 'SUO!S!;)ap ~U!Uo!~!~d a~UI OJ,

    .UIaIq01d re10dUIa~ 'e pU'e

    UIalq01d re!~t!ds t! q~oq SaUIO;)aq ~u!Inpaq;)s UO!~;)nl~S

    -U! 'snqJ, .Sa;)lnoSal ~U!~ndUIO;) aq~ SS01;)~ SUO!~;)nl~S

    -U! UO!~!~l'ed o~ S'eq laInpaq;)s UO!~;)nl~SU! aq~ 'Saln~;)a~-!q;)lt! asaq~ UO .sAt!Iap JO saI;)A;) a10UI 10 auo In;)U!Ut!;) Sa;)lnoSal ~U'e~S!P uaa/t\~aq UO!~t!;)!UnUIUI°:) .sa;)lnoS

    -al ~U!~ndUIO;) l!aq~ a~nq!l~S!P ~'eq~ Saln~;)a~!q;)lt! al'e

    Saln~;)a~!q;)lt! It!!~t!dS .[~I] sda'II pU'e '[~~] S10SSa;)-old P!lD '[f1~] /t\1:111 'sM1'IA pala~snI;) apnI;)U! Saln~

    -;)a~!q;)lt! It!!~t!ds JO saldurnx3 .pa~t!;)!IdUIO;) a10UI UaAa

    S! ~u!Inpaq;)S Uo!~;)nJ~SU! 'Saln~;)a~!q;)l~ I'e!~~ds uO

    .sU!ds la~S!~al JO laqUInua~l'eI t! o~ ~u!pt!aI ~noq~!/t\ alq!SSOd S'e d'II tpnUI S'e ~!OId

    -xa /t\oqaUIOs ~SnUI lalnpaq;)s UO!~;)nl~SU! aq~ 'saInpatps

    poo~ a~t!laUa~ OJ, .alnSSald la~S!.'aal laq~!q put! Sa~Ut!l

    aA!I la~U01 aAt!q OSre (d'IV UIs!IaIrel'ed IaAaI UO!~;)nl~S-U! a10UI asodxa ~t!q~ sa;)uanbas apo:) .alnSSald la~S!

    -~al put! UIS!Iallt!l~d al'e sanss! Alt!UI!ld o/t\~ aq~ 'SM1'IA

    UO!~on po.l~uII

    .;}.Ln1~1~'1{:>.lV

    MI7A p;}.L'd1Snl:> V Uo s'dnb~u'1{:>'d1 6u~lnp'd'1{:>s puv 1U'dm

    -u6~ssv 1.LV-'d'1{1-Jo-'d1V1S .l'dao % n Jo 1U'dm'dao.ldm~ uvpuV ' .lOSS'd:>O.ld mvH 'd'1{1 Jo .l'dlnp'd'1{:>s 'dm~1-'d:>vds 6u~1S~

    -X'd 'd'1{1 .l'dao % 19 Jo 1U'dm'dao.ldm~ 'd:>uvuuof.l'dd 'd6v.l'dav

    uv U~V1qo 01 'dlqv s~ 6u~lnp'd'1{:>s 1U'd6.l'daUO{) .1U'dmu6~ssv

    .l'd1Snl:> P'dU~UU'd1'dP'd.ld 'l{1~m SUO~1:>n.l1SU~ ;}.LV 'I{:>~'1{m 'SUO~1

    -:>n.l1SU~ P'd:>vld'd.ld 01 'dnp S1U~V.l1SUO:> SV 11'dm sv 'UO~1

    -vz~m~u~m UO~1v:>~unmmo:> puV '6u~:>uvlvq pv01 'ms~I'd11v

    -.lvd sv 'I{:>ns S1U~V.l1SUO:> IVUO~1~PV.l1 'dlpuv'1{ fi11njss'd:>:>ns

    01 'dlqv s~ 1l .'dU~'1{:>vw MI7A p'd.l'd1snl:> v puv .lOSS'd:>O.ld

    mvH 'd'1{1 :S'd.ln1:>'d1~'1{:>.lV Iv~1Vds om1 01 6u~lnp'd'1{:>s 1U'd6.l'da

    -Uo:> P'd~lddv 'dav'1{ 'dM .s:>~1s:t.ln'd'1{ 1U'd.l'd1T~p 6u~d01'da'dp

    -0:> puV S1U~V.l1SUO:> 'dld~nnm 6u~lpuv'1{ Jo m'dlqo.ld 'd'1{1s'd.if~ldm~s 6u~lnp'd'1{:>s 1U'd6.l'daUO:> ' .l'd'1{10 'I{:>V'd 'l{1~m 1:>V.l'd1

    -U~ 01 'd:>VJ.l'd1U~ 'dUO filuo PUV1S.l'dpun 01 p'd'dU puV 1U'dP

    -u'dd'dpu~ 'd.lV s'dssvd 11v 'dsnv:>'dEI .S1U~V.l1SUO:> 1UV1.LOd

    -W~ 'd'1{1 11v S'd.ifS~1VS 1V'1{1 'dlnp'd'1{:>s v 'd:>npo.ld UV:J .l'dln

    -p'd'1{:Js 1U'd6.l'daUO:J 'd'1{1 'S1U~W1SUO:J 1uva'dl'd.l 'd'1{111v SS;}.Lp

    -pv 1V'1{1 s'dssvd Jo S'd:t.l'dS V 6u~filddv fiEI .S'd:>U'd.l'dJ'd.ld

    'dS'd'1{1 6U~fij~pom fiq S'd1V.l'ddo ssvd V .s1°1s 'dm~1 puv

    'd:Jvds 'dld~nnm .lOJ S'd:>u;}.L'dJ'd.ld sv 11'dm sv 'S'd:>u;}.L'dJ;}.Ld

    s1~ Jo 'd:>U'dp.ifUO:> 'd'1{1 ss;}.Ldx'd 01 ssvd v smo11v 'd:>VJ.l'd1

    -U~ 'd'1{1 'PV'd1SU~ :'d1nI0sqv 10U 'd.lV S'd:>U;}.L'dJ;}.Ld .UO~1

    -:In.l1SU~ 'I{:JV'd .lOJ 'd:Ju;}.l;}J;}.Ld IV.lOdw;}1 puv Iv~1Vds s;}p~a

    -O.ld 1V'1{1 'd:JVf.l'd1U~ uowmo:> "dldm~s V ;}.Lv'1{s s;}ssvd 'd'1{.L

    .1U~V.l1SUO:> .l0 W;}lqO.ld .lvln:J~1.Lvd V S;}SS'd.lppV 1V'1{1 :>~1

    -s:t.ln;}1{ V 6u~1U'dm'dldm~ 1{:>V'd 's'dssvd 1U;}pu'dd'dpu~ Jo

    p'dSodwo:J S~ .l;}lnp'd1{:Js 1U'd6.l'daUO:> V .S'd.ln1:J;}1~1{:>.lV IV~1

    -vds Uo 6u~lnp'd1{:>s UO~1:>n.l1SU~ puV 1U'dmu6~ssv .l'd1Snl:>

    .lOJ :y.lOm;}WV4 IV.l;}u'd6 v s~ 6u~lnp;}'1{:>s 1U;}6.l;}aUO{)

    ':J.:>~.I':J.sqv

    npa.':j.!w.SJI..'J~J@{ u~w~s 'UOSUaMSS '0.'Ja!p ":j.I~M }

    A.'J%uqJa.L Jo a':j.n':j.!':j.suI s':j.':j.asnqJ~ss~W

    aq.'JU!S~l~WV U~W~S 'UOSUaMS au~qs 'u!ddnd o.'Ja!G 'aa'I la':j.I~M

    Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

  • ~

    -uedepu! Jo pesodwo:> S! Jelnpeq:>s ~Ue~JeAUO:> V .){JOM.

    -eW~JJ S!q~ Se~~J~Snn! f: eJ~!d .s:>!~s!Jneq ~u!Inpeq:>spU'e S~UreJ~Suo:> AJ~J~!qIe Aj!:>eds o~ Agee ~! se}[ew ~~q~

    ){JoM.eureJj ~u!Inpeq:>s reJeue~ ~ S! ~u!Inpeq:>s ~Ue~JeA

    -uoD .spoq~ew ~u!Inpeq:>s reUO!~!p~J~ WOJJ eJn~IedepI~:>!P~J ~ '6u~lnp~t[:>s 1U~6J~auo;} s~ueseJd Jed~d S!q.L

    .A~po~ s~s!Xe uo!sue'pCe q:>ns ou

    -~In:>YJ!p S! SUO!~:>llJ~SU! pe:>~IdeJd ~oddns o~ S){JOM.-eureJJ q:>ns ~u!pue~xe 'JeAeM.OH .[16] ew!~ ew~s eq~

    ~~ UO!~~:>°n~ Je~s~eJ pu~ ~u!lnpeq:>s Uo!~:>nJ~SU! WJoJ-Jed o~ s~dwe~~~ elq~uogeeJ ueeq eA~q eJeq~ 'eldurexe

    JOd .Jeq~e~o~ swelqoJd eq~ n~ sseJpp~ o~ ~dwe~~~ o~ S!

    q:>~oJdd~ pJ!q~ V .segeqd ~uenbesqns Aq ep~w SUO!S!:>-ep Jo A~!renb eq~ ~:>e.lJ'e AlesJeAp~ U'e:> pU'e UO!~~WJoJU!

    re!~Ied uo pegeq eIe segeqd AlIee eq~ Aq ep~w SUO!S-!:>ep ge 'swelqoJd ~u!JepJo egeqd se:>npoJ~u! ' JeAeM.oq

    'q:>~oJdd~ S!q.L .segeqd Jo e:>uenbes ~ U! ew!~ ~ ~~ euo

    S~UreJ~Suo:> eq~ sseJpp'e o~ S! q:>~oJdd~ Jeq~ouv .Jeq~e~-o~re eJnsseJd Je~s~eJ eJo~! pU'e d'II ~U!puy uo sn:>°J

    slaInpaq:>s :)srn Am?m 'aloJalaqL .d1I aI~~1I aA~q o~

    pua~ SW'Rl1i'Old la1i'a~u1 ~som 'alomlaq~lll.!l .sla~S!1i'al Josua~ aA~q pm? suo1~:>nJ~su1lnoJ o~ dn anss1 m?:> sJ'P.fR:>s

    -ladns :)srn ulapom 'aIdm~xa lod .maIqold sno1las

    ~som aq~ pl~M.O~ s~lo]Ja ll~ ~:>al!p o~ S! q:>~oldd~ auo.lauu~m :Jot{ pv u~ U! S:>!~S!lnaq pm? S~U!~l~SUO:> 1i'u1

    -~:>!IJuo:> aIpu~q S}{lOM.aW'RlJ 1i'u1Inpaq:>s fRUO!~!~l,L.fRuasl~ S~! U! S:>!~S!lnaq aId!~Inm al!nbal A~m laIn

    -paq:>s ~ 'sqd~J.'J AJ'P.l~!ql~ loruaM. mloJlad °L .ms!IaIfR

    -l~d U!'eJ.'J-aSl~O:> aq~ ~!oIdxa pm? UO!~~:>!unmmo:> az!m

    -!u!m o~ ~m?~lodm! alom S! ~! Sqd~l1i' asaq~ lod .sq~~d

    I~:>!~!l:> Au~m pu~ aIq~I!'eA~ ms!Iall~l~d pau1~J.'J asJ'p.o:>

    aA~q sqd~J.'J IaIfRJ'p.d '~~d .llaM. }{lOM. o~ AIa}{!I al~ s:>!~

    -S!lnaq pa~q q~~d-fR:>!~1l:> 'sqd~J.'J asaq~ lod .sq~~dI~:>!~1l:> M.aJ ~ Aq pa~~u!mop aJ'p. Sqd~l1i' M.Oll~U '1i'uo1

    .aln~:>a~!q:>J'p. I~!~~ds ~ O~UO Sqd~l1i' asaq~ 1i'u!Inpaq:>s Jo

    ma[qold aq~ lap!Suo:) .sm~J.'Jold :>!lamnU o~ 1i'U!llOlUn

    doOI 1i'u1A[dd~ molJ 1i'u!mo:> sqd~J.'J Jo aA!~~~UaSaldal S!( q) qd~J.'J a[!qM. 'sW'RJ.'Jold :>!lamnU-uou U! uaas sqd~J.'J

    Jo fR:>!dA~ s1 (~) qd~lf) .suo1~:>nJ~SU! uaaM.~aq sa:>uap-uadap ~~~p ~uasaldal sa1i'pa pm? SUO!~:>nJ~SU! ~uasaldalsapou 'Sqd~l1i' aq~ uI .mnJ~:>ads ~ Jo spua OM.~ molJ

    sqd~J.'J a:>uapuadap ~~~p aA!~~~UaSaldal s~:>!dap ~ aln

    -1i'1d .Sqd~l~ Jo sadA~ ~uala]J!p lOJ llaM. }{lOM. S:>!~S!lnaq

    ~uala]J!p asn~:>aq sa!~[n:>ffi!p sa:>'eJ OS[~ laInpaq:>s V.a[npaq:>s poo1i' ~ a~~laua1i' o~

    laplo U! SUO!~:>nJ~SU! pa:>~Idald Aq pasodm! S~U1~l~SUO:>

    "(q) lalleJed pue ~ej aJe sJa4~o al14M'(e) s4~ed le:>!~IJ:> Maj e ~q pa~eU!WOp pueIJI4~ aJe awos .s:>IJsiJa~:>eJe4:> JuaJaulp aAe4

    !;4deJ6 a:>uapuadap e~ep ~uaJaula "Z aJn61~

    (q),t,

    ,.

    .: ;

    *

    ~.~

    ~t..---:- : 1"

    .., ;..

    ". ~~~ , '.

    c

    ;r*, cc~.wS!lelleJed pue~t!le:)01 ueeMteq yoepeJt InjeJe:) e S! t! :Sel:)~:)UeAeS ~IUO Se>let '(:») U! 'elnpe4:)s lew!tdo e41.elnpe4':>s el:)~:)-t46!e ue ot speel pue StUeW

    -eJ!nbeJ U°!te:)!UnWWO:) 46!4 se4 6U!UO!t!tJedeA!sseJ66e '(q) ui .elnpe4:)s el:)~:)-J46!e ueOJ speel u°!te:)IUnWWO:) SeZ!WIU!W pue 1.J!le:)-01 Sez!w!xew Je4J 6U!UO!t!tJed eA!teI\JeSUO:)'(e) ui .IJ°!t:)nJJSU! "eA!e:)eJ" e4J OJ enp ~:)ueJ-el jO el:)~:) euo Se>leJ U°!te:)!UnWWO:) eJe4Mllun leu°!t:)unj eUO 4J!M 4:)ee 'sJeJsnl:) eeJ4t4J!M eJm:)eJ!4:)Je ue Jep!SUO~ .JeJsnl:) Jue-Jey!p e sJueseJdeJ J01°:) epoU 4:)e3 .seJm-:)et!4:)Je le!teds Uo 1.J!le:)01 pue WS!lelleJed

    UeeMJeC~ yoepeJt jO eldwexe u'V' .I. eJn6!::1

    (1l)~

    ~,\:l([~""

    "-.:! ~~

    Ci)(:»0(q) ~,

    } ~R(;~, -l-.'.'~ ~ ,\il~~~~ t-~\

    r'@81~'m 1

    1.~ (ZwC

    l!mI

    .m

    ~

    ~

    1,:JffiJJ.

    ..c

    ,

    :+

    ,!

    '\ ~

    ~b

    ID

  • f:

    .101b":1W~1 pU~ :11:J/i:J pU~ ' .J:11b"nl:J pU~ :11~1 'b":1b"b"vd pu~ b":1b"v'ld ;Alq~

    -;}jju~q:J.l;}~U! p;}sn ;}q lI!M SU.1.1;}~ jjU!MOlloJ ;}q~ ' .l;}d~d ;}q~ uI (

    .s'dpnl:>uo:> L UO!~:>'dS .)flO'\\ p'd~~I'dlS'dP!AOld 9 UO!~:>'dS .[v~] lOSS'd:>Old ,\\1:rH 'dq~ pU~ A\I'IA

    p'dl'd~snl:> ~ :s'drn~:>'d~!q:>l~ o,\\~ lOJ S~lnS'dl re~U'dUl!l'dd

    -X'd S~u'ds'dld 9 UO!~:>'ds .}[lO'\\'d~lJ lno U! p'd~U'dUl'dldUl!

    Al~U'dlln:> s'dssed Jo UO!~:>'dll°:> 'dq~ S'dq!l:>S'dp V UO!~:>'dS

    .s'dssed U'd'd'\\~'dq 'd:>~Jl'd~U! ~unnp'dq:>s ~U'd~l'dAUO:> 'dq~

    S'dq!l:>S'dp f: UO!~:>'dS .S)flO'\\ ~! '\\oq S'd~~l~snll! o~ 'dldUl~-X'd m! s'dsn pm! ~unnp'dtps ~U'd~l'dAUO:> S'd:>npol~ll! ~ UO!~

    -:>'dS .s,\\°lloJ se p'dZ!m!~lO S! l'dd~d S!q~ Jo ~S'dl 'dqJ.

    .Sla~Sn{:> l!aq~ O~ SUO!~:>ru~SU! pa:>~{dald JO Sloqq~!aU

    ~:>~l~~~ A{~UOl~S SUO!~:>ru~SU! pa:>~{dald :sa:>u~qm~S!pJO ~O{ ~ sasn~:> ss~d aq.L .(J ) U! UM.oqs S! ~{nSal aq.L

    .sapou pa:>~{dald WOlJ UO!~~WIOJU! ~U!Sn SUO!~:>ru~SU!~!q q:>!qM. 'dO'Hd30V1d pU'e 30V1d uru aM. "pCaN

    .(f,' la~Sn{:> U! && pU'e '1&

    '0& '61 SUO!~:>ru~SU! '.6.C1) Sla~Sn{:> :>y!:>ads U! a{qwass~o~ ~lT?~S SUO!~:>ru~SU! Jo SdnOl~ pu~ ' la~Sn{:> ~Sly aq~ JO

    ~no paqsnd al~ SUO!~:>ru~SU! M.aJ ~Sly aq~ :sa~u~q:> {~la

    -AaS O~ p~a{ s:>!~S!maq asaq.L .(a) U! ~U!~{nSal 's:>!~S!maq

    (aVO1) C1JUVlvq pvol aq~ pu~ (WWOO) UO~1VZ~UL~U~ULUO~1VJ~UnULULOJ aq~ uru aM. uaq.L .(p) la~Sn{:> ~Sly aq~

    U! (.:>~a '9& 'g& 'f,'& SUO!~:>ru~SU! '.C1.~) q~~d re:>!~!l:> aq~ U!

    SUO!~:>ru~SU! aq~ jO ~q~!aM. aq~ SaS~al:>U! q:>!qM. '(H.LVd)6U~UC1"16uC1.J1fl "1vd IVJ~1.z..tJ uru aM. 'uaq.L .sla~snI:> ~ua

    -la.IJ!p o~ SUO!~:>ru~SU! ~U!~nq!l~S!P Aq ws!Ia[[~l~d as~al:>

    -U! sdlaq :>!~S!lnaq S!q.L .(:» U! ~u!~Insal 'Al~awwAs

    :![~alq o~ (3SION) :>!~S!lnaq uO~1Jnpo.J1u~ C1fl~OU aq~ AId-d~ aM .(q) U! UM.oqs s~ 'pa~nq!l~S!P AluaAa al~ s~q~!aM.

    aq~ 'A[[~!~!UI .ddddj wolJ a:>uanbas apo:> [[~WS ~ uo

    sa~~lado ~u!Inpaq:>s ~Ua~laAUO:> M.oq SM.oqs V aln~!.i

    .V UO!~-:>as U! pa:>npOl~U! aq [[!M. S:>!~S!lnaq laq~o .sauo pap~O{

    ssaI aq~ uo waq~ sa~al:>U! pu~ la~snI:> sla~snI:> pap~oI

    Alq~!q uo sa:>ualajald aq~ sa:>npal sa~u~q:> (aVO1) :>!~

    -S!lnaq C1JUVlvq pvol aq.L .SUO!~:>ru~SU! pa:>~Idald aq~ Aqpa~:>alas sla~snI:> aq~ uo pa:>~Id al~ sloqq~!au l!aq~ pU'e

    SUO!~:>ru~SU! pa:>~Idald ~~q~ slaJald (30V1d) :>!~S!lnaq1UC1ULC1JVldC1.ld aq.L .la~snI:> aw~s aq~ U! SUO!~:>ru~SU! ~U!

    -loqq~!au ~uapuadap daa:![ o~ Sa!l~ (WWOO) :>!~S!lnaqUO~1VZ~UL~U~UL UO~1VJ~UnULULOJ aq.L .la~snI:> aw~s aq~

    U! laq~a~o~ sq~~d I~:>!~!l:> U! SUO!~:>ru~SU! aq~ Ire daa}{o~ a:>ualajald ~ sassaldxa 'aldw~xa lOj '(H.LVd) :>!~

    -S!lnaq 6U~UC1"16uC1.J1fl "1vd IVJ~1.z..tJ aq.L .sA~M. ~uala.IJ!p

    U! alnpaq:>s aq~ aAOldw! O~ :![lOM. S:>!~S!lnaq ~uala.IJ!a

    .~U!-Inpaq:>s ~S!I lOj A~!lO!ld UO!~:>ru~SU! aq~ ~ pasn S! aw!~

    pallaJald aq~ ~la~snI:> pallajald aq~ o~ pau~!ss~ S! UO!~-:>ru~SU! aq.L .aw!~ pallaJald ~ pU'e la~snI:> pallajald ~

    q~oq sapnI:>u! q:>!qM. '1o1fl pC1.J.JC1JC1.ld aq~ ~ pa~~U~!Sap S!~q~!aM. ~saq~!q aq~ q~!M. d~w aq~ U! ~ols aq~ 'sa~aldwo:>

    ~u!Inpaq:>s ~Ua~laAUO:> uaqM .s~q~!aM. asaq~ ~U!~U'eq:>Aq UO!~:>ru~SU! U'e Jo ~u!Inpaq:>s aq~ sa:>uanIJu! ss~d ~

    ~d~w a:>ualajald ~ U! s~q~!aM. s~ pa~uasaldal al~ UO!~

    -:>ru~SU! q:>~a Jo sa:>ualajald I~lodwa~ pu~ I~!~~ds aq.L

    [.s~oIs aw!~ pu~ sla~snI:> lOJ SUO!~:>ru~SU! jO sa:>ualajaldaA!~~{al aq~ U! sa~u~q:> S~ sa:>!oq:> l!aq~ a~~:>!Unwwo:>sass~d ':![lOM.aW~lJ ~u!lnpaq:>s ~Ua~laAUO:> aq~ uI

    .sanb!uqJa~ reUO!~!p~l~ O~ paxedwoJ ~u!InpaqJs~Ua~laAUOJ JO SSaUaA!~Ja.IJa aq~ JO UO!~~l~SUOWap ~ .

    'sanss! J1J!Jads-a.In~Ja~!qJxe pue s~u!'e.I~SUOJ re.Iaua~ q~oq ssa.Ipp~O~ SJ!~s!.Inaq Inj.IaM.od jO ~as ~ jO uo!~~Inw.I°j aq~

    'eJnsseJd Je~

    -s!~eJ pu~ '~u!InpeqJs '~uewu~!sS'e Je~snIJ .Jo sweI-qoJd peu!qwoJ eq~ sseJpp~ o~ qJ~oJdd~ IeAou ~ .

    ~sa3naJaJaJd pa~q~!a/A no

    pas-eq sass-ed ~n!Inpaq3s naa/A~aq a3~JJa~n! IaAon ~ .

    :a.l\? .lad\?d S!q~ Jo suo!~nq!.l~uo;) aq.L

    .~q~!aA\.\? o~ aId!.l~ aw!~ pU'R 'a;)\?ds 'uo!~;)n.l~su! U\? sd\?w ~\?q~

    UO!~;)uIlJ ~ndu!-aa.lq~ \? ge pay!;)ads a.re sa;)ua.laJa.ld 'AIre;)

    -!.\?a O~ ~nd~no .lO ~ndu! aq.L .a:>\?J.Ia~u! uow

    -WO;) \? a.reqs .laInpaq;)s ~Ua~.laAUO;) aq~ U! sageqd nv

    .waIqo.ldaW'es aq~ ssa.lpp'e A\?w S;)!~s!.lnaq aId!~Inw .a.lnssa.ld .la~

    -s!. )

    l qJBd .B"P!.1:J J

    "'!J'!.1n"H Jo u°!J""n°:J ~u!Inpaq:>s ':J.ua~.laAuOD~

    Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

  • v

    as1?qd P!OA1? O~ pU1? sas1?qd uaald~aq >I:>1?qpaaJ ap!A

    -old O~ IT1Jasn S! aln~1?aJ S!qL .ssa:>old aA!~1?la~! U1?

    JO ~l1?d S1? lO AI~uapuadapu! laq~!a 'sam!~ aId!~Inm

    pa!Idd1? aq O~ :>!~S!lnaq 1? SldOII1? >IlOldam1?lJ aqL .g

    uI "aseqd auo Aq uo!s!;)ap ~UOlM. Al'elOdma~ ~

    mol.J laAO;)al Alreln~~u U~;) ~u!Inpaq;)s ~Ua~laAUOO "f:

    .papaau J! aJ!oqJ fl?u9 aq~ ~Ja.IJ'R /i.I~uol~s U'eJ s~d

    /i.u~ 'ap!s laq~o aq~ uO .uo!s!Jap ~ a){'eUl O~ ~q

    ~! aSn~Jaq ~snr UO!S!Jap aIq~laAoJalun pu~ lood

    ~ a>{~Ul ~OU spaau aseqd V .suo!s!Jap S~! ~noq~

    a:>uap9uoJ ssaldxa O~ aseqd ~ SA\OII~ aJ~Jla~u! aq.L .~

    °aA!SSaldxa /i.laA

    S! ~U![npaqJS ~Ua~laAUOJ O~ aJ~pa~U! pa~q-~q~!aA\

    aq~ '~~l~UOJ uI °sas~d ~uowu UO!~~W1OJU! JO

    a~uuqJXa pa~!W![ /i.laA /i.[UO A\O[[U sla[!dwoJ ~SOW °t

    .fi,;la~snl;)x;l U'eq~ laq~~lfi,;la~1v.J.;ldoo;) ap~m al~ SuQ!s!;>ap ~u!lnpaq;>s s~I .A~A\~ U!~Wal '0 apou s~

    qJns 'sa!~ ~UO1~S ~noq~!A\ sapou aI!qA\ '){J~q paAOWAII~n~uaAa al~ '9-1 sapou s~ qJns 'auo la~SnIJ O~

    sa!~ ~UO1~S q~!A\ sapou 'laAaA\oq 'AI~uanbasqns .la~-snIJ ~Sly aq~ WOlJ A~A\~ paAOW Alre!~!U! al~ sapou

    ~SOW '(q) O~ as!OU Aldd~ aA\ uaqA\ 'aldw~xa aq~

    :St}.In1~t}J ~U!M.OnoJ t}q1 seq ~u!Inpt}qJs 1Ut}~.It}AU00

    .(~) U! UM.OqS S! t}Inpt}qJs I~uY t}q.L .t}m!1.It}q1°U'e(WWOO) UO~1vz~m~u~m UO~1VJ~UnmmOJ un.I t}M. /i.IreU!.!I

    "v .It}1snIJ 01 pt}1J~.I11~ S! ll-61 dno.I.'a' t}q1 M.Oq t}A.It}SqO

    .a:luaJajaJd a4J Ja6uoJts a4t 'JOIO:l aLIt JatLl6!1a4.l .Jatsnl:l te4t JOj se4 uolt:lnJtsu! ue a:luaJajaJd jO laAal a4t stuasaJdaJ ~tua LI:leajO JOIO:l a4.l .Jatsnl:l e stuasaJdaJ uwnlo:l 'v' .(e) U! sJaqwnu uo!t:lnJtsu! a4t Ot puods-aJJo:l sJaqwnu MOJ a4.l .uo!t:lnJtsul ue sJuasaJdaJ MOJ 'v' .dew a:luaJajaJd JaJsnl:l e S!6-qv saJn6!::1 UI aJn61j LI:le3 .6u!lnpa4:1s aw!J tou '6u!lnpa4:1s a:leds saJeJJsnll! ~IUO aid.wexa S!4.l .sassed jO sa!Jas e ~q pa!jlpoW S! alnpaLl:ls tua6JaAUO:l a4t MoLl MoLls (6)-(q)saJn6!::1 .sJatsnl:l tuaJau!p Ot 6u!puodsaJJo:l sape4s tuaJaulP LIJ!M 'pa:leldaJd aJe sapou

    Jeln6ue!J.l .suo!J:lnJtsu! uaaMtaq sa:luapuadap tuasaJclaJ sa6pa ~suo!J:lnJJsu! JuasaJ.daJ sapoN .apo:l palnpa4:1s a4t jO uo!JetuasaJdaJ 4deJ6 a:luapuadap etep aLlJ SMo4s(e) aJn6!::1 .ddddj WOJj a:luanbas apo:l e uo sateJado 6ullnpa4:1s JUa6JaAUO~ .V aJn6!::1

    (~)(j)(a)(p)

    (;»(q)(~)

    Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

  • 9

    pasn s~q~!aJ\\ aq~ 'asn aJ\\ S:>!~S!.lnaq JO ~as aq~ :.lO.l.la-pue

    -re!.l~ /i.q pa~:>a[as a.ltl s.la~aW'e.ltld ~U!A\OnoJ aq~ '/i.[~ua.l

    -.lna .pa![ddtl S! :>!~s!.lnaq q:>tla saw!~ Jo .laqwnu aq~.lO .lap.lo aq~ uo SUO!~:>!.l~sa.l ou a.ltl a.laq.L .X!l~tlW

    ~q~!aJ\\ aq~ tI!A S:>!~S!lnaq .laq~o q~!J\\ sa~tI:>!Unwwo:> /i.[UOpue ~U!'el~SUO:> a[~U!S tI Ssalpptl O~ s~dwa~~tI :>!~S!lnaq

    q:>tla .~u![npaq:>s ~Ua~.laAUO:> lOJ pa~uawa[dw! aAtlqaJ\\ S:>!~S!.lnaq JO UO!~:>an°:> tI s~uasald uo!~:>as S!q.L

    .0 S! { x -01 : ~ > x > O}~W ~.I~ pu~ '01 S! { x -01 : ~

    > x > O}~W i!:Ju~:lSU! .I°d .(uo!SSiJ.Idxi! i!q:l Jo i!n(~" aq:l U.Imi!.I

    x~w i!(!qA\) si!n(~" Jo :li!S Ui!"!:a' ~ .I°J uo!SSiJ.Idxa i!q:l saz!W!~W

    :I~q:l i!(q~!.I~" i!q:l Jo i!n(~" i!q:l SU.Ima.I x~w ~.I~ uo!:1:JunJ aq.L~

    "'I"M=:{::IX1!W ~.I~(!).l;J~sn[:rp;J.U;JJ;J.ld =

    "".~.~M:={ : 1X'eW ~Ie(!)"W!:1-P".I.I"J".Id =

    S;)!~s!.lnaH Jo uo!~;)aIIOat~:~U!A\OnoJ aq~ auyap aA\ '~ UO!~:>n.I~SU! U'e UaA!f)"'J

    1 = "'J'~M=::{ : ~A

    1>"'J'~M>O:::1'1'~A

    :paU!~~U!'eUI a.re S~U'e!.reAU! ~U!A\OnOJ aqL .s~oIs-aUI!~.IaAO 7 's.Ia~snI:> .IaAO :> 'SUO!~:>n.I~SU! .IaAO sU'eds ~ ~a1

    .aUI~S aq~ s~q~!aA\ aq~ daa~ U'eJ J;.aq~

    'sa:>!oq:> a.IOUI .IO auo O~ ~Ua.Ia.IJ!pU! a.re J;.aq~ JI .aInpa1f>s

    pa.IlaJa.Id aq~ ~Ja.lJ'e ~~q~ sa~u~q:> UI.IoJ.Iad O~ pa.I!nb-a.I ~OU a.I~ sassed .d~UI a:>ua.IaJa.Id aq~ ~u!~~Ind!U'eUI

    J;.q saJua.IaJa.Id S~! sassa.Idxa ~! 'uaqL ..reJ os aInpaq:>s

    pa.I.IaJa.Id aq~ Jo s:>!~s!.Ia~J~.req:> aq~ aU!UIla~ap O~ X!.I~~UI~q~!aA\ aq~ pU'e qd~.I~ aJuapuadap aq~ sau!urnxa ssedV .J;.IuaAa pa~nq!.I~s!P a.re s~q~!aA\ aq~ Ire 'J;.Ire!~!UI

    .(1dD) q~uaI q~~d-re:>!~!.IJ aq~se s~oIs aUI!~ J;.U'eUI se a~~JOIre aM. .aUI!~ .IaAO sU'eds 7

    pu~ 'a.In~Ja~!q:>.re aq~ U! s.Ia~snIJ aq~ laAO su~ds :) '~!un

    ~u!Inpaq:>s aq~ U! SUO!~Jn.I~SU! Ire .IaAO sU'eds ~ a.IaqA\

    '1':>'~M X!.I~~UI reUO!SUaUI!p aa.Iq~ ~ U! sa:>ua.IaJa.Id sa.IO~S

    ~I .[6] suo!~aa.I~ .IO '[61] S~JoIqladJ;.q .IO '[01] S~JOIqladns

    '{L] sa~.I~ 's>poIq J!seq aq J;.~UI 1f>!qA\ 'S~!Un ~u!Inpa1f>S

    renp!A!pU! UO sa~~.Iado ~u!Inpa1f>S ~ua~.IaAuoD

    .J' uo!~:>as U! pa~uasa.Idaq n!A\ saAIasUIaq~ sassed aqL .sassed uaaA\~aq a~J.Ia~

    -U! ~u!Inpaq:>s ~Ua~.IaAUO:> aq~ saq!.I:>sap UO!~JaS S!qL

    ,,'~', ",~'7~~, u-t "'~"M"(1.:J':&) q~a.I°J

    ..:M

    :SUllOJlad AldUl!s UO!1~Z!reUllOU aq1 ~S1U'e!l'eAU! lnOaa1U'ere~ 01 paz!I~UllOU aq U~;) Sa;)UalaJald aqL .

    .UO!1;)lll1SU! q:>~a

    JO l81SnI;)-p8llaJ8ld pU'e 8Ul!1-p8ll8Jald aq1 SaZ!O-UlaUl osI~ 11 .aUl!1 (1)0 U! paU!Ulla1ap 8q U'e;) Aaq1

    1~q1 os '8Ul!1 pu~ a~ds q10q l8AO s1q~!aM. aq1 JO

    SUlnS aq1 JO JI:Yt!l1 sdaa:){ Alre1UaUlal;)u! Ula1SAs aqL .

    .U01S-uaw1P aw1~ aq~ ~UO~ a~~l I~wS t? u1q~1A\ S.IUO10 'u01suaw1P a:>t?ds aq~ ~uOIt? S.IUO '.6.d 'Sa;)!l~t?W

    aq~ JO ~l'p.d Uo ~1 °P S.IUO aA\ 'pt?a~sUJ .aA1Suadxa

    S1 ~1 asnt?;)aq u01~t?lado IInJ s1q~ WlOJlad 1aAaU aM.

    ".r~~M(rm- I) + ".1. t~M Ym -t ".1.t~M .(1 ':J) q:>1!a .I°J

    :.c = I~ put? 'l = U q~1A\ 'u01~t?lado s1q~JO WlOJ 1aIdw1s t? sasn u01t?~uawaIdw1 ~Ua11n;) 1no

    [u.r]3'l

    "'1.'1~M*'lm =:{ -t".1.rM.(1':J)q:>1!a.IoJ

    :SA\OIIOJ se S1 U01~t?U1qWO;) 1t?au1Iaq~ 'I = :Ym [U.I]3:Y=:{ a1aqA\ um ,... , Im SU01~;)ru~su1~ndu1 aq~ 10J s~q~1aA\ P~ ' .c U01~;)ru~su1 ~nd~no Ut?'u~ ,... '~~ ' I~ SU01~;)ru~su1 ~ndu1 uaA1D .U01~;)ru~su1

    1aq~0~ JO X11~t?W t? a;)np01d o~ S.Il'p.aU1I pau1qwo;)aq ~;) SU01~;)ru~su1 alOW 10 OA\~ JO Sa;)11~t?W aqJ. .

    .10~;)t?J t? S.q pa1Id1~Inw 10 '~~~SUo;) t? S.qpasea1;)ap 10 pasea1;)U1 aq ~;) :J.r~ M ~q~1aA\ s.UV .

    a:>~J.Ia~u! ~ua.'d.IaAUOQI::

    {(!).Ie~snl:rpe.I.IeJe.Id # ;)

    !".~.'M ~=:{ : ;)(!)la~snl:>-dnlauuru ~w ~l1/

    .SUO!~;)n.l~SU! pa;)U'eA-p~ aq~ ~!o{dxa o~ alq~ aq n!M pu~ .laq~a~o~ waq~pug n!M .lalnpaq;)s aq~ ~~q~ os 's~uawa.l;)u! pU'e

    sassa;);)~-A.lowaw .laq~a~o~ daa~ o~ A.l~ p{no;) sged

    auo 'uo!~;)n.l~su! ;)g!;)ads t! q~!M ssa;);)t!-A.lowaw uo

    ~uawa.l;)u!-0~n~ ~!oldxa o~ a{qt! S! a.ln~;)a~!q:':>.re u~

    'aldurexa .l°J 'JI .a.ln~;)a~!q:':>.re ~u!Al.lapun aq~ Josa!~!.re!ln;)ad ssa.lpp'll o~ pU'e .la{!dwo;) ~ ~a~.re~a.l o~

    A~M Agea U'e s.laHo S!qJ, .A~!xaldwo;) ~!sap sa;)np

    -a.l a;)~J.Ia~u! UOWWO;) 'aA!ssa.ldxa aq~ put! 'A{~uap

    -uadapu! Ua~~!.lM a.re S;)!~S!.lnaq ~ua.laH!p .l°J sageqd

    .S;)!~s!.lnaq MaU U~!Sap .lO S~U!'e.l~SUO;) MaU a{pU'eq

    O~ .la~!.lM .lal!dwo;) aq~ .l°J Agea ~! sa~~w sasged

    uaaM~aq ( sd~w a;)ua.laJa.ld) a;)~J.Ia~u! a{dw!s aqJ, .9

    .stUalqo.ld ~u!.lap.lo

    Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

  • 9

    "fl U!q aq~ 'AI~!~!UJ .SU!q O~U! pauo!~!~d aJ'e IaAaI ~

    uo SUO!~Jru~SU! 'UO!~~J!unmwoJ aA!SSaJXa ~noq~!M. UO!~

    -nq!l~S!P UO!~Jru~SU! Jo sI~o~ ~np aq~ wloJlad °.L.laq~o qJ~a J'eau al~ ~~q~ SUO!~Jru~SU!

    laq~a~o~ ~u!doo}{ a[!qM. '~l~d~ J'eJ al~ ~~q~ SUO!~Jru~SU!

    a~nq!l~S!P o~ Sa!l~ ssed aq~ 'pua S!q~ °.L .UO!~~J!unw

    -moJ [~!~ua~od az!m!u!m O~ S! ~o~ puoJas aq.L .sla~

    -sn[J SSOlJ~ ws!IaI~l~d a~nq!l~S!P o~ S! ~o~ AJ'eW!ld

    aq.L .S[~O~ OM.~ seq uO!~nq!l~S!P [aAa'I .~OOl ~saq~lnJ aq~molJ aJU'e~s!p S~! aq o~ (~)IO}nO}I auyap aM. '~ UO!~Jru~SU!

    uaA!D .sla~Sn[J SSOl~ l~nO}l aw~s aq~ ~~ SUO!~Jru~SU!

    sa~nq!l~S!P ssed S!q.L ( 'IaAa'I) e'Jnq!.1'Js!P IeAe'I

    (dO) q~~d re:>1~1J:> ~ uo suo1~:>llJ~SU1 aq~ Ire doo}{ o~ sa1J~

    s~d s1q.L (H.LV d) ~u!uaq~ua.l'Js q'Jed Ie;}!'J!.1:J

    'nMl"1 -+ l'nM '(1 '~) q:>1!a .10}

    :SA\OIIoJ S'e a;)ua.IaJa.Id S!q~

    ssa.Idxa aM .papaau aq U'e;) sa!do;) a.IaA\ 's.Ia~snI;) .Iaq~oaq~ SnS.IaA 'alq~IfI:IA~ Ap~a.Ire a.re ~~~p a.IaqA\ ' .Ia~snI;)

    ~S.Iy aq~ a.Iow ~U!z!I!~n alnpaq;)s ~ o~ a~~~U~Ap'e aA!.'ii' O~

    ~U'eA\ aA\ 'a.In~;)a~!q;).re S!q~ .I°d .~!un ~u!Inpaq;)s A.IaAa

    JO ~U!Uu!.'ii'aq aq~ ~~ .Ia~snI;) ~S.Iy aq~ U! alq~IfI:IA~ a.I~

    ~~~p aq~ II~ ~~q~ S! ~U'e!.reAU! U'e 'a.In~;)n.I~S'e.IJU! A\I1A

    pa.Ia~snI;) .Ino UJ (.LS'HI.iI) .Ia1snI;) 1S.Iy 01 qsnd

    u)d".nMOO1 -t (~)d".r~M'(1'aaDV7d:inId 3 :&) 1fJ1!" .IOj

    'uaq.L .1a1-snI:> pa~Ida1d s1-! aq (~ )d;J 1-aI '~ UO!1-:>ru1-SU!pa:>ulda1d UaA!{) .a~lt!I S! aSUa1:>U! 1-q~!all1 aq1- 'SSaU1-:>a1-10:> 10J pa1!nba1 S! UO!1-!PUO:> S!q1- a:>U!S .1a1-snI:> awoq

    l!aq1- U! pa:>uld aq 01- SUO!1-:>ru1-SU! pa:>ulda1d 10J 1-q~!all1aq1- SaSUa1:>U! ssud S!q.L (~aV'Id) ':Juama:>eIda.ld

    (:1)pvol/".t1M-t "'t1M '(:1.1 '~) q~" .lo.f

    :Ji}~snI3 ~t/q~ uo Pt/°I It/~o~ i}q~ Aq pi}P!A!P

    S! Ji}~Sn[3 t/ UO ~q.'a!i}M q3t/3 .sJi}~snI3 SSOJ3t/ .'aU!3Ut/req

    Pt/°I SWJOFi}d sSt/d S!q.L ( aVO'I) e;)uereq pe°'I

    (;I '~)1S~P/".J',M ~ "'J"M'(;1'1'aHOV7dHHd ~ ~) q~~ .10}

    'uaqL .a:>u~~s!P S!q~aq (:> '~)7S~P ~a'I .:J U! uo!~:>nJ~su! pa:>~IdaJd ~sasoI:> aq~

    o~ a:>u~~s!P S~! A.q :> Ja~snI:> q~a JoJ ~q.'a!aA\ S~! ap!A!p

    aA\ '~ UO!~:>nJ~SU! pa:>~IdaJd-uou q:>~a JOd .SUO!~:>llJ~SU!

    II~ O~ UO!~~WJoJU! ~uawa~IdaJd sa~~.'a~doJd ssed S!qL

    (dO'Hd~:JV'Id) uo!'Je~edo.Id 'Juawa:>eIda.Id

    XVW-aNV1I/()pU~.I + ".1'1M -t ".~.1M '(:J '1 '~) q~i! .I°J

    .UIs!Ian~xed lOJ ~u!Inpaq:>s a~~~!I!:>~J o~ punoxe

    SUO!~:>nl~SU! sp~alds pu~ Al~aUIUIAs }{'ealq sdlaq as!ouaqJ, .uo!~nq!J~s!P ~q~!aA\ aq~ U! as!ou Jo ~unourn lreUIs ~

    sa:>npol~U! ssed S!qJ, (::1SION) uo!'J:>npo.I'Ju! es!oN

    .s.Ia~snI:> aIq!geaJun aq~ .I°Js~q.'a!aM. aq~ .'au!qgenbs Aq AIdw!s 'sa.In~:>a~!q:>.It? awos U!

    s.Ia~snI:> Ire U! paInpaq:>s aq ~ouut?:> SUo!~:>n.I~SU! awos

    ~t?q~ ~:>t?J aq~ ssa.Ippt? Ut?:> auo S!q~ o~ .reI!W!S sged V

    O-+".~.'M '(;J'.1-7da>1nd,>1'~) q~;}.I°J

    ""'l.~Ml-? "'.'1'~M'(~) q;)1Ja lOJ

    .WWOO q~!/t\ laq~a.'aO~ ~! Unl

    A[rensn a/t\ pU'R 'Ualpl~t[:J-puv.J.fj put? S7U;}.J.vd-puwfj Slap!S

    -UOJ ~t?q~ S!q~ jO ~Ut?!lt?A t? pa~uawaIdw! osIt? aAt?q aM

    ~ Jo Sloqq~!aU3U

    "'1'uM =:{ "'1'~M-? "'1'~M '(:J '7 '~) q;)1Ja lOJ

    .UO!~Jal!p ~JallO:> aq~ U! s~q.'a!a/t\ /t\aJIs O~ ~t?q~ .'aU!Snput? ' la~snIJ :>!J!Jads t? U! Sloqq.'a!aU aq~ nt? jO s~q.'a!a/t\ aq~

    .'aU!UlWnS Aq auop S! S!qL .a.re (qdt?l.'a aJuapuadap aq~ U!

    SlOSSaJapald pU'R SlOSSaJJns) Sloqq.'a!aU jO ~SOW alaq/t\Sla~Sn[:> aures aq~ U! aq O~ UO!~:>nl~SU! Ut? lOj ~q.'a!a/t\

    aq~ .'aU!gealJU! Aq Pt?°I UO!~t?J!unwwoJ SaJnpal sged

    S!qL (WWO::)) uo!~ez!w!u!W uo!~e:>!unww°::)

    .a~uelS!q~ ap!S~nO s~q~!aA\ aq~ 1~ OlaZ O~ saqgenbs sged S!qJ.

    .alq!geaJ aq n!A\ ~ols-aW!~ auo AluO 'q~~d ~:>!~!l:> aq~

    JO ~l'p.d S! UO!~:>nl~SU! ue JI .BI- 7dD pue dl uaaA\~aq

    s~ols aw!~ aq~ U! AluO palnpaq:>s aq ue:> UO!~:>nl~SU! aq~, ( U!~q:> lOSSa:>:>ns JO A:>ua~~u Jeal Aue o~ q~~d ~sa~uol

    aq~ S! BI pu~ '(U!~q:> lOSSa:>apald JO A:>ua~~u qd~~ aq~Jo do~ aq~ wolJ q~~d ~sa~uol aq~ Jo q~uaI aq~ S! dl'q~~d I~:>!~!l:> aq~ JO ~q~ual aq~ S! 7 d D J! 'oS .SlOSSa:>

    -:>ns l!aq~ la~~ lOU 'SlOSSa:>apald l!aq~ alOJaq palnpaq:>s

    aq ~ouue:> qd~l~ a:>uapuadap aq~ Jo alPP!w aq~ U! UO!~

    -:>nl~SUI (aWI.L.LINV '.Juewu~!ssu ew!'.J Ie'.J!'.J!uI

    (')"".J.'Mf: -+ (')"".J.'M '(;) '~ 'dD 3 ~) q:J1!6.I°.J

    .dO aq~ 10J 1a~snI;) uasoq;)aq~ aq (~ ););) ~a'I .sla~snI;) awoq ~U'RAaIa1 aq~ o~ asoI;)AII~;)°I ~da){ pU'R sa;)a!d alOW 10 OA\~ U! Ua){01q S! q~~d

    I~;)!~!l;) aq~ '(q~~d aq~ Uo SUO!~;)nJ~SU! pa;)~Ida1d alOW10 OA\~ a1~ a1aq~ uaqA\ '.6.a) sla~snI;) ~Ua1aIJ!p p1~A\

    -o~ &"e!q ~U01~S aA~q sq~~d aq~ JO SUO!~lOd ~Ua1aIJ!p II

    .pa~;)aIas S! 1a~snI;) pap~oI ~&"eaI aq~ as!A\laq~o .1a~snI;)~~q~ o~ paAOW S! q~~d aq~ ' 1a~snI;) reIn;)!~d ~ 10J &"e!q

    aA~q sq~~d aq~ U! SUO!~;)nJ~SU! II .1a~snI;) aw~s aq~ U!

    .Molaq uo!~d~:>sapaq~ U! papnI:>u! ~ou S! da~s S!q~ 'f.~~Aalq lod .f: uo~~asu~ paq~l:>sap S~U~!l'RAU! aq~ alnSUa O~ sged f.laAa JO puaaq~ ~~ UO!~~Z!I~WlOU uru aM ' f.lt?SSa:>au laAauaqA\

    .aln~llJ aq~ U! uo~~:>alas S:>!~S~lnaq:>~~~wa~sf.s alow ~uawaldw! O~ ~:>adxa aA\ .uru al'R s:>!~

    -s~lnaq aq~ q:>!qM U! laplO aq~ pllt1 'S:>~~S~lnaq aq~ U!

    Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

  • L

    aurns aq~ :>:>A\~'H q~!A\ sal'p.qs .Ial!dmo:> sn.Ioqo aqJ,

    .aI:>A:> auo Jo A~reuad ~ q~!A\ '~~~p

    a~oma.I ~sanba.I u~:> Suo!~~.Iado A.Iomaw .ms!lalrel'P.d

    mnm!~m .I°J s.Ia~snI:> SSO.I:>~ paA~aI.Ia~u! al'p. sassa.Ipp1?

    A.Iomaw ..Iaq~oU1? o~ .Ia~snI:> auo mo.IJ anl~A .Ia~s!.'aa.I ~Ado:> o~ al:>A:> auo sa)(e~ ~I .s.Ia~snl:> ~ua.IalJ!p uo salY .Ia~

    -s!.'i1a.I uooA\~aq SanreA SaAOm ~!Un .IaJSU1?I~ aqJ, .OOOv'H

    sd!W aq~ uo paseq al'p. sa!:>ua~~1 uo!~:>n.I~sur .~!un .IaJ

    -SU1?I~ auo pu~ '~!un ~u!od .'aU!~~o1J auo 'A.Iomaw/ !l'IV

    .Ia.'aa~U! auo '!l'IV .Ia.'aa~u! auo :s~!un UO!~:>ullJ .InoJ

    seq .Ia~snl:> q~3 .s.Ia~snl:> 1~:>!~uap! .InoJ q~!A\ au!q:>-~m MI'IA pa.Ia~snl:> ~ a~~lnm!s o~ ~! asn aM .sau!q:>

    -~m MI'IA pa.Ia~snl:> Jo SUO!~~.In.'ayuo:> ~ua.IalJ!p AU1?m

    a~~yn1:u!s U1?:> ~~q~ ~UaUIUOl!AUa lo~~ynm!s/.Ial!dmo:> alq

    -!xa1J ~ S! ma~sAs MI'IA pa.Ia~snl:> sn.Ioqo aqJ,

    .al!~ q:>~auo apo:> aq~ o~ .IO~~:>°lre .Ia~s!.'i1a.I reUO!~!p~l~ ~ sa!Idd~

    ~! 'uaqJ, .qd~l.'a q~a uo .'au!ynpaq:>s am!~-a:>~ds smloJ-.Iad pU1? qd~.I.'a a:>uapa:>ald ~~~p aq~ s~:>n.I~suo:> :>:>A\'e'H

    'a:>~.I~ q~a .I°..i .sa~.I~ .'aU!ynPaq:>s alom .IO auo O~U!urnl.'ao.Id ~ndu! q:>~a Sap!A!p :>:>A\'e'H .[8I] Uo!~~~uasa.I

    -dal a~~!pam.Ia~u! J!nsq:>~w aq~ Jo do~ uo ~I!nq S! ~I

    .sal!~ A\'e'H SSOl:>~ ~! Saz!Ialrel~d pu~ m~l.'aold U1?l~.I°..ilO 0 re!~uanbas ~ sa)(e~ ' .Ial!dmo:> A\~'H aq~ ':>:>A\'e'H

    .A:>ua~~[Jo al:>A:> ~l~Xa auo sa)(e~ doq I~UO!~!PP~ q:>~a

    ~saI!~ .'aU!loqq.'a!au OA\~ lOJ sal:>A:> aalq~ S! :![.IoA\~au :>!~~~Saq~ uo A:>ua~~'I .padd~m-.Ia~s!.'i1al al'p. s~lod :![lOA\~aU

    :>!~~~S aq~ 'p1?aq.IaAO UO!~~:>!Unmmo:> a:>npa.I OJ, .([VI] o~laJal aseald 'sl!'e~ap .IoJ) saI!~ ~ua.IalJ!p uo sIl'IV /aIY .Ia~

    -s!.'aa.I aq~ uaaA\~aq sanl~A l~I~:>S a~nol o~ pasn aq u~:>

    ~~q~ :J[.LOm1aU :J~1V1S pallol~uo:>-.Ial!dmo:> 'alq~mm~l.'ao.Id~ seq A\~'H ':![.IoA\~au :>!{U'RuAp aloq aloqmlOA\ 'reUO!~!p

    -~l~ ~ o~ reUO!~!pp1? UI .s:![lOA\~aU qsam '~u!od-o~-~u!od

    ~!A pa~:>auuo:> a.I~ saI!~ aqJ, .OOOv'H sd!W aq~ uo paseq S!

    ~as uo!~:>n.I~su! S~I .s!l'IV pU1? 'au!lad!d lossa:>o.Id 'sla~-s!.'i1a.I 'A.Iomam ~~~p 'A.Iomam UO!~:>nl~SU! UA\O S~! seq

    aI!~ q~3 .qsam vXv ~ U! saI!~ 9I seq adA~o~old A\~'H

    I~n~:>~ aqJ, .qsam I~UO!SUam!p OA\~ ~ U! paZ!U1?'alo saI!~

    sas!ldmo:> au!q~m A\~'H aqJ, .au!q:>~m A\~'H aq~ Jo aln~-:>!d ~ SA\oqs 9 aln.'a!..i 1UeWUO.l!AUe ~1UeW!.ledx~~

    .[O~] J.IW ~~ padoIaAap a.In~:>n.I~ge.IJu~ A\I'IA pa.Ia~snI:>

    sn.Ioq:) aq~ pU'e [v~] a.In~:>a~!q:>.rn M.'e1I aq~ :SUIa~S.{SOM.~ U~ ~u~Inpaq:>s ~Ua~.IaAUO:> pa~uaUIaIdUI~ aA~q aA\

    s~Insa'H9

    "'(1)13"3!,'M~.I-t "'(~)13"3!,'M '(;) ':&) q:J1!a lOJ

    .Sa:)lnOSal a~1uTJu1 S1?q au1q;yem t? J1 palnpaq:)s

    aq ut?:) uo1~:)nl~SU1 aq~ uaqA\ S1 ~1 asnt?:)aq uo1~t?mrxold

    -dt? am1~ poo~ t? s1 UO1'Pnl~SU1 U'e Jo IaAaI aq.L .uo1~

    -:)nl~SU1 q:)t?a Jo IaAaI aq~ ~U1z1S1?qdma /i.q uo1~t?mloJu1am1~ aq~ Jo a:)Ua~laAUO:) aq~ dlaq o~ s~dma~~t? SS1?d s1q.L

    (daHdWa) a;)uy~s!p q'Jed {U;)!'J!.1;) az!seqdwa

    .q~t?d pl'eA\dn U'e ~uore ,,~ sa~t?~

    -t?dOld slossa:)apald S~1S1A ~t?q~ UO1~:)UfiJ l'eI1m1S V

    u~ -t ~

    ("~)e:>uepyuo:> > (U~)e:>uepyuo:> ~(~)Iosse:>:>ns 3 u~ I u~ puy

    ".r'l,Mg.O + ".J.'Mg.O -t ".J.'M '(~ ':» ~e IOJ

    V~U # ~) ~[!qA\.("~)e:>uepyuo:> > (~)e:>uepyuo:> ~("~)IOSSe:>:>ns 3 ~ I ~ puy

    :q~1?d pl'eA\.UA\.Op 1? .'auOI1? 'l~

    sa~1?'a1?dOld .'aU!A\.°IIoJ aqL .UO!~;)nJ~SU! ~uapyuo;) pa~;)aI

    -as aq~ aq 'l~ ~a'I .la~aW'el1?d ~ndu! U1? S! 1 Ploqsalq~

    a;)uapyuo;) aqL .q~1?d 1? .'auore Sa;)!l~1?W ~Ua.'alaAUO;)

    .l!aq~ sa~1?'a1?do.ld pU1? suo!~;)n.l~su! a;)uapyuo;) q.'a!q s~;)al

    -as SS1?d S!qL (dOlldH.LVd) uo!'Jua'udo.ld q'Jud

    .~SO;) UO!~1?;)!UnWWO;) S~! UaA!.'a ~!oldxa

    Alq1?~yold U1?;) A\.'IrH ~1?q~ ws!lalrel'ed Jo A~!l1?lnU1?i3 wnw

    -!U!W aq~ O~ Ala~1?w!Xoldd1? puodSallO;) slaAallnoJ aqL

    .A\.'IrH uo slaAaI lnoJ AlaAa ~! Aldd1? aA\. Al~uallno .slaAal

    ~uala.y!p O~ saw!~ ald!~lnw pa!ldd1? aq U1?;) 'I~A~'I

    .EI U!UO!~;)nJ~SU! AU1? pU1? ~ uaaA\.~aq a;)U1?~s!p wnw!u!w aq~

    S! EI U!q 1? pU1? ~ UO!~;)nJ~SU! U1? uaaA\.~aq a;)U1?~s!p aqL

    .SU!q SSOl;)1? SUO!~;)nJ~SU! a~nq!.l~S!P aA\. q;)!qA\. ~1? A~!l'eln

    -U1?i3 a;)U1?~s!p wnw!u!w aq~ sI0l~UO;) 6 la~aW'el1?d aqL

    61 81~pdn~ 0,"~ -'I = 'I

    ~ 0,"~ n EI = EI

    {(EI'~)8:>m!1S!P: 613 ~}X'em~J1! = ~ 0,"~

    ()1I!q-1X8U-1I!qorp1InOJ = EI

    # 'I elIqM.{6 < «~)1I!q-1s8S0I;TP1Iy '~)8:>m!1S!P ~'I 3 ~ I ~ } = 61

    "EI -'I = 'I

    :> J81SnID q;)ge.loj1 = (~)I8A8I I ~ 1IO!1:>nJ1S1I1 = 'I

    ~ ~U! 'I ~U! :e~nq!J~S!aI81\81

    "au!4:>ew Me~ a4.l "g aJn6!.i

    :~U!A\OnoJ aq~ wloFad aA\ 'uaqJ, "(O"Z) Ploqsalq~~ u~q~ la~~a~ S! a:>uapyuo:> asoqA\ pU'e ':> S! la~snI:>

    pallaJald asoqA\ SUO!~:>lll~SU! SU!~~UO:> :J la~snI:> q:>~a lOJ

    Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

  • 9

    .S~U!'1/.I~SUO;) ~U;)W;):n!ld;).Id ;)S;)q~ s;);)np".I U.In~ U! q;)!qA\ 'S;);)U;)P-u;)d;)p ;)SI1!J ;)~1!U!W!I;) O~ ~U!W1!U;).I "88 ;)sn S;)OP ;);)A\1!'HE

    .UO!~:>n.I~SU! q:>t?a JO ~uam~!sSt? ft?Iodwa~ aqJ, "Z

    .la~-snIJ J91Jads ~ o~ UO1~JnJ~su1 AlaAa lOj ~uaUIu~1sse

    W '.;1.~ 'UO1~1~d pallajald aq~ ~u1q~lJSap d~UI V .1

    :s~doA\~ O~U! ~!Ids S! laInpaq:>s~Ua~laAUO;) aq~ JO ~nd~no aq.L .SA\OnoJ &"e slaInpaq:>s ~U!

    -~s!Xa aq~ q~!A\ sa;)~Jla~u! laInpaq;)s ~Ua~laAUO;) aq.L.UaA~ laplO aq~ U! Unl al'e S;)!~S!maq aq.L

    .sruoqo pU'e A\'e1I lOJ laynpaq;)S ~Ua~laAUO;) aq~ /i.q pasn

    S;)!~S!maq aq~ S~S!I 1 aIq~.L s.laInp8q;)s 'JU8~.18AUOD

    a~~~U'eAp~ a){e~ S.laA!~;)~ o~ alq~ S! ~u!lnpaq;)s ~Ua~laAUO;)~~q~ S! uosea1 aqL .;);)It\1?1I au!laseq SUllOJlad~no SS.~lt\

    -re ~Unnpa1:fJS ~Ua~laAUO;) 'SJ{l'P.Ulq;)Uaq asaq~ 10d .S!SS.-reU'R a;)Uan~UO;) UlOlJ SUO!~;)nl~SU! S.lOUlam pa;)~lda1d

    q~!lt\ apo;) X!l~~m asuap aIe sJ{l'P.mq;)Uaq 1no JO s.U'RW

    .sal!~ 9110J % I~ JO ~UaUlaA01dUl! a~~laA~ U'R q~!lt\ 'SJ{l~m1:fJUaq

    aq~ JO ~Som 10J SUO!~~ln.'ayUO;) al!~ Ire 10J ;);)It\1?1I au!1

    -aseq SUllOJlad~no S.1~ua~S!SUO;) ~u!lnpaq;)s ~Ua~laAUO;)~~q~ It\oqS s~lnsa'H .Si)I!~ 91 10J ~~~p am'es aq~ s~Old

    9 a1n.'a!d .sal!~ 91 o~ olt\~ 10J ;);)It\~'H o~ ~u!lnpaq;)s~Ua~laAUO;) JO a;)U~UllOJlad aq~ sa1~dUlO;) ~ alq~L .Sla

    -1!dUlO;) SnlOqO pU'R ;);)It\1?1I au!laseq aq~ q~!lt\ s~lns-a1 1no pa1~dUlO;) aM. suos!;redwo;} e;)~W.l°J.led

    .S.laA!~~~!renb s~lnsa1 aq~ ~;)a1Ja ~OUop S.aq~ ~nq 'am!~ uO!~~lnUl!S Uo Ult\op ~n;) o~ pa~u~q;)

    Ui)8q aA~q SaZ!S malq01d aUlOS .UO!SlaAUO;) 1010;) AflAo~ HD'H Saop AnA .uO!~~;)!ld!~lnm X!l~~m aldUl!s ~ S!

    InUlAA .UO!~~X'ela1 'HOS :>{;)~IH P8'H ~ S! JlOSq'H .1a~IY

    'HId ~ S! l!d .Ulq~!lO~IV qseH a1n;)as JO Uo!~~~uaUlaldUl!

    U'R S! ~qs .aUl!~-Unl i)q~ JO %og SaUlnSUO;) ~~q~ Ul01J

    ddddJ JO do01 1aUU! aq~ S! lau1a:>{-ddddd .(lau1a:>{-ddddJ'A~~;)mo~) g6;)ads pu~ '(UlXUl pu~ '~~UadA 'S.J{saIOq;))

    ~6;)adS JO L~seN '[I] (aJ!1 '!qO;)~r) a~!ns J{l'p.mq;)ui)q It\~'Haq~ apnl;)u! SJ{l~Ul1:fJUaq JO Sa;)lnoS 1no s:>{;rewq;}ueH

    .l;}~snI;) ~Slg ;}q~o~ p;}dd~w ;}IP. SUO~;}l ~u1Inp;}q;)s ;}Id1~Inw SSOl;)~ ;}A1I

    ;}IP. ~~q~ s;}nfRA Ire 'SllJoqD uO &.SUO1~;)llJ~SU1 P;}:reId;}ld

    ;}WO;);}q s;}sn pU'R suo1~1ug;}P ~u;}nb;}sqns ~l;}I1dwo;) ;}q~

    /i.q p;}l;}~UnO;)u;} ;}Sn/uo1~1ug;}P ~Slg ;}q~ Jo l;}~snI;) ;}q~ s1l;}~snI;) s1q~ ';);)M~'H UO .l;}~snI;) ~U;}~S1SUO;) ~ o~ p;}dd~w

    ;}q ~snw s;}sn pu~ suo1~1ug;}P s~1 'SUO1~;}l ~U1Inp;}q;)S ;}Id

    -!~Inw SSOl;)~ ;}A!I S! ;}nI~A ~ U;}qM 'Sl;}I1dwo;) q~oq uI

    .ws1I;}IreIP.d ;}sodx;}

    o~ /i.l~SS;};);}U s1 ~u1IIolun I~uo1~1PP~ ou ~~q~ OS 'SUO1~;}l

    ~U1Inp;}q;)s ;}q~ Jo ;}Z1S ;}q~ S;}se;}l;)U1 osre ~u1IIolun s1qJ,.S;}I1~ lO sl;}~snI;) Jo l;}qwnu ;}q~ /i.q sdooI ;}q~ sIIolun /i.Ire

    -nsn ssed ;};)u;}nJ'iuo;) ;}q~ 'sdooI X1l~~W ;}SU;}P lod .Sl;}~

    -snI;) lO S;}I1~ ;)g1;);}ds uo P;};)~Id ;}q ~snw ~~q~ SUO!~;)llJ~S

    -U1 ;};)U;}l;}J;}l /i.lOW;}W P;};)~Id;}ld S;}~~;}l;) s1s/i.reU'R s1qJ,.[f:l] S;};)U;}l;}J;}l /i.lOW;}W Jo /i.~n1q~P1P;}ld ;}q~ ;}z/i.reU'R

    pU'R ;}se;}l;)U1 O~ s1s/i.reu~ pu~ UO!~~WlOJSU'Rl~ ;};)U;}llJ~

    -UO;) /i.oIdw;} l;}I1dwo;) SllJoqD ;}q~ pU'R ;);)M~ q~og

    .[8] UO1~~;)

    -oII~ l;}~S~;}l l;}~snI;)-'dI~U1S reUO!~!p~l~ /i.q P;}MOIIOJ '~u1-Inp;}q;)s ;}W1~-'d:reds swlop;}d ~Slg ~I "j1nsq:rew Jo do~uo P;}~U;}W;}Idw1 s1 ~1 ';);)M~ ;}}[1'I .;}ln~;)llJ~S I;}A;}I q~1q

    .Jalnpaq;)suo!~;)nJ~su! UMO S~! Aq AI~uapuadapu! pa~ndmo;) aJ'p.s~uam~!sge reJodma~ aq~ ' JaAaMoq ';);)M~'H J°..!I .Jaln

    -paq;)s ~S!I aq~ JOl sa!~!Jo!Jd ge s~uam~!ss~ reJodma~

    aq~ sasn sruoqD .Ja{llpaq;)s ~Ua.'aJaAUO;) aq~ Aq UaA!.'a

    s~uamu.'a!sge re!~~ds aq~ asn ;);)M'e'H pU'e snJoqD q~oH

    .suI4:>ew Me~ SI!J..9~ e uo 6ullnps4:>s ~US6JSAUO:> pue :>:>Me~

    IJSSMtsq suos!Jedwo:> s:>uewJoj.Jsd .9 sJn6!~

    "MI1A paJa~snl:> (q) pueau!4:>ew Me~ a4~ (e) JOj Jalnpa4:>s ~Ua6JaAUO:>a4~ ~q pasn s:>!~s!Jna4 jO a:>uanbas .I. alqe.L

    0~~

    0

    l(q)(~)dDHdW3

    dO'HdH.LVd

    WWOD

    dO'HdH.LVd

    'I3A3'I

    dO'HdH.LVd

    H.LVd

    3DV'Id

    QVO'I

    dO'Hd3DV'Id

    3WI.L..LINI

    v

    d:)HdW3

    WWO:)

    dO'!:Id3:)V'Id

    3:)V'Id

    WWO:)

    HJ.Vd

    J.Sl:Ild

    3Sl0N

    3WI.L.LINI

    9

    9

    O~

    z..

    v~

    Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

  • 6

    aM .[g] OOd pU'e [&~] svn :MI1A pa.Ia~snI;) .I°J sanb!U-tpa~ ~u!{llpatps/~ua~!sge ~U!~spca OM.~ o~ ~U!{llpaq;)s~Ua~.IaAUO;) JO a;)U'em.I°.J.Iad aq~ sa.redmo;) 8 a.m'j!.!I

    .s~uam~!sge poo~ o~ a~.IaAUO;) O~ S;)!~s!.Inaq UO!~tl;)!unm

    -mO;) pue 'ms!Ia(re.red 'sq~tld re;)!~!.I;) .Iaq~o a.I!nba.I snq~

    s}(.remtpuaq asaqJ, .tlqs pU'e (aU.Ia}(~ddd.J .I°J UO!~tlm.I°J-U! (ll.Jasn a(~~!( sap!A°.Id ~uama:>1!(da.Id '~8tl.I~UO;) UJ .;)!~

    -s!.Inaq ~U!;)U'ereq P'eO( aq~ ~U!sn pU'e uo!~tlm.I°Ju! ~uam

    -a:>1!(da.Id aq~ ~u!~tl~tldo.Id Aq 'App!nb suo!~n(os poo~ O~a~.IaAUO;) O~ a(qtl S! .Ia{llpaq;)S ~Ua~.IaAUO;) aq~ 'UO!~tlm.I°J-U! ~uama:>1!(da.Id (ll.Jasn q~!1nS}(.remtpuaq .I°.!I .sa;)ua

    -.IaJa.Id re.Iodma~ AJ!pom A(uo ~tlq~ sasged apn(;)xa Aaq~

    pU'e 's~unO;) UO!':Pn.I~SU! ;)!~tl~S am8tlam s~OId aqJ, .M.tl'H

    uo sged ~Ua~JaAUO;) q:YfIa Aq pa~U'eq;) a.re sa(!~ pa.I.IaJaJd

    asoqM. SUO!~;)n.I~SU! Jo a~tl~ua;).Iad aq~ SM.oqs l. a.m'j!.!I

    .ma(qoJd S!q~ ssa.Ipp'e n!1n ~u!{llpatps~Ua~.IaAUO;) O~ sged ~U!.Ia~snI;) tl ~u!~tl~a~u! ~tlq~ padxa

    aM. -;);)M.tl'H U! ~d.Ia~uno;) ~U!.Ia~sn(;) aq~ U'eq~ p.re~a.IS!q~ U! ~ua!;)llia ssa( uaaq 8tlq s8tld uo!~nq!.I~s!P (aAa( .Ino

    .ms!Iantl.red pau!'e~-aug A.IaA ~u!~!o(dxa pU'e ~U!pug

    a.I!nba.I S}(.remtpuaq asaq~ uo dnpoods poo~ ~U!u!'e~~V

    .s~uamu~!sge poo~ AU'em ~sa~~ns ~ou op SUO!~;)n.I~SU!

    pa:>1!Ida.Id asntl;)aq ;);)M.tl'H au!(a8tlq ueq~ as.IoM. sm.Io.J.Iad

    ~u!{llpaq;)s ~Ua~JaAUO;) 'tlqs putl (au.Ia}(~ddd.J .I°.!I

    .suo!~;)n.I~su! Jo s~uam~!sge re.In~tlu poo~ A.IaA O~

    p'ea( O~ ~no SU.In~ UO!~tlm.IOJU! S!qJ, .SUO!~;)n.I~SU! .Iaq~oJO ~uama;)tl(d aq~ ap!n.CJ O~ UO!~tlm.IoJU! ~uama;)tl(da.Id Jo

    .au!4:)ew Ja~snl:)-aI6u!se o~ aAI~elaJ SI dnpaads "MIlA paJa~snl:)-Jnole uo 6u!lnpa4:)s ~Ua6JaAUO:> pue 'svn ':>:>d

    ueaM4aq SUOSIJedwo:) a:)uewJojJed .8 eJn6!.i

    .Me~ UO sJuawu61sse le!Jeds Jo a:)ua6Jal\uo:) .L aJn61:1

    "al!J auo uo a:)uewJoJJad OJ aA!JelaJ sI dnpaads .dnpaads :):)Me~ "~ alqel

    Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

  • 01

    .papnI~xa a.re sa~ua.IaJa.Id re.IOdwa~

    AJ!POW AIuo ~tlq~ sasStId .SruoqO Uo sStId ~Ua~.IaAUO~

    q:>'ea Aq pa~mlq"J a.re saI!~ pa.I.IaJa.Id asoqM SUO!~~ru~SU!

    J!~tI~S JO a~tI~ua~.Iad aq~ SMOqS 6 a.I~!d .s:!{.rewq"JuaqX!l~tlW asuap .Ino .IOJ SUo!~!~.red re.In~tlU poo~ pug o~

    UO!~tlW.IOJU! ~uawaJtlIda.Id asn 01- aIqtl S! laInpaq"Js ~ua~-laAUOJ aq~ ' M'e1I U! a:!{!'I .aU!qJtlW A\I'IA pala~SnIJ

    -lnoJ tI Uo 'AIaA!~~adsal '%S~ pml %vI Aq OOd pml

    SVJ1 sw.I°J.Iad~no ~u!Inpaq"Js ~Ua~laAU00 .SSaJJtI 1i.:I.0-waw reJOI-UOU tI 10J aU!qJtlw A\I'IA pala~snIJ aq~ Aq

    pallnJU! S~SOJ tll':pCa aq~ ~UnapoW Aq 'UO!~tlWlOJU! ~uaw

    -aJtlIda.Id 10J S~UnoJJtI AIlad01d S~SOJ UO!~tI~!UnWWOJ

    pml sq~uaI a{llpaq"Js ~U!~tlW!~sa 10J wq~!.IO~re aq~ 'OOd10d .SUO!~Jru~SU! paJtlIda.Id JO la~snIJ awoq aq~ o~ A~!lO-!ld ~saq~!q aq~ aA~ o~ ladtld reU~!lO aq~ U! paq!l~Sap

    J!~S!maq OSdO aq~ AJ!poW aM 'sva 10d .UO!~tlWlOJ

    -U! ~uawaJtlIda.Id q~!M Wq~!lO~re ~U!~S!Xa q~tla ~ua~ntl

    -se ;Ia~snI:> U! }{;IOA\. ;Iaauo!d aq.L .spoq~am UO!~~:>oI

    -I~ ;Ia~S~a;I pm? ~u!Inpaq:>s ~S!I reUO!~!p~;I~ q~!A\. paId-no:> '~uamu~!ss~ ;Ia~snI:> op o~ sA~A\. IaAou uo pasn:>

    -oJ seq q:>J~aSa;I q:>nw .AIa~~mdas smaIqo;Id aaJq~ aq~

    SSa;Ippe Sa;In~:>a~!q:>;I~ I~!~~ds ;IOJ s;IaI!dmo:> Am?W

    .~uam~!sse ;Ia~snI:> o~ ~u!Inpaq:>s ~Ua~JaAUO:>JO UO!~~:>!Idd~ aq~ S! ;Iad~d S!q~ Jo sn:>°J aq~ ~nq '(IIaA\.

    se S;Ia~S~a;I ;IOJ sd~m a:>Ua;IaJa;Id ~U!PP~ Aq) ;Iaq~a~o~

    S}{se~ aa;Iq~ II~ m;IoJ.Iad m?:> ~~q~ }{JOA\.a~.IJ re;IaUa~ ~

    pap!AO;Id aA~q aM .uO!~~:>°Ire ;Ia~S!~a;I pu~ '~u!Inpaq:>s

    '~uamu~!sS1? ;Ia~snI:> a;I!nbaJ Sa;In~:>a~!q:>;I~ re!~eds

    }{.lOA\. pa':J~Ia'H9

    .A~!I~nb ~uawu~!ss~ .Ia.Iood

    q:>nw U! s~Insa.I osre s~uauodwoJ Jo .Iaqwnu aq~ ~u!Jnp-a.I 'sJ[.I~wq:>uaq .Ino .I°J ~~q~ puy aM. ' .IaAaM.°H .II~wS

    ~daJ[ S! s~uauodwoJ Jo .Iaqwnu aq~ J! paJnpa.I AII~J!~~W-~.Ip aq mlJ aw!~-aI!dwo:) .o~U! SUO!~Jn.I~SU! aq~ Sap!A

    -!P AIre!~!U! ~! s~uauodwoJ Jo .Iaqwnu aq~ o~ aA!~!SUaS

    AIq~!q S! :):)d ~~q~ a~ou aM .:):)d mlq~ .Ia~~aq AIq~-.Iap!suoJ areJS q~oq AaqJ. .aw!~ Jo ~unow~ aW'es aq~

    ~noq~ aJ[~~ SVfl pu~ ~u!InpaqJs ~Ua~.IaAUOJ ~~q~ SM.oqsa.In~y aqJ. ..IaInpaqJs aq~ U! ~uads aw!~ apn[Ju! s~uaw-a.InS'eaw Jno -~uawu~!sS'e uo!~Jn.I~su! .Ia':jJ~ .IaInpaq:>s

    ~S![ ~uapuadapu! u~ asn :):)d pu~ ~u!InpaqJs ~Ua~.IaAUOJ

    q~og .sn.Ioq:) UO :):)d pml SVflJo ~~q~ q~!M. ~u1InpaqJs

    ~Ua~.IaAUOJ JO aw!~-aI!dwoJ aq~ sa.I~dwoJ 01 a.In~!.!!

    .s.IossaJo.Ido.IJ!w a.In~nJpu~ u.Iapow Aq pap!AoJd d'II Jo [aAaI aq~ ~.Ioddns o~Al'essa:>au S! ado:>s a~.I~I ~ asn~Jaq 'puo:>as pu~ ~suo~

    -aa.I~ pu~ SJ[:>°Iq.IadAq S'e q:>ns sanb!uqJa~ Uo!~~~uasa.Ida.I.IaI!dwoJ U! s~UawaAoJdw! O~ anp '~S.Iy :suoS'ea.I OM.~ .IOJ

    sas!.l~ paau S!qJ. .sUO!pn.I~SU1 JO .Iaqwnu .Ia~l'eI pml.Ia~.I~I a[pu~q O~ swq~!.IO~I~ ~u![npaq:>s pu~ ~uaw~!s-S'e Uo!pn.I~SU! .I°J paau ~u!S'ea.I:>u! mI S! a.Iaq~ asn~:>aq

    ~mI~odw! S! A~!I!q~I~:>S .~u!InpaqJs ~Ua~.IaAUOJ JO A~!

    -I!q~I~:>s aq~ au!w~xa aM A~!I!qele;)s aw!~-al!dwoo

    °SnJ04~ UO SW41!J061e J01 az!s 1nd-U! SA aUI!1-alldwo:> 10 uos!Jedwo~ 00 ~ aJn6!~

    palnpall:)S SUO!\:1nJtSui Jo JaqwnN

    oog~ ooo~ oog oooz0

    ~ooo.o

    ~o.o

    ~

    (1)n".IDc.Eo5"

    cc-3ID

    -;;-IDno~c.~

    001-

    oooo~

    ooo000~

    .snJo4:> uo s~u8wu6!sse le!~eds lo 8:)U86J8AUO:> .6 8Jn6!:I

    S8SS8d

    ",,00H.LVdlS"I~3SION 00

    Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

  • II

    .6661 'SI-v sa~~d '(V:JSI) ~np~7~1{;).LV .L~7nd-wo:J uo wn~S'odwliS 17JUO~77JW~7UI 1{79g uI .sau!qJew

    M~"H JOJ ma~sAs AJomaw pa~eu~w-JaI!dmoo V :sd~W.I~MJ1!~V .V p~ 'aq~u!sexemv .S 'aa'I .M. '~nxeH ."H [~]

    .L66I 'f:vI-vf:I sa~ed

    '(W:J:Jd) S'~u~I{;)7JW 6u~7ndwo:J wo7S'n:J p~S'7JEI-S'Vf)dduo wn~S'odwliS 1{7g uI .~u!~ndmoo asodJnd IeJauaD JoJ

    saJn~JnJ~S uo!~e~ndmoo :a~!ns 'lxemq:>uaH M.V"H aqJ,leMxe~v .V p~ '!Un~J{1!qqeAaa .S 'm!)I .r 'JoIAeJ, .W'enJ1!H ."H 'PIO~U!~M. .3 'aa1 .A "lue~ .w 'qqeH .r [I]

    AIuO 'aAoq~ aq~ JO .suol~;)nJ~sul pa;)~IdaJd ~uno;);)~o~ul a}{~~ o~ pa~lsap are saq:>~oJdd~ ~UatU~lsge Mad

    .sUO1~;)nJ~sul pa;)~Id-aJd aA~q aM uaqM ~uatU~lsge Ja~snI;) ul punoJ aM tUaI

    -qoJd ~ulJapJO ageqd aq~ ssaJp~ o~ ~1 pasn aA~q aM pue

    'paSJaAaJ JO pauod~sod aq o~ Suolsl;)ap sMoIre ~~q~ }{JOM

    -atU'eJJ reJaUa~ ~ Sap!AoJd ~ulInpaq;)s ~Ua~JaAUO;) '~geJ~-UO;) UJ .reuy pue aIq~;)oAaJI! sl uolsl;)ap AJaAa ' JaAa

    -MOq 'saq;)~oJdd~ asaq~ Ire UJ .[II] JaInpaq:>s ~slI uaA1Jp-aI;)A;) AI~SOtU ~ o~ul UO1~~;)°ll~ Ja~s~aJ pue ~uatU~lsge

    q~oq ~ul~~~a~ul Aq 'da~s auo U1 -UO1~~;)°Ire Ja~s~aJ

    pue '~ulInpaq;)s '~uatUu~lsge -S}{ge~ aaJq~ Ire StUJoJ-Jad S'HVO .[f.'~] Jaynpaq;)s ~slI UaA1Jp-aI;)A;) ~ o~ul ~uatU

    -~lsge ~ul~~J~a~ul Aq Jaq~a~o~ ~ulInpaq;)s pue ~uatU-~lsge stUJoFad SV!l .~Ulreauue pa~~IntUls uo pageq

    sl q;)~oJdd~ aq.L .[91] dSa M1'IA ~ uo ~Uluol~l~red

    pue ~ulInpaq:>s uuoFad o~ q;)~oJdd~ paulqtUo;) aAl~~Ja-~1 ue saqlJ;)sap sJadna'I .suol~nIos paulqtUo;) pasodoJd

    aA~q S}{JOM ~ua;)aJ 'stUaIqoJd ~ulJapJO ageqd PloA~ °.L

    .sf)Va ~ndul Jo q~uaI uol~n;)a-xa aq~ azltUl~do O~ ~dtUa~~~ Af~;)aJ1P ~OU saop , JaAaMoq

    'tUq~lJO~re slq.L .uol~~;)!untUtUo;) azltUlultU O~ salJ~ ~~q~

    ~uluol~l~red ~ln;)Jl;) tU°JJ pa~d~p~ tUq~lJO~re ~n;)-ultU~ sasn ageqd ~uatUu~lsge aq.L .~uatUu~lsS'R aJoJaq ~ul

    -Inpaq;)s stUJoFad ~I .sageqd Jo ~U1JapJO aq~ ul saq;)~oJd-d~ aAoq~ aq~ tUOJJ sJa.IJ1P q;)~oJdd~ aq~ '[f.'] uI

    .sUO1~;)nJ~sul pa:>1?IdaJd tUOJJ S~UreJ~SUO;) saIpueq osI~;);)M~'H '~uatUa;)~Id ~U1Jna .saIl~ O~ sJa~snI;) sd~tU 1UdW

    -d:)vld ~~ul~JatU q~noJq~ sJa~snI;) Jo JaqtUnu aq~ sa;)npaJfjU~fj.jdW ~tUslIall~J~d aI~~lI aA~q ~~q~ SUO1~;)nJ~sul Jaq~a~-o~ sdnoJ~ fju.ud1snl:) :sda~s aaJq~ Ul patUJoFad sl ~uatU

    -~lSSV .[tI] ~ulInpaq;)s qd~~ ~S'R~ Jossa;)oJdl~IntU JoJ

    padoIaAap sanbluq;)a~ Sa~~JaAal ;);)M~ .aInpaq;)s aq~saAoJdtUl Ja~snl;) Jaq~oue o~ ~uauodtUo;)-qns ~ ~U1AOtU

    Jaq~aqM ~ul~;)aq;) Aq '~ua;)sap aAl~~Ja~! q~noJq~ paAoJd-tU! AI~uanbasqns are s~uatU~lsge aq.L .~lJa~lJ;) UO!~

    -~;)luntUtUo;) pu~ ~Ul;)U~I~q P~ol aIdtUls uo pageq SJa~

    -snI;) o~ pa~lsge Alre!~!Ul are s~uauodtUo;) aq.L .paul~ld

    -xa ~ou S! poq~atU ~;)~xa aq~ q~noq~re 'atU!~-aIldtUo;)

    pue a;)uetUJoFad uaaM~aq .IJOO~J~ aq~ Sa;)U~I~q ~~q~"7 JOJ anl~A ~ ~;)alaS O~ S;)!~slJnaq aIdtU!s sasn ~I ."7, Ja~atU'ered ~ Aq padd~;) S! ~uauodtUo;) ~ Jo azls tUntU!

    -X'RUI aq.L .~SJy q~~d-re;)l~!J;) 'dn tUO~~oq qd~~ a;)uap

    -uadap ~~~p aq~ ~Ul~!S1A Aq s~uauodUlo;) rel~d sPIlnq~I .[g] s~uauodUlo;) rel~d uo pageq q:>~oJdd~ ~uatU

    -~lSS'R aAl~~Ja~l ue S! OOd .suolpnJ~SU! pa;)~IdaJd J°.J

    ~oddns aq~ ~noq~!A\ '[L I] f)!lg Jo ~uelJ'eA ~ sasn JaI!d-UIO;) MoIJ!~Inw aq.L .~sa!lrea ~! a~n;)axa U~;) ~~q~ Ja~

    -snI;) aq~ o~ UO!~;)nJ~SU! q;)~a d~tU AIlpaaJ~ pue UMOp

    -do~ qd~~ aq~ SaSJaA~J~ ~1 'uaq.L .sUO1~;)nJ~SU! pa;)~ld-aJd ~noq~ UO!~~UlJ°.JU! a~~~~doJd o~ dn-tUo~~oq qd~~

    a;)uapuadap ~ SaSJaA~J~ mq~!JO~re aq~ '~SJ!d .tUq~lJO~

    -I~ ageqd-oM~ ~ sasn S! f)!lg .[9] f)!lg sl ~uaUIu~ls

    se:)ue.Ieje'H

    .( SUO!1-JnJ1-SU!paJ~IdaJd) 1-U!~J1-SUOJ A\aU ~ pu~ (UO!1-~J!UnmmoJ pu~, A1-!reJOI 'ms!IaII~J~d) S1-U!'eJ1-SUOJ reUO!1-!p~J1- q1-0q , Jau

    -u~m pa1-~J~a1-U! U~ U! '1-JOddns 01- JaInpaqJs 1-Ua~JaAUOJ

    aq1- JO A1-!I!q~ aq1- molJ SamoJ SU!'e~ aJU~mJOpad asaq1-

    JOJ UOS~aJ auo .A[aA!1-JadsaJ '%J71 pu~ % I~ JO 1-uam-aAOJdm! aJU~mJOpad pa1-~J1-SUOmap pu~ ' MI'IA paJa1-

    -snIJ pm? A\~'H 'saJn1-Ja1-!qJJT? I~!1-~ds 0A\1- UO 1-! pa1-uam

    -a[dm! aA~q aM .){JOA\aurnlJ ~U!s!moJd ~ S! ~u!InpaqJs

    1-Ua~JaAUOJ 1-~q1- aJUap!Aa s1-uasaJd Jad~d S!q.L

    .SUO!S!Jap aIq!sJaAaJJ! JOOd ~U!P!OA~ snq1- 'SUO!S

    -!Jap J!aq1- 1-noq~ aJUapyuoJ AJ!Jads 01- sass~d SA\OIre

    SSaUaA!ssaJdxa aq.L .smaIqoJd ~U!JapJO as~qd a1-~!AaII~sdIaq qJ!qA\ 'AIaA!1-~Ja1-! UaAa JO Sam!1- aId!1-Inm pa1-nJa

    -xa aq 01- sas~d SA\OfI~ osI~ 1-1 .SJ!1-S!Jnaq A\au a1-~J~a1-u!

    JO S1-U!~J1-SUOJ A\au aIpu~q 01- JadoIaAap JaI!dmoJ aq1-

    JOJ, A~a 1-! sa){~m A1-!J![dm!s aq.L .aA!ssaJdxa pu~ aId

    -m!s aJ~ sass~d uaaA\1-aq aJ~pa1-u! S1-1 .~u!InpaqJS pm?

    1-uamu~!ss~ UO!1-JnJ1-SU! ~U!mJOpad JOJ ){JOA\am~JJ aIq!-xaI:J ~ '~u!InpaqJs 1-Ua~JaAUOJ SaJnpoJ1-U! Jad~d S!q.L

    UO!snl:JuoaI..

    .UO!~~la~! JO ~SO;) aUI!~-a[!dUIO;) aq~ ~noq~!!A ~nq'sass~d ~uapuadapu! ~U!~~la~! JO UO!s!;)ald aq~ aAa!q;)~ O~

    a[q~ S! ss~d paSOdUIO;) aqJ, .laq~a~o~ UnI pU'e paSOdUIO;)

    aq O~ sas~d !AoIJ~~~P pau~!sap £.[~uapuadapu! sa[q~ua

    q;)~Oldd~ S!H igI] 1UdUL;1:Jvld;1.l t{dv.l6 uo pas~q sass~d

    ~Uala!J!p O~ a;)~Jla~U! ~U!~Sala~U! U~ SaSOdOld laUla1

    .)fIP.UIq;)Uaq q;)~a UO £.[~uapuadapu! pa![dd~ S! uo!~n[-oAa aq~ uaq!A la~~aq UaAa SUIIOJ.1ad ~! pu~ 'SUO!~n[OS

    [~laUa~ pOO~ spuy q;)~Oldd~ aqJ, .[t] aZ!S apO;) aZ!UI!~-do o~ sass~d Jo iaplO aq~ aA[OAa O~ UO!~n[OS UIq~!IO~[~

    -;)!~aUa~ ~ sasn ladooo .~U![npaq;)S ~Ua~laAUO;) q~!!A

    sam~~aJ pu~ S[~O~ IP.[!UI!S al~qs S~al~ asoq~ U! saq;)~old-d~ aUIOS .SUO!~~Z!UI!~dO 1~[~;)S U! Sm;):Jo UIa[qold ~U!

    -laplO as~qd [~;)!S~[;) alOUI ~ ~~al~ !AaU £.[aA!~~[al ~

    S! Sam~;)a~!q;)l~ pala~Sn[;) UO SanSS! ~U!laplO a~qd

    .UIaq~ ~loddns £.[~;)al!p ;);)!A~'H pu~ D11H

    Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

  • 61

    .ZooZ I!ldV /qJ:reW 'gf:-gz sa~~d 'O.j:J~W 888[

    .sm~l'Jold asodmd {l!lauaD p~ S~!nJl!:) axeA\Uos lOJ

    J!lq~d I~uo!~~~ndmo:) V :loSSaJOldolJ!W A\~"H aq.Ll~A\xe~V .V p~ 'aq~u!~l1!mv .S '){U~~ .W .S .A 'u~m

    -P!uqs .N '!){sauas .W 'J~xes .V '~W .V 'aa'I .M. 'UOS

    -uqor .d 'aa'I .M.-.r 'u~mIJoH .H 'PI~A\uaalD .H '~~lp

    -oqD .d 'J:reIz~uaM. .a 'laIl!W .r 'm!){ .r 'loIA~.L .w [f7z]

    .8661 '9If:-80f: sa~~d '( O'l:I:J

    -IW) a.jn7:Ja7~1{:J.jTJO.j:J~W Uo wn~S"odwliS lTJuo~7TJWa7uI

    7S"TC uI .saln~J"~!qJxeolJ!W aI!d la~s~""H pala~snI:) lOJ

    ~U!Inp"qJS O~ 1IJ~olddV A\aN V :"Inp"1IJS pu~ U~!S

    -sV p"y!Un .,,~UO:) .w ..L pu~ '~nl"u~H .s 'l"ZO .3 [f:z]

    .IOOZ 'I9-Of7 s,,~~d '(O'l:IDIW) a.jn7:Ja7~1{:J.jTJO.j:J~W Uo

    wn~S"odwliS lTJuo~7TJWa7UI 1{7tC UI .s"ln~J"~!qJlV lOSS"J

    -old P!lD JO uo!~~nI~A3 "J~dS U~!S"a v .l"I){J"){ .s

    pu~ 'la~lnH .a 'm~~u!I~xe){U~S .){ 'u~r~xe~~N ."H [zz]

    .9661 'zz-96-N.L -s:) ~lod,,"H I~J!u1IJ".L .~u!Inp"1IJS UO!~

    -Jnl~SUI pu~ UO!~~JOIlV l"~S!~""H ~u!u!qmo:) .u"A""H .S

    pu~ 'xe){xes .A 'm"I~d .A .){ '!U~A\~OW ."H [IZ]

    .IOOZ l"qm"~d,,s 'A~oIou1IJ".L

    Jo ,,~n~!~suI s~~asn1IJ~s~w 'S!S"q~ S,l"~~W .s"U!qJ

    -~W M.I'IA lOJ "ln~Jnl~~lJuI UO!~~I!dmo:) .az~w .a [OZ]

    .Z661 'f7g-gf7 sa~~d '(O'l:IDIW)

    a.jn7:Ja7~1{:J.jTJO.j:J~W UO wn~S"odwliS lTJUO~1TJWa7uI lTJnuuv

    1{1g'6 uI .){JOIql"dAH "q~ ~U!Sn uo!~nJ"x3 pa~~J!p"ld

    lOJ ~loddns laI!dmo:) "A!~J"IJ3 .uu~m~u!lH .V ."H pu~

    '){U~H .3 ."H 'u"q:) .A .M. 'U!'I .:) .a "'){Iq~W .v .S [61]

    ."qn1I/np".pl1!Al1!q.SJ"".A\A\A\/ /:d~~1I J!nsqJ~W [81]

    .f:661 'Zf71-19 s,,~~d '6u~1ndwo:J.jadns

    10 lTJWnof uI .laI!dmo:) ~u!Inp"qJS aJ~.J.L A\og:!~Inw

    "q.L .~laqua~~n"H .r pu~ 'Il"uuoa,o .r 'X!N ."H 'U!,,~S

    -u"~qJ!'I .M. 's"zxe){ ..L 'l"~l"qu"pna~ .S 'A"uA\o'I .d [l.1]

    .OOOZ 'OOf:-I6Z s,,~~d '(..LDVd)

    s";lnb~u1{:Ja..L UO~1TJ1~dwoD pUTJ s";1.jn7:J;l1~1{:J.jV lallTJ.jTJdUo a:Ju;I.jaluoD lTJUO~7TJW;l1UI 1{16 uI .sdsa M.I'IA

    p"la~snI:) lOJ ~u!Inp"qJS uo!~Jnl~suI .sl"dna'I ."H [91]

    .W06 '686-oL6 sa~~d '(7dOd)

    fl;j6vn6uv7 6u~wwv.l6o.ld fo fl;jld~;)U~d uo wn~flodwliS

    1{16;; tII .stIo~~~mJoJstI1!~ ptI1! sas/i.I~tIV A\o1J~~~a ~tI~

    -sodmoo .sJaqm~t{O .0 ptI1! 'aAOJD .a 'JatIJa'I .S [g1]

    .8661 'Lg-9v sa~~d '(SO7dSV) flW;j1

    -flliS 6u~1V.l;jdO puv fl;j6vn6uv7 6u~wwV.l6o./,d .lOf 1.lod-dns lv.ln1;);j1~1{:J.J,V uo ;j;)U;j.l;jfu°:J lVUO~1VU.l;j1UI 1{18 tII

    .atI~t{~W A\~'H ~ tIO ms~IaI{1?J'ed IaAa'I-tIo~~;)nJ~StIJ Jo ~tI~-Inpat{;)S am~.L -a~dS .at{~tI~seJ'emv .S ptI1! ' J1!JIJ'eS .A

    'qq~H .r '~tIt{S1JJ{~JS .a ')ftI1!J.!I .W '~nJ'eH .'H 'aa'I .M [v1]

    .6006 '(.L:JVd) fl;jnb~u1{;);j.L UO~1vl~d-w°:J puv fl;j.ln1;};11~1{;).lV l;jllV.lVd uo ;j;)U;j.l;jfu°:J lvUO~1

    -VU.l;j1UI 1{n T tII .a:>tIan~tI°O ssaJpPV /i.Jomaw ~tI1

    -~:>a~aa ptI~ ~tI~seaJ:>tII .at{~tI~seJ'emv .S ptI1! tIasJ'e'I .S [f:1]

    .6006 '18-1L sa~~d '(V:JSI) ;l./,n1;);j1~1{;).lV .l;j1nd

    -w°:J uo wn~flodwliS lVUO~1VU.l;j1UI 1{'16;; tII .~tI~ssa:>

    -oJd pa~nq~J~S~a IaAa'I tIo~~:>nJ~stII JoJ am~:>a~~t{:>J'eoJ:>

    -~W ptI1! ~as tIo~~:>nJ~stII tIV .t{~~ms .a. r ptI1! m~)I .S-.H [61]

    .1006 'f:v1-f:f:1sa~~d '(V:JdH) ;j.ln1;);j1~1{;).lV .l;j1ndwo:J ;j;)UV~Of.l;jd

    1{6~H uo wn~flodwliS lVUO~1VU.l;j1UI 1{U tII .sJossa:>oJd

    d'II paJa~snlO JOJ )fJOA\am~J.!I tIo~~~JatIaf) apoo A\aN V

    :S'HVO .~reA\~~v .)I .V ptI~ 'nI~o~:>qa .)I 'sel!'e)l .)I [11J

    .f:661 tI1!r

    '8v6-666:(1)L '6u~1ndwo;).l;jdns fo lVU.lnof ;jt{.L .tIO~~~I

    -~dmoo J'ere:>sJadns ptI1! MI'IA JoJ anb~tI1fJa.L aA~~:>a.ya

    tIV :Jf.J°lqJadns at{.L .J:.JaA~'I .a ptI1! 'mloH .r 'q~~H .f)

    '~J'et{o/i.~)I ..L ')ftI1!H .'H 'a~~allano .'H 'tItI1!m~tI~JH .'H

    'Ja~J'eM .N '~tI~t{O .d 'tIat{O .M 'a)fI~W .S 'nA\H .M [01]

    .8661 '9L6-g96 sa~~d '(V:JdH) ;j./,n1;);j1~1{;).lV

    .l;j1ndw°:J ;j:Juv~Of.l;jd 1{6~H uo wn~flodwliS lVUO~1VU

    -.l;j1UI 1{1r tII .sJossa:>oJd anssI ap~M JoJ ~tI~lnpat{:>S

    tIo~~aa~ .a~uoo .w ..L ptI1! '~~rJatI1!H .S '~)fu~A~H .V. M [6]

    .9661 'v6f:-oof::(f:)81 'flW;j1flliS puVfl;j6vn6uv7 6u~wwv.l6O.Ld uo flUO~1:JVflUV~ W:J V .~U~

    -:>saI~oo Ja~s~a'H pa~~Ja~I laddv .M .V pu~ a~Joaf) .'I [8]

    .1861 /i.lnr '06v-8Lv:(L)0f:-0 'fl.l;j1nd-W°:J UO flUO~1:JVflUV~ {if{if{ifI .uo~~~dmoo apo:>oJ:>~W

    I~qoID JoJ anb~ut{:>a.L V :~u~Inpat{:>S a~~ .Jat{s~d .V. r [L]

    .9861 'ssaJd .LIW .fl;1./,n1

    -;);j1~1{:J.lV MI7A .lOf .l;jl~dw°:J V :6opllnH .s~IIa .'H .r 19]

    .8661 'sa~Jo~~Joq~'I PJ1!JI~d ~~aIA\aH 'f:1-g6-'IdH~Joda'H ~:>~utf)a.L .~oJddV A\aN ~ :sJaI~dmoo dSa

    MI'IA paJa~snIO JoJ ~uam~~ssv uo~~:>llJ~SUI .~Iosaa .f) [g]

    .6661'6-1 sa~~d '(S{if.L:J7J flW;j1flliS PaPP;jqW{if .lOf fllo°.L puv

    fl.l;jl~dw°:J 'fl;j6vn6uv7 uo dO1{fl:y.l°M uI .smt{~~Jo~IV

    :>~~auaf) ~u~sn a~ds apoo pa:>npa'H JOJ ~u~z~m~~do

    .tI1!~tI1!~Jqns .a ptI1! 'a)fla~t{:>S .r .d 'Jadooo .a .)I [v]

    .6661 '00f:-666 sa~~d '( O'}J:JIW) ;l./,n1:J;j1~1{;).lVO.l:J

    -~W uo wn~flodwliS lvuo~1vU./,;j1UI 1{1g;; uI .S.lJoap~~

    Jo s~s/i.l~uV J:.J'eu~m~IaJd V :sMI'IA JoJ saI~d Ja~s~a'H

    pauo~~~~J'ed .n~I°:>~N .V pu~ '~~na .N 'o~u~~~d~o .V [f:]

    Proceedings of the 35 th Annual IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO-35) 1072-4451/02 $17.00 © 2002 IEEE

    Index: CCC: 0-7803-5957-7/00/$10.00 © 2000 IEEEccc: 0-7803-5957-7/00/$10.00 © 2000 IEEEcce: 0-7803-5957-7/00/$10.00 © 2000 IEEEindex: INDEX: ind: