27
49 1390 97 - 71 : 2 1390 : 26 1390 . » « » « . . . . . 1 . : . JEL : A12 A19 Z12 . () [email protected] () [email protected], [email protected] 1. Interdisciplinary Approach

ç6 A06)B ç ,%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*Cê :( AE6, 'F :( G&)3ç)B +()Bijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3010_f596d7f27fde0615d35f7877a2cd... · 2021. 1. 18. · ç6 A06)B ç ,%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*Cê

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • !"#$%&'()*( +,"%-.( +" /"01,23"4 56"74 849 8'"-9!:1390;" 897-71

    '"?! @6 A06)B ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6,-46 +('F :( G&)3)B +()B

    !"#$%&' ()%*'+#,-'./0) 123%45"'%67#48-'9

    !":2 "#"$%1390 :&$'( 26 )*+,1390

    ,"%-.(HCH, A!D0(+( IJK 5:)!( E G0()-L?BMB (6 '"7$M9! '"3(,,"%-.(,JN,"M%-.( 5CM#*F :( )M-OB P6, QC "B R"S! T*( .G0( 5,)E U$I8A!DM0(

    VD0( '"3(,,"%-.( ;"*)W3 @)X3 , "B (6 A!D0( ,"%-.( 6, ()Y»,"%-.( B A!D0(A&"Z( U?E)K [* '(J#\« »,"%-.(A=M> UM?E)K [M* '(JM#\ MB A!D0(«

    -0,A! +C#B CM4 ,C

    ,"%-.( /J74B (6 A!D0(A! G`0 +)?X7La 6JbME CM*, 1?(JN "!( .CLcBAB d7\ 6,e?-3 2?3 V, @)X3 6, A!D0( A3"_! B AOIJK )(Jf gD>( 2I +(

    ( h"`R "B [?0DEJi3 ,"%-.( :( G&)3)B QC "B R"S! T*( .G0( -4(C3 )B6, A!D0*)W3 A$`& jZ,"%-.( +:(,)A!D0(86()M. MIJK ,6JM! (6 AMS?=$K GM&"?6

    A! 8'"B: 6J-0, ]?^ :( A!D0( ,"%-.( C#a ) @)X3 T*( 6, .C,'"#k7 [*B A!JO=! ]?^ :( E +C^( +(J- QJ>J! U?E)K G0,

    A!A! 8,6FTM*( .CM4 'F :( 3"Y, A_?E)K @)X3 U$0 B dl". 6)! B '(JK'"?! ,)m*6 'Jk7 A\J#-! +",)m*6 UR"H 6, G&"?6-46+(1 `R"n! ,6J!

    A! 6()..,)?Y

    5p(+C?$E +":-.%/0# "123#4$56-78#"$(!9:4%6$, -.;99% 7:42?7#.S_bC#B +JEL:A12 -A19 -Z12.

    6#"@9: ABC D 9E "123# D .%/0# FG% HIJE6#" .*=C (L) M"N O%# HPE6#"[email protected] Q3 49*=C H8AR .SC TU0 4V=W D (L) M"N O%# HPE6#" "123# D .%/0# FG% 42? I?# XY?Z

    [email protected], [email protected]. Interdisciplinary Approach

  • 72 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    1 .!CS!4[\I\" -]9[0/ZA@6 "123# .6^AW 4;,0 , 4_;% " .%/0# "123#7#4[:" " 4[Z [0#7[:

    .0# H"$Z a=b "Ac 4, # >*=_% >6#""123# 4bA 42?'d, >9% )# " 4, 4bA "A[V6.[6#""123# -Q=C )# " >P*: M

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...73

    /CI1.U?E)K AN)B,"%-.( 5:J^ 6, G=> Q"q! +"U?E)KQ"q! +"U?E)KG=> +"

    "123# 4

  • 74 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    ? 42#i9% 4 f$56 )# 7#A2r%.Z >#i9% 4D HI? 7#"$,]9[0/ZA@6 a[2J% " >#$[P" f[$56 4,[E% o[3#^ [

    0#.-.% IR 4 oNR >Y9*W# -f$56 )# 8# ] $: 7#A2r% .%/0# 7^, 9C 8# >#A

    ."$Z L!" O/0# " >h V2C# 8# D "A*6 4S;% )#.% &/ IYZ)# )99V )*e .2[0Z .[0$, D .%/0# "123# " &$P6 D"7[:

    $:>9% )A6 7:IY#$! $, 7D$% D .!$G% , >( " -&$P6 D" 42[?-I[Ib OA[=C I[9SA " 7#a0Y% ?#"$,"123# 7#A2r% D Q9:

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...75

    , IY6% 4;! 4, 4Z 0# .#D D fh $P" )9Y*: D ... D *c -ZE% -4,B% -9, 7: .c$,LAeA%7:HI? 42E6 .+;! 7:.I:"o9=r 7:[[$W 8# D [[+;! [[0A -[[SR )$[[2+, " 4[[Z [[0# .[[;9;r o%[[? .%/[[0# 7"[[123# .[[+;!

    k^I20# 0# 42!$d Og6# Y0 D 2Z .YG .=N# ,Y% X0#$, D 7$9_0Y?Z 0A 4Z 0# .;9;r -SR )$I, " D

    o9=r )# $d# .0# HI? 42?A6 (:;!D [0# H"

    I?, HI? I9SA.2

    .[+;! O[JR# o[3#^ [ D OA[1G% #D ->h$3 6 &$P6 )# " "AbA% Q9:"A, d80 4, $id6 -&$P6 )# .W VY2_% 7:kA[N# D 4;!

    0# .%/0# uVY20#.3&D >[*: &$[P6 )[# " [9;r &D )#$,Y,D .2:[;! F[G2% 7[:.0# .%/0# uVY20# kAN# , d80 -46A*6 7#$,-.[+;! O[JR# >#" #$[3 [YV% [, &$P6 )# "

    .%O/[0# " >h 7^[, [V2C# 8# >Y9*W# , # O/0# " 9JS% kAN# >#A ."A[*6 uVY2[0# -47#$[, r, " -46A*6H# )2[_6#" O#$[R [, -O/[0# " 9JS% kAN#"[_! 7[:Z D o[W, 7[: D i9P6#

    HV4%$[0 D O#$[R k[% {#I[9( a[bA% D HI? H?# 4%$r% a0J% aS3 " 4Z HIYYZ I[6# 78D.%"A?5- 4Z 0# HI? 42!$d 4g926 )9Y H# )[# $9\ 8# 4Z .S% $: ([, [:4k/[R I[h [0"

    .I? I:#Ac >h ]S% l? D 0#(8# I[, "A[? ][S% # 7i[9 |C$? 0#Ac ._Z $d#H#, O/0# )96#A3 ,U% D LD$E% 7:4."Dh 0"

    1. >Ec")1385(2.7Ac) "#j61385 D ( O6AJ6)1386(3 . O6AJ6)1386(4. .g69% 7I*R#)1361(5. 716#)1428(

  • 76 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    I%h" I9SA >#i9% o,;% " 4G9? 4;! |̂ AN#., >h TU0 )99G DU,#A[e [+Y D [0# fDh >I%h 0I, IY#$! 7#$, # [, 8# ( D (.... D f3_% -4,B% -4C#i% -9, IC#A3 o%4[0"

    ) >h >I%h.0# H"$Z )99G (fZ8 D *c o%1D .6[V% " F/2[c# $Wc 4, 4G9? 7!$C 42VS#$90 4Z .?D.%$, tA=0 D -IYYid $2E9,H"$Z o3#IR 4, 49NAa[bA% 4[2VS# 4[D )[# 4Z I6#

    " .;9*C f+V? 8D$,4$56 " >*=_% >6#""123# ):z.% .%/0# "123# 78#"$(."A?2

    46A*6 8# $P" .J 4=@_% )# 7:»4*9, «#A[,# >"$[Z 4![e# >DI[, # 4[*9, +;! .c$, .0#.b#"# "$JD , D .+;!3.% .0$, " .IYYZ # 4=@_% )# $P" .c$, o,;%I[C#A3 8# H"*: >Y*:.%/0# uVY0#. .[% .%/0# "123# "#D H# )# 8# 4Z .*9:"A, I9x "A% 4, 4bA , )#$,Y,.% $d# 4J6h 4 ."$Z L!" O/0# " >h V2C# 8# D "A, )@*U% >h >"A, .%/0# 7^, 9C 8# >#A

    7A[2! -I?, HI? 4v## I+2g% 7A0 8# f$56 )#gR .[2R D H"A[, [9 ."#" i[96 .C$[? 58# [%#$P" F$W - )2c#"$6 4, 4bA ,$2E9,% 4[, -(7D[2! ) f$56 )#n 4[#IYQ[=C .[00# .6[V% H8#I[6# D I[R " # RV% )# >#A420" D )DI 78D$%# .%/0# 4G%b 7"123# O56 D "123# #$8 "$Z 7IY,>Di!#)[# $[, " 4[Z

    79_,c " RV% 0" )# 8#"[123# a[2J% H8A[R " |/[G! [RV% )[# -Q92_: OJR# .[*6 78D$%# .%/0# 4G%b 7"123# O56 D "123# Q=C $, # .6#IY $m# D IY2_: .%/0# .I[6#'d

    >D8AR $P" D )I+2g% $2E9, 4bA fD$e 4=@_% )# 7"123# O56 D "123# Q=C ov_% 4, #.% >E6 # .%/0# 4G%b.I:"

    1..=%GS#)911M(2. >Ec")1388(3., >*: " IIb ov_% p" 7YG% 4,oV3 8# "AbA% .+;! 7:4. .YZ 7DI+%)1389(5. .3"N D .=9C*0#)1389(

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...77

    3.»A!D0( ,"%-.( «A=> U?E)K '(J#\ BA% D h 4, "123#>[,8 [$G 4[, 4[bA [, a[9Z$ )[# ."A[?[9:% 8# >[0Y?D h HA;S, G0D3 SR F/c.% .=V I6#A

    4S;% )# 4%#"# " 4=@_% )# .I6gYP, .%/0# aS3 " -fR/N# .ZI6# , # 7"123# ov_% O*.!$d I:#Ac #$3 7$2E9, .0$, "A%

    1. >Ec")1385(

  • 78 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    )9Y*:>Di!# &$P6 D" $, &$P6 -HI?"o%Z+,[E% )9[C " 4[Z "#" "A[bD i[96 7$[0# .*+% fD[Y*: D [0# O/[0# 4[#$d#$;20# D >#$d fVm# o,3 .,$g AW.I?,f#A1 4, # Q=C >6h YV% )# $,.[% $[1rY% 4[,$g 8# 4[2!$d$,Z .I[6"$4[, 4[Z .#A[1

    HI680 7#ib#!"_R 7:oAr ..I6$'(fVm# $56 4, -oZ " %#>#$d +Y .*=C !$G% -4, 4,$g $W 8#.% 0"H"#" D HI:E% 4, .J2% .YG -IhU0#D/, 7:4 H# &D D 0# ._R

    H#i[d >[6h HI[9;C 4[, .0# .;UY% o9=r -.2!$G% )9Y >"$, .[:.[% .[;= #"[YG%4[Z I6A[?.=9=r1.V9Z$ 2H#id D B3 " .IY?,OA[+#A3$,Y,)# " ov_% .c$, >I? )?D 8# (

    f0A_r% $,#$,-4[,$g ][*Z [, 7A[@ o9*J Z )# .Q9YZ 4,$g # "Ac f0A_r% I, %4[Z [0# )[# [_: 4[Z 7i[9 ."#" [V2C# D &8# Q[: [% [g 4[Z [_96 7I"$ .0#

    " Z 8# 3#D , ,U% .:d % f9e$!.%[% F/[c EZ 4, Q: .:d D Ih. G .I[0[, .[Y.% .( IIb f9h 4Z Q$.0# 3#D F/c

    1. Analytic2. Synthetic

    3. 7$56)1385(

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...79

    h-/"nB( A*()Y 2Z " $(A( .I? 4v## $(A( 0A &D )#».*=C f!E2Z# UY% «7$'(I9x 9G%D .[,$g

    0A .=Z )96#A3 .=*C .#$d.% ";26# ", 4, fI? 4, # O.% D "$9dY# :IAd[+\I\"4 >"+6 YZ 7#$, "Ac»]i9!2% «.% {9( b >h #->h , 4Z I6$,8# i[96 # .,$g OA=C

    .%$, >9%7A[@ p2Y2[0# D 0# .,$g OA=C " .v#$;20# UY% $JY% |2R#$N $(A( .I6#"8# # [:H#id.% )J*%$9\ |;UY% -.,$g f#I:E% D .1l? 7:7A[@ -7D $[56 8# .I6#"H[d 9[: [:

    .*6 .,$g fVm#.I6A?1

    kU,#.% >#$d:IYAd2».*6 $d#fVm# >A*: 4Z Q9:#Ac[, # ]A@ fR/UN# ->#$dH#i[d 4[Z Q9Yi[d$, # 7[9G% I[, $id[6 -Q9YZ pc .G9VW OA=C 8# |#A+0 HI?" 9G%7[:

    fVm#>D" 4, Q: # $'(6I:" H# .,$g OA=C D$*=3 .« .[% "+YE9( -D )# 8#YZ [Y7[b 4[, 4[Z IfVm# -7$'(»kU,#7$'( «Q96#I, Q=C $9\ D Q=C >9% i99* 9G% #.$[: >"A, .*=C 9G% )#$,Y,

    >A%8h "I% 4, >h " 4Z 0# )# H#id .I[?, $[_9% .[,$g 7[:[+6h I9[?AZ9[NA1c [ I6kU,#] 7$'(4, # 4$56#D 4=90DIYYZ OA=G% 4$56 >h >9% .;UY% ,.

    kU,# &D:0# a9 $ )# 4, .#$d-kU,# A5Y% 4, D 3A% 7A@ ] >"$Z w$U%->A%8h $G% ">h >"#" #$3 II? D l0 7:

    4g926 " 4$56 )# $d# kR>A%8h.% 42?#'d YZ ""$d kU,# -l0 7:A[c 7[b D "A? # "3A% 7A@ 4,.% 7$P" -4[g926 " ."A[? #$[J i[96 >h }A[1c" o[R#$% )9[*: I:" >h

    .% *? 4, {6P2?'d 4, V_6 $$, 7A@ ] -HIE6 kU,# |/G! 4Z 7A@ .Iht-!"3)B A4JK"Eu +"

    7A@ V2C# 7:9G% 8# $P" .J.% -.%/0# "123# 7:4%6$, I6#A7[:(.[?AZ^ .[E:Dj4%6$, )# .I?,4$56 4CA*g% 4, uA,$% :.0# :

    4%6$, 2c0.V=0 .E:Dj( kAN# HI*C {l, D" 8# .?AZ^ 7: -.,g# .E:Dj( kAN# D.0# HI? o9JE

    1. 7$56)1385(2. O#h)1370(

  • 80 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    &D H," ! {9( IV6 4Z 7"#A% H," .V=0 .E:Dj( kAN# I, 4Z .E:Dj( 7:2b# +6h 8#.% "A*Y: -"$Z Y.[E:Dj( 4[%6$, ][ .V=[0 "$[V:# |[00# .I[:")[# .[?AZ^

    .% "i?Ad # fD$e$! 4Z IYZ7:49e$! 4(.00# 7:&A[Z^ 4[Z -4[%6$, " 42h4.% 4%6$, OD;%I6$9d #$3 kU,# $G% " IV6 -I%6.V=[0 "$[V:# -)l[0 $[P" 4[, .

    %6$,4HIC3 -9;r&D 7#.[% #$[3 4Z 0# .2cY?2[_: "#'[d4kA[W " I[V6 4[%6$, OD[;%$E9(2Z " ."A? w/N# kU,# -4%6$, 7DuUr6# !$E9( -"123# Q=C1- [$56 404 4[( 7#

    2_: 4, uA,$%44$56 l04%$[0 O[56 " "$[c "123# 7:7#" .[YG"$!D [96/;C -.[#$dA;R.% H"$*?$, .NA1c 9JS% M.2[_9_Z% $[J#A[YC 4, 9JS%4 [*2b#>"A[, $;2[_% -.C

    2b# fV0Y%.C*..l Q_9S$% D :^Z 7#8, f^"V% " O"$%.E:Dj( kAN#.,g#.% .*Y:# # % i96 4%6$, ]O#I[Z [ D QD$, {9( 46AP 4Z IYZ

    &D" # .;9;r 7:.,g# "$V:# |00# .Q9YZ kV6[%6$, ][44[CA*g% o%[? .[E:Dj( 8# 7#.% >E6 4Z 0# l0 7:A20":".% # 4%6$, >h 46AP IA[5Y% )9[*: 4[, ."$[, {9[( >#A[

    7A@ I9SA 4, .,g# "$V:#HjD 7:.% 4%6$, )# " 7#$56 $: ->h " 4Z I%g6#4 +Y 46 HjD2_: kAR4.% 42c0 4%6$, OD;%2_: >h HI6$9d$," 4J=, -"A?4 .[_: i96 OD;%[3#D " $2[E9,

    >*=_% >6#""123#&D )9*: 8# H8D$%# i96 7:HI? 42#$P" [0#.# &$[P6 )[# 8# $mx[2% f^A[1r% 8# 4[6A*6 I[Y $[8 ".% .0$,:Q9*6

    4[Z [0# HI[? Og6# 49e$! )# , .0$, )#»4[$56 -&$[P6 )[# ")$[2+, " [% >#8#"$[(# -SR-Q9:[h w/[N# D .,$\ 7"123# Q9:"$Z Hi9%/0# +Y Z )# D 0# .%/0# 7:.«2

    1.66 .)1374(2. .YZ 7$3,)1389(

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...81

    3-2.GRu,[?0DEJi3 ,"%-.( A=9$& 1?"=! 'C4 52?!D0( )B A*"rR(-!D0( A*DS\ 6"-&6 VJO=! 'C4 52?Q)%!5C##E .[%.[, 4[[Z Q9[6#"F$[[1% .[/;C [[2! [r, " ]9[[0/ZA@6 f[$56 -I[["$X[[0#$, HI[YYZ

    >+b4%$0 }c .Y9,.0# H"#" #$3 t/% # D# f'S D "$! -H"% SN# 4Z 0# 7#".[2RC"# )# $d#=_% I3 -Q$'6 Q: #oJ[? .%/[0# .6[V% X[0#$, [RV% )[# 4[Z [0# )[# Q

    6.0# 42!$P.% gY# "HI[? A[Vg% i96 .%/0# >#IY*EI6# 46AP 4Z Q9Y9V, Q9:#Ac)[# [ I[6#2!.IYYZ $G 8, aS3 >*: " #

    fg6#....;INI*r%1.% :IAd»>"$[Z $Z#I[R k[V6" 4[Z [0# 7"$[! -.[/;C >*=_%0# .%/0# 7:gY: , "Ac 7:2! ,U«.# 8# q!Oi9S[Y9b% H[P6 -[$G >I? .%/0

    [2! " [96/;C o[N# 8# O[+S# [, $[P" .c$, r, )# " .0# "A+E% |/%Z $G )# " F$[1% .[djD 8# .[[J 4[[Z "$[[c "[[123# " HI[[YYZ[[2! &A[[c "$[[! 7[[: [[0# ]9[[0/ZA@6

    .%:IY_A6»F$1% $: .6_6# 2! /[0# 96/;C oN# $, .J2% -HIYYZ[96/;C o[N# .[0# .%Hi9P6# LA*g% .YG8# .[El, F$[1% 9l[E " # "#$[!# 4[Z .[?8# D .[;UY% -.[v/;C 7[:

    .[9R 7[:896 )9%x[ 7#$[,) .[+6 f%I[c D ^[Z I$c 7#$, "Ac I%h" (.[RD D 7A[YG% -.% #I:.IYZ2

    h-,J0 jB"K 5C##EC?RJK 6"-&6 'C4 52?!D0(#IVC...0AI*r% D)9%#34[Z I[6I;2G% -.%/[0# a[S3 " H[PY, D HI[YYZI9SA [2! 4[v## "

    " # "Ac "A0 0# &/ " H#A*: .%/0# HIYYZI9SA.IYZ $Z#IR .%/0# #8, 2! .YG.% >h ]90/ZA@6 O$! IY6% >Z*Z i96 # HPY, D HIYYZI9SA .%/0# .IY6#"

    $,Y,I9SA )#0 HIYYZ.% .GI[93 4[, V[_6 $[8 ,[U% # "A0 a_Z " "Ac 9,A=U% , IYZ"DIr%:IYZ $Z#IR "Ac 7I%h" 7:

    )1(PPNETTSGPNETUU !" ..),(

    $G )# "PNET[0# S[c "A[0 - DG4[$9c A[%# " D# 4[Z [0D# "A[0 8# 7#I[;%.% F$1%.IYZ, )# "A0 )#$,Y,:, 0# $,#$, HPY

    1. Siddiqi, Mohammad Nejatollah (2005)2. .6/9b ), D o%#8)1378(

    3. Abdullah Yusof and Mohammad Amin (2007)

  • 82 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    )2(GqCqR ##" )()($

    >h " 4ZR D .+6 I%h"C: 4Z 0# .+6 4Yi:IY2[_: H[PY, I[9SA 8# .G, D" $ D$"A[0Z8 $_Z 8# oV3.0# O8^ .2c#"$( >A" $P" D f

    )3( ("8#"$, I, 4Z .6A" $P")–(.2c#"$( fZ8 #I;%)#" $$ net

    >Y[;r% )# HdI" 8# .%/0# HPY, -0# lE% 4Z >[Y*:4[2VS# ."#" Oi9S[Y9b% $[JA" $P" « .[0# .3[, "A[c "A[bD $[, , " )9[Y*:[rF$1%-HIC$W[c 4, I, 4Z "#" "AbD .!$1% pl% 8# .=3#IR TU0 H#A*: 4Z I6I;2G% 7#

    ."$', fAN ;, 4%#"#.% .%/0# 4Y*: 4Z I6$9d# 7#$, .00# 7:896 8# .rU0 )9Y ] )9%x 4Z7"#$[!

    .% *? 4, .%/0# 4h )9%x >#A 4Z"D-( .[% $!F$[1% 4[Z Q9[YZ)9G% o3#IR 8# id$:w)9( $6 .[! I:#Al1" HI[? I[9SA .6[V% $[P" 8# H"h , 4,E% >I% Q9:h $0 $, # .%/0#

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...83

    )[# .[SD I[YZ [Sc" 7"[123# f#A[%# D 4[G%b " 0# AVg% SD" .:d >9% )# ">D$9, 7#$, D fD$e IR " I, ;! 4=@_%#$r6# 8# >I9EZ.I?, >#$r, D F14[bA .[*Z $d#

    ."#" :V? iY9Z 7A@ , 7A@ )# I; 4Z 0# lE% |/%Z Q9YZ.S[% )9%x ,Y% HP6h # SD">Di!#SD" 4Z .G,Y% $,.% $56 " .,$\ 7: .[% i96 fZ8 o%? I6$9d .I[Y6#"[D

    9SG! 4*: -4G%b )# " .%A*C {l,A,$% 7"123# 7:"#$[!# 4[Z .2%I[c D I[9SA L#A[6# 4, u.[% .[+S# #A[m 4[, >I90 D .J96 D >_R# A5Y% 4, o;2_% f_0n% $W 8# |*9;2_%# I[YYZ

    .% o%?."A?# )9*: " " D .%A*C {l, "123{l,Q9*1 [6I;2G% .c$, >h .%A*C 7$9d I oN# 4Z»#A? «Q9*1 O56 "*6 .0# O/0# " .%A*C 7$9d.% .2R# 4, HP6h #A? 4Z I6$'(

    4=90D96 I[?, [0"6 [ 0" |G3#D -.%/0# D .3/c# $56 8# 46h EZ 7#$, 7# [_-4[J=,Q9*1 7#$, 7#i,# #A? 4Z 0# 7$9d[0# HI[? 42!$'( O/0# G$? "2[ IY[0 [% -4[2VS#

    , 4=@_% )# 4JY# )*e Q92!96 C"# )# 7#$, .S^I20# .[0# d8[06 .6h$3 f*=_% 8# 79_,Q9*1 7#A? $56 $d# C"# )# X0#$,.[($, [!#A% O"$% $Z# .2R .%/0# AEZ 7$9d

    .I? I:#Ac 42!$'( i96 O/0# G$? " 4=@_% )# -IY?, AEZ " "_! iZ#$% L#A6#k[R )[# [,4( k^I20# )#.% 7# "A?$Z# f$56 4[, .%A[*C {[l, "D I6A[? 4[2!$'( [gJ A[W

    !#A D .0#$ZA%" IC#A3.%/[0# "[123# "#D .[0$, 4[6AP9: >DI[, -.[2$Z# D .%A[*C 7: %# .I6A? ".% >E6 LA*g%D o[c" [ 4[9bA .ZI[6# [, ]9[0/ZA@6 Q9:[*=[_% "$[! I[%h" -.%/0# "123# " I%h" 8A kI% .0$, ".% $8 "#A% o%?:I6#"

    )5(gicY %%"

    :>h " 4Z

    1. .6/9b ), D o%#8)1378(2. .;IN)2005(

    3. Chaudhry Mohammad Hussain (1994)

  • 84 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    & '

    )(,)(,)(,)(

    )(

    riiyeeyzzytt

    ezc

    ezytycc

    ccc

    """"%"

    ###"%"

    2

    1

    21

    ,#A )# "z D fZ8e M[_YI, D

    Q"#" #$3 469% .2%# # *?.2.[% >[E6 a=U% )#[2! [r, " >*=[_% >6#""[123# 4[Z I[:" .%/0# .6V% 4, O#i2S# >DI, ->*=_% "$! ./;C$2E9, 7A, D ~6 , # ]90/ZA@6 Q9:*:

    H"$Z w$U% .%/0#.I6# )9Y*:46A*6 7#$,kI% , 4E3Y% "->/[Z "[123# " HI[? "+Y[EV( 7: )# |G3#D{0$(% >"$Z )iPb D "123# $:#A w/N# , h 4Z "#" "AbDn

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...85

    S^" 4, 4bA ,.% $56 4, -HI? D$% 7:4[, # [% 4[D )[# [+Y 46 4Z I0 .%/[0#"123#7"#D 4[, # [% 4Z 0# o*2r% 9_, 4J=, -I960 I:#Al6[, .[2R {v[B23# 4[Z I6[EJ, .[:

    AN#4[6A*6 H8D$[%# 4[Z I[?, 42?#I6 7d80 Q: O/0# 49SD# k" # a[=U% )[# 8# 79[_, 7[:{l," $[99s k*C# >DI, .%/0# )DYC 4, 4e$3 M#D# O6 $99s 4=@_% IY6% "123# =2l% 7:

    >h 9:%.Q92_: I:? -14=@_% )# .=N# =C 3#D "-.%/[0# o;2[_% .6[V% 4[, >"$J6 4bA D&D )9Y*:4$56 " HI? 42!$'( .0Y?HI[C 46#i9% .0$, "4[Z [0# lE% o3#^ -f$56 )# 8# ] $:.*6"$Z L!" O/0# " >h V2C# 8# >#IY >#A O56 D FG% -&$P6 )# 4Z #$ .%/0# .*=C

    0# H"#" FG2% "123# .11l XD" >*: 4, # 9*:# D 4V=\ D H"#" #$3 49?R " #.)[#>A@: 4Z 0# .SR "3.% .C*2b# OA=C >#$PE:Dj( 8#:IAd» {;6 OPY+,6 &$'(».*=C «

    # $l% %#Ab 7#$, .6_6# OA=C D .C*2b# f;9;r 7A0 8#0Q[=C O[6 4[Z #$-.[+Y 4[,.[[% tI[ "A[[c [, # .[[Nc f$+[? D [V2C#[[, 4[Z 7[[V2C# :I[EZ>[[Y*: [9:% 4[[, 4[bA

    ]¡ASAvI#-[g,6 f$+? )# .0# g9, D a0Y2%6 |/%Z -.6_6# D .C*2b# H8AR " fGSU%., #I23# .CA6 -4Y9%8 )# " )911l2% f#+# 4,4[JY# )*[e .0# HI9El, $1R D IRO[56

    >#A[YC r "Ac I;C 4v## $m# " i96 # %#Ab .3/c#» 4[2![mA% .[*=C 7[: «H"$[Z $[B2%" -"#" O"$[% "A[c 4[, Q[=C >#A[YC 4[, .2R# 4, # .*=C 4V? D .*=C E9( I;C >#A2, $d# .0#

    .% HIYhH"$[, 4[9bA 7#$[, oJ[? )9[*: 4[, # I;C )9*: >#A*G2[0# -.[?D$!6 -7$d-Q[_8 HI[C >9% )# " !"#" #$3 H""$Z 0" N$! 8# -IY2_: t" "DIr% " f/91r Ge.% OD$r% {Ac 0" 7DC" 8# L!"H"[0 I[Y, " +6h ;9;R " .IY6% .RA[S"DI[r% "A[c

    HI?I6#.P6[, A[% )l[0 $[, 7I:[? )[# D4.[% 4[Z [0# o[9d ][% HP[E6#" "2[0# :I[Ad1. Ach$9%)1370(2. .=9C*0#)1389(

    3. Hutcheon (1997)4. Mario Bunge

  • 86 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    H"0 7:IY(

    Q=C.#$d:]i9! -.#$dfVm# D :.#$d .[% O/C# # : !I[YZ34[, {#$[d |̂ A[N#7Dh"$[d4c? HI? !A% -Q=C =2l% 7: 4, Q[E *93[*: 8# .[?A(4-.[G3#D .6[G%Hj[D 4[,4h 7#$, i96 # .h«.5

    4 .A!D0( V"3 "B ,"%-.(4G0A oJ? # >h >#A2, I? 4Z "$JD )#>#A[YC [r -[_6#" .9% -42?7#842?#$! D7#9U% "A%.[% #$[3 4[GS)[# 4[*: t$2[E% 7[Y, D "$[9d

    &D42? O56 D" 4Z 0# )# :aS3 " # 7#)[# 8# D I[YYZ [9

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...87

    8# "#$% 4Z 0# a0Y%».%/0# "123# « #»"123#« , 4Z Q$9P, 7»V_6 7 «A[_Y% O/[0# 4, 4U,# ] 8# gY# " % 3#D " .0# HI?»_6.V «.% )l0A2[0" £[rS 8# I[Y $[: 4Z Q9Ad

    .% A_r% I? )?D 7#$,» .%/[0# "123# «.r=U[1% >#A[YC

    >A .YDYC o,;% " 4Z 0#»4%$0 "123#7#" «»#$d"+6 "123# «4, .[% Z[g6h 8# D "DO6 , 7"123# a2J% D" 4, >#AYC D" )# 4Z 7:»4%$07#" « »#$d"+6 «4[, i[96 % -I6#" H?#

    O6 , "Ac 7"123# a2J%».%/0# «.% H?# Q9YZ[*=Z "[8 9[_, [9%A*C o[9S" 4[, 4[2VS# 4[Z 4».%/0#«? .+Y 4, >#AYC )# -7"[123# O[56 .2R a2J% 4bA2% # HI6AY.[*6 .[NcD I[YZ

    >#AYC 4J6h kR»4%$07#" «.% .+Y 4,"A[c 4[, A[_Y% 7"123# O56 D a2J% Dh" I6#A[$W 8# 4[Z [0# 4[6dD"$9\ D I[Ib Q[=C ] .%/0# "123# -HP6 )# X0#$, )#$,Y, .I?,

    [, D HI? ISA2% pD"i% 7IY#$! .[% DoJ[? 8# [( D "A[?#"A[c$, o;2[_% .%[56 8# 7$[9d.I? I:#Ac

    .=V3 HP6 "- "123# H¡#D 8# "#$%8AY:[%# ."A, HI? Hi9%/0# 4Z "A, ]90/ZA@6 "123# >*:HP6 )# "-.% 7IIb D o;2_% 91l? 4, .%/0# "123#I0-)[# " 9%/[0# #A

    )?D .[% $56 4, $6D$, 7#$[, [J:# )$[2+, I[08# [!$[eD )[#8# OA[0 I[Y#$! 4[, O#i[2S# -&D .;9

  • 88 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    [, $Z#I[R 4[Z "A[, I[:#Ac ]9[0/ZA@6 "[123# .=Z aS3 >*: " % 7:"D20" o*C " Q:~6 .%/0# )DYC.0# HI? 7i9%hD 42VS# .;9#AYC 4, "123# D O/0# 7A:%[0# 7$E, Q=C ] "123# 4Z YG% )# 4, .0# .;9DI, !9: )# " #$8 ."A? "#I*=3 !9: )$

    9=,3&D =2l% 7:-"#" "A[bD .%/[0# "[123# [, V$[% [=2l% OA=C " 4Z .;9

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...89

    h--46C#a ,)m*6+(.% #$3 $56 I% .=Z LAeA% ] &D )# "d4, HP6h D "$942[? I[Y [$W 8# >[%i*: AW

    .% .0$, =2l%# 3#D " ."A?.% #$3 r, "A% .23D "$JD )" LA[eA% ][ 4[Z "$9dO5642? 7:D I[?, 42!$d #$3 r, "A% D HI? w$W )J*% oJ? D fAN $: 4, =2l% 7#

    D )# )2!$d oJ? 4, LAeA% ] "A% " RV% )# *b "$J $gY% .[% "A[?.i[Z$* o[N#GSU% " ;r%4O56 )# 8# ] $:42? 7:[0# )[J*% 4[2VS# D [0# 4=@[_% ][ .0$, -7#

    $[, .[Y2V% &D )[# [;9;R " ."$[9P6 fA[N [+6h )9[, uV# "g# 7#$, .Nc &/ |%DiS "$JD»43/C "A% LAeA% « >$3 ] "DIR " 4Z 0# D J$%h " {9( I[? 4v## >*Sh.14[,

    >#AYC LAeA% $d# -46A*6»I%h" a_Z«[;r% -Q9[:" #$3 $56 I% .=Z LAeA% ] >#AYC 4, #&D X0# $,.[E% [c D .[=Z F#I[:# 4[, 4bA , D .%/0# OA=C 8# ]$: .0Y?.[=Z 7[:

    4$56 4, LAeA% >h >A%#$9( -OA=C )# 8# ] $: " "AbA%.% 78#"$( ."8#"$(t-'"?! ,)m*6-46+(

    >*:-I? 42

  • 90 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    f+% >"#"2c[0 )iP[b -fCA[eA% 7#D[% # 7I[Ib D %[b 2c[0 -.WVY20# 7:V3.=-.CAeA% 2c0 .YG-.%IYZ.1

    )# kR{0$(.% {9(.[% 4[6AP V$[% OA[=C .[0$, D 4[GSU% [, 4[Z Ih)[# 4[, >#A[f+%.% 46AP )l0 $P" 4, ! 0" :Q[=C o[% .%/[0# V$% OA=C 8# H"#A

    f+% )# -FG2% "123# Q=C YZ " .%/0# UY% kAN#: # 4,AWT9rN 4[, ."Dh [0"¡#D 8# >%"#$%H)[*# [Uc 8# [;r% >h "A[bD , 4Z 0# f+% 8# .Nc .h 8# ( D :

    Q[+% [3#D "Q[: 4[Z .=J[E% )$["#" "A[bD .%/[0# "[123# " >A[YZ#-&D ][ "A[V64$56# " kG! 7D8AR D ]9%"Zh 9W D" $56 I6#A2, >%i*: 4Z 0# T9rN 78#"$(42[? )

    #x" {[:"$JD $9[0 4[, 4[bA , 4Z 0# )# " i96 .;9[%i*: >#A[2, &D >h a[S

    9!$42? O56 D" $: 7:."$Z H"h H#i[d $[: 4[Z #$[ [0# 42? ] 8# $#$! >h "G,# 4Z 4Z 0# .E6#" .%/0# "123# #$8=% , I," i[96 .6_6# OA=C $P" "G,# .2R ."A? I9SA .%/0# kAN# D "123# IC#A3 )2?#" £Ar

    QE D I6#" ABR >h.6+b 8#I6#.*6 4Z G%b o9S" 4, I6#A $Wl, "A? 42!$d HI"6 >h # +b >h 8# .%/0# "123# .YG .0# HI%h "AbD 4, "G,# )9*:H#id 4Z 0# IY*?8 >h 7[:

    1. .J=%)1381(2. Critical Thinking and Action3. Problem Solving4. Decision Making5. Analytical Thinking

    6. .?,/%)1387(

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...91

    *:4H"$Z £rS "Ac k" " # .6_6# "G,#[;! 4[Z [0# FG2% "123# Q=C F/c $, )# D I6#IYYZ$Z#IR >_6# ] f/* 7D $,H-.[3/c# "A[bD 4[, $P" D 0# H"$Z iZ$* 9,A=U%

    a[S3 " I[, % i96 7"123# fCAeA% " )#$,Y, ."#I6 7Z D# .6_6# D .Y" -.C*2b#Q[=C Q95Y D .R#$W 7AW # )9*=_% 7"123# f#A%# D .%/0# 4G%b 7"123# O56 -.%/0# "123#[0# o[%Z 7"123# O56 ] .R#$W 7YG% 4, Z )# .I?, L? e "A% |G3#D 4Z Q9YZ

    "Ac .%/0# .V2J% .6V% $, 49J , 4Z$8 Q: -[, D H"A[, .%/0# {Y, O[56 Z% 7[:D .2[_9_4%$0.6D$9, 7:"A*6 Q: D I?, 42?#" M$! 7#", .I?, fD9% "$JD 4, uA42?7#-.% $56 4,z[l# [, FI[: )[# 4[Z I[042?$9\ !9:_9% (Z 8\h " 42VS#) 7#4[Z [0# )9[Y [!9: )[# "$Z[Z #$8 .I?, $$

    42? !9: F/c$, O56 ] 4Z 0# )# $, oN# >h " 4Z) 7#42? aS\ " 7#]-42[?Y, -("A? D, D HI? ISA2% $, # IY D" 99% "$JD "42?-.[V9Z$ O[56 ][ " [RV% p#i[2%# , 42? $: A: " k/;20# 7#

    .% )9, 8# 7IR2[? ][ 7D $[, iZ$* "$JD )# " #$8 ."D4 .[_96 }[c)#$,[Y, "*e42? O56 IY $5Y% 8# # t$2E% fCAeA% D Q9:J%# -I:"9[0D I[".[% 7$[)[# D I[:"

    &D D .6V% " 7D >I? 2!$d 8# 0# .6J%#" >I[? "DI[r% D }[c Q[=C ][ .0Y?

    1. >Ec")1363(

  • 92 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    H$#" >*:"A? 7$9dA=b@_% )# .Oib k*2R# 4=.EI6#1.% {:Z # ;r%D I[:" )#$,[Y, " Q9:*: >"$Z Hi9%/0# I:? $2*Z o*C)9E9(."A, Q9:#Ac>#AYC 4,-46A*6|/[% LAeA% $d#

    =@_%4I?, I%h" a_Z-.% $8 #"A*6 ,U% .:I6%80 )# &D:"A?

    6(,J731.3 AC3"!:"0'"?! ,)m*6 6, r$-c! VJ$\ "B vJZJ! [* nB(6 vJ-46+(%x i6, D t" :'c)2005(.

    .% .G0 4Z 0# )# "$JD )# Q+% .djD 3#D ">#A[2, >h .W 4Z IYid$, # .?D IYZ4,9!$ 8# >%i*: AW&D $[P" D .[+;! uVY2[0# .6[V% D kAN# " "AbA% 7:.[*=C 7[:

    # IY6% k[U,4[%6$, kA[N# [ .[#$d ."$[Z H"h [% D

    HI9%6.% (Q#" Q+% 4bD ] #$8 .IYh, 7i9 % $d# .YG .0# 4;! 4=@_% -.%/0# "123# O6 4

    1. Dogmatism2. .%s9()1387(

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...93

    -Q92[[?#I6 [[:;! D 4[;!f/J[[E% 8# .[=9cHI[[? 4[[2h1 4bA , .!$W 8#4$56 4JY# 4, 3#A% 79_, " .%/0# "123# " 78#"$(.*6 -"#" "123# ]9%"Zh D .11l {6#" 4, 8964$56 526# 49;! ] 8# >#A)[# " 78#"$[(

    .?#" # Q=C(7"[123# ,#D Q95Y 4N$C "#D D "A? pc :;! H8AR 8# 49;! 4Z .b"#" kJ?# "A?-Y H8AR #$8[0# ][A@ k^I2[0# D 4[%6$, D .[11l kI[% I[Y%896 -Q9[5

    .[=Z fCA[eA% 4[, uA[,$% -.[+;! O[JR# .I?, Y0 D 2Z D O/0# $, .Y2V% 4$d# 2[_: D IY/2V% ov_% .[11l .CAeA% -"123# H8AR " )9*=_% 4, 2[_:M[VU6# D [+6h cY[? 4[Z IY

    A,$% D _96 49;! Z LAeA% >h , M#I1%)[?D f[VC 4[, .[0# .[0Y?Z H8A[R 4, u $[-49J 7"123# OJR# cY? 4$d#49J %# 0# "123# H8AR " % Hd"A[c 8# $9\ Z$R Hd

    .0# Z$R2>9% "$JD zl# , >#A2, 4Z $2+, 4 42VS#42?7#- 1l D :;! H8AR D" $:.YG% )# 4, ."A*6 *b b ] " # "123#6#A2, .%/0# "123# ;r% 4ZrEc")1363(2. >Ec")1385(3. "+2b# D .r9b$ "+2b# oJ? D" 4, # "+2b# IY#$! .c$,.g$l420".% 7IY,X[0# D [YV% $2[E9, .r9b$ "+2b# .IY*6

    .% #$3 l? $56 D 7¦ $, # "AcD ._96 l? >h $56 ib 7i9 #Ic QJR 4g926 " D I:"& ... D >[_r20# D X93 7:&D 4=*b 8# "+2b# %# .0# .r9b$ "+2b# 7:.g$l.#%# D kAN# X0#$, ;! -0# .RD 4, IVG >*: 4Z4[Z [0#

    x L? 7A0 8# +6h 9gR.% o9JE # 4G9? 4;! X0# D HI"$d I9$2E9, 4GSU% 7#$, .I:" 4, >Ec")1363.I9YZ LAb (

  • 94 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    gY# "][ 7#$, "+2b# 8# )l0 % .23D 4Z 0# )# >h D Q9YZ 4!e# # .V=U% 0# O8^.% >9% 4, .%/0# "123# ;r%I[Yh$! 4[, 4[bA [, Q9:#A[l, 4[Z [_96 )# |%DiS % "#$% -QDh

    D FG2%.6[V% D kAN# 4JY# 4, $56 4J=, .Q9YZ "+YE9( # kr% 7$%# -f+% )# a_Z OA0$%4;!"+2b# " # .%8, 8# ( -o,;% " %# .0# $,4[,) "$[JD )[# .6[V% I9SA D IR#D &D )# >"Dh 0"/JE% oR 4, 4bA4g926 D HI? $2*Z "+2b# $m# -(f>0h .=*C 7$9dI[:#Ac $ .I[?2)9[Y*:

    2J64 -I? 4v## )# 8# {9( 4Z .r9eA 4, 4bA , 4Z 0# )# 0# w$U% gY# 4Z .*+% 9_,fAN 4, D 42_, QE , !9: )# IV6-"$9d #$3 H"h 0A 4=@_% )99V 8# ( D 4WA,$% 4=@_% 4, H

    D "A% "$!.% "N MAm .IYZ"-1l I+2g%.% 2!# D 4GSU% 4, .11l fAN 4, .+;! , IY ] " I+2g% )# :.14[Z 7I[+2g% >A[*: ."8#"$(

    .% $56 +# 7"123# #A,# " ;!.IYZH-4[*: " "[+2b# H8[b# 4[Z .YI[+2g% 4, H8D$%# 4Z 0# .!G2% >#AYC >*: >#AYC )# :O I+2g%4[2! # #A[,#M/[W# I[6#

    .%."A?D-# 8# "#$% :o%Z QSCrV $, HD/C 4Z 0# ._Z >#AYC )->[!$C >A[*: .%/[0# OA[=C $P" " -kAN# D 4;! " "+2b# D $!=_% i96 ... D $9_

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...95

    .%A,I? Q9:#Ac .%/0# D .6#$# Q9:h 780)[# [, D[( -a0Y% !9: "+YE9( :>#$[+ -I?# .0Y?Z HD" 4%6D .%/[0# F[G% HIJ[E6#"

    O%# HPE6#" -"123#(L) M"N. -.3"N 7I+% D eI*r% -.=9C*0#»!9: "$,Z.2cY[? O/0# f%#iS# >9, " 99% fGSU%42?7# H*? -7..C*2b# D .PY:$! fGSU% HIJE:Dj( :>#$+ - .B$% -716#)1248 -(a0J*S#-.%/0^# $JEc")1363(.%/0# "123# f_=b 4=_=0 --.6#$Yl0: -(L)M"N O%# HPE6#". "AG_% ->Ec")1385(HdI" -.%/0# "123# 4, "AbA% 7:-)DI[ [, -[:2

  • 96 !"#$%&"4 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( + 56"74 1,23"49

    Q9R )_R -7I\8# A()1389(O$6 {VYb ->#$[+ -.%A[*C 4[_=b -.Y" Q=C D 7#i!#-HP[E6#">#$+.

    -.66)_r%)1374(- -"123# Q=CuUr6# !$E9(- :>#$[+ ->A[_6b D X/[d [2Z 4*b$.PY:$! D .*=C f#E26#.

    .6/9b ), D o%#8)1378(-.%/0# "$JD , >/Z "123#-% :Q3n.Y9*c O%# .PY:$! 4_0.H? 8Y+% -H"#i9=C)1387 -(»>9% "$JD42?{:Dj( " 7#.C*2b# OA=C 7:« ( 4S;% 4*b$ -

    .!#" f^;% 4CA*g% 8# ->A@:&D D 7$56 .6V%>[9% f[GSU% .0Y? 42[?7# :>#$[+ -..C*2b# D .PY:$! fGSU% HIJE:Dj(

    )8 -.=%C )IS#)911M(-49;E%IS# ªG*=S# w$? .! 49+VS# ªeD$S#.%/0^# $JA%#$9( .11l 7:"$di9% 4CA*g%$[56 $[8 -.%/0# "123# 4<

    % :>#$+ -7"$bD$, .*9R e$9=C $2Z"n.J6, D .SA( f;9;r 4_0. -$N6 -78#$9? OJ%.%/0# "123# .=N# uAUc-(L))9Y%n*S# $9%# O%# 40I% f#E26# :Q3.

    /%HI[9RA -.?,)1387 ([S# -»>[9% LA[eA% .P2[?« 4[*b$ -*g% 8# -"^#D [6$, 4[S;%4[CA f^;%&D D 7$56 .6V%>9% fGSU% .0Y?42?7# .PY:$! fGSU% HIJE:Dj( :>#$+ -

    ..C*2b# D HI9RA -.?,/%)1387( -»42? &D>9% &D D 7# 42[?7#«-8# -4[A, $[9( 4[S;% 4[*b$

    f^[[;% 4[[CA*g%&D D 7$[[56 .6[[V%>[[9% f[[GSU% .[[0Y?42[[?7#[[E:Dj( :>#$[[+ - HIJ..C*2b# D .PY:$! fGSU%

    )_R -.J=%)1381( -4%6$,o*C 7*Y:# :.0" 7i-O+ ¨-4EI6# O9( $E6 :>#$+..YZ 7DI+%- eI*r%)1389(.6#$Yl[0 4=[_=0 -7"[123# O[JR^# f[h .[+;! .[0$, - [:-

    -(L)M"N O%# HPE6#">#$+.>[c )_r% D XVC -Ach$9%)1370(-U%.%/[0# 4[9S% D 7#I[J6, " 7$[56 f[GS-4[*b$

    % -.SIP9, .v9e I*r%.>#$# 7#IJ6, 4_0n)_R -7$56 3h)1385( -4$56.%/0# "123# 78#"$(OA[=C a[2Z )DI[ D 4[GSU% >%8[0 :Q3 -

    .HPE6#" D H8AR HPE:Dj( D .6_6#$

  • ,"%-.( 'C4 52?!D0( 5C*C :( AE6, @6 A06)B...97

    h-A9?$X3(Ault, David and Gilbert Rutman (1978), “The Role of Economics in

    Interdisciplinary and Problem-oriented Programs”, The Journal ofEconomic Education, Vol. 9, No. 2.

    Chaudhry, M. Hussain (1994), “A Comprehensive Macroeconomic IncomeDetermination Model for an Islamic Economy”, the PakestanDevelopment Review, Vol. 33, No. 4, part 2, pp. 1301-1314.

    Drake, Susan M. and Rebecca C. Burns (2005), Meeting Standards throughIntegrated Curriculum, http://www.brookes.ac.uk/researches/

    Selamah, Abdullah Yusof and Ruzita Mohammad Amin (2007), “A Surveyon the Objective of the Firm and Models of Producer Behavior in theIslamic Framework”, Word J.KAU: Islamic Economic, Vol. 20, No. 2,pp. 3-16

    Siddiqi, M. N. (2005), Teaching Islamic Economics, Scientific PublishingCentre, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.