Agenda Item No.1 Confirmation of the minutes of 59 meeting

160eda

MINUTES OF 60TH MEETING OF EDUCATION COMMITTEE(AYURVEDA) HELD ON 16.8.2007 AT NEW DELHI.

PRESENT

1. Prof. Kulwant Singh Chairman2. Dr. S Bannigol Vice-President (PG)3. Dr. BK Jaya Singh Vice-President (UG)4. Dr. KV Shah Member5. Dr. OP Vashisth Member6. Dr. Ved Prakash Tyagi Member7. Dr. D Ramanathan Member8. Dr. RS Parihar Member9. Dr. Jagjeet Singh Member10. Dr. VV Chhikara Member11. Dr. IM Jha Member12. Dr. SN Parchure Member13. Dr. Kamlesh Verma Member14. Dr. NS Tyagi Member15. Dr. SC Gupta Member16. Dr. Hari Ram Bhadoria Member

Dr. PR Sharma Secretary, CCIM

Dr. Bimla Chaudhary could not attend the meeting.

Agenda Item No.1 Confirmation of the minutes of 59th

meeting of Education Committee(Ayurved) held on 4.2.2007 at NewDelhi.

It was noted that the minutes of 59th meeting of Education Committee(Ayurved) held on 4th February, 2007 at New Delhi were placed beforeAyurveda Committee at its meeting held on 5.2.2007 and the same wereratified by Ayurved Committee

Education Committee confirmed the same.

260eda

Agenda Item No.2 Inclusion of MD (Ayurved) degree ofBabasaheb Bhimrao Ambedkar BiharUniversity, Muzaffarpur in the SecondSchedule to IMCC Act, 1970.

It was noted that Ayurved Vachaspati MD (Ayurved) awarded by Baba SahebBhim Rao Ambdekar University, Muzaffarpur (Bihar) is not included in theSecond Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970. The following colleges affiliated to thisUniversity:-

1. Government Ayurved College Patna UG 50 permittedPG 04 Dravvyaguna04 Rasashastra

2. Yatindra Narayan Ashtang Ayurved Not permittedCollege, Bhagalpur

3. Ravindranath Mukherji Ayurved UG 40 permittedCollege, Mothari

4. Dhanwantry Ayurved College, Buxar Not permitted

5. Rajkiya Ayurved Shivankar Ayurved UG 30 permittedCollege, Begusarai

6. Swamy Raghvendracharya Ayurved UG 40 permittedCollege, Gaya

7. Moti Singh Jagashwari Ayurved UG 40 permittedCollege, Chhapra

8. Nitishwar Ayurved College, UG 50 permitted.Muzaffarpur

Government of India was the requested of the University vide letterNo.R.12013/22/97-Ay.Desk dated 21.7.2006 under Section 14 (2) of IMCCAct, 1970.

University is following the nomenclature as prescribed by CCIM underconcerned Regulations.

University has forwarded the curriculum and syllabus being followed bythe University. It seems that University is following the syllabus andcurriculum as prescribed by CCIM.

360eda

There are already break for conducting PG Course reads as under:-

Admitted students have passed the Post Graduate Course in Dravya Gungand Rasashastra in 1993, 1996, 2000, 2002 and 2006.

Education Committee agreed to send the recommendations toGovernment of India for inclusion of the same in Second Schedule toIMCC Act, 1970 for the period for which permission has been givenby the CCIM for conducting PG Course in Rasashastra andDravyaguna by Government College, Patna.

Agenda Item No.3 Provision of out patient Department(OPD) for the the Department of VikritiVigyan – regarding.

It was noted that a letter dated 12th July 2007 received from Dr. AC Kar, MD(Ayurved Kayachikitsa (Vikriti Vigyan) stated

That the Vikriti Vigyan discipline was functioning earlier under theDepartment of Kayachikitsa since there was no existence of theseparate Department for Vikriti Vigyan.

As per the CCIM notification, OPD department has been allotted toKayachikitsa, Shalya, Sahalakya, Prasuti, Kaumarbhritya, Rasashastra,Dravyaguna and Swasth Rakshan.

Since Vikriti Vigyan was functioning under Kayachikitsa, the studentsopted for Vikriti Vigyan were attending the OPD.

Recently the Vikriti Vigyan has been functioning as a separatedepartment as per the CCIM guidelines and almost all the colleges hascreated an independent department for the Vikriti Vigyan discipline.

Since there is no mention of OPD for the Vikriti Vigyan Department somany colleges including BHU have withdrawn the OPD facility for theVikriti Vigyan department.

It has created lot of dissatisfaction among the PG students of VikritiVigyan.

Rogi & Rog Pariksha is the basic training on which the principle oftreatment is decided.

460eda

Without the ODP how it is possible to train the students of VikritiVigyan about Rogi & Rog Pariksha? Now-a-days all are interpretingthat Vikriti Vigyan is equivalent to Pathology, which means only thelaboratory practices. So the scope of Vikriti Vigyan should not besqueezed only to the laboratory practices. Vikriti Vigyan covers theclinical diagnostic principles as well as the laboratory methods.

In view of the above it was requested to make provision of OPD for VikritiVigyan in the interest of the students. Accordingly revised guidelines mayplease be circulated to all the colleges for making arrangements of OPD forthe Department of Vikriti Vigyan.

Following provision of OPD have been made in the Minimum Standards andRequirements for Ayurved Colleges & Hospitals.

“Swasthya Rakshan (Samhita, Dravyaguna, Rasashastra and Swastha Vrittaincluding Yoga and Agad Tantra).”

Education Committee agreed to include the provision of OPD ofVikriti Vigyan once in a week in addition to the above.

Agenda Item No.4 Recogniton of Dr. Baba Saheb AmbedkarMarathwada University, Aurangabad.

It was noted that Ayurvedacharya (BAMS) and Ayurved Vachaspati(MD.(Ay.) and Ayurved Dhanwantari awarded by Dr. Baba Saheb AmbedkarMarathwada University, Aurangabad granted by the University before theestablishment of MUHS, Nashik is not included in the IInd Schedule to IMCCAct1970. These courses were conducted by the University by affiliatingfollowing colleges.

1.Sh. Chhatrapati Ay. Medical College, Aurangabad

2. Govt. Ayurved College, Nanded

3.Govt. Ayurved College, Osmanabad

Government of India was forwarded the request of the University vide letterNo.R.12013/5/2005-Ay.Desk dated 22 March, 2005 for comments asrequired under Section 14(2) of IMCC Act, 1970 .

These colleges before shifting the PG Course in MUHS, Nashik i.e. 2005-06were permitted to conduct Graduate and Post- Graduate courses as under :-

560eda

1.Chhatrapati Sahu Maharaj Shikshan 80 UG permittedSansthan Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, 04 Sharir RachnaAurangabad 04 Kayachikitsa

2.Govt. Ayurved College, Osmanbad 50 UG permitted02 Rasashastra02 Shalya

3. Govt. Ayurved College, Nanded 60 UG permitted04 PG in Shalya04 Kayachikitsa03 Rachna Sharir02 Prasuti & Strirog04 Kriya Sharir02 Dravyagun03 Kaumarbhritya02 Rognidan05 Shalakya05 Rasshastra

Now colleges are affiliated to MUHS Nashik for Under-Graduate from 1998-99 and Post-Graduate from 2005-06 onwards.

It was observed that University had followed the nomenclature of degree forUG & PG as prescribed by CCIM and Syllabus and Curriculum as prescribedby CCIM.

Education Committee agreed to recommend to Government of Indiafor inclusion of the same in Second Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970 forthe above said period.

Agenda Item No.5 Proposal to start PG degree in AsthiSandhi Rog and Aghaat Vigyan inAyurveda.

It was noted that Dr. Sanjeev Sharma, Reader, Department of ShalyaTantra, RGG Ayurved College, Paprola, Distt. Kangra HP has submitted arepresentation to Chairman, Education Committee (Ayurveda) and Dr. SKSharma, Advisor (Ayurved), Department of AYUSH, Ministry of Health &Family Welfare, New Delhi to start the Post-graduate Course in Asthi SandhiRog and Aghaat Vigyan in Ayurveda.

660eda

The matter was placed before the 36th Ayurveda Committee and AyurvedCommittee referred the matter to the Education Committee (Ayurveda).

CCIM has made the provision of Post-graduate Course in followingsubjects:-

1. Ayurved Siddhanta2. Samhitas (a) Charaka Samhita (b) Sushruta Samhita (c) Vagbhatta

Samhita.3. Rachana Sharir4. Kriya Sharir (Dosha – Dhatu – Mala Vigyana)5. Dravyaguna Vigyan6. Rasa Shastra7. Bhaishajya Kalpana8. Prasuti Tantra & Striroga9. Kaumar Bhrittya10. Kayachikitsa11. Swasthvritta12. Rog Nidan & Vikriti Vigyan13. Manas Roga14. Shalayatantra15. Shalya Tantra – Kshar Karma – Avm Anushastra Karma16. Shalakya Tantra - Netra Roga17. Shalakya Tantra - Shironasamukhakarna Roga.18. Panchkarma19. Agad Tantra and Vyavhara Ayurveda20. Sangyaharana21. Vikiran Vigyan

Education Committee decided that content of the syllabus beasked and be placed before next meeting.

Agenda Item No.6 Resolution of Prof. CHS Shastry.

It was noted that following resolution moved by Dr. CSH Shastry andseconded by Vaidya Jagjeet Singh and Vaidya Ved Prakash Tyagi:-

“In suppression of UGC Regulations No.F 1-11/87(CPP-II) dated 19.9.91 andnotification No.F 3-1/94(PS) dated 24.12.98 the UGC had made theRegulations for minimum qualifications required for the appointment andcareer advancement of teachers in Universities and institutions affiliated to itand circulated vide letter DO No.F 3-1/2000(PS) dated 4.4.2000 by Dy.Secretary UGC (copy enclosed).

760eda

Annexure to these Regulations, provide that the research/teachingexperience are considered at par for appointment to vartious posts inteaching.

Presently there is an acute shortage of teachers in Ayurveda specially insubject like Sharir Rachna, Kriya Sharir, Swasthavritta, Agadtantra,Kaumarabhritya etc. There are many research workers working for Ayurvedin the Council, Ministry and other recognized institutions.

Thus in order to mitigate the dearth of teachers it is resolved that anyresearch experience in the research Council, Health Ministry or otherrecognized institutions in Ayurveda should be considered and treated at paras teaching experience for recruitment of teachers in Ayurvedic college,whereas teaching experience is given there it may be replaced asteaching/research experience.””

The matter was placed before the 36th Ayurveda Committee and AyurvedCommittee referred the matter to the Education Committee (Ayurveda).

Education Committee agreed to treat the half of Research experienceas teaching experience for Ayurved Post-graduate working in CCRASand other recognized Research Institution.

Agenda Item No. 7 Visitation reports of the collegespermitted during the year 2002-03,2003-04, 2004-05, 2005-06, 2006-07

It was noted that 22 colleges have been permitted by Government of Indiaduring 2003-04, 2004-05, 2005-06 have been visited by the visitors of theCentral Council of Indian Medicine. Visitation Reports was discussed by theEducation Committee and decided as under::-

S.No. Name of the College Recommendations of EducationCommittee (Ayurved)

1 Sri Sri Ay. College ofSciences, Bangalore

After considering the visitation reportthe Education Committee decided notto recommend to Government ofIndia for further extension ofpermission to the College.

2 Rural Institute of Ay. &Research Centre, Myani

After considering visitation report theEducation Committee decided torecommend to Government of India

860eda

for further extension of permission tothe College.

3 Atrey Ay. College,Bangalore

After considering visitation report theEducation Committee decided torecommend to Government of Indiafor further extension of permission tothe College.

4 Ashwini Ayurved College,Tumkur


5 Dr. DY Patil Ay. College &Research Institute, NaviMumbai


6 Chhatisgarh Ay. MedicalCollege, Chhatisgarh


7 CB Guttal Ay. MedicalCollege, Dharwad


8 Vagdevi Ay. College,Warangal

After considering visitation report theEducation Committee decided torecommend to Government of Indiafor further extension of permission tothe College. It was also decided thatcollege be asked to enhance the dailypermission OPD.

9 University College ofAyurved, Jodhpur

After considering visitation report theEducation Committee decided thatGovernment of India be requested notto allow the admission for nextsession i.e. 2008-09 till theshortcomings are not fulfilled bythe college.

10 Himalaya Ayurved MedicalCollege, Dehradun

After considering visitation report theEducation Committee decided torecommend to Government of India

960eda

for further extension of permission tothe College.

11 SDM Ayurved College,Terdal

After considering visitation report theEducation Committee decided torecommend to Government of Indiafor further extension of permission tothe College

12 Shri Raghvendra Ay.Medical College,Chitradurga


13 Govind Bhai Jorabhai PatelAy. Medical College &Research Centre, Gujarat

After considering visitation report theEducation Committee decided not torecommend to Government of Indiafor further extension of permission tothe College.

14 Parul Institute AyurvedLimda Vadodra


15 Amrita Ayurved MedicalCollege, Kollam


16 Shri Narayan Institute ofAy Studies & ResearchPuthur, Kollam


17 Major SD Singh Ay.College, Farukhabad


18 JD Ayurved MedicalCollege, Aligarh


1060eda

19 KMCT Ayurved MedicalCollege, Kozhikode


20 Mannam Ayurved MedicalCollege, Pandalam


21 JR Tantia Ayurved College,Shriganganagar


Agenda Item No. 8 New Proposals received fromGovernment of India

It was noted that 51 proposals were received from Government of India asper details given below, as required under Section 13 A of IMCC Act, 1970for examination of Scheme and for furnishing the recommendations toGovernment of India for issuing or not to issuing Letter of Intent.

It was noted that following proposals have been received from theGovernment of India, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, New Delhi underSection 13 A for formulating recommendations to Government of India forissuing or not issuing Letter of Intent in first instance as per details givenbelow:-

Ayurveda

To establish new college 23To start new PG Course 16To increase intake capacity 09+01(PG)

Total 49After examination of the proposal college have been proposed for visitation.

Visitation reports were considered by Education Committee and decided asunder:-

1160eda

S.N Name of theCollege

Recommendations ofEducation Committee

1. GurunanakAyurved College,Muktsar

Increase intakecapacity from 40 to 60in Ayurvedacharyacourse.

After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter ofintent for increase intakecapacity from 40 to 60.

2. Mai BhagoAyurved College,Muktsar



3 Sri Baba MastnathAyurved College,Rohtak

and to start PG in

Dravyaguna 06Rasashastra 06Shalakya 06Kayachikitsa 06

After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter ofintent for starting PG in

Dravyaguna 06Rasashastra 06Shalakya 06Kayachikitsa 06

4. SiddhakalaAyurvedMahavidyalaya,Snagamner

And to start PG in

Balroga 02Prasuti & Striroga 02

After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter of

1260eda

intent for starting PG in

Balroga 02Prasuti & Striroga 02

5. YMT AyurvedCollege, Mumbai(PG)


And to start PG in

Kayachikitsa 04Dravyaguna 04Rasashastra 04


Kayachikitsa 04Dravyaguna 04Rasashastra 04

And to increase intakecapacity from 50 to 60.

6. Al Ameen MedicalCollege, Malegaon

To establish NewAyurveda College

After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter ofintent for establishmentof new Ayurved Collegewith intake capacity of50.

7. KusumtaiRajarambhai PatilAyurved College,Chiptune,Tatnagiri (MS)



1360eda

intent for establishmentof new Ayurved Collegewith intake capacity of50.

8. Shri VivekanandAyurvedMahavidyalaya,Rahuri

to start PG in

Rasashastra 04Rognidan 04Shalakya 04

And to increase intakecapacity in

Kayachikitsa 04-06Prasuti & Striroga 04-06


Rasashastra 04Rognidan 04Shalakya (Netra Roga) 04

Also to increase intakecapacity in

Kayachikitsa 04 to 06Prasuti & Striroga 04 to 06

9. Annasaheb DangeAyurved College,Sangli (MS)


And to start PG in

Rachnasharir 05


Rachnasharir 05And to increase intakecapacity from 40 to 50.

10. RVS AyurvedCollege,Coimbatore



1460eda

intent for establishmentof new Ayurved Collegewith intake capacity of50 subject to makeavailable the NOC of theState Government andConsent for Affiliation ofthe University for 50students.

11. PN PannikarSauhruda AyurvedCollege, Kasargod,Kerala



12. GovernmentDhanwantriAyurved College,Ujjain

To start PG in

Panchkarma 05Ayurved Siddhant 04

After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter ofintent for starting PG inPanchkarma 05Ayurved Siddhant 04

13. GovernmentAyurved College,Bangalore

To start PG in

Rasashastra 06Roganidan & VikritiVigyan 06

After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter ofintent for starting PG inRasashastra 06Roganidan & Vikriti Vigyan06

1560eda

Subject to obtaining theNOC of the StateGovernment and Consentfor Affiliation of theUniversity.

14. GovernmentAyurved College,Kannur

To start PG in

Rachna Sharir 05


Rachna Sharir 05

Subject to NOC of the StateGovernment and Consentfor affiliation of theUniversity.

15. National Instituteof Ayurveda,Jaipur

To start new PG in

ShalakyaPrasuti & StrirogaAgad Tantra 06


ShalakyaPrasuti & StrirogaAgadtantra 06

16. Pawan RajaAyurveda CollegeBhandara, Pauni

To establish newAyurved college.

After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter ofintent for establishment

1660eda

of new Ayurved Collegewith intake capacity of50.

17. AajeevanSwasthyaSamvardhaAyurveda Manavi,Chitrakoot, Satra

To establish newAyurved college

After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter ofintent for establishment ofnew Ayurved College withintake capacity of 50.

18. Patanjali BhartiyaAyurvigyan AvamSansthan,Haridwar


After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) did not agreeto recommend toGovernment of India forissuing Letter of intent forestablishment of newAyurved College.

19. Ashvin RuralAyuveda College,Manchi Hill,Sangamer

To increase intakecapacity from 40 to 50.


20. MNR Ayurvedcollege, Medakap


After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter ofintent for establishmentof new Ayurved Collegewith intake capacity of

1760eda

100.

Dr. VP Tyagi and Dr.Jagjeet Singh gave a not ofdissent against the decisionfor recommending for 100seats.

21. Shri VageshwariAyueved College,Karimnagar (AP)



Dr. VP Tyagi and Dr.Jagjeet Singh gave a not ofdissent against the decisionfor recommending for 100seats.

22. Shri AnnasahebDage AyuevedCollege, Sangli


and to start PG in

Rachna Sharir 05

After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter ofintent for increase intakecapacity from 40 to 50

and to start PG in

Rachna Sharir 05

23. Arogya Institute ofAyueved andResearch


After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and all

1860eda

Richabarcli, Indore relevant papers theEducation Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter ofintent for establishmentof new Ayurved Collegewith intake capacity of100.

24. DhawantariAyurved College,Latur



It was also noted that CCIMhas already granted thepermission for 50 seats.

25. Dr. BRKRAyurveda College,Hyderabad

To start new PG in

PanchkarmaAyurved Samhita 06


PanchkarmaAyurved Samhita 06

26. VPS VarierAyurved College,Kottakal

To start new PG in

Dravyaguna 04Panchkarma 04Swasthavritta 04


Dravyaguna 04

1960eda

Panchkarma 04Swasthavritta 04

27. SanjeevaniAyurved College &Hospital, Khanna



28. Datta AyurvedCollege, Buldana



29. GovernmentAyurved College,Tripunithura

To start new PG in

Dravyaguna 04Panchkarma 04Shalakya 04Rasashastra &Bhaishajya Kalpana 04


Dravyaguna 04Panchkarma 04Shalakya 04Rasashastra &Bhaishajya Kalpana 04

30. Silvar OakAyurved MedicalCollege, Jabalpur


After examination ofproposal alongwith thevisitation report and allrelevant papers the

2060eda

Education Committee(Ayurved) decided torecommend to Governmentof India for issuing Letter ofintent for establishmentof new Ayurved Collegewith intake capacity of70.

31. Grantham Collegeof Ayurved &Research Centre,Gwalior



32. Mahavir AyurvedMahavidyalaya,Mandsour.



33. Shri VijayMahanteshAyurved College,Ilkal



2160eda

34. SSN AyurvedCollege, Paikmal



35. Shri VidyasagarAyurved College,Belgaum



36. Shri Uttam RaojiDhake AyurvedCollege, Washim



37. ChhatrapatiAyurved College,Aurangabad

To start new PG in

Rognidan & VikritiVigyan 02Shalya 02Prasuti & Striroga 02


Rognidan & VikritiVigyan 02

2260eda

Shalya 02Prasuti & Striroga 02

The visitation of Ayurved College, Akurdi was not received.

Agenda Item No. 9 Consideration of National Policy for thepersons with diabeties

It was noted that a letter No.Z.28015/108/2005-P&C dated 5.8.2005 hasbeen received from Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Department ofAYUSH, New Delhi regarding National Policy for the persons with disabilities(Copy enclosed). Following points in the National Policy could beimplemented:-

i) Development of modules and facilities in disability prevention, earlydetection and interventions for medical and para-medicalpersonnel;

ii) Introduction of modules of disability prevention, early detection andinterventions in medical education courses.

Education Committee constituted a sub-committee of followingmembers to give its recommendations regarding the details of thedisabilities and the remedies thereof to put up before next meeting:-

1. Dr. KV Shah2. Dr. SN Parchure3. Dr. VV Chhikara4. Dr. BK Jaisingh5. Dr. NS Tyagi6. Dr. AV Joshi

Addl.Agenda Item No.1 Recognition of PG degree of GauhatiUniversity, Guwahati, Assam.

It was noted that Post-graduate qualification of Gauhati University, Guwahatiis not included in 2nd Schedule to IMCC Act, 1970.

In this regard following facts a re placed below:-

2360eda

Government of India vide their letter no.R.12013/1/2006-Ay.Desk hasforwarded the request of University under Section 14 (2) of IMCC Act,1970.

Government Ayurved College, Guwahati, Assam is affiliated to thisUniversity.

The said college has been permitted by CCIM for conducting Under-graduate with intake capacity of 40 students and PG in Kayachikitsa,Ayurved Siddhant and Samhita with intake capacity of 06, 03 and 03respectively.

University has followed the nomenclature of degree. University has also decided to follow the syllabus of PG Course as

prescribed by CCIM. The degree has been awarded by University for first batch in 2004.

Education Committee agreed to recommend to Government ofIndia for inclusion of the same in Second Schedule to the IMCCAct, 1970.

Addl.Agenda Item No.2 Minimum Standards & Reequirement ofAyurved Colleges & Hospital –violation of PG Regulation 2005 by theUniversity. - regarding

It was noted that a letter dated 10.4.07 received from Dr.Anand V.Joshi,Member, CCIM and Principal Bharti Vidyapeeth University, Pune regardingviolation of Post-graduate Regulations, 2005 by the Universities referring tothe Ministry’s letter dated 23.10.06, CCIM’s letter dated 30.3.07 and18.3.07.

In his letter, Dr. Joshi states that after approval of the Minimum Standardsin the 40th meeting of Central Council, the same was circulated to all thecolleges for implementation inspite of objections raised by members in thesaid meeting and the Central Council has totally rejected the Govt. of India’sdirections in their letter dated 23.10.06. Further, as per newly framedMinimum Standard, there is a lot of reduction in comparison to the MinimumStandards prescribed in 1989 and also, there is no mention aboutconcurrence/approval of the Govt. of India with regard to these newlyframed Minimum Standard.

Also, there should be Theory and Practical exams for Preliminary MD/MScourse as per Post-graduate Regulation, 2005 but Rajiv Gandhi University ofHealth Sciences, Bangalore has cancelled Practical/Viva exams. ForPreliminary MD/MS Course at their University level which is violation of thePost-graduate Regulation,2005. Similarly, in violation of the said Regulation,

2460eda

2005 the Banaras Hindu University has made the eligibility criteria foradmission to MD/MS(Ay.) according to which MBBS holders are also eligiblealong with BAMS.

Bringing the above facts to the notice of the Council, Dr. Joshi has requestedto give necessary instructions to the concerned Dy.No.374/23.4.07.

It was also noted that Government of India had also forwarded the letter ofDr. AV Joshi. In this regard it is also submitted that there is no clear cutprovision of theory and practical examination for Preliminary examination atPG level.

Education Committee discussed the matter with Additional AgendaItem No.3

Addl.Agenda Item No.3 Resolution of Members

Proposed by Dr. Manohar M Jumle, seconded by

1. orZeku esa vk;qosZn dk lokZaxh.k fodkl gks jgk gSA fdUrq vk;qosZn egkfo|ky;ksa esa f”k{kdksa dhU;wure la[;k Hkkjrh; fpfdRlk dsUnzh; ifj"kn~ esa denh gS A ,d rjQ ge v/;kiu fo"k; oLrq ,oa izk;ksfxdv/;kiu ds ?kaVs c<k jgs gS nwljh rjQ izk/;kidksa dhU;wure la[;k de dj jgs gS ;g vk;qosZn egkfo|ky;ksads fodkl rFkk vk;qosZn foKku ds fy, mfpr ugha gS Avr% vk;qosZn egkfo|ky;ksa esa iz/;kidksa dh U;wurela[;k c<kusa ds fo"k; esa fo’ks”kr% laLd`r lafgrkfoHkkx] ’kjhj jpuk foHkkx] nzO;xq.k foHkkx] jl”kkL=foHkkx] dk;fpfdRlk foHkkx ,oa “kY; foHkkx esaxaHkhjrk ls fopkj fd;k tk, A

Education Committee (Ayurved) reiterated earlier decision in thematter.

2. jl”kkL= esa HkS"kT; dYiuk nks vfHkUu vkSj ,d&nwljsds iwjd fo"k; gS A vr% bUgsa ,d gh fo"k; ds :i esa

2560eda

ekU;rk nh tkuh pkfg, rFkk bldk uke jl’kkL= HkS"kT;dYiuk gh jguk pkfg, ftlls inP;qRrj fo|kFkhZ dksnksuks fo"k;ksa esa izf’k{k.k izkIr ds ewyHkwr vf/kdkjls oafpr u jguk iMs A

Education Committee (Ayurved) reiterated earlier decision in thematter.

3. vk;qosZn okpLefr (,e-Mh- vk;qosZn) (,e-,l- vk;qosZn)ds izFke o"kZ ikB~;dze dks ysdj cgqr Hkze gS AorZeku esa rhu izdkj ds ikB~;dze py jgs gS Aegkjk"V~z vkjksX; foKku fo|kihB ukf”kd ds nks iz”ui=j[k jgk gS fylesa ,d vuqla/kku i)fr ds fy, vkSj nwljklEcfU/kr fo"k; ds fy, gS fdUrq lEcf/kr fo"k; okys i= esaikaWp&Ng fo"k;ksa das ,d&,d iz”u gksrs gS vkSjmUgsa tkaWpus okys ijh{kd Hkh mrus gksrs gS Avr% lEiw.kZ ns”k esa flQZ lEcfU/kr fo"k; dh v/;kiu ,oaijh{kk dh O;oLFkk ds lkFk ,d:irk gksuh pkfg, A

Chairman, Education Committee (Ayurved) clarified the matter asper syllabus.

Proposed by Dr. SN Parchure, seconded by Dr. KV Shah

1. In the recent judgment OF Kerala High Court writ PetitionNo.10033/2006. The Court held that CCIM has got no power tonotify to allow the ISM graduates to use modern medicine CCIMhas filed a SPL 6116/07 in the Supreme Court which was notadmitted so makes chaos in the ISM (Ayurvedic) graduates inIndia. Taking into consideration the seriousness of the decisionresolves that review petition be filed in the Supreme Courtimmediately and senior lawyer be appointed for the review petition.

Education Committee (Ayurved) agreed to file the review petition.

2. In the Regulation of PG (February 2005). There was no mentionabout the age of the PG teacher up to which age he can guide. Thestudents taking on to consideration the paucity of the senior

2660eda

teachers and guides, the age limit of the PG norms. So it isresolved that the registering university be directed accordingly thatthe PG teacher can accept the students up to 65 years of age.

In the College where retired teachers are working all those teacherscan guide upto the age of 65.

3. In the Regulation of PG (February 2005) the direction of ATKT isnot cleared rule No --- say. The student after the passing thepreliminary examination has to keep four terms. There by thestudents does not get any advantage of ATKT. It is resolved thatCCIM has to give clear direction that four terms of the student willbe calculated even after the student get ATKT.

Chairman, Education Committee (Ayurved) clarified the matter.

4. The CCIM general body passed the resolution no ---- in themeeting held on 23-24.3.2004 about allied or a college subject. Inmany states and universities the colleges are not -- the PG or UGteacher in concerned subjects as the PG in that subject has startedjust recently in very few colleges in India. So it is resolved that thecircular be issued for implementation of allied or ancillary subjectwith immediate effect.

Education Committee (Ayurved) decided to pursue the matter withthe Government of India.

5. In the preliminary examination (MD Ayurved) the syllabus of K &Kh group is not finalized making lot of confusion in the mind of theuniversities, teacher and students. So resolves that the detailsyllabus of K & Kh group be prepared immediately, by the expertcommittee.

Education Committee noted that syllabus of PG has already beenprepared it is the verge of the implementation.

Proposed by Dr. AV Joshi, seconded by Dr. SN Parchure

1. The Government of India was notified minimum standards and otherrequirements for Ayurved colleges in 1989. It needs to be revised byorganizing workshop. Bharati Vidyapeeth University, College of

2760eda

Ayurveda, Pune is willing to host the said workshop with the help ofCCIM and Government of India and other resource persons in theconcerned subject. It is resolved to seek permission to organizeworkshop at Bharati Vidyapeeth University, College of Ayurveda,Pune.

Chairman, Education Committee (Ayurved) in UG Regulationsclarified that CCIM after considering the required amendments issubmitting the required amendment to Government of India time totime to accord the sanction.

2. There is alack of research in Ayurved among the professional itself.To create good research oriented scholars, it is a need of the today,to introduce Research Methodology in the curriculum of BAMSCourse. It is resolved to introduce Research Methodology as asubject of study in following three phases in the BAMS Course.

I BAMS Fundamentals of Research in AyurvedaII BAMS Drugs & Pharmaceutical Research in Ayurveda.III BAMS Clinical Research in Ayurveda.Also resolved to create separate Department in Research Methodologywith staffing pattern of minimum 01 Professor, 01 Reader and 01Lecturer.

Education Committee (Ayurved) did not agree to it.

3. It was discussed in the last CCIM meeting to introduce InternalAssessment Scheme in BAMS Course. It is resolved to implementthe internal assessment scheme to BAMS Course with 20% Internalassessment marks and 80% University examination marks in eachtheory and practical subjects.

Education Committee (Ayurved) reiterate the earlier dicision in thematter.

4. It is observed that some Universities are not following the notifiedPost-graduate Regulations 2005 in their Universities.

a) Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi is allowed MBBS graduatesfor admission to MD/MS Courses in Ayurved which violates thePost-graduate Regulations.

b) Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences is not not conductingpractical examination for 1st year MD/MS Courses which violatesthe Post-graduate Regulations.

2860eda

In spite of violation of Regulations the Central Council of IndianMedicine/Government of India has recognized Post-graduate Degree’s ofthese Universities.

It was resolved to implement the notified Post-graduate Regulations, 2005 inall Universities by conducting visitation by visitors of CCIM.

Education Committee decided that letter be written to bothUniversities.

Addl.Agenda Item No.4 Age limit for a PG teacherand guide

It was noted that a letter from Principal, Tilak Ayurved Mahavidyalaya hasbeen received. The content of letter are as under:-

That many Ayurvedic colleges in Maharashtra State are conducting Post-graduate courses. It has become difficult for them to admit the studentsbecause Maharasthra University of health Sciences Nashik to which all thesecolleges are affiliated in this state, does not recognize any teacher as a post-graduate teacher and as a guide to guide PG students after the age of hissuperannuation i.e. 58 years in Government service and 60 in grant-in-aidcolleges.

There are no guidelines in this respect with the university and Universityfollows Central Council of Indian Medicine. According to our knowledgethere is no mention about these guidelines in the CCIM gazeet of 11.2.2005.

Let us kindly know upto what age limit any teacher can work as a post-graduate teacher and guide as per CCIM guidelines or respective universityis free to take the decision.”

In this regard following facts are placed below:-

No age limit of teaching staff has been prescribed under UG and PGRegulations.

Central Council has already agree to enhance age of teaching staffupto 65. Letters were sent to all concerned.

In last meeting, Central Council has also agreed to enhance age limitupto 70 years subject to extension of the period year to year basis andfitness of physical and mental health as well as re-employment withfull pay scale.

2960eda

It was further noted that before issuing the letter, matter was againdiscussed with the than President, CCIM and Chairman, EducationCommittee (Ayurved) and were opinion that as after 6.11.2007, theGovernment of India is final authority to grant the permission for thecolleges of Indian Systems of Medicine therefore, Central Council of IndianMedicine should get the approval for the same before issuing the letter inthe matter.

It was also decided to obtain the age limit decided by UGC. Accordinglyletter was issued but no reply has been received so far. However, thematter was discussed in UGC and it was told that:-

i) Centrally funded institute age is 65 yearsii) for re-employment 65 to 70.iii) Other institution 62 years.iv) As per University norms

Kindly refer the decision under Additional Agenda item No.3 onresolution of Dr. SN Purchure.

Meeting concluded with a vote of thanks to the Chair.

3060eda

Documents

Agenda Item No.1 Confirmation of the minutes of 59 meeting