187

?D+;$:+1>=R=K;IMR,h.n,/1>%639%[email protected],R,/D+;He!gf .6125>;Ibcseweb.ucsd.edu/~mdailey/papers/thesis.pdf · @]%'*+M 1>= % ,/D+; .63 =K1 %0@. r - f f f f ,/% # f. f,/% f = ? . .,/% f

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • ����������������������������������������������! ����#"$�

    ��%'&)(+*-,/.0,/12%'34.65879%�:-;=?%0@BA�12C'D�E�F;HG';I5J��12=K*4.65L�;%'3

    �!:+12=K=K;IMR,/.0,/12%'3S=K*+T+&)12,R,/;I:P123S(4.6MR,K1U.65V=/.0,K1>[email protected],K1>%'3Y%6@�,/D-;MK;

  • ��%'(cb�MR1>C'Dc,

    7O.0,K,KD+;Ie �gfk �.6125>;Hb'� u0v'vcu��5258MK12C'Dc,/=?MK;I=K;IMRG';I:8f

  • �?D+;$:+1>=R=K;IMR,h.n,/1>%639%[email protected],R,/D+;He!�gf� �.6125>;Ib 1>=�.6(+(-MK%qG';I:8�J.03+:12,)12= .6NIN;P1>3 Z[*4.05>12,b .63+: @]%6MK& @]%'M)(+*+T+521>NN

  • �����^�F� �����?�����Q�����

    �12C'34.0,K*+MK;_Lr.6C'; fgf$f$fgf_f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf 121>1

    �r.6T+5>;�%0@B��%'3c,K;=W,Q%6@ �r1>C'*+MR;1

    ��1>=W,Q%6@a�r.6T+52;1

    ��Nhm[3+%qeQ52;1

    � �3c,/MR%�:+*-NI,/12%'3 f$fgf$f$fgf_f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf �

    u �;IG6;.65B@]MK;IZ`*-;

  • �-f ��%'3+NI5>*+=R1>%'3 fgf$f$fgf_f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf �

    � ��3-:+;3-C �k.6NI;g�Q;%'39�BMKMK%6MK= fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf � �� f �^.6Nhm[C'MR%'*+3+: f$f$fgf_f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf � vu f ���-(�;&);1��p.0,K1>%'3)fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf � �u f �Q;%63Y=K(4.6NI;�.03+:Y@]* ���[email protected]; ��(+MR;%639N=R%'3Y%'3PNp.0,K;=R%'3Y%6@r=K12&\125U.6MR12,b =R,KMK*+NH,/*+MR;=RN%63 fgf$f$fgf_f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf �

    ��f 79;I,KD+%`:+= f$fgf$f$fgf_f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf �qv6v

    � f ��;I,e#%'MKmY:-;I,h.01>5>= f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf �qv6vu f ��;I,e#%'MKm ,KM/.6123+1>3-C f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf �qv �� f ��;I,e#%'MKm e#;

  • u f 79.0,/;IMK1U.05>=?.63-: 79;H,/D+%`:+= f$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf ���'u� f �Q;*+=R1>%'3 fgf$f$fgf_f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf � ���

    � ��%'3+NI5>*+=R1>%'3 fgf$fgf$f$fgf_f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf � �

    � 791���,K*+MK;_%6@r; ��(�;;p.0MK3+123+CsMK*+52;:+:+;I395>.pb';;3+CsMR*+5>;I= fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf � ���

    ��12T+5>12%'C'M/.0(+Dcb f$fgf$f$fgf_f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf � � �

    G`1

  • �F�W`� ��� �a�W"$�����

    u f � �?D+;N=K*+.65 MK;INm0;g=W,/1>&�*+5>1�.63+: 3-%'3�E�@X.0N12m6;$=R,/12& *+521�12=�.6NINT+5db�=R(V;IN1��I;%'3+=�*+3+:+;IMeQD+1>NhDP%'3+;_=Wb�=W,/;I& =K(�;1��&\.6C';a.63+:�"$.0TV%'M[tR;I,/=�.0, � G';=KN;I=3c,/;I3+=K1d,b�1>3

    ,/D+;(+MR%�NI;C'Dc,K=a.6=R=K12C'3+;*-=?N3-N3-N.65V@]MR;.65@]MK;IZ`*-;C'Dc,g.6=R=K1>C63+;; MR;

  • u f � � 79%'3+%65>12,KD+1>NB3-;I,e#%'MKm�,/MK.61>3-1>3+C��nD+%'5>:�%6*-,a=R;I,a;%'3+=If L�;3+123+C9eQD-;3+C_%'M#.0, �qv'v'v;.654@]MK;IZ`*-;3�@]%'MK&\.0,/12%'38�c.0=�:+;I=KNT�;1��NH,/;&)1>5>.6M�(4.0MK;5U.0M^(4.6MR;&)1>5U.0M�&)%'MK(+D-=��V � �12=R,/MK.6NI,K%'MK=If fgf_f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f_fgf$f$fgf$fgf$f$fgf$f_fgf$fgf � �

    � f � � . �g� �-.6&)(+52;Y(+MK%6,K%6,b`(+1>N

  • � f � ��;I=K*+5d,/= %0@�� %'*+3+C ;H,S.65lf � = � � � � ��)� ��(�;&);3c,�MR;%'3 @]MR%'& =/.6:+3-;=RC'*+=W,?:+;

  • � f �qv ��T+125>1d,b ,/%9:+;I,K;:-1>&);%'34.05 =KN123+CO%6@^D`*-& .63 .63+: 3+;H,e�%'MRm MR;3c,QMK;I(+MK;I=K;I3[,K=�%'3-;g%6@�,/D-; � �; ��(+MR;5>.6MK1d,b�=R(4.6N3+:-*+NNI;�MR;3-C9=R;I, MR;3+C9.65>5(4.01>MK=IfP�MRMK%'MT4.6MR=a:+;I3+%6,/; � � � N=K;I:8�k.63+:9 �� �1>=RC'*+=R,K;%'3 NI5U.6=R=K1 � Np.0,K1>%'3 .6NN=R;

  • ��f ���+.0&\(+52;_; ��(+MK;I=K=R1>%'3+=�%[email protected]';T-*-,/; ,K% =K*+T[tR;3+;I: %'3 �'v � %0@\o6��� � � .63+: ,K;3+C-f �KL ������El,/MK.61>3+;I: �S3+;I,e#%'MRm`=g.6MR; ,KM/.6123+;&)1��%'3S.0MK;_=KD4.0:+;

  • ���W��!��� �����^�F�

    � f � ��7O-� @]%'M�,/D+;),/D+MR;=$.63+: ,/D+MR;%'3P&\.0,/MR1>N

  • ��� $���Qj �F� _"g79� ����

    �a12MK=R, .63+: @]%'MR;3+C\&\;g1>3c,/% .\=RN;I3c,/1>=W,pf��^,/D+123+mSD+1>=�:+;I:+1>N=R%'38�� �.pG`1>: ��%�;I5>5>;0�8��*-MR,/12=_La.6:-C';I,R,p�F��*+m[& .03 ��.6&)=K;Hb'�8��:4.6& �a.pb`5>%'MI�8� �(+123+CS&\;0�r.03+: T�;NNI;6�c.63-: =R,K1>& *+5>.0,/123+CQ:+1>=RN3+CY=R%'&); %6@,/D-; �$f Vf�=K*-T`tR;

  • ��D4.6(�,/;3 @]*-5>5l�#1>=\. MK;I(+MK123c, %6@_&\.0,/;IMK1>.65Q.6(+(�;p.6MR1>3+C 1>3������ ���� � ��� ����� ���

    ������ � ����

    �� � ��� � � � � � ���������� ��� ��� �������79�� LBMR;:+C6;P79���(+(8f u � � �'v f��e�.6=\,KD+;P(+MK12& .6MWb MR;3 @]*+5>5 �F1>=g.9MK;I(+MK123c,%6@r.�&\.63[*+=KNIMK12(-,?=K*-T+&\1d,K,K;=?(4.0(V;IM

  • ����r�

    ��NI,K%'TV;IM u�� � ��� � � ��%'MR38�4��525>;I3[,K%qeQ38�4Lr;I3+3+=Wb�5dG0.63+1U.

    ��� �'u ��f Vfk��%6MR,/D9�^.6MR%'5>1234. `,/.0,/;$��3-12G';IMK=R12,b

    ��� ��� � ��� � � �%6@ ,e�.6MR;g �;I=K12C'3+;3+C)��=R=K1>=W,h.63c,��%'&)(+*-,K;;IC'%+�+���

    ��� ��� � u6v'v6v ��%'3+=R*+52,/.63c,p�k��;I,/MR%'5>%6C'1>N��3-N6f

    -.639 �1>;IC'%+�+���

    ��� � � � u6v'v � "�M/.6:+*+.0,/;$`,K*+:+;I3[,��Q;(+D-=

  • �.6125>;Ib6��7 f �gfd�$��%6,R,/MK;I5>5 �_" f j!fd��.63+: ��:+%'52(+D+=I�_�$f�� u6v'v'v � f � =K1��`E�*+3+1d,S3+;I,e#%'MKm 12=.6525rb'%6* 3+;I;=RN(+D+=I�-�_f � u6v6v'v �Hfr�=

    � �[email protected]=Ifg�3 �Q;.-��o-fd�F�Q*+(+(+1238�F�?f2�F.63-: "�5U.03 �C';[email protected]+C_=R,K;3+.0,/;�=R,KM/.0,K;

  • ���?`�Q������� ��� �QA�� ��W--��a�r�B�?�W���

    ��%'&)(+*-,h.n,/1>%634.65�7P%�:+;I5>=?%6@aA�12C'D�E�F;HG';I5��1>=K*+.65�Lr;IMKNI;%'39.63+:9��;IN52;Ib �%`NI,K%'M?%6@aLD-1>5>%6=K%'(+Dcb 1>39��%'C'3+1d,/1dG';$�NI1>;

  • M/.01>3[TV%qe �B.63+:)%6,KD+;3+C ,KD+;Y=/.6&); NI%'&\(-*-,h.0,K1>%'3+.65#&)%`:+;&)(�%'MR,/.63c, @X.6NI,K%'M ,/D+.63\:-1��V;%'M ; ��(V;IMK1>;I3+N3 (+MR;3+C_N

  • � ��������� �

    ���������� � ���������

    A�%qe :-%�;I=�,KD+;_T+M/.6123SMK;.6=R,@];Ie :+;INp.6:-;:-;3+CYD+%qe

    ,/D-;�3+;=#e#%'MRm��k.03+:Y,/D+;�MR;3�,KD+;#(-MK1>&\.0,K;G`12=K*4.65c=Wb`=R,/;I& D+.qG6;�T�;3+C'52;9G`1>=R*4.65�N%'3+= %'3%'T`tR;INI, =RD4.6(�;Y.63+: 12:+;&)(+52b ,K%�% 5>.6MKC6; .63+: NI%'&)(+5>; � ,K% .65>52%qe%'T+=R;%638f �3 (+=Wb�NhD-%'5>%'C0b'�QMK;I=K;p.0MKNhD+;IMK=SD4.pG'; &\.6:+;9C'MK;;3-C ; �-(�;&);;I= � (+MK;I:+1>NH,/12%'3+=%65>%'C6b)%'M?NI%'&)(+*-,h.n,/1>%638��D-% e#;IG6;3�@];3+C,/D-; %6(V;IM/.0,K1>%'34.05�NhD4.0M/.6NH,/;=W,/1>NI=S%6@_,/D+; G`1>=R*4.65�=Wb�=W,/;I& @]MK%'& TV;ID4.pG�12%'MS.652%'3+; 12= ,/%`%*+3+NI%'3+=W,/M/.01>3+;I:8fQ�3ON%'38�k=R%'&\;$(+MR%'C'MK;I=K=�%'3O%'T[tR;3+;I: :-%'& .01>3+=�=R*+NhD .6=_NhD4.6M/.0NI,/;IM_MK;%63 %6@^NI%'& E

  • u

    (+*-,/.0,/12%'34.65?&)%`:+;3+C ,/%qe�.6MK:-=Y. T�;I,R,/;3+C %0@�(+=Rb`NhD+%65>%'C'12Np.65Q:4.n,h.-f �#bN3 =KNI1>;=�,K% =K;C6%'MK1d,/D+& ,K%; ��(+5>.61>3P=K%6&\;_(+D+;I3+%'&);;�(+MK%6(V;IMR,/12;3Y(+=Wb�NhD-%'5>%'C0bYe^[email protected] .6T-=R,/MK.6NI,%'3+12=R,K=$T�;

  • =K(�;;I==R,KMK%'3-C'52b)=K*-C'C';3 MK;%'3 N52;.65@]MK;3+(+*�,s.63+: ,KD+; %qG';IM/.6MRNhD+1>3-C ,h.6=Rm 1>[email protected]+:+1dG`1>:+*4.n,/1>%638�.6=Q%'(+(�%'=R;3-C � 3+:+123+C'= %'3�D+%qe D[*+&\.63+= @X.65>=R;3+C9,/D+;\; ��(V;IMK12&\;I3[, � =�=R,/*-:-b (+D+.6=K;0fOj ; � 3+: ,/D+.0, ; �-(-5U.6123+1>3+C=K*-T`tR;=K;gMK;IN;I3+:+1>3-C

    &);=K&P��.63-: ,KD4.0,_(+MR%'T4.6T-1>5>1d,bS:+;%634.65&);I,h.0(+D+%'M^@]%'M?D-% e e�;$MK;I&\;I& T�;3 N%63; ��(�;&);=R% ; ��(+5U.01>3+=?T�%6,/DY,KD+;_:+1>=RN= . 52%'3+C D+12=R,K%'MRb

  • %6@ =R,K*+:-b`1>3-CPNIMK%'=R=WE�N3c,K= 1>&)(V%6=K;T+*�,/1>%63+= %6@�; ��(V;IMK12&\;I3[,/[email protected],K%'MK= .63+: MR;(+=�*+=�1>3c,K;3���D4.6(�,/;%'3+=g@]%'M�@]*+MW,/D+;IM MK; E=K;

  • � ��������� �

    � ���������� � � � �� ��� ����� ������� � � ���

    � �����

    �?D+;IMK;P1>=s=R,KMK%'3-C ;HG�12:+;%`Np.6521��=�,K%P=RD+%qe D+%qe ,KD+; @X.6N:+;$.s(+MR;12&\1234.6MWb\NI%'&)(+*-,h.n,/1>%634.65J:-;

  • j ; (+MK;I=K;I3[,�,e#% @];%'3P&\;INhD4.63+12=K& 12=Q.)C'.0,/123+Cs3+;I,e#%'MRmS,KD4.0,Q&);.0,/;I=�. NI%'&)(V;H,/12,K1>%'3

    T�;I,e#;1lfr�3P79%`:+;

  • :4.0,/.)=R*+(+(�%'MR,�,/D-;$G`1>;He ,/D+.0,Q,/D+;$&\;INhD4.63+12=K&)=�*-3+:+;3-C)@X.6NI1U.65J1>:+;I3[,K12,bSMR;N � = :+; � N=a5>1>&)12,K;12&\1d,�:+12=KNI*+=K=R1>%'3 D+;5>;I: �R.6=K=R%�NI1U.0,K12G';��9(-MK%'=R%'(4.6C0E3+%'=R1>NI=aeQD+%�&\.pb�D4.pG6;^3+%'MR& .65�.6T+125>1d,b�1>3�@X.0N%'3 ,/.6=Km[= �]1>=a1d,B.�@X.0NNI=sD4.pG';S:+1��)NI*+52,b (V;IMR@]%'MR&\123+C :+1 �)N&);3�EN.6=K=_:+12=KNIMK1>&)1>3+.0,/12%'3O%6@�N52;;I3c,�eQ12,KD =K;HG';IMK;(+MR%'=K%'(+.6C'3+%'=R1U.$T+*-,?.0(+(4.6MR;3+:-12G`1>:+*+.65>=�@]MK%6& ,KD+;C'3-1 � N

  • =KD-;%'3,h.0=Kmse^.0=�1>3)&\.63cbse^.pb`=?.6= :+1��)NI*+52, 1>3),/;IMK&)=#%6@JN%'38�`b';H,�j!f o-f4(V;IMR@]%'MR&\;I:Ye�;I5>5lf7O.6MW,/D4.P�k.6M/.0D .03+: D-;3�E�N.6=K= :-1>=KNIMK12&\1234.0,/12%'3_,h.6=Rm 1>3cG'%652G`1>3+C�@X.0N&)1>5>.6M�;Ib'; EC'5>.6=K=R;C'3+1 � Np.03[,K52b T�;I,R,/;=KNIMK12& E1>3+.0,/123+C\,KD+;�@X.6NI;N�(+.0,/12;: 3+%0,=KD-% e ,/D+12=�; �J;INI,%63 (�;=RN&)1>34.0,K1>%'3�(V;IMR@]%'MR& .63-N3-C MK;I=K*+5d,^e^.0=Q,KD4.0,^eQD-;;IM3Y(+MR;&)(V%'MW,h.63c,�Np.pG';%'34.n,/;M8(+MR%�NI;3-C�%6@-3+%'MK&\.65 �q*+(+MK12C'Dc,[email protected]=R*4.65r%'T`tR;

  • MK;IN5>.0,/;IM/.65�%`N3-N:-;; ��1>.-�'1>3 eQD-1>NhD)(4.0,/12;=a��f sf � ��;ID+MK&\.63+3g;I,B.05lfd� ����� � �Hf��?D+12=r(4.n,/1>;I3c,D4.6=$.S=R,KMK1>m[123+CY:+; � N3c,K;;3+:-;N%63 %6@�(4.0,R,/;IMK3+=s%6@�T+MK.61>3 :+.6& .0C'; � o6*+%'5U.O.63+:�LB5>*+3�Em6;H,K,1>;HG';s,/D+.0,$(+MK%'=R%'(4.6C63+%'=K1>.YMK;��+;

  • �qv

    =K(�;T-52b NI;;Ie ,/D+;�TV;ID4.pG`1>%'MK.654:+1>=W,/123+NI,K1>%'3+=BT�;I,e#;

  • � �

    MK;IZ[*+1>MR;^(4.6MW,RET+.6=K;I:sMK;=@]%'M=K*+NhD MR;3+.0,/;?NI5U.6=R=K1 � Np.0,K1>%'3s%6@J.�3+%qG';I54=Rb`3c,/D+;H,/1>N�%'T`tR;INI, N.6=K=I� �/"�MK;;I=;&)1>5>.6M =R;%'3 1>3�@]%'MK&\.0,/12%'3 � "$.6*�,/D+12;

  • � u

    .63+:\&\;INhD4.63+12=K&)=&\12C'Dc,:+;IG6;%6(8�+.63-:\:+;I=KNIMK1>T�;�(-MK;&)1>34.0MRbgN%'(-&\;I3[,�%6@�@X.0N%634.65J&)%`:+;3+;I: ;IG`1>:-;%'C6b

    .63+: .0:+*+52,�TV;ID4.pG`1>%'M�,KD4.0,[email protected];I=�123 D`*-& .63 [email protected],/=�D4.pG6; .652=K%Y(+MR%qG�12:+;&)(�%'MR,/.63c,�N%'3.6MR1>=K;I=&);=R*4.65_.0,R,/;%'3 12==K(�%'3c,h.03+;Np.05>52b\1>3-=K;;

  • ���

    *-,K1>5>1��1 f9:-;Y�NhD+%63+;3+C @]%6M =K%'&); %6@Q,KD+;Ym[3+%qeQ3�:+.0,h.-f�?D+; =RN:+=�,/D4.0,�=K;HG';*+:-1>3+C :+1 �J;IMK;%'34.05���.6=B%6(+(V%6=K;%qe MR;3cG'%652G';I:8f^�F.0,K;=R*4.65�=Rb`=W,/;C'Dc,?,KD+;.6=K;I:P,K%)@X.pG'%6M,/D-;\=K.6&\; D+%65>1>=W,/12N =K*+T-=Rb`=R,K;MR;

  • � �

    ��������� � � &(� �����

    �39.)=R;3-CsMK;%'3O1>= �R=R(+5>1d, �YT�;I,e#;%'3 .6MR1>=R;

  • � �

    ������������� ���� ����� ���� ��� ��� ��� ���

    � � � � � � �� ����� �!� �� �"� �#� �$�%����&' �!� �(�

    ) * ��� � �%� �+�, ��- � � �(�.�

    ���#�� �"� �#� �$�%����&)0/$1 �2� �� �"� �#� �$�%����&

    3�3

    �a12C'*+MK; u f � i �?D-;%'3 &)%`:+;& *-5>1�.63+: 3+%'3`E�@X.6NI;HE521>m0;O=R,K1>& *-5>1�1>=Y.6NINT+5db =R(V;IN1��I;*-=:+;I3c,/12,b\%'M^NI5U.6=R=?%6@F,/D+;�=W,/12& *+5>*-=%'3+=*+3+:-;NhDP%'3+;_=Wb�=W,/;I& =R(V;IN.65>1��

  • � �

    e#%'MKmkf �#b9.65>52% eQ123+Cs,/D+;g3+;I,e#%'MRm`=�,/% 52;p.6MR3 .63-:O:+12=KN3 ,KD+;_T+M/.61238fB��5d,/D+%6*+C'D e#;$&\.6m0;$3-%)NI5U.612&\= ,/D4.n,%'*+MB&)%`:+;N5db�(+5U.0*+=K12T+5>;#1>3).63cbs=K12C'3+1 � Np.63c,Be�.pb'�c,/D+;Q; �-(�;

  • ���������� ����������

    ���

    ���

    �����

    ��� ���

    ����� �! "�� #�$��% &�'#�(*)�)+'�#��% (*)+, - ���.�����

    /103254603287:9�?

    @�A%@ #�(B"�C#�(B)�)+'�#��% (B)+,

    DFE 4.=G>�2IH

    DFE 4.=G>�28J

    �X. �

    ���������� ����������

    ������

    ������

    �����

    ��� ���

    ����� �! "�� #�$��% &�'#�(*)�)+'�#��% (*)+, - ���.�����

    KFL:M6M =�NO7:9�?

    #�(B��"�� '��P' )+�P'�QR#�(*)�)+'�#��% (*)

    S / M 067 =TH

    S / M 067 =IJ

    �XT �

    �a12C'*+MK; u f u i)79%`:+*+5>.6Mg3-;I,e#%'MKm &\%`:+;I5�.6MRNhD+12,K;123+;p.0M�D+12:+:+;3VU � ��.�%0@�,KD+;�&)%�:-*+5>;I=

  • ���

    ;38f

    ��� � ��� � ����� ���-����� � �� "���������"� &����� ��� � � �! &��

    �) �� +����� ������� � ��� ���������

    �123+NC'3-=.se�;I1>C'Dc,�,/% ;;�C612G';I3 .63P1>3-(+*-,�(4.0,R,/;;�� 12=?. �[email protected];�=K(�;=R,

  • ���

    �a1>C'*-MK; u f � i���-.6&\(-5>;�@X.6NI;6�4T�%�%'mk�+NI*+(8�k.63-:9N:+*4.05>=�@]MK%'& ,/D-;��%6,R,/MK;I5>5a.63+: 79;I,KNp.65d@];s:4.0,/.6T4.6=R; � ��� ��� �Hf$�3 ,KD+;3[*+=R%'1>: 5>%`Np.6521��I;

  • u6v

    @]MK;IZ[*+;.63+N=R,K%'MR,K1>%'3J�+.63+:P=K1��;I,�.4 � u #5 u 4eQD+;IMK;65 12=^,/D+;_12& .6C6;�eQ1>:-,KDP.63+:7� 12=Q.63S1>3c,/;IC';

  • u �

    �a12C'*+MK; u f � ia�Q;p.05-N

  • u'u

    ����� � ������ ��� � ��������� ������� � ���� � ��� � ��

    ��*+M � MK=R,^&\%`:+;%'MR;,/D-; ; �`,/;I3c,Y,/% eQD-1>NhD =K(�;&)(+52;9NI%'&\(�;I,K12,K12G';P&)%�:+*-5U.6M=Rb`=W,/;3 eQD+12NhD ,/D-;9; �-(�;3+C65>;HE�5U.pb';IM_5>1>3-;p.6M3+;H,e�%'MRm[=3+C$3+;H,e�%'MRm\52;p.6MR3+=#.63 123+(+*-, =K(+.6N;I=g.n,K,/;I&\(�,$,K%&\. ��1>&)1��m6;I5>12D+%�%`: %6@�,/D-;�,/MK.61>3-1>3+C$=K;H,Q.6=K=R*+&)1>3+Cs.�"$.0*+=K=R1U.63 &)1 �`,K*+MK;�&\%`:+;I5V123eQD+12NhD9;&\.6C';6f��?D-;)MR;

  • u��

    N3 ���cu NI%�; �\NI1>;I3[,K=g@]%'M�;58NI%�; �)N;I3c,/=Q@];5V1>3Y,/D-;$MK.63+C'; � � � � � fj 12,KDO,/D-;�MK;I=K*+5d,/123+C MR;&)%'=W,rNI;123+;p.0MK52b�=K;;6f

    ����� � � � �"& � ���� &��-��� ��� � �

    �3 ,/D+;I=K;P; ��(V;IMK12&\;I3[,K=52%qeQ1>3+C

    ,/MK.61>3-1>3+Cs(+MR%�NI;.65>1��;I=

  • u �

    � fQ��;3+NIMK;p.0=K;&);3 ��(-(V;I3+:+1 � � � f ��@�,/D+;YCc.n,/;Y3+;H,e�%'MRm 5>;%qeQ52b)MK;I5U.0,K12G6;�,/%g,/D+;�; ��(V;IMR,/=I�+,/D+;Hb C6;&);%634.65(4.6MK.6&);I,/;IM =K(+.6N;3-C9(4.0M/.6&);I,K;

  • u �

    Faces Books Cups Cans

    Stimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Ave

    rage

    Wei

    ght

    Face id ME network

    Face ExpertNon-face Expert

    �a12C'*+MK; u f �-i8j ;NhD-;IG';IMQ; ��(V;IMR,Q;I&\;IMKC';I:9.0=�@X.6N3+Cs%63+;_; ��(V;IMR,�T[bSMK.63+:+%6&\5db MK;I&\%qG`1>3-CN

  • u �

    0 25 50 75 100

    % damage

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    Tes

    t se

    t %

    cor

    rect

    Face-dominating expert damage effects

    facesbookscupscans

    �X. �

    0 25 50 75 100

    % damage

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    Tes

    t se

    t %

    cor

    rect

    Non-face dominating expert damage effects

    facesbookscupscans

    �XT �

    �a12C'*+MK; u f �i �X. ���k.6N

  • u

    ����� ��� � ���� ����������� �) � ����!� � �-�!� ���$&��

    �?D+; MR;%`Np.6521��1d,b ,/% MK;IN=ge#;YN.6*+=R1>T+52;S@]%6M)NI%'&)(V;H,/12,K1>%'3 T�;I,e#;[email protected]%'(+&);

  • u��

    ��� � � ������ � ��� � � ������ �� � � �� ��� ��� � � � � � ����

    �3 ,/D-;�&)1 �`,/*+MR;#%0@k; ��(V;IMR,K= &\%`:+;I5qtR*+=W, :+;I=KNIMK1>T�;3+C�,h.6=Rm .63+:s=W,/MR*+NI,K*+M/.654:-1��V;3-(+*-,�=W,/1>&�*+5>1F,/D4.03 . =R1>&)(+5>;�5>1>3-;p.6M�:+;=K12%'3 T�%'*+3+:4.0MRb'�8e#; .6:+:-;.6M$3+;I,e#%'MKm � =\%6*-,/(+*�, *+3+12,K= N%'39.63+:P5>;3+C MK*-5>;3S:+;H,h.6125lf�?D+;g&\%`:+;5U.0M#,/%),/D+;�7O� 1>3P,/D4.n,�1d,�1>&)(+5>;I&\;I3[,K=�.)@]%'MR& %6@ NI%'&\(�;I,K12,K12G';=K;I5>;INI,/12%'3 1>3 eQD+12NhDs,/D+;QCc.0,K1>3+C�3+;I,e#%'MKms52;p.6MR3+= eQD+12NhD)&)%`:+*+5>;�1>= T�;I,R,/;;�,K%$(-MK%`N%'MR;D+%qe ,e�%_T+1>.6=K;I= &)1>C'Dc,a. �J;INI,B=R(V;IN.65>1��p.0,K1>%'38i � �F,/D-;?:+1>=RN%'3_5>;HG';I5 �X=R*+T�%'MK:+1234.0,K;G`=52;�G0.6MRb`123+C ,/D+;sMK.63+C';s%0@#=R(4.0,K1U.65a@]MR;;

  • u��

    .63+: N.6T+5>;s=R(V;IN.65>1��p.0,K1>%'3 @]%'M�@X.6NI;\(-MK%`N3+CS,/D+12=_; ��(V;IMK1 E

    &);=Y; ��(V;IMK1>&);%'3 %6@?,/D+;\MK;I=K(�%'3+=K;I= @]MK%'& ;&);%634.65BG';INI,/%6MK=3+C =K;I,:-*4.651>3 ,/D+; ,KM/.6123+1>3+C =K;H,Y@]%'M *+=R; 1>3 :+;H,/;3-C eQD+;I3 ,K% =R,/%6( 3+;I,e#%'MKm ,/M/.01>3+123+C+f j ;=K;H,�,KD+; 5>;3+CPM/.0,K;)@]%6M�.65253+;I,e#%'MKm e#;C6D[,K=�,/% v f � .63+: ,/D+;I1>M�&)%'&);3+;I: ,/D4.0,B._&);p.03s=KZ[*4.6MR;

  • �'v

    D+%'52:Y%'*-,Q=R;I,QeQ12,KD+%'*-,Q%qG';IMR,KM/.6123+1>3+C .03+:P.65>52% e#;%'3 ,h.0=Kmk�re#;\@]%'*-3+: ,KD4.0,g.63 7O-� ,/D+MR;3Y%qG6;3-C+fB�4%'M?.6525JMR*+3+=QMK;I(V%'MW,/;I:P123 ,/D+;�MR;&)(+52b ,KM/.6123+;3+.0,/;gTV%`%'mk�JNI*+(8��.63-: Np.63 NI5U.6=R=K1 � Np.nE,K1>%'3 � � � %'*-,/(-*-,/= �Hf

    �4%'M^;%63+=

  • ���

    0.5*300 4 51 2 0.5*3 0 0

    1 2 3 4 5

    High frequency patternLow frequency pattern

    �a12C'*+MK; u f � iS�(+5212,K,K1>3+C91>3+(-*-,s(4.0,R,/;IMK3+= 1>3c,K% D+1>C'D =R(4.0,K1U.65 @]MK;%qe =R(4.0,K1U.65@]MK;IZ[*+;.qb`=�,/D+;gMK;3+C\:+;C63+= ,/%_;p.0NhD\&)%�:-*+5>; @]%'M ,/D+;^,KM/.6123+1>3-C�(4.0,R,/;%63S.63+:9,KD+;�%0,/D+;IMMK;IN.65J@]MK;IZ[*+;3-@]%6MK&\.0,/12%'38f

    �3_,/D+;N%'3 @]%'Mg.63cb C612G';I3 (4.0,R,/;IMK3 .0TV%'*�,D4.65d@ ,/D-;�,/12&\;0f��%S.65d,/D+%6*+C'DO%63 .63cbO=R1>3+C'52;gMR*+38�J,KD+; &)%�:-*+5>;I=�e#%'*+52: =KD+%qe . (4.0,R,/;1��p.0,K1>%'3 =K12&\125U.6Mr,/%g,KD+;�MR;

  • �cu

    Faces Books Cups Cans

    Stimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Ave

    rage

    Wei

    ght

    4-Way Classification (control)

    Module 1Module 2

    Faces Books Cups Cans

    Stimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Ave

    rage

    Wei

    ght

    4-Way Classification (split frequencies)

    Module 1(high freq)Module 2(low freq)

    Faces Books Cups Cans

    Stimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Ave

    rage

    Wei

    ght

    Book id task (control)

    Module 1Module 2

    Faces Books Cups Cans

    Stimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Ave

    rage

    Wei

    ght

    Book id task (split frequencies)

    Module 1(high freq)Module 2(low freq)

    Faces Books Cups Cans

    Stimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Ave

    rage

    Wei

    ght

    Face id task (control)

    Module 1Module 2

    Faces Books Cups Cans

    Stimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Ave

    rage

    Wei

    ght

    Face id task (split frequencies)

    Module 1(high freq)Module 2(low freq)

    �a12C'*+MK; u f � i���G';C'3+;I:g,K%�;p.0NhD�&)%�:+*-5>;T+MK%6m6;*-&\3 � �[;p.6NhDY&)%�:-*+5>;?MR;

  • � �

    @]%'MQ%'3+;$&)%�:+*-5>;�,/%)=K(�;3�@]%'MK&\.nE,/12%'38��NI%'&)(4.6MK;I: eQ1d,/D ,/D+; @]%'*+M�E�e�.qbcE�N%63 .03+: =K.6&\; E(4.n,K,/;IMK3 N3-=�,KD+;�NI%'&\(�;I,K12,K1>%'3S@]%'[email protected]:+;IM/.6T+5dbO52;%63 .63-: . N=RN&)1>34.0,K1>%'3 ,h.0=Kmkf ��%0,/D %6@_,/D+;I=K; ,h.0=Km[==KD-% e . ��-� =K;;I=1��

  • � �

    0 25 50 75 100

    % damage

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    Tes

    t se

    t %

    cor

    rect

    High spatial frequency module damage effects

    facesbookscupscans

    � . �

    0 25 50 75 100

    % damage

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    Tes

    t se

    t %

    cor

    rect

    Low spatial frequency module damage effects

    facesbookscupscans

    �XT �

    �a12C'*+MK; u f �pv i�� �V;3+C),/D+;s=R(V;IN1��I;:+;I3c,/1 � Np.0,K1>%'3 3-;I,e#%'MKm[=_@]MK%'&�a12C'*+MK; u f � f �rMK.61>3+123+C %'3 @X.6N1��p.0,K1>%'3 .03+: =R(+5>1d,K,K1>3+C ,KD+; =K(4.n,/1U.05�@]MK;IZ`*-;3�@]%'MK&\.0,/12%'3YT�;I,e#;

  • � �

    ��������� � ��� � ��!� & � � �� � ���� &������ )*������� �!�� � ���"& � ���� � �� "���������"��)*�� )*�� +�

    ��� +�!������� � ,

    �3)%'MK:+;IM ,/%$.0,R,h.6123 ._T�;I,R,/;IM *-3+:+;;#=K(�;3-C ,/D+;$=/.6&);�=R,K1>& *-5>1JT-*-,�=K1>&)(+52;%'3)3+;%'3�%6@�,KD+;S5>%qe=K(+.0,/1>.654@]MK;C'D)=K(4.n,/1U.05k@]MR;3-@]%'MR& .n,/1>%63)123 %'*-M#=W,/1>&�*+5>*+= MK;I(+MK;I=K;I3�E,h.n,/1>%63 ,/% N.6=K=R1 � N3+(+*�,=R,K1>& *-5>*+=?MR;

  • � �

    (+MR;IG`1>%'*-=K52b :+;:+;I3c,/1 � Np.0,K1>%'38i��rMK.61>3 3-;I,e#%'MKm[=_,/%Y(�;%63 1>3 ,KD+;C'D La.6=R=%'3 123 ,KD+;:-:+5>; E=KN;)"_.6T�%'M � 52,K;;I,K;:\%'*-,?=R;I,^,K%�:+;H,/;IMK&)1>3+;�eQD+;3+123+C � � � (4.n,K,/;IMK3+= �H�-.63+: ,/D-;MK;I& .01>3+123+C�,/D-MK;5M/.03+:+%'& e�;I1>C'Dc,K=3+C\;3+C\(4.6=R=�,/D+MR%'*+C'D ,/D-;

  • ,/MK.61>3-1>3+C =K;H, 123 . M/.03+:+%'& %'MR:+;3-C MK.0,/; v f � .63+: &)%'&);3+C+f

  • ��

    ��� � ��� � � �� � ��� � �

    �� � �� 0 200 400 600 800 1000Training Epoch

    0.0

    0.1

    0.2

    0.3

    0.4

    0.5

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    Per

    -Pat

    tern

    MSE

    training errorholdout error

    0 200 400 600 800 1000

    Training Epoch

    0.0

    0.1

    0.2

    0.3

    0.4

    0.5

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    Per

    -Pat

    tern

    MSE

    training errorholdout error

    � � � � �� 0 200 400 600 800 1000Training Epoch

    0.0

    0.1

    0.2

    0.3

    0.4

    0.5

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    Per

    -Pat

    tern

    MSE

    training errorholdout error

    0 200 400 600 800 1000

    Training Epoch

    0.0

    0.1

    0.2

    0.3

    0.4

    0.5

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    Per

    -Pat

    tern

    MSE

    training errorholdout error

    �� �� � ��� ���� � � �� ��� �� � � � �� � � � � � � �� � � �� �� � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � ! � "� � � � � "� �� � �� �� � � � �� ��� �$# % � � � � � � ! � � � �& � � � � �

    � � � � � � � � % � �' � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � ��)( � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � *+ � � �� � � � �� � %� � � � �� � � � � �� � � ( � � � �

    � �� � � � � �� , - � � � � % � � � �� � . � � � � � % � � �� � � � � � "� �� � � � � � � �/� � � �� � �� � � � �� � � �� � � �� � � � �� � � � � � �0 0 0 � % � � ��

  • � �

    �?D+;Y3+;H,e�%6MKm[=s1>3 ,KD+; D-1>C'D (+.6=K= NI%'3+:+1d,/12%'3 C';I3+;5db D4.6: .O&)%'MR; :+1 �\NI*+52,,/12&\;�52;p.6MR3+1>3-C+�-,/D-%'*+C'DS,/D+;$1>&)(4.6NH,^e�.6=�C6MK;p.n,/;3 ,KD+;%'=R;3+C). �B*+N:+;N6f j ;_*+=K;I:P,KD+MK;I;g=W,/12& *+5>*-=^N

  • � v

    �F%qe La.6=R= A�1>C6D9Lr.6=K=

    �k.6NI;�� Faces ObjectsStimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0C

    lass

    ific

    atio

    n A

    ccur

    acy

    Faces Objects

    Stimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Cla

    ssif

    icat

    ion

    Acc

    urac

    y

    �#%�%'m�� Books OtherStimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Cla

    ssif

    icat

    ion

    Acc

    urac

    y

    Books Other

    Stimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Cla

    ssif

    icat

    ion

    Acc

    urac

    y

    �a12C'*+MK; u f �qu ir��;%'3 .6NINC6DSLa.6=R=�NI%'3+:+1d,/1>%63 :+1>:Y3-;I,e#%'MKm[[email protected]>5,/%\.6NhD+12;IG6;�C'%`%�:S,/;I=R,�=K;H,�C';I3+;1��p.0,K1>%'3Jf��BMKMR%'MQT4.6MR=�:+;I3+%6,K; .63�� � v�� v �sN

  • � �

    � f�A�-��iJ,KD+;s=/.6&);s=K;H,$%6@ (4.0,K,K;.65a@]MR;&)(+521 � ;I: N.6=K=R1 � ;IM^(�;:-;%'3J�r.03+: N:-;%'3J�.652,KD+%'*+C'D @]%6M TV%`%'m 1>:+;I3[,K1 � NNg%6@=K*-TV%'MR:+1>3+.0,/; E5>;HG';I5 NI5U.6=R=$,KD4.63 12=$A�-� 1>3-@]%'MR& .n,/1>%638�F.63+: ,KD4.0,_,/D-;\@X.6NI; 1>:-;%'3=K(�;;_,/% =K;;YMR;%qe =R(4.0,K1U.65@]MK;IZ[*+;=�,/.6=Kmkf �?D+;Y; ��(�;N 3+;H,e�%6MKm .63+: ,KD+;)3+;p.6MR;=?,/D+.0,Qe�;gD4.pG';$%'3+52b ,/M/.01>3+;I:9%'*-M3+;H,e�%'MRm[=\%'3 @X.6NI;3 ,/D+; 3-;I,e#%'MKm 1>= MR;%'C61>Np.05 ;IG`1>:-;%qe =R(4.0,K1U.65@]MK;IZ[*+;3-@]%6MK&\.0,/12%'38�?.63-: =R*+C'C';I=R,K=PD-% e ,/D-; :+;IG6;%6(+1>3+C T+MK.61>3 NI%'*+52: TV; T+1>.6=K;I:

  • � u

    Faces Books Cups Cans

    Stimulus Type

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Subo

    rdin

    ate

    Cla

    ssif

    icat

    ion

    Acc

    urac

    y

    Full patternsLSF patternsHSF patterns

    �a12C'*+MK; u f ��� i��*+T�%'MR:+1>34.n,/;HE�5>;HG';%'3O.6N

  • � �

    ,/%qe�.6MK:$.?=K(�;52b^5>%qe G�12=K*4.05c.6N3+C

    @X.6NI; .63+:9%'T`tR;INI,�12:+;3 D+12C'D�E�(4.6=K= � 5d,/;IMK;&\.6C';I= %6@[email protected] D+12C'D�E(+.6=K= � 5d,/;%'38�6.63+:\La.6MRm6;IM%qe^E(+.6=K= � 5d,/;3+C_%6@[email protected]%qe =K(4.0,K1U.658@]MR;3+(-*-,/=If?�a1>3+.65>5db'�4"_.6*-,KD+1>;IM%'3 ;I3+N%'39%6@B,/D+;�1>3+(+*�,=K(+.6N3+CQMR;3c,K=r%'3�12,/=F=R%'5>*-,K1>%'3$=K(+.6N=�&\%6MK;�=R;

  • � �

    :+1dG�12=K12%'3S%[email protected]%'M^,K%\,KD+;gC612G';I39,/.6=Km � ,/D+12=Q1>=�;IG`1>:+;I3c,�1>39�a12C'*+MK; u f � �4eQD+;IMK;g,KD+;$3+;I,WEe#%'MKm � =$:-12G`1>=R1>%'3 %0@#5>.6T�%'M�G0.6MR1>;I=�:+M/.6&\.0,K1>Np.05>52b eQ12,/D ,KD+; ,h.0=Km9e#; ,/MK.61>3O12,�,K%Y(V;IMR@]%'MR&9f

    ��*+M?.63+.652b`=K12=�%6@F,KD+;�5>%qe .63+:YD-1>C'D =R(4.0,K1U.65k@]MK;IZ`*-;& *+52*+=�MR;%'3)3+;I,e#%'MRm .63-:),KD+;�3-;p.6MR;.65+@]MK;IZ`*-;3�@]%'MK&\.0,/12%'3s1>3 ,/D-;�MK;I(+MK;I=K;I3[,/.0,/12%'3 12=#NIMK1d,/1>N3+.0,/; E5>;HG';[email protected]'D =R(4.0,K1U.65@]MK;IZ[*+;3-@]%'MR& .n,/1>%638f

    �?D+;S;N=�5>;p.0:+= ,/% ,e#% 34.0,/*-M/.65�,KD+;N: 5>%qe =K(4.n,/1U.05�@]MR;NHE�5>;HG';%'3 ��%6M=K*-TV%'MR:+1>3+.0,/; E5>;HG';I5?1>:+;I3[,K1 � N&)(+5>;)@]%'M�,KD+;Y=R,K1>& *+52*+=�=R;I, e#;Y*+=K;I: 123 ,/D+;I=K;S; ��(�;&);:9TV;g3+% =R*+MK(+MR1>=R;g,/D+.0,�D-1>C'DP=K(4.n,/1U.05F@]MR;

  • � �

    �r.6m6;I3 ,K%'C';H,/D+;IM=�;MR1>Np.05>52b :+;3 . =Rb`=R,K;3+;I: Tcb NI%'&\(�;I,K1dE

    ,/12%'38f �?D-1>= NI%'&)(V;H,/12,K1>%'3 NI%'*+5>:�;p.0=K1>5db TV;PT+1>.6=K;I: Tcb�=R,/MR*+NI,K*+M/.05�.63-: ;MR%'3+&);%63 :+*-;O,/% ,KD+;[email protected], � = 52% e .6N.65a@]MR;1>=W,/12N MK;I(+MK; E=R;%'3-=�.0(+(4.6MR;;I=K12%'3+;=B3+%0,/D+123+Cg&)%'MR;^,/D4.63\.63\%'*-,/521>;IMNp.05a;IG`12:+;

  • � �

    ��=^e#;_=R,/.0,/;I:9123 ,/D+;�123[,KMK%`:+*+NH,/1>%63 ,/%s,/D-1>=^NhD4.0(-,/;IM3 .YD+%'&)%'C';I3+;;;

  • @X.6NI;1>=W,/12Np.65252b � .6=^%6(V;IM/.0,K1>%'34.05>1��I;;r,/;=83+%0,

    ,/D-;�&)%'=R,#:+1>MR;N?(+MR%�NI;3+C �],/D-;.6:-G0.63c,/.6C'; @]%'M8eQD+%65>;;HG';I5aMK;IN3+NI5>*+:+123+C "_MR;3 ,/D-;)e�.pb NhD-1>5>:-MK;3-34.0,/;I52bcE=R(V;INNp.05>52b TV;I3+; � N1d@];6f

    ��%0,/; ,/D+.0,�e#;\.0MK; 3+%0,_.6MKC6*+1>3+C\,/D4.0,�@X.0N=I�k,KD+;$; ��(V;IMR,�%6M�&)%�:-*+5>;�=R(V;IN1��I1>3+Cs@]%'[email protected];�MK;IN3-C�,/D4.n,5>%`Np.05>1��I;3 ,KD+; 3+;I,e#%'MRm`=$Np.0*+=K; MK;I5>1>.6T+5>;g:+%'*+T-5>;s:+12=K=K%`N.0,/12%'3+=T�;I,e#;3+CSNI%'&\(�;I,K12,K12G';�N=�,K%P=W,/*+:�b @]*+3+NH,/1>%634.65a=R(V;IN.65>1��p.nE

  • � �

    ,/12%'3 1>3 @X.6N1��p.0,K1>%'3

    .63+:P5>%`Np.05>1��%634.65J&)%`:+;Np.05>52b(+5>.6*+=K12T+5>;0f ��=9.63+%6,KD+;3-NN:-;&)1>5>.6M,/;INhD+3+12Z`*-;

  • � ��������� �

    � � � ����� � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � �� � �������

    � ����� � � ��������� � ����� ���

    �3S,/D+12=?NhD4.6(-,K;1>NI12,K52b ;I3+N& *-5>*+=Q:+12=R,/123+NI,K12G6;3Y79 _ �[email protected];�=R(4.6NI;6� � u �(-MK%ntR;INI,/12%'3+=#%6@J,K;

  • � v

    � ��� � � � �

    �� ���

    `,K*+:-b`1>3+Cs,KD+;_;%'3Y&);3+C =R*+T`tR;

  • � �

    &);3 ,/D+12=

    NhD4.6(�,/;12&\1d,s:+1>=RN1>NI12,K52b =R,K%'MK;OMK;16,KD+;Ib_=W,/*+:-b6f ��*-=K;Ibg.63-:g��*+3+3+12N12;5U.0M &\%6MK(+D @X.0&\125>1U.0MK12,b$123[G6;%63 eQ12,KD+%'*-,�(V%'=R12,K1>3+C_,/D4.n,,/D-;\=R1>&)1>5U.0M�(4.6MR;NI12,/5dbOT-5>;3+C ,e#%S%6@,/D-;M ; ��;=),/% .6:+:-12,/12%'34.65Q12& .6C6;HET+.6=K;I: @X.6NMR52b N%'38f��?D+;=K*-T`tR;;I:�123 M/.6NI;9.03+: ; �`,/;I3[,\%6@�@X.6N.65�D4.01>M;?,/;I&\(+5>.0,/;�N%'3s,K;

  • � u

    �a12C'*+MK; � f � iB�?D+MK;I;g3+%6MK&\.65>1��;I=B%6@�,/D+;?3+%6MK&\.65>1��&);%634.65'=RNp.6521>3+C�.6(+(-MK%c.6NhDg,/%�&\%`:+;%'*+=F(+D-;&);%634.65+=RNp.6521>3+Cg%'3 ,/D-;�=K12& E1>5>.6MK1d,bs&\.0,/MR1 �s@]%'M �qv'v %6@�,/D+;�@X.6N

  • � �

    �'� ���� #%�$&(��� ���!������� � � G'%'3 :+;IMg7O.65>=RT+*+MRC9.03+: N%'3 =Rb`=R,K;& *-5>*+=�.03+: MK;

  • � �

    �?D[*+=).65>52%qeQ1>3+CO.6:4.6(-,K12G6; e�;I1>C'Dc,/=s@]%'Mg,/D+;P7O _ MR;;6�=R1>3+NI;,/D-; MR;3+C &)%�:+;I5�%'3+5db *+=R;;,/%�.05>5>%qe .6:4.6(�,/12G6; e#;=�e#%'*+52: T�; � ,R,/1>3-C �'u (+.6M/.6&);I,K;3c,/=If �?D[*+=*+=I�V123+=R,K;p.6: %6@ .\=K*+&)&\;I: N5F%6@,/D-;

    ; ��;I&\(+5>.6MK=123)&);5>.6MK1d,b\,K%),KD+;�; ��;=�.6T�%qG';s. 3-%'1>=Wb9NIMK1d,/;%'3Jf��?D-; &\%`:+;I5�D+.6=�. =R1>&)1>5U.0MK12,b\=KN123+C (+.6M/.6&);I,K;: @]*+3-NI,/12%'38f� �*+;�,/% =K(4.6NI; 5>12&\1d,h.0,K1>%'3-==^%6@�,/D-;$&)%`:+;& -.6&sE(+52;g@]M/.0&\;He�%'MRmk�JT+*-,�%'3+5dbPeQD-;3c,/MR%�:+*-N3-CS,KD+; (-MK%6,K%6,b`(V;\(+MK%0E(�%'MR,K1>%'34.05a,/%Y,/D-;\=R1>&)1>5U.0MK12,bP%6@ ,/D-;\(4.0MK;5212,b�:-;3+C �R%'5>:��_,K% ._(+MK%6TV;�.6MK;Q,/D-;==K*[email protected];�.0,B,KD+;�(V%'123c,N%'3 �X5>12C'Dc,/123+C NhD4.63+C';I=

  • � �

    b';H,B.652=K%�(+MK%qG`1>:-;#=R%'&\; 5>;HG';I5`%0@4:+1>=RN&)1>34.0,K1>%'3�=K*+(+(�%'MW, �]1lf ;6f ;IG6;5>5T�; NI%'3+=R,KMK*+NH,/;I: �Hf9��@?e�;Y.0=K=K*-&\; . "_.6*+=K=R1U.63 &\1���,K*+MK;&)%�:+;I5l�B123 eQD+1>NhD ,/D-;Y:+;5d,�@]MK%6& "_.6*+=K=R1U.63 �WT+5>%'T-= � N=RD+%'(8�

    ��� � ���Hfj ; Np.03 @]%'MR& *+5U.n,/;s,/D+;),h.6=Rm %6@^(+MR;3+CP,/D+;\D`*-& .63 =K*+T[tR;:-,KD+=�%6@a,/D+; m0;NH,/12%'38f$A�%qe#;IG';IM=R% e^.03[,�,K%&)1>3+12&\1��3c,/%Y,KD+; (+MK123+N;I=�*+3+:+;IMK5db�123+CY,/D+; D[*+&\.63 :4.0,/.-fs��@#,KD+; (+MK12%'MK=_.03+: eQ12:-,/D-=e#;: NI%'3+=R,/.63c,p��e#; e�%'*-5>: D4.pG';). =K12&\(-5>;g,e#%S(4.6MK.6&\;H,/;IM�&\%`:+;I5a(+MR;: � ,K%\.s,/;I=R,�=R,K1>& *-5>*+= � i

    � � ��� � ������

    � � � ��� ! � ���� �eQD+;IMK; � @]%'5>:+=8,K%'C';H,/D+;IMF,KD+;B*+3+1d@]%'MK& (+MK12%'MF.63+:_3+%6MK&\.65>1��p.0,K1>%'3�N.0,/12%'3 %0@^,/D+; "$.0*+=K=R1U.63 m6;IMK3+;I5>=C63+%'MK;s,KD+;\NI%'3+=W,h.63c,/=I�

    D+%qe#;IG';IM=�;5db9,KD+; =/.6&);s.6=�,KD+; G';IMK=R1>%'3 %6@,/D+;)"$�?7 :+;5>5B=RD+%qe_�a,/D-1>=_&\%`:+;I5 N.6MK1d,b :4.0,h.s1239.03[b %6@a%6*+M?MK;I(+MK;I=K;;I: ; ��;%'3 D4.6=�,e#% 1>3�E,/*-12,/1dG'; &)%6,K12G0.0,/12%'3+=If �a1>MR=R,p� eQD-;m0;

  • ���

    MK;I5U. ��;I: � eQ1>:+;IM � :+1>=RN&)1>34.0,K1>%'3gTV%6*+3+:4.6MR1>;I=,KD4.63 @X.6N

  • 79%�:-;C'Dc,/= L � (+MR%ntR;%'3�T-*+1>5d,F1>3c,/%?,/D-;#&)%�:-;&)(V%'MW,h.63c,�,KD4.63g.65>52% eQ123+C^,/D-;m6;IMK3+;I5�@]*-3+NI,K1>%'3s,/%_G0.6MRb�eQ12,/D :+12=R,K1>3+NH,/12G6;=R%_%6@83+%0,/;Q1>= ,KD4.0,,/D+;�L � (+MR%ntR;=�N

  • � �

    "$�?7 �'7O _ �1>& -.6&)(+52;��'7O _ 7 7O�$7 �'7O _

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    P(o

    ld)

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    P(o

    ld)

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    P(o

    ld)

    "g�?7 �67O _ ��e?,/= �12& �.6&\(-5>;��67O _ ��e?,/= 7O7 �_7 �'7O _ ��e?,K=

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    P(o

    ld)

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6A

    vera

    ge P

    (old

    )

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    P(o

    ld)

    "$�?7 �6L � �1>& -.6&)(+52;��6L � 7 7 �_7 �0L#�

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    P(o

    ld)

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    P(o

    ld)

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    P(o

    ld)

    "$�?7 �'"_.6T�%'M �12& -.0&\(+52;��'"_.6T�%'M 7 7O�$7 �'"$.0TV%'M

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    P(o

    ld)

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    P(o

    ld)

    DP SM T SP DM D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    Ave

    rage

    P(o

    ld)

    ActualPredicted

    �a12C'*+MK; � f u ir��G6;.6MQ&\%'MR(+D+=��� � ��%'3�E�(4.6MK;I3c,�,h.6MRC';I,K=��a-L �

    �12&\125U.6M (4.6MR;&)1>5U.0M &)%'MR(+D+=��+ � �12=R,KM/.6NH,/%'MR=

  • � �

    � � � � � � � � � ��� ��

    �?D+;QMK;I=K*+5d,/=B@]%'M ,KD+;?&\1��`,/*+MR;?&\%`:+;: ,K;: .0NI,/*+.65>5db�T�;�1>3-N;I&\=QeQ12,KDO,/D-;�e�%6MKmP(+MK;I=K;3-NI,/1dG';I3+;%6M�; ��(V%'=R*+MK; .63+:9,KD+;3-NI,/1dG';I3+;1>m0;_;C6;%'3+=Q%'M�"_.6T�%'M � 5dE

    ,/;IMQMK;=W,h.63-N

  • � v

    MK;I=K;I3[,/.0,/12%'3 �X%'Ms. MR;3�@]%'MK&\.0,/12%'3�E�(+MK%`N

  • � ��������� �

    � � � ����� � � � � � � � � � ����� � � � ��� � � �����

    � � � � � � ����� � � � � � ��� � �� � �������

    �?D+;IMK; .0MK;_,e�% NI%'&)(V;H,/1>3-C),KD+;%'3 Np.n,/;;=KNIMK12&\1234.0,/12%'3 %6@J3+;p.0MKTcb)(4.61>MR=%6@8; �-(-MK;3-;;%6C'1>N3+.0,/12%'38�4.63-:OMK;IN.61>3Y&\.63cb %0@�,KD+;�=K;I;3+C652b\NN38f

    � �

  • � u

    � ��� �����

    ���������������

    A�%qe :+% e�; =R;%63+= 1>3 @X.0N%'3PTV;H,e�;I;3+;I: D+1>=�,/D-;%'3-=KD+12( eQ1d,/D @X.6N.65B; ��(+MR;%'3-= � �Bm[& .038� ��� ��� . �Hf � �^.6=R1>N��9;=I�n(-D[b`=R1>%'52%'C6b'�0.6(�E

    (+MK.61>=K.65 &);=K&)=N5db5>;%'=R=�%0@B. =K1>C63+1 � N

  • � �

    1>3-=K1>:-;�,/D+;�(�;12m6;I52b\%�NINN�;NC'34.05>=3-N*-:+1>3+C. =R;I,\%6@�@X.6NI1U.65?&�*+=KNI5>;P&\%qG';I&\;I3c,/= .03+: T�%�:�b &\%qG';I&\;I3c,/= �];6f C+f .6(+(+MR%c.6NhD %'M)eQ1d,/D�E:+MK.qe�.65 �Hf �?D+;�=K1>C634.65>=#.6MR;�3+%6,�;3PN3ONI1>MRN%63 � =,/D-;=R,K1>3+NH,p�-.63+:Y;p.0NhD9;I&\%6,K1>%'3)@X.6&)1>52b 12=?.6N EN;I:gTcb�.�=K&\.6525'=K;H, %6@4:-1>=R,K1>3+NH,/1dG'; =K1>C634.65>= � @X.6N.65c; ��(+MR;%'3-= �H�'e#;�&)1>C6D[,�; �-(�;NI=^%6@:+12=KN

  • � �

    � 3+:\12, ;p.0=K1>;IMB,/%$:+1>=W,/1>3-C'*+1>=RD\T�;I,e#;& *+521-,/D-;�=K.6&\;Q:+12=R,/.63+N3+C\N%63 �H�c%'M?(�;3\eQD-1>NhD =W,/1>&�*+5>*+= �R� � 1>= =KD+%qeQ38�-=R,/12& *+52*+= � � �1>=B=RD+%qeQ38�[,/D+;I3\;I12,/D-;1-.6MK;?3-;p.6M ,KD+;?Np.0,K;123+C�T�;%6M

  • � �

    @X.6NI;^(4.612MK= ; �-D-1>T+1d,/;1>[email protected]=?:-1>:S3+%6,&)12,/;I:g,K%�5>%qe^E52;IG';I5-(�;;�@]%'M�@X.6N.65�; ��(+MK;I=K=R1>%'3 MK;IN*+:-;&);%63 %6@Q(+MR;MK= =R,KM/.6:-:+5>123+C�,/D-;� v � Np.0,K;&)1>3+.0,/;I: ,/D4.63 ,/D-%'=K;)N

  • ��

    � � % %( � � � � "� � � � � � � ( � �� %� � �� � � � � � �� � � + � �� � � �

    * � ,

    �� � � �0 � �0 � �0 � �0 � �0 � � � � � � � �

    � � % %� � � � � �0 � �0 � �0 � �0 � �0 � � � � � ��

    *� ,

    �� �� � �� ��� * � , - � ! % � � %� � � � � ( %� � � � %� � � �� � � � � " �� � � �� � !� � � � � � � �� � � � �� � � � "� � "� � � � � � �� � � � - � ! � � � ���� � � �� � � � �� � �� � � � " �� � � � � .� � * � � � � , * - � ! � � � �� �� � � � � ��� � � �� , � * � , � � � % � � "� � ! "� � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � % %� � � � �� � � � � � �� � � �� � � � � � "� � ! � � � � � � � � % � �� � � %� � � � � ( % � ��

  • � ,/NI%�� .63+:O7O.6C';I; � = � ��� �'u ��(+MK%qG6%�N3 @X.6N.65�; ��(+MR;%63 MK;IN1d,[email protected];1d,bg&)%'MR(+D+=;Q�Bm[& .03\.03+:�4MK12;&\.6C'; EZ[*4.65212,bg&\%6MK(+D)=K;IZ`*-;: =R;& *-52,h.03+;3+C�T�;I,e#;=RN%'3�,h.6=Rm�f���*-,�%'3_,/D+;BeQD+%65>;6�q,KD+;#MR;N1d,/;

  • � �

    ,/D-;Ib .0MK; &\.6m[1>3+C . (+*+MK;I52b9(V;IMKNI;&)1>3+.0,/12%'3 �XLr;HG`, �1>3-CS.63+: A�.6MR34.6:8� ��� � �r"_%'52:+=R,K%'3+;0� u6v'v'v �r"�%'5>:-=R,/%63+;s;I,g.65 f2� u6v6v�� �Hf �a1>3+:-1>3+C'=

    %6@��^L ; �J;INI,/= 123 @X.6N.65#; ��(+MK;I=K=K12%'3�=R,/12& *+521#MK.61>=R; ,/D+;Y(�%'=K=R1>T+125>1d,b ,/D4.0, (�;%qeQ123+Cs*+( %'3P,/D+;$e�%6MKmS%6@BD+12=�.0:-G`1>=K%6M � j %`%�:�e�%'MW,/D8�

    ��� ��� �$@]%'*+3-: ,KD4.0, ;I&\%6,K1>%'3 Np.0,K;3-C'=s.63+: =R*+T`tR;=RC'*+=W,/;%'3 .6=gN5>12(+=K;eQD+%'=R;�&\. tR%'M�. ��1>=Qe�.6=�(+52;p.6=K.63c,/3+;I=K=�G�=IfV*-3+(+5>;%'3 �]; ��;1 � ;=K;$.63-:9:+12=KC'*-=R,�; ��(+MR;%'3-= �Hf79%'MR;OMR;

  • � �

    @X.6NI1U.65F; ��(+MR;%63+=�&)1>C'Dc,�D4.pG';s. &);(O%0@ � f v � �qv6v � ��1>39%'3+;g(4.6MR,K1>NI*+5U.6MQN;12m6; �NhD+52%'=KT�;;3+:-;N);;I=_%�NIN3-CO.0,g�Bm[& .03 � =$(+MR%6,/%6,b`(+12Np.65; ��(+MR;%63+=&);%'3+.650=RNp.6521>3+C�� =K;I;^�a12C'*+MK;

    � f � � @]%'MQ.63Y; �-.6&\(-5>; ��(�;%`Nhm (-MK%'(�%'=K;I:�,KD4.0, @X.6NI1U.65^; ��(+MK;I=K=K12%'3 123[,K;%'3 � MR=R,)1>3cG'%652G';I=.6(+(-M/.612=K1>3-C ,/D+;s; ��(+MK;I=K=K12%'3 1>3 ,/;IMK&)=�%6@ (+5>;%634.65>5db�NhD+%`%'=R;^.�5>.6TV;I5c@]%'M�,KD+;�; ��(+MK;I=K=K12%'38f�4%'525>%qeQ1>3+C��NhD-5>%'=RTV;IMKC � ��� � u � �n,KD+;Ib(+MR%'(V%6=K;

  • v

    � ������� � ����� ��& ��� ��� ��� ������� � � � ����� � � � � ������!�-� � �!� &��� %'*+3-Cs;I,?.05lf � ��� � ��=R;I,?%6*-,^,/%g@]*+MR,KD+;%'=RTV;IMKC � =9%6M9�Q*+=R=K;C'*+MR; � f � � �X. ��.6:-;3c,%6@_. &\%6MK(+D TV;H,e�;I;3+;I=K= .03+: @];%'3\.65>%63+C_&\%'MR(+D ,/M/.03+=K1d,/1>%63+=��[%'3+;Qe#%'*+5>:\; ��(�;%'3-=T�;I,e#;C'Dc,�; ��(V;INI,$Np.0,K;NhD =R*+T`tR;&)1>3+.0,/;)TV;H,e�;I;3 (+MR;IG`1>%6*+==R,/*-:+1>;I= �X�B,KN& *+521#e#;:+;I3[,K1 � NNI;^(+MR%�NI;T+52; ,/M/.03+=K1d,/1>%63+=F.6MK;MR;3c,/;I:g123g�r1>C'*+MR; � f u fr�3$T�%6,/D_; ��(�;&);

  • &)%'MK(+D_,/MK.63+=R12,/12%'38� =K*-T`tR;

  • u

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    % id

    enti

    fica

    tion Happiness

    SurpriseFearSadness (Maudlin)DisgustAnger

    H S F M D A H10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90* � ,

    0

    1000

    2000

    3000

    4000

    Hum

    an R

    T (

    mill

    isec

    onds

    )

    HappinessSurpriseFearSadness (Maudlin)DisgustAnger

    H S F M D A H10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90*� ,

    �� �� � �� �� � � �� � � � � � � � �� � � " �� � � � � � �� � � * � � � � , - % � � � ! � �� ��� * � , � � ! � � � � � % � � � � � * � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �# �� ("� � � � �� � � � � � � , � � �� !� � % � � � & �� � � �� � � % %( � � �� %� � �� � � � �� %� � � � � � � "� � � � � � "� � � � � �� � � �� � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �� � �

    � � � � ( � � �� � � � ( � � � % %( � - � � ( � � � � ��� � � � � �� � �� � � � � � � � % � � � � � ( � � � �� � � ( � *� , �� � % � � � � � � ! � � "� � � � � � � ! �� � � � ��� � � � �� �� � % � � � � � � ! � � � � � � � � � � �� �� � � �� �( ��� � � � �� � � � "� � !� � � %� � � � � ( % � � * � � �� ��� � � �)( � � �� � " � � % � � �� � ��

    � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � �� � � , �

  • �3 ����(�;3+.0,/;)(4.612MK=�%0@�=W,/12& *+5>1 .652%'3+CO,KD+;Y=K1�� ,KM/.63-=K12,K1>%'3-= A�.0(+(+1>3-;3 TV;H,e�;I;3 �r1>C'*+MR; � f � f$�?D+; & .01>3 � 3-:+1>3+CY%0@ ,KD+;s; ��(�;&);C'3-1 � ENp.03[,K52bST�;I,R,/;=RN&)1>34.0,K1>%'3 (V;IMR@]%'MR& .63-N

  • H S F M D A H9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    50

    60

    70

    80

    90

    hum

    an %

    cor

    rect

    AB

    X

    �� �� � �� �� �� � � �� � � " �� � � � � � �� � � * � � � � , - % � � � ! � �� � "� � � � � � � & � � �� � � � * � �� , � � � � � !� � � � � � � � � � �� - � � % � � ��

    � � %� � �� �� � � � � % � � � �� � � � "� � ! � � ��� � � � � � � � � �)( � � � � � !� � � � � � � � � �� � � � �� � � � �� � � � � !� � % � �� � ! � �� � � �� # � � ��� � � � � � � �� � � � �� � % � � � � " �� � ! � �� �� � � � � � � � ! %� � � ��� � � � �0 � �0 � �� � � � � � � � � ��� � � � "� � ! � � � �� � �� � � � � � �� � � �� � � � �

    � ! % � � � �� � � " � �0 � � � � � �� � �0 � � � � � � � � !� � % � ��� � � �0 � � � � � �� � �0 � � � � � � � � !� � % �� � � � � � !� � � � � � � �� � �� �� � � �� �)(

    � � � � � � �� � � � �� %� � � � � ( % � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ( � � � �� � � � � ��

  • �a1234.65>5db'�[1>3 � ��(�;&);:�(+MR;&);3P.65258%6@�,/D+;I=K;�=R;;He ,/D-;MK;IN%'3 MK;IN.6T+5>;�:4.0,/.-f

  • ��

    � ������� � �� � &(� &��������� � � �!� ����� �) ) �� "����� � � ����!�������� ���! +�������&(����La.0:+C';I,R,�.03+:9NI%'5>52;p.6C6*+;%'3(�;3 =R%'&);�%6@�,KD+;�MK;I=K*+5d,/=?%'3 Np.0,K;N%'3 � �^.65>:+;IM?;I,�.65 f2� u0v'v'v � f�8b'%'3-=3-C�l79 _ ��MR;IG';;I: =K12&\125U.6M?*+3-:+;3+C\,e�%0E�:+1>&);%634.65FN*+=R1>%'3 ,KD4.0,�,KD+; D+1>C'D`E5>;HG';I5aN; �ONm6;g�NhD-5>%'=RTV;IMKC\.63+:9��*+=R=K;I5>5F& .pbY123S(4.6MR,�MR;��4;INI,�=K1>&)1>5>.6MK1d,b\.0,Q5>%qe5>;HG';I5>=Q1>3 ,KD+;�G�12=K*4.05�=Rb`=R,K;

  • 3+1d,/1>%638fF�?D+;^1>:-;p.�%0@4,/D+;I1>M�=Rb`=R,K;34.05>52b�(+MR%'(V%6=K;3+C?T�;I,e#;%63 � ,/D+; (+1���;1d,b�MK;I:+*+NH,/1>%638�'(+MR%�:+*-N3-C�=K;I(4.6M/.n,/;^52% e^E�:+1>&);%634.65c:+; E=KNIMK12(-,/12%'3+=�%0@?,/D+; @X.0N= T4.0=K;= %6@@X.6NI1U.65 ; ��(+MK;I=K=K12%'3 MR;%63 T�;3 ,/%PD+1>3c,_,/D+.0,_=K*+T[tR;N

  • � �����2�� �����

    � � � �#� �2��� � ������ �����

    � � �(� � �� � � � �����

    � � � � &!�.��� �����

    � � / �.�

    �� � � � ����&

    � ������

    � � ����� ��-��� � � � -� �2&+��� ����� � � � �2-* � � &����(� �2-

    ���

    �a1>C6*+MK; � f � i 7P%�:+;I5��NhD+;I& .0,K1>N0f

    1>3-C .63+: ,KD+; =W,h.0,K1>=W,/1>NC'*+MR; � f � � �,/D-;P=Wb`=R,/;I& *-=K;1�;%qb';I: 123 & .63cb (-=Rb`NhD+%'52%'C'1>N

  • u � v � u��cu &\.63[*4.65252bS.05>1>C63+;C6*+MK; � f � �X. �Hf\�?D+;=R,KMK%'3-C .6C'MK;I;

  • �'v

    �� �� � �� �� - � ! % �� � � � � � � �� � � �� � � � � � � � * � �� � � � � � % � � , � ! % � � � �� � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���� � � "� � � "� � � � � � � � �

    � � �� � � �� � � � "� �� � � �� � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �

  • ���

    �?D+; � MK=R,^5U.pb';IM�%6@�,KD+;�&)%�:+;I5k1>=^.g=K;I,^%6@F3+;%'3=Rb`=W,/;C'Dc,�%'MK12;%'3-=: .03+: � v � 52,K;.pb';=_,/M/.01>3+;I: ,/%P=K12&\(-52bMK;I(+MK%`:+*+NI;�1d,/= 1>3+(+*�,#%63 12,K=#%6*-,/(+*�,#,KD+MK%'*-C'D .$34.6MKMR%qe NhD4.63+3-;.6*+=R1>T+52;$&);p.03+=�%0@B:+1>&);%634.65>1d,b MR;3-CA�;IT+T+1>.63O52;p.6MR3+1>3+C)MK*-5>;=�3+;I,e#%'MRm � =e#;C6D[,K=s:+1>MR;N3+NI1>(4.65 N=g5U.pb';IMT4.6=R;;%'3$%'3 L ������f��,#1>=1>&)(V%6MR,h.03[,a,/%$3+%6,/;Q,/D+.0,,/D+;�3[*+& T�;%qe^E:+12&\;I3+=K12%'34.65�%'T`tR;INI,WE5>;HG';I5�MK;I(+MK;I=K;I3[,/.0,/12%'3 1>=g=K(�;;I: �[email protected]@];%'MQ,/;I&\(�%'MK.65FN

  • �cu

    � L�;=Q5>.qb6;;I3[,�&\;H,/D+%`:+= @]%'M#NI%�:`E

    1>3-C . =K;H, %0@�=W,/1>&�*+5>1 �B%6,/D+;IM\&);I,KD+%`:+= e�%6*+5>:�(+MK%6T4.6T+5db .65>=R% e�%'MRmkf �4%'M ,/D-;9NI*+MKMR;;INI,K12G';I52b � ��%'C'%6,KD+;I,K1>= .63-: �D-;3[T�;.6MKC';3[*+& T�;%'3-= ,KD4.0,#=K*+T`tR;INI,K=^& .0m6;�%'3 ,/D-;:4.0,/.-f j ;_,K;= N%63 5U.pb';IMB1>=B.03); �`,/MK;I&\;I52b�=K1>&)(+521>=R,K1>N &\%`:+;I5-%6@�D[*+&\.63Np.n,/;%'3+C�.6=r12,�1>=�=K*��)NI1>;123+;p.6M�N

  • � �

    j ;?=KD+%'*-5>: .652=K%�(�%'1>3c,a%'*-, ,KD4.0, ,KD+;?=Rb`=R,K;&)(V%'MW,h.63c,.6=R(V;INI,/=?%0@�G`12=K*4.65V(+MK%`N3+Cs123 ,/D+;�T-M/.61238��=R*+NhD9.6=^;Ib6;�&\%qG6;3cG0.6MR1U.63+NI;6fQ�?D+;I=K; NI%'&\(-5>1>N5>;I: T�;%'MK.65J; ��(V;IMK1>&);&\.0,/12%'3 %6@r(+MK%`N3+C\.0,Q,/D+;_NI%'&\(-*-,h.0,K1>%'3+.65V52;IG6;3 ,KD+;�G�12=K*4.05�=Rb`=R,K;%'3YMR;3+C,/D-;�&)%�:+;I5 � =#(-MK;NI,K1>%'3-= ,K% D[*+& .03 :4.0,/.g@]MK%6& 1>:+;I3[,K1>N3c,/;IMK(+MR;I, � � u �s,KD4.0,)eQD+;NH,�D[*+& .03 :+1>=RN%'3P.6T+125dE12,b � � � �B,/D4.0,�,/D+;�&)%`:+;&)1>5U.0MK52b�=K;I3+=K1d,/12G6;�,/%�&\1��-;I:�E123 ; �-(-MK;3+C�.634.65db�=R1>=�(+MK%`:+*+NI;&)1>5>.6M;%'34.05J=K12&\125U.6MR12,b =W,/MK*-NI,/*-MK;_@]MK%'&�,/D+;_&)%�:+;I5�.63+:PD[*+&\.63S:4.0,h.�f

    � ��� � � ���� ��

    � ��� ��� � �� ����-������ �) � ����!� ��� � ��� � ��� �����)*�� � ���� +��?D+;�NI%'3+3+;INI,K1>%'3+=#1>3),/D+;�&\%`:+;.qb6;;:+;s@]MR%'& ,KD+;\; ��(+MK;I=K=K12%'3&)%'=R,Q.0C'MK;I;

  • � �

    5U.0TV;I5>;N.6TV;I5>;I:\1d, �W=K*+MR(+MK12=K;: �WD4.6(+(cb'f � �?D[*+=I��,/D+;IMK;s1>=�3+%Y1>3-@]%6MK&\.0,/12%'39123O,/D-; ,/M/.01>3�E

    1>3-C =R1>C'3+.65?N%6*+=K5dbg*-3+=K;I;3+=R1>C'Dc,3-C,/D-;�G0.652*+;Q%6@8,/D-;�(+1���;;I&\;I3[,e#;3+:+12Np.0,K;�,/D+;_@];p.nE

    � "�0*+�,��#%��1*���.���� �P������0*2�E*+�07F���%�,�)(�� S?7=�0* ���)���5�0(��E*>�,�>��( :���0808�������� #%�&��( ��. ����)�����.�.�� ;0H����E�7=����*�� ;������E�).��'*�*���.���� ;������E�P���)3��E*�� H������E�.���'�)��.�.���������E�)�0��?��.�3��.Q����������E:

  • � �

    ����(+MK;I=K=R1>%'3 ��;I,e#%'MRm�� ��%'MKMR;=K; �qv'v f v � �cu f � � �12=KC'*+=W, �qv'v f v � �cu f � �

    ��3+C';T-*-,/12%'3 %6@#(4.6MR,K;1>(-=NhD ,/D-;�;Hb';;

  • � �

    � � % %� � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �� %� � � � � � � � ��

    �� �� � �� � � + � � �� � � � � %� � �� �� � � � � � � " � � � "� � � � � %� � � �� � �� �� % � � �� � % %� � � ! � � � � � � "� � � � %� � ! � � � � % �� # �� � � �� � ! � � � �"� � � � � "� � � � � %� � � �� � � � � � � � ( � � � � � � ! � � �� � � � �� ! � � % %� � � ! � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � "� � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � ��

    � � � �� %� � � � � �� � � � � � � �� � �� "� � � �� � ��

  • � ��� � � � �� ����-������ �� +� &(������-�� +��� ����- +���&(���� � � &(�

    �;HG';;I=QD4.pG';$MK;

  • � �

    eQD+12NhD e#;?&)%�:+;I5�MR;;HG';I5lf �?D4.n,#12=5212,bg%6@ v f � @]%'MD4.6(+(+123+;&);C'*+MR; � f � f �?D+;)MK;%'*+=Ii .6=g.S=K;1.6(+(-MK%c.6NhD-;&);

  • ��

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    % id

    enti

    fica

    tion Happiness

    SurpriseFearSadness (Maudlin)DisgustAnger

    H S F M D A H10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90* � ,

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    % id

    enti

    fica

    tion Happiness

    SurpriseFearSadness (Maudlin)DisgustAnger

    H S F M D A H10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90*� ,

    �� �� � �� �� �� � � � # �� � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � " !� � % � �� � ! � �� � * � , � � ! � � � � � % � � � � � * �� � � � � � �� � � � � � , � � �� !� � % �

    �� & � � � � �� �� % %( � � �� %� � � � � � � �� %� � � � � � � "� � � � � � "� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � ( � � �� � � � ( � � � % %( * �

    � �� ��� � � �)( � � �� � " � � % � � �� � �� � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � �� � � , � *� , � � � � �� � � �� � � � � � �� � � � � � � � �� � ! � � � � � � � � � �� � � � �� � �

    � � � � � � � � � � � % � � � � � � � " � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � �� � � � � � �� % �� �� ( � � � � �� � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � �� � � � �

    � �� % �� �� � � � !� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � * � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � , � "�� � 0 � � � � ��� � � � � � � ! � � � �� � � � ��

  • �'v

    0

    1000

    2000

    3000

    4000H

    uman

    RT

    (m

    illis

    econ

    ds)

    HappinessSurpriseFearSadness (Maudlin)DisgustAnger

    H S F M D A H10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90* � ,

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    mod

    el R

    T

    HappinessSurpriseFearSadness (Maudlin)DisgustAnger

    H S F M D A H10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90 10 30 50 70 90*� ,

    �� �� � �� �� �� � % � � � � � � ! � � � � "� � � � # �� � � � � � �� � � � � � � �� * � , � � ! � � � � � % � � �� � � ! � � "� � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � �� � � � ��� �� � �� � * � , � � � %� � � � � � "� � ! �� � � � � � �� * � � � � , � * � , � � � � � � � � � � � " � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � �� ( !� � � � "� � � � � �� ! � !� � % �� � � � ��� � � � ��

  • ���

    �?D+;&)%�:+;I5c.652=K%Q(+MK%qG`1>:-;3+=R1>C'Dc,�123c,/%QD[*+& .03$:-1>=KNIMK12&\1234.0,/12%'3�T�;=KNIMK12&\1234.0,/;�@X.6NI;:+;=�,K%

    1>&\.6C'123+;�,KD4.0,,/D+;Q&)%�:-;==RD+%qeQ3 %'3+;[email protected];�.n,�.�,/12&\;Q.03+: =W,/%'MR;5>.6MK1d,b'�[.63-: ,/D+;I3Y*+=K; � &\123`*-=#,/D-1>=�3[*+&�TV;IM?.6=^. &);p.0=K*+MR;%6@a:+1>=RN1d,b'fB��3P1>3c,K;3+C .6=K(�;;IG6;3-C9NI%'MKMR;%63+= .0,�;p.6NhD (+MR%�NI;3-C 5>;IG6;3+C ,KD4.0,s,/D-;; ��(+5>.634.0,K%'MRb (�%qe�;IM %6@�,/D+;9&\%`:+;I5?MK;

  • �cu

    1>3-C+f �3P=K*+NhD9:+%'&\.61>3+=I��e#;_; ��(V;INI,�,/D4.n,Q:+1>=RN%'3 e�%6*+5>:PTV;�T�;3+;I:P123S.5>;

  • � �

    H S F M D A H9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    50

    60

    70

    80

    90

    hum

    an %

    cor

    rect

    AB

    X

    �X. �

    H S F M D A H9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    3070

    5050

    7030

    9010

    1090

    0.0

    0.1

    0.2

    0.3

    obje

    ct le

    vel d

    iscr

    imin

    atio

    n

    �XT �

    �a12C'*+MK; � f � i �1>=RN&)1>34.0,K1>%'3s%0@F&\%'MR(+D =W,/1>&�*+5>1 f �X. �#L�;&); =K*+T[tR;3+CY&)%'MK(-D=R,K1>& *-5>1lf��?D-;��+E�. ��1>=�5U.0TV;I5>=F,/%�,KD+;^5>;H@ , .03+: MK12C'Dc, %6@+;p.6NhDs(�%'1>3c,a=KD+%qe eQD+1>NhD ,e#%�=R,K1>& *-5>1e#;C'D-52b N

  • � �

    90 70 50

    Percent mixing

    -0.5

    0.0

    0.5

    1.0

    1.5

    Scor

    e

    Far prototype (model)Unrelated expressions (model)Far prototype (human)Unrelated expressions (human)

    �a12C'*+MK; � f �pv ir��T+1>5212,b$,/%_:+;H,/;

  • � �

    .63+:P; ��(+MR;%63�EMR;

  • � �

    Human MDS Configuration

    Happiness

    Surprise

    Fear

    Sadness

    Anger

    Disgust

    Network MDS Configuration

    Happiness

    Surprise

    Fear

    Sadness

    Anger

    Disgust

    * � , *� ,

    �� �� � �� ���� � � �� � � � ! � � �� � � � � � � �� � � " � � ! � � � �� �� � �� � � � � � % � � �� � � � � � � � �� !� �� � � � ! � � �� � � � � " � !� � � � �� - � � % � � ��

    � � %� � �� �� � � � � � "� � � � � � %� � � �� � "� � � � � � � � �� * � , �# � �� !� �� � �� ( � % � � � �� � � � � ( � � � "� � ! � � � � � � � � �� # �� ("� � � � �� � � � � � % � � � � � � " � � ! � � � �� � � � � * - � ! � � � �� �� � � �� ��� � � �� , * �� � � � � � 0 � � � � , � * � , �# � �� !� �� � �� ( � % � � � �� � � �

    � ( � � � "� � !� � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � % � � � � � � " � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � �� % �� �� ( � � � * �� � � � � � 0 � �0 � , � � � � � � � � � � ! � �� � "

    � !� � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � �� � � � � � � � ! � � � � � � � � �� �� �� � � � � � � � � � %� � � � � � � �� � 0 � � � � � � �� % � � � %� � � � � � � � 0 � � � � � � ��� � � � �� � �� � � � � 0 � � � � �

  • ��%�&);p.6=R*+MK; ,KD+;=K12&\125U.6MR12,bQT�;I,e#;1F,/D+;s3-;I,e#%'MKm[=D4.6: 3+;IG6;%'=R;\NI%'MKMR;%'3 M/.0,K;&)1>5U.0M�,/%SD[*+&\.63+=�a3+;HG';;I=K=&)(+52b . (4.0,RE,/;IMK3 N.6=K=R1 � ;IM�123+NT+52;�MR;5a:4.0,h.0T4.6=K;s%0@^MK;I5>1>.6T+52bPMR;1d,bMK;I:+*+NH,/1>%638��e#;���0�7=�.������ #@����*���OK7 *��0# ������5�0(��E* �,� �0( : ��08�8 ��C7=�0*��,�A�

    �2�)������� �,O'P�,*���#%�����+��.>.�(���30����(�S RP�,�����,*A� 8&: �0H��&�!4J�)�,*����0.>���)����* ���� #%�&'��(� .>���0*�*���(��1�����0� 4J����� �������*�.��)R�Q���,��.�

    ���0�7=�.������ )�1�2� ��.J.���#%�,4J�)���/(��14F�,*A�P8&: �D;��&:

  • � �

    5>;HG';I5>=�.0,�eQD+1>NhD D[*+&\.63+=_.0C'MK;I;�%'3 ,KD+%'=K;�=/.6&); ;%'3+=If��4%'M�; �-.6&\(-5>;6�VD[*+& .03+=�.6MR;T�;12m6;HeQ1>=K; � 3+:+=_12,�; �`,/MK;I&\;I52b ;=R*4.65@];p.0,K*+MK;I=�,/D4.n,�:+12=KNIMK1>&)1>3+.0,/; D4.6(-([b ; ��(+MR;%63+= @]MK%'& ,KD+; MR;3+123+C =K;H,pf#��3 ,/D+;�%0,/D+;IM^D4.63+:J�+D[*+& .03+=?*+=K*+.65>5db � 3-: ,/D4.0,?@];39%'*+M�=K%`N=�%6@@];p.0M�123P,KD+;g(�%'(+*-5U.6MQNm0;��

    ��M#=R1>&)(+52bg,/D4.n,#@];%'3+=^.6MK;�(V;IMKNI;5dbs=K12&\125U.6Mr,/%$%6,/D+;IM#; ��(+MK;I=K=K12%'3+= � ��*-MMK;I=K*+5d,/=Q=K*-C'C';=^,KD+;_Np.6=R; � NI*+52,K*+MK;_(+MR%'T4.6T-52b D+.6=^G';IMRbS5>1d,K,K5>;�,K% :+%eQ12,KD ,/D+;s:-1��)N=?=R*��)N12;.0,/;9,/D4.0,Y,KD+; *+3-:+;3+C (-=RbcENhD+%'52%'C'12Np.65F=K(+.6NN&)1>5>.6MK1d,b %6@;I&\%0,/1>%634.65�=R,/.0,/;I=3O,KD4.0,�(+=Wb`NhD+%'(+Dcb`=K12%'5>%'C61>Np.05a=K(+.6N%'52%'C6b'�; ��D+12T+12,K=s. =K12&\125U.6MR12,bO=R,/MR*+NI,K*+MK;YG6;12m6;),/D4.0, %6@Q,/D+; D[*+&\.63+=If �?D+1>=s12=�;IG6;&)1>5>.6MK1d,b�=R,KMK*+NH,/*+MR;�123 ,/D+;?,KM/.6123+1>3+C�=K12C'34.65 �6eQD+1>NhDse�.6= .652e�.pb`=#.05>5dE�%'MWE�3+%'3+;0�M/.n,/D+;IM�,/D+.638�V@]%6M�; �+.0&\(+52;6��D[*+& .03 =K*+T[tR;

  • � �

    5>%6C'1>N*-,K1>%'3 :+12: 3+%6,M/.03+:+%'&)52b�.6=K=R%�NI1U.0,K;^@X.6N.65-; ��(+MK;I=K=K12%'3+=eQ12,KD);I&\%0,/1>%634.65-=W,h.0,K;3[*+%'*+=R52b %'M�.6=�:+12=KNIMK;I,K; ;I3[,K12,K1>;.61>3-;=B,/D+.0,=K*+T[tR;.6*+=K12T+5>;0��e#%'MKm[123+C\12&\(-5>;3[*+%6*+=& *+5d,/12:+1>&);%'3+.65 =K(+.6N

  • �qv6v

    NNI,K%'MRb MR;3 :+1��V;3O=K1>&)1>5>.6M?MK;I=K*+5d,/=Ifg�4%'M�1>3+=W,h.63-N

  • �qv �

    (+MR;1��=�,KD+MK%qeQ3 .pe�.pb'�r,KD+; %qG';3-;p.6MR52bO,KM/.63-=R@]%'MR&\;I: ,K%9D4.pG6; &);p.63 v .03+: G0.6MR1U.63+NI; � %qG';IM,/D-;�,KM/.6123+1>3+C�:+.0,h. � =R%g,/D+.0, ;p.6NhD � 52,K;123+;p.6MF:+12&\;I3+=K12%'3�E.65212,b MR;;I&\;I3[,#"_.6T�%'MBMK;I(+MK;I=K;I3[,/.0,/12%'3\G`1>.g._(+MK123+N%63 1>= @X.6N1d,h.0,K;C';[email protected]),/D+;�; ��(+MR;%'3SMR;3+;I: ,/%Y&)1>3+12&\1��=RD+%'(8�

    ��� � ���Hf$� ��� ,KD .6NI,K%'M � =�1>&\.6C';I=�.6MK;s*-=K;

  • �qv'u

    =R,K%'( ,KM/.6123+1>3+C-i�,KM/.6123+1>3+C_12=#=W,/%'(+(�;3+123+CsMK*+3-=QeQ1d,/DS;IG6;%'39.63+: D-%'5>:9%'*-,�=K;I,K=3-:+12G`1>:-*4.653+;H,e�%'MRm[=:-;p. 1>=^,K%s(+MK% tR;5dbO123cG';MR=�%6@Q; ��(+MK;I=K=K12%'3�(+MK%0E,/%0,b�(�;

  • �qv��

    ; �-.6&)(+52;1>3-C =K;I;%qe :+12&\;I3+=K12%'34.65=K(+.6N; ,K%9MK.0,/123+C'=�%6@ ,/D-;M_=R1>&)1>5U.0MK12,b � ��%'MRCO.63-: ��1>3-C'%�;I==Q:4.n,h.\TcbSNI%'& E(+*-,K1>3+C ,KD+;YN5db'�ae#;N=W,h.63+NI; �]:+1>=R=K1>&)1>5>.6MK1d,b �V& .n,/MK1���eQ12,KD,/D-;�,/MK.63+=W@]%'MK& � 4 � � � � � � 4 � � �'u ,K% %'T-,/.61>3 G0.65>*-;&�*+5>1F.0,�;;HG';I5r%6@r,/D+;g3+;I,e#%'MRm��VN&)1>5U.0MK12,bs.0,Q:+1��V;;I&\;I3[,�1>&\.6C';(+1��-;I5�G0.652*+;#G6;

  • �qv �

    � ��� ��� � ����!� � �!��������� 4 � � �!�

    j ;�.0=K=K*-&\;Q.�3+;H,e�%'MRm � = MK;I=K(�%'3+=K;Q,/12&\; � �a� �a12=B:+1>MR;==B.0MKT+1d,/M/.0MRb �HfaA�;= ,KD+;Q3+;I,e#%'MRm � = %'*-,/(-*-,@]%'MB;&);9eQ1d,/D . 3+;H,e�%'MRm � =P%'*-,K(+*-,Y;IMKMK%6M �l�;I1>:+;I3[TV;IMKC.63+: 79Nq��52;5>.63+:8� ��� ��� �H�V; ��NNH,/12%'3+=g.63+: D[*+&\.63 �r�?=g@]%'Mg.65>5B=W,/12& *+5>1.03+:MK;I=K(�%'3+=R; (4.612MK=�@]%6M�eQD+12NhD TV%0,/D D[*+&\.63 .63-: 3+;I,e#%'MRm9:4.n,h.\e#;5U.0T+5>;0f?� %6*+3+C ;H,.65 f � = N;HG';

  • �qv �

    D4.6:P3+%6,QT�;&�*+5>*+=I�8e�; @]%'525>%qe�;I: � %'*+3+CS;I,g.65 f � =_&\;H,/D+%`:+= �U� %'*+3+CP;I,g.65 f2�

    ��� � ��Hfa�k%6M ;3+C ,/D+;I=K;9=KN

  • � ��������� �

    � � ��� � ��� � � � ��� � � � � ��� ��� ��� � � � �����

    � � � ��� � � ����� �� � � � � ��� � � �������

    j Dcb :+%P(V;I%'(+5>;s@]MR%'& :+1 �J;IMK;I3[,gN3c,K;3c,/;I3+=K1d,bO,/%[email protected]; ��(+MR;%'3-=g(�%'=K;I: Tcb @];I& .652; 34.nE,/1dG'; o'.6(4.63+;I=K;\&\%`:+;%qeQ= *+=B,/%$.63+.652b �.6=

  • �qv

    ����� �����

    ���������������

    �?D+;1>:-;p.^,/D4.n,8,/D+;[email protected];B=K12C'34.652=8;(STV;H,e�;I;%'3.63+:[email protected]�TV;ID4.pG`1>%'MIf�A�;�(+MR%qG�12:+;=RC'*+=W,/1>3-C @]%`%`:8�B%'M � � .6= ,KD+;P.63c,/1d,/D+;I=K1>=s%0@�%0,/D+;IM); �[E(+MR;%'3-=52;6f_��%P=R*+(+(�%'MR,�,/D+12=�,/D+;I%'MRb6��D+;sN%'3+;I;N3+=F.03+:_N

  • �qv��

    T+*-,P:+12=/.6C6MK;N5c=R;I,B%6@kT-1>(�%'5U.6MF:+12&\;I3+=K12%'3+=�=K*+NhD).6=r(+5>;5212,/12;MK1�;I,g.65 f2� ��� � � ��D4.pG'; ;%qb6;&�*+5>1F1>3-N*-:+1>3+C)MK;I5>1>.6T+52bcEMK;IN3+;I=K=I�^=/.6:-3+;: T�;^3+%�=K*+M�E(+MR1>=K;Q,/D+.0,,/D+;�& . tR%6MK12,b�%6@J,KD+;�NIMK%'=R=WE�N%63 MK.0,/D-;;3c,/;IMK(+MR;I,h.n,/1>%63 %6@#,/D+; NI*+52,K*+M/.65:+1 �J;IMK;=R,K;

  • �qv��

    @X.6NI1U.65#; ��(+MK;I=K=R1>%'3+= e#%'*+5>: T�;Y1>3 NI;3 =R%�NI1U.65#NMRN3+=W,h.63-NNp.03�E��&\;IMK1>N

  • � �pv

    (+MR;I,h.n,/1>%63s.63+:�,KD4.0,Bo'.6(4.63+;I=K;?=R*+T`tR;;I=K=B.0N.6=K;I=�; ��(+5U.6123P,KD+;$N

  • ^'^-^

    � � ���� �!��� � � ����! &��

    e'�{�(7)�����(�IN{^`ST��,-&��-�/^SIDH����,-&���Uv,R�E[u%'/%���(��)y��� �(/��.��7)/=-1][@

    �����],-?'���6��,-�?'��)BDH��%'� ^ M �(%2b-cqNH����,-��b�^'1 m�Ud1jg!�]�(/�l���)q%-D�(

    ��d�/�����.�������������7/8:9.��#��(�l,-��{ p������)w,y8�.����D��:7/���.����%'�/�F,-���.�o,-������),R�@)/���(������������?2��

    �����p��.��%'�"������%'��7�.��(%B "���{�(���.�$#�7/&��(7/���-1][@/�2)���.������8/7/�(��%'�%-Dj�����.�5%-������l "���.�y,-�@DH%'&�&�% ���

    ^'1��l7� 8����!%-D "���{�(�����s��%f:�����p='%-7C�����o�����p��%'�����E�%'�/�qN M Ud�^�

  • ^'^b

    �(

    ��� �/��&fR,-&�7���\���q��,-# �#��.%'�����)�����,-?'�p "���.�l��

    ����&����/��,-�.&�=G�(��,-��.DH%-������)q�(%a,����,-�C%-D6^�P'B,-�)s�.�(,-�)F,-�.)s)��f:�h,>�(��%-�%-Duc'/1\zj�/,-���&���/�����/��%:#����.����)wDJ,-#����,-�.�o��

    % ����

  • ^'^�e

    #�%-�

  • ^'^�P

    �!,-�.��)2%'�2�/����f:��%'7�v�.�(7/)�����u%-D*',-�F,R����.�!,-�)agT�����.��#�,-�G�����(������r��=G�(,R�����?'�KDH%-�v����%R�(��%-�F,-&DJ,-#��h,-&l������.�����.��%'� N xw,R�(�.7��%R�(% ,-�/) zh��(��%-�C%-Du��F,R��F,R�.�(��#�7&�,-�!�����#��l�(%BDH7/�(7/���G�.��7)������1

    ���A,B����#�%'�)w,-�F,-&r=:�����p%-DufR,-�.�h,-�/#��%'�C��

    �G0214351��,R�(���?'�@,-&�%'��R�� "�GDH%-7�)C�(F,>��(/�l��,-�.?'���F,R&������#��"%-D��o��%-7�q�},-�/���7&�,R�(��%'�2 p,-�6�%G&�%'�/?'���]�.��?'��rkF#�,R��(���%'����.����%'�/?'&�=� ����Q��

    �C�%'�L��gT�.�h,-�Q0a1 3�1]��78:9.��#�������F,-� ���� �(

    �A*',-�,-����.�s��78:9.��#�����1Q���f:���� %-Dl�(

    ���BDJ,-#���,-�/) ��

    �s&h,-#H� %RD, ��,-��?'���F,-&"�(,-#��h,-&!?-��%'7�Q�����#��� ���(/��� �(/�w0a1 3�1�(,R���&��-�` p�"�5%:%'&���)o�(

    �p0214351`gT�.�h,-�2,-�)2�%'��� gT����,-�y�.78:9.��#��(��;-�.������%'��.���jDH%-�v�.78�.���

  • ^'^S

    [u,-8&��aS�1�^V�]gT�F,-&r=:�����@%RDjfR,-����,-�#��o%'�s�����(������r��=C�(,R�����?-��13�%'7/��#�� )K1 D 1 � ������o��%'7� b ^m/^'14b' 3��d� ^ e/14S-m �14�SRm�Siu%-����) c ^e��1 c'c �l,R�(��) S e�b�1 m�S �o��%'7� � 3��d� b m/1 e'c �14'-�b�o��%'7� �+iv%'����) ^`b m/14-c �o��%'7� � �l,R�(��) ^ ^e/1 c'e 3��d� �+iu%'�.��) c /14RP �14c/^S3��d� � �I,>�(��) S b�14b-m �14-P'e Miu%-����) � �I,>�(��) e' e�'b�14-c �o��%'7� � 3��d� �+iu%'�.��) ^`b /1 P�c �1 M e M b�o��%'7� � 3��d� � �I,>�(��) ^ ^'1 P

  • ^'^�c

    Japanese US Asian US Non-Asian0

    1

    2

    Mea

    n In

    tens

    ity R

    atin

    g

    MaleFemale

    *

  • ^'^

    [u,-8&��pS�14b��jVp%'���.��&h,>�(��%-�28����� "�����}*',R�F,-������-�'0214351RgI����,-�K�',R�)B0214351R�%'��� gT����,-�y�.78:9.��#��(��;#�%-�/DH7����%'�s�},>�(����#�����1

    *',-�F,R����.� 0214351F�%'�L��gT�.�h,-� 0214351FgT�.�h,-�*',-�F,R����.� � /14m-m'm /14m M S0214351F�%-����gI���h,R� � /1 M S-0214351FgI���h,R� �

    ,-�F,R&�=:������1[v% �����&�%'���C��

    � �o��%-7� � iv%'����)K� �o��%'7� � �I,>�(��)�!,-�) �G�.%'7� � iu%'�.��)

    � �I,>�(��)����������(,R#��(��%'��G��%'���q#�&�%'����&�=-� "��#�%'���F,-�.��)Z�(

    ��,�f'����,-?'�*',-�F,-�������#�%'��DH7����%'���,R�(�.�r� �r�(O��

    �,�f-���(,R?'�C0214351#�%-�/DH7����%'� ��,R�(�.�r�51C[@

    �},f-����,-?'�}#�%'�/DH7�.��%'� �},R������#���� ����2��,-�.?'���F,R&-�(,>�(���/?'�KDH%'��5%-����)2����%-�(��%'�a,-�)a�(,R����)a����%-�(��%'�a,-���\�.

    % � ���

  • ^'^�m

    t x < g 3 W xw��,R�t P14- ^'1r^ M ^'1r^c ^'1r^` ^-14e'c ^'1r^` ^'14c'x ^'1 b-b e/1 c' b�1 'e ^'1 m'e ^-1 b-e b�1 e� b�14'S< ^'1�^�e b�14- e/14b-e ^'1 m-P b:1 -m b�1 M c b�1 P-Pg ^'1�^�e ^'1 M e ^'1 P'P P1 'e ^-1 b'b b�1 m M b�1�^�3 ^'14c- ^'1 e-P ^'1 M P ^'1 e�S P/14e'c ^'1 PP� ^'1 S-S ^'14SRP ^'1 e' ^'1 c'm ^-14e�b ^'14S�^ ^'1 P'm

    xw��,-� ^'14c-m b�1r^ ^'1 m� b�1 � ^-1 M S b�1 e'e*',-�,-����.�

    t x < g 3 W xw��,R�t P1�^� ^'1 � ^'1 -P ^'1 -P ^-14e�b ^'1 -P ^'14c-x ^'1�^�c e/1r^` ^'14S M ^'1 c'c ^-14'm ^'14S'b ^'14c M< ^'14RP ^'1 M ^ e/1 �S ^'1 e'm b:14'e ^'14'S ^'14m-cg ^'14RP ^'1 M P ^'1r^c e/1 'm ^-14'c ^'1 M P ^'1 :^3 ^'1 P'm ^'1 'm b�1 'e ^'1r^ P/1�^e ^'1r^c ^'14m-eW ^'14-e b�1r^`S ^'1 P'P b�1 e�b ^-1 b'b b�1 M ^ ^'14mRP� ^'1 P/^ ^'1 P M ^'1r^` ^'1 P^ ^-1�^c ^'1r^m ^'14e-

    xw��,-� ^'14c�^ ^'1 m'e ^'1 c-P ^'14�^ ^-1 �^ ^'1 c-PgT�����.��#�,-�

    �(��)O����%-�(��%'�K1z]��%R�(��%-�$&h,-8���&��o,-�.�Bt � tI,-���='�vx �_3�,-)|N x,-7/)&����U���< � gIDH��,-��)�Kg � gI�?'�.=-�v3� 3�7�.���������)�F,-�)CW � W����?'7�{�(��)K163���?-���kF#�,-���(&r=q)���5���.�����@����,-��p,-���T��F,-)/��)s����85%-��

    ��,R�(�.��#�����1 � /�����C)/���5�������#����B%�#�#�7���E�(

    �C*',-�F,-������C��,R�(���?'� ,R���,R&� p,=:�B

    ��?'

    ���2�(

    ,-��(/�agI��������#�,-�s�(,>�(���/?'��1

  • ^'^ M

    gT�!,2kF�F,-&5,-�F,R&�=:�����"%-D ��

    �����(���/?'���< p�T�5���.DH%'�.����)C,2%'�/��� p,�=C,-�,-&d�=:�����o%-D\f-,R���h,R�#��B%'�$��

    �B)��,-?'%'�F,R&j��&����������(�o%RD6��

    �B#�%-�/DH7����%'�Z�},>�(��� �ADH%'���,R# O%-D6%'7/�#�7/&��(7/�(,-&h~R�(,-#��h,-&u?'��%-7��G�(

    ��� #�%-���F,R����)��(

    ��#���&�&\����,-��o �r�( [v7��R��=�; �y#�%'�.����#��(��%'��DH%-�,-&�&j�F,-���. �����B#�%-���F,R�����.%'��G,-�/)���� � �4�S:1+

  • ^`bR

    ����������.����=%RDEe DH%'�p��

    �o�(

    ����)DJ,-#��-1][@

    �����78:9.��#��l?'%-�%-��DJ,-#��o7/�F,-� 8��?'7%'7/��&�=�#�%-������#����%'��oDJ,-#��27/�F,-� 8��?'7%'7/��&�=}���#�%'���.��#����,-�)A%'��GDJ,-#��G������)K�DH%'�@�(%-�(,-&K#�����)/���a^`~-e�� �~-e��/14S'~-e/�v?'�rf����?A,-� ,R#�#�7/�(,-#�= %-D@S- �1

  • ^`b:^

    [u,-8&��aS�1 e �\gT�F,-&r=:�����@%RDufR,-�.�h,-�#��o%'�s#�&�,-���.��kF#�,R�(��%'�A,-#�#�7�(,-#�='13�%'7/��#�� )K1 D 1 � � � ��o��%'7� ^ e/1 P M 3��d� ^ ^�P14m' /1 ''/^iu%-����) S ^c'm�1 P^ �o��%'7� � 3��d� ^ P1 S:^ /1 'e-P^�o��%'7� �+iv%'����) S ^ M 1 P-P 3��d� �+iu%'�.��) S e/1�^�m /1 '�-c�o��%'7� � 3��d� �+iu%'�.��) S /1 P� /14 M S'bz]���.%'� c�Rm Nn/1 �b'U

    �����

    ���������������������� ��!#"��%$��&'���(*)��+�*�+�,&*�+$�&'�+�*���(.-/����%�*0����1&*�2�&'&'�1&3��

    H M F A S D0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    Mea

    n A

    ccur

    acy

    MaleFemale

    * *

  • ^`b-b

    Vp7/&��(7/��� t x < g 3 W xw��,-�*',-�F,-� /1 M b�^ /1 c�S-e /14b M /14�^c /1 m'm'e /1 c'e'c /1 c'm-P0a1 351 /1 M P

  • ^`bRe

    Vp7/&��(7/��� t x < g 3 W*',R�F,-� e/1 m M ^-1 S-e ^'14SRP b�1r^ b�14m�^ ^-1 P M0214351 e/14S- ^-1 P

  • ^`b>P

    �������.%'�Of:���� ���/?s��

    �qDJ,-#��R1 �

    ��� �(,R&������#��B���G&�% G�%'�������?'��DH���7�:7/�����(&r=O�.����,A?-��f'���������.���.����%-� ,-�.��%:#��h,>�(��)+ �r�( ��%'��� ����%-����%'�F,R&I�{� ,R����8/7/�sF,�f'���%Q�.����%'�? ����,-��%-� ��%&���,-��� ��

    �,R����%:#���,R�(��%'�K�\&���,-)���?$�(%�&�% "������)|�.����.������f:����= ��%���

    �s#�,R����?'%-�.='1

  • ^`b-S

    �.����%'�/?'&�=-1 tI��/����)/��#�����) ��F,R�y��%$��,-����� ,R����F,-����%'��=� ���(/��� ,A�(��?-

  • ^`bRc

    *',-�F,R����.�2�.����.���(�rf:����=}��%�,-�?'����� "�a�.����%f'��)A�(

    �o�/7����)���# /�����A,-�/?'���������.���.����%-��T,R�)����#�%'���7/����)},-�?'��� ����DH%'�]��

    �I*',-�F,-������I,-�)}0214351���78

  • ^`b-

  • ^`bRm

    *-glV �(��f-� �����&�,-�F,R����%'�/�%-D�(/�6)/���5�������?@������7&r�(��1

  • ^`b M

    �(

    ,R�o�(

    �B�{�(��� 7&�� "�����q�%R�o#��.%'�����)K�������%'�����?s��%-��� %-D\��

    �BF,-����1y*',-�F,-������q��7/8:9.��#��(�,R�.�(����87/����) ������� � � � �����(������r��=y�(%o��

    �!

    %'&�����/��,-)q�.����� 7/&�����F,-�B�(/��=B)��) �(%o�(/�!DJ,-#����%'�&r= �.����� 7/&��j������

    �q����������

  • ^e-

    �������������������������� ���� ��

    ������������������

    !�#"#���%$&"'�

    ()� &"

    �)�*� ���

    +-,������*� ��$&�#�

    !�#"#���%$&"'�

    (.�#�/0�1��$23�!��4657�1���"

    89��*� �4���� � ��

    +-,������*���:��$1'��

    ; ��$1���,

    ; ��� ��-����

    ; ��$1���,

  • ^e�^

    �(%�,-�/�. "����(

    �.��� �:7/���.����%'�/���

    � W%:��� �(/�"DJ,-#��h,-&'�d�������������%'� �.��#�%-?'�������%'�a�����.DH%-����,-�#��\%-D,-�y����%R�(��%-�&������ ��,-#

    ���/�8���,-�,R�

  • ^e'b

    � $��-������&���

    �%�����#�����&��� 8���������&���

    �1"�'�� � � �������&���

    ; ������� ������&���

    �4��������� �������$�� � ;�����

    � ������� ����� ���� �� $���� ��!�-�7����� "'���� � "��%�&"��������

    �(��%-�A���!����)7#���)s�(%q, &�% "���?�)�����������%'�F,-&

  • ^e-e

    ��,-�}�{�(7