Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
AVERTISSEMENT
Ce document est le fruit d'un long travail approuvé par le jury de soutenance et mis à disposition de l'ensemble de la communauté universitaire élargie. Il est soumis à la propriété intellectuelle de l'auteur. Ceci implique une obligation de citation et de référencement lors de l’utilisation de ce document. D'autre part, toute contrefaçon, plagiat, reproduction illicite encourt une poursuite pénale. Contact : [email protected]
LIENS Code de la Propriété Intellectuelle. articles L 122. 4 Code de la Propriété Intellectuelle. articles L 335.2- L 335.10 http://www.cfcopies.com/V2/leg/leg_droi.php http://www.culture.gouv.fr/culture/infos-pratiques/droits/protection.htm
!"#$!"$%&'()*+ ,- ./0/(
!"#!$$$$ %&' (
)*+ *,,- ))( )%
%'$. /" 0!1") ' 2" (
%'$3 "34351#")
'/64351 ")
( ) %'$3 3!' 7"51#
/ '3)0#!" &
)")3
'$83"!
&5 9"30
! "
))
1$ 23$1 1 4$% 56 "" $
3 ," $7 2 ! " 8
9 : ; $ 8" $ 1
8$ 4 $ 7 ! #$ 124
$$39
$ 24" 13!
!2$8"$ 51
!$42%818$124725$8$
<$ 1#$$1$8$488";1<$569
:;1 !$55 ;
2$ 516 "+$%!8$124$$$
,=>?)@- /((8$48"8"<$569
$!"! 5 "55 $3
251 51 #$ A! #"" $%%!
$ $ 3 5 $7 & ,3* $4
2%818$68$$8"$$<$9
$!B 7" ; 2$4" "@
C! $4 2%8 1 8$ 6 11 8$ 4 $"
1 569 : $ 8$61 ; $ 1 1 $ 8$
288$"#$21277188"$!1" 18$$!
7! 83" 8$ 8 8$4"
5#$1 "#$ 13$"$351149
:8$%$337$$$ """8,#$88"
$%"$4D
2"#$8 1$% 7$D 8 ; 13$3 $ 3
251 51#$ "8!
8$8$61!"! 5 "55$ !&
! ! 8""$ ' 8$ $
18"51$"51#$!
'%()!B 7";2,@,!8$
"8$18""$816!
* ! 5 " 55 $ 3 2%
-$$$!8$8771"E18"$9
:" 1;1$113$3#$1281
" 4 3 $ 13 44" 8$
8$61D
6 $ A! + &4*!, &A5$*!-
&*!&+<1*!%&*!!'!$6 $3$$-"
&* 113 A! &A*!-#%% &-""*!-
&*9 : 1 8$ 13$ $ 7$$$! 8$ $
23 18"5 "$! 8$ $ $ $ "
$9
" (!! 8$ $ 8 #$
1!83""$$9
%'%!8351!8$8
8"8"59
113$"!$&%!
%$!$84
%,&*
-8$$83"9113
2"#$ 2"8$ " 8$37"1
868$1;349
1 11 8$ 18 " ; 1
%!#$$1$118$$85#$1" 1
11$!8$$79$%!23$14
8#$29:8$%$31F$!%!#$$17
1177#$2<1$"18";1;3$8<9
:2 " 1 1 ; &! #$ "" 8$61
18"54 1 4! 8$ 8"$ $
#$$$ 8$9
# "
) 2
& ::::::::::::::::::::::$;
" %1) $$::::::::::::::::$$-
$;/:::::::::::::::::::::::::$$<
$*/0 :::::::::::::::::::::::::$$+
$*$;/5)1) ::::::::::=
$*$*/555& 8"::::::::::::::;;
$*$>//8"?) ) 9(
8"@:::::::::::::::::::::::::::;-
$>/8"::::::::::::::::$$;=
$>$;/")1 A:::::::::::::::::::$$;=
$>$*/")1 ::::::::::::::::::::**
$>$>/")& ? 0 >@:::::::::::::*B
$>$B/'4C::::::::::::::::::::::::$$*-
$>$-/3'C:$::::::::::::::::::::::::$$*D
$>$D/ :::$:::::::::::::::::::::::*<
$B/"::::::::::::::::::::::::$$$*+
$-/5 & 9 ::::::::::::$>,
" %() $$::::$>-
$;/ :::::::::::::::::$><
$;$;/ ::::::::::::::><
$;$*/ ) &::::::::::::::>+
$;$>/ ) & ::::$$$>=
$*/!5() :::::::::::::::::::$B*
$*$;/' ) &::::::::::::::B*
$*$*/' ) ::::::::::::::::::::::$B>
$*$>/"( ::::::::::::::::::$$BB
$>/ $:::::::$:::::::::B-
$>$;/5) )?$$@::::::::::BD
$>$*/' :::::::::::::::::::::B=
$>$>/!) 5)::::::::::::::$$-;
$>$B/" )5)%
) ::::$$::::::::::::$$::::::::-*
$B/"::::::::::::::$$$:::::::::$$$-=
$-/5 & 9 ::::$$$::::::$$$D;
" %58":::::::::$$$D-
$;/!5() 1) &:::::::::::$$$D-
$;$;/) ::::::::::::::::::::::$D-
$;$*/5 ::::::::::::::::D=
$;$>/55 ) :::::::::::::::$<D
$*/!5() 1() &::::::::::$$<=
$*$;/") 5() (::::::::::::+;
$*$*/ 5)5 :+B
$*$>/!E5 ) :::::::$$+D
$*$B/ A):::$$:$$$=;
$>/"::::::::::$$$:::::::::::::$=<
$B/5 & 9 $$::::::::::$==
" 4% () (::::::::::::::$$$;,;
4$;/ & ?0 !" @:::::::::;,>
4$;$;/) ::::::::::::::::::::::;,>
4$;$*/5 ::::::::::::::::::::;,B
4$;$>/5 )2 &%8!":::$$$;,=
4$;$B/55 ) :::::::::::::::;;*
4$;$-/' ::::::::::::::::::::$;;-
4$;$D/F)5 :::::::::::::$:::$$;;<
4$*/) ?3'C@:::::::::::$$;*;
4$*$;/) ::::::::::::::::::::::;*;
4$*$*/ *'*=:::::::::::$;*>
4$*$>/ ::::::::::::::::;*+
4$>/") 55%GHI0!"3'C$$$;>>
4$B/ %0!"JGH::::::::::::::$;>B
4$B$;/) ::::::::::::::::::::::;>-
4$B$*/5 0!"JGH::::::::::::::::$$;>D
4$-/":::::::::::::::::::::::$$;B,
4$D/5 & / 4::::::::::$$;B>
"& ::::::::::::::::::::::$;B-
$ %"
$ %
G
&
88$1B428"4#$$ 1
213 8 $ 39 8$! 8 8$4 $ "3$ $ G)61 6
$ "1#$ 8$ 8$$ "9 $% 77
13"84#$$3" 8$8$189" $
& H$!8"!I *$1"$ "4
11 ; J "8$"9 "4881 $ $ 1 8
&$13!4!I *251118 "2"1 H7& =!
%! %* "#$ 18 $ 21856 $ 2"#$3
2"619
$ 88" 8$ 8$$ " ; 8$ 2" 8
1 $"!1! <$! 511 $4 7" $%
8361 "57$ 97$$!
8$ 2" 4 J 47"! 1 1 8$ 8$ 8
"79 8!1"58$4J8$ &8
241* 779 5#$ "4#$" "51! 2"!
854K#$!$8;13$39
8 ; 13$3 8$ 2" "#$ 8 $ 8$
"51#$9 %77" 88;13$3#$ $8 $
18"$2$9 4! 85$ 18"$ 1
"$"&%-$ D- *912888$
87 2" &1! $! 999*$ 2" 13&$%
8$ 8$ 4$! I *9 8361 1<$ - ! #$ 7 $
$! " $ 18"$ 71 "4"! 24 G(((L !
$1$918"$418#$D
• 2$2"2$"1#$!
• $418"1$"2"9
$ %
=
7 4 8361! $ #$ ; 1$ 18"$
2$ $% $ /((L &1 18$@- D @- *! 81
24 2$2$1"#$!1B$$ 1
"51#$89
2 % 8 ; 13$3 @- #$ 8$4"
5#$$4$"J977!5#$81"4J1
2$H1162"8$!4$ $7"$;
" $ 8 31 ; 2"8$ 2" "
8$ $"51#$18342884 "9
$ $ $ 81 58 1$! 86 $37 88 5#$! $
"$8""$88718;13$3#$$
77"5 %98$688";""
1$18"$71- 9$!8"H
3";2$1&3HMDM*!1"$%$118"
- 11 $$ #$ 2 %! 77$"9 7! $4$%
1"$% $83 18 M #$2" @-
"4#$"91$%$418";3"!11" "
&,8 D, *! 5&,>*44$3$!
%31$5&+AE*!135&E*1"$%;
$$89
58" 5#$$" "$8$
56 71 1D 8$4" 5#$ 1 " "49
% $% 1 8$ 5" 18" 8$4" 5#$!
2$ 2$ 3 "1#$ 1J1 18 #$ 71! 8$4"" 1
7"#$! ; 8 3 1"#$ 1" $ $ 8$"
8" 2$ 1856 "49 4 18"
477$1$N$8""8$ 4"8N9
8$87%8"11"4J1
"9 8$6 8" ; 27"18#$ 1!
5#$ N @$ "488" $ $ 3! $ 88
218"!1"5N88"""#$"8N9
$ %
>
6158"; 56 H3"; 2$1!
#$ $$ #$ 2=@ 8"" 87 - $9
#$"8J<$"8$ 3 85 7$ H! $$
"8$"J 8$ 743 8$ 1 2 %9 86 4 "1"
"8N183";2385$!
" $$ "#$ 77$" 7 8
4 18"$ $ $39 7 4 81
"1"!712"8$41185""$
- 9 $ ; 17 $ "$ 81 " 71 8 @
8$4"$%3!$"$$8$$
4J1$9
58 56$4$%1"$%8$48";
18M $ " 2$ "3$59$ 23! 27$
2"8$! $ 1 8$4" &- $ * 18"$ $ $3
34"$18"" "!8$1$2$%"8"
$ " - 9 $! 56 2$ $4$ 1"$ 81$!
13 5! ; 8 $% 3 1"#$! 8""9 18"
8" $ 8#$9 3 85 5$ 18"$! $
11 8$ $! 83 $3$ $8 $ 58$
9"$22$1#$597!$"3$5
8 , OM "" 4 23<7 1 "4 27$ $ 88
2"8$ $% 719 $5M $8 , !
677388"""#$188361"$$
73882% 6&N"#$*9
'
& "
0
)
1)
$;/:::::::::::::::::::::::::$$<
$*/0 :::::::::::::::::::::::::$+
$*$;/5)1) ::::::::::=
$*$*/555& (8"?8"@:$$$::;;
• @ 7 $$3$I I IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 99GG
• @ 7 $8I I IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII G=
• @ 7 $15#$I IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII G'
$*$>//8"?) ) /(
8"@::::::::::::::::::::::::::$$$$$;-
$>/8"::::::::::::::::$$;=
$>$;/")1 A:::::::::::::::::::$$;=
$>$*/")1 ::::::::::::::::::::**
$>$>/")& ? 0 >@:::::::::::::*B
$>$B/'4C::::::::::::::::::::::::$$*-
$>$-/3'C:::::::::::::::::::::::::$$*D
$>$D/ :$:::::::::::::::::::::::::*<
$B/"::::::::::::::::::::::::$$$*+
$-/5 & 9 ::::::::::::$>,
P
$'(
/
8838;13$38$ 2" "#$;
82$8$"51#$9 8$"$7Q77!$
8 2419$$ 58! 86$37 88 $ 25
8 ; 13$3!$8$88 71 77$"4$
8$68"$%8;%&%-$ D- *9
"$$1"$1"$%$"$1#$2"
- #$$88$%8;$1819
ΙΙΙΙ$;
G?(P!5185 $1854&G/??@G?=)*8$
2% 6 25 6 77$ 2" 2$ "9 G?>?! $
87$ 2$4" +R! 5 -5 53 &G/))@G?P)* "
2" 2$88#$$$$%3$%"8$
2$$39$8$!342882$$ """8
H! 4 ; $ #$2 4 18" D 2" 4 2$ " "9
85"16 88 3 8 ; 13$39 G?>)! 9-9 53
<$ S1 3 ,4 &G?GG@G?)P* 2$ 1 ;
+1 519 "$ 7#$ 189 G?>)!
S99 ,4! #$ 4 <$#$T; $ 8$ 7 8$ 8
$1$$! " $ $ =@= $ 2$ 3 2 $7$#$ 4
"8&7 $Ι9G*94%8"! 248;13$3
$3$"9"8#$!2417#$2"8$18#$
<$!"$4S99,47$1N"$872$5#$8$
8$2" UGV9
- $Ι9GD$S13,4UGV
1 8 ; 13$3 88$ G??) 4 51 3#$
2 1 $W &G?>)@G)()* 5 9
$'(
?
"3"8168;13$3;8 H$29$"3$$=(61
6!13$%7#$77$ 55$ 8;13$3
$ 39 "G)>(!9+$9 81;$
" 8$ 88 8 ; 13$3 4 18"$
71G(((L 9 8$ 4" "3$ 6 $ $
3#$ - 51 + &G)()@G))=* #$ "488 $ "1$ 8
X-$ &- *"4$8$PXSG)0)99+7$81;
$ " " X!3$$81 "$ #$
89 71 24 1" S5 5 213
34"8"8+98<8$%1"817"488
5 8 4 8 11,1 &G)P>! 1 13
-$ D- ,""*8&G)P?!- S5*98
$ 8$ 8 7$ 2" 8$ 71 81
8$2$8$2"#$8 9
"G)/(!58"$"551
8$ 2" 8 $ 2"8 47 " "#$9
8! 88 % " G)?( "$% 86 $
73 $" 49 $% 85"16 84#$ $ ""1
5 !$78$@:8#$$$5598
$"48818;13$388$"G))(4$
" 2" 7Q 88! 8 #$ "
$ 8 "8$39 $1! 13$ 8 ; 13$3
" " 2$9 81 8 13
81$8$249
$*0
%77"88;13$3977"18
$18"$71!$$"$$
&#$ $ #$*9 8 3 18"$ &Y =((L * 8
&- *!;113"5 $2&- *;8585#$&585
-$ D- *985$18"$&ZP((L *8;37$
& 3-$ D - *- &3$Ι9G*9
$'(
)
3$Ι9GD77"88;13$3U=V
$*$; 5)1)
"$!88712$8;13$3
"811"7"- 98$! 8$2" 4$
""$ "51#$! #$ 8 ; 13$3! 41 18%9
77! 7$ " $$61$D H&8$!X *! "2$
$7$$72884""571"$
71 &$! 5$*9 8 ; 13$3 ""1 $ 13
1$ 1" " $ 86 8$ 8$ 8$ $5"9
88"X9 1$ &7 $ 9=* $" 8$ "
712$8;13$39
- $9=D5"12$1$8;13$3U>V
1$8;13$318"#$""1D2!
5!2"8#$$98$2" 3"
$$8$"51#$#$2"42$9$N"5!
$'(
G(
2% 6 $4"$ =@ &G*92"$ 2%<$#$2; 2!
$ 2% 25 6 &=* #$ 218 8 $ 8$ 2$9
" 3 &>* $ 81 " 2" "#$ #$
5$92$5$ ""8123$1(!/
- !3$8"$;$1551#$&[(!'*U'V9
−−−−→→→→−−−−++++
**
*
*
;&G*
−−−−−−−−++++→→→→++++ *
*
*
*&=*
*
*
;**
→→→→++++ &>*
18"$ 71 - 24 G(((L 9
18"$"2$1"$%8"88""818$$
7!1" 1$183"4$1"$%18 F$
89
5#$""1J351#$1 2$
8977!5#$188"88""1$"$$
O$ % 7 N $ $ F$ 89 8$! 77"
18"48"$772%8"51#$1834
$""18$"428851#$9 @8$4B
$"1$5#$$8$71$97!
1"$% 4 8" $ 3" $$ 8 " 2$ 8 4$
51#$4$189$$3718!"
#$ 213 8" $ " 1 $ 73 \
73U0V9
" #$ 8 " $ "
2"9 "#$! ""1 4 J 8$%! $$ 1%!
"51#$1 7 8" $ $7 2"5 U)V9
$86$3$4""#$!$%"5""
4$881$%%"$$8$719
4 "2"4$5$$ H9$;2"!
J181"3$%77" H$"92181"3"$% H"
$'(
GG
8$"4$2% 6&N"5#$*25 6&N"#$*#$
8"<$3$371 $92"" 1$3
$$ #$ 8$ $ 1 2 =@ 5 4 29
45! 8$ "8$81 8$$
"$"#$25U0V9
1"$%"7"8$- 1 58"$
$1 &&!*>@%! * 8$ 5 U=V! 1 X 4
H 3" ; 2$1 8$ &@?M* U=V 51 5
8$ $ & >@%* U=!?!G(V9H 3"; 2$1 &M*
18" $1 18" 111"$ 2" U=V9 8 13$%
18" 88" 8$ 181D " " &, * U=!/!G(V!
544$3$U=!/@?V!%+1$5&+AE*
U'!G(V!8$"11!EU'V8U'V9
$*$* 555& 8"
- $4881$ "1"D$3$!8!
15#$9%2$171#$"$7 $1<$9
• 7 $$3$U0V
71 $3$! "488" 8 1@S 5$ &7 $ 9>*! 8"
1 5 8$4" <$91$$ $3==
11164$ $$$G0(192"$$ $$ 5
1 592" "8" $ 213 5 ; 2%8
2$3)11 $" $$91"$2$
"8"$3!8$$4X92"$4829
7$X$"8$1$9"
$%$3"!;2$7$!22$$342$
$4 X 2$ $ $39 1 86 277$
$447$&7 $9'*97$%2% 6&$2*
<" ; 2"$ $3! " $%8$ %"1"925 6$ ;
2%"$$$39
$'(
G=
- $9>D "1"$3$1@S 5$UG>V
- $9'D"#$$$3$UG>V
7 $ 8" 24 3 $88 77"
77 " 2%8 51#$9 7$ X 33
"""85$18"$92"5""8$18;$#$
7 $89 8!88B$%4"1<$973"
8$&[(!=0@(!>SO1=*UPV3$8$5 184
3$ 7 $ 8 &[= SO1=* UPV9 1 71
18" 2$ 5#$ 41"$9 "1"
$" 8$ 73 2" "488 8$ 8$$
XW9
• 7 $8U0@P!G>V
"1" 8 &7 $ 90* 8$ J 1 71 $ 4
7 $9 5#$ ""1 18 F$ 8 71 8 73
"8$977" "1"782""1$889"
$ 2" 8$ J $88 $ ""1 "3" $5 19
$'(
G>
2"8$2132$1$$$%$=((]19
7$% H$%81" 177"$%7 $D7W&7 $90*
$7W9 2$7 $7W! 7$% H$% 71$
)(L$%8$7W!1J19
5 81237"8$^1$
5 $3$!$8"4"8
$79 "#$ "#$ 3$ 77 $ 1 288
&13O$*9171$ 5#$#$8$"$9
"1!2"5""$8$18%;$#$8$7 $
$3$98$!; 18"$! 51#$ """8 77"
77"77"""115$$X
&$X$1811$*9
- $90D 7 $87W2$- UPV
%187 $8$"<$8""4
7 $ 9P9 2 7 $ "488" 8 $H@% #$ 7 88 ;
5 84$171$925 648
8 #$ 2 84 2%"$9 X "" 4 0( 1$
1""9 - 812124?0_#$2
$" "!4$8$"#$1%1GXS9
$'(
G'
- $9PD$$"5H$H@%&WWW95%91*
• 7 $15#$U0!G>V
$$15#$71"2$882$8$"9
7$% H 1J1! 88$181@
$@58$"18"2135@"@
&7 $9/*91877"84"#$7 $
7$%"&7 $9/*92"8$$24G((]1#$
"8G@=119
"1"15#$8"73177$7"
8$!$838$ $74!$7"$$
7319171! 127"1""1
8$79 1388""!731731318$$
8$ 1%1! 81 24 $ 1 8 11
$2" 1394"1<$ "1""1
71 #$ " 2$ 5#$ "$ 41 18%9
8$!13 $88184#$"877"77
2%8"9
- $9/D "1"15#$47$% H$%1J1"UG>V
$'(
G0
$*$>/8"?) ) 9(8"@
8361 - " $ 18"$ 71 "4"
24G(((L 918"$2$"181"$%
41"$%#$788;5 18%$1719
8$!77"772%851#$""118F$
8 "68$484#$"5"""1#$$
8 $ 71 $ 879 18"$ 71 84#$
" 183613"51#$1"$%91"$%
"7"!88B85885&=M=/$M>*U?!G(V$
4$ 27 5 &*@" &M*9 " $ 4$
2" 84#$" 8 $ 17 1$$ &
8"8"!88$485*U?V9
$"4#$"8$1";2138361;1$
18"$71$%$/((L 9 18"$2$
J 8 8 73 7 4 "#$ " 39
18"$ 77 $ 5% 8$ 18 1"$% $3! 11! 8
2182%311$9 1"$%11
"$%#$1"$%$17 4@;@4551#$9
4/((L !"4"""1118!#$812B
$"4$927777"7751#$2%8
" " 1 1 18 #$ 8$ $ 18"$ 71
G(((L 9231 18"$ 288 8 #$ 77 879 77!
218 2$1$87189$18
15$871!18$"4"88
$719
$'(
GP
@$%32$- $ 71UG'V &213$
78$G125 611"*
8$8$871D
a.&'*4D$%38&A*!
D7"18&A*!
D"8&b*!
D$$%38&*9
7"12$88"77"85
29
a5@&0*
2"#$&0*4#$2"#$38"
#$8"38$98"3$$!2"#$&0*4D
&*a5&*@&*&P*
4$7"13$42"#$&P*$<$7"$
; 2"#$ &0*9 2"#$ &P* 7 4 85"16 $ $%
"9 $ &c* " $% "#$ " $% "9
%812"85#$"$7118
44$2"#$39
c5a5&*@5&a(*&/*
ca&*@&a(*&?*
$"#$&/*&?*!2"#$&P*4D
&*a5&a(*dc5.&a(*@c&)*
$'(
G/
"1 8 2"#$3 UG0V 8 7 $
" 3&>*#$" 2" D
e"ae,"de"&G(*
4De"a4258#$$#$"2" 3""8"
&:91@G*!
e,"a42583,33!" "$8"3"
"#$&:91@G*!
e"a428&:91@G9f@G*!" "$8"35$
& ""*9
86 8" " &>* ; 2" H$%9 "
" 1#$ H$" 8$ #$2 18 11 H87!
"12583,338$788#$$4
511#$D
&GG**&%8
,*&!, (
(*&! (
+
+=
ag%&G=*&*&G=*
&G>**&!,=G
*&!,*&!,e,===" −−=
4D,a583,332$ H&:91@G*!
,(a583,33&:91@G*!
a H87h?!>G':9f@G91@G!
a8&*!
(a8&*!
a18"$"&f*!
%a71286!
a88$ H&*9
13"#$&GG*!&G=*&G>*!2583,33"
2%818D
+∆=∆=G
==
=G
(=("
,, &G'*
$'(
G?
2$ 81 B #$" 2""
8$;82583,339
H-,
" ∆−= &G0*
4D7"1"4"8"2"#$3&A*!
HD132""5 ""!
-D13-h)P0(( 9
13 &G'* &G0* 81 "1 2%8 $
8 2"#$3 " 3 8 ; 13$3 &>*9 8
85"#$"9
−==G
==
=G
(=(5"#$
-=
&GP*
4(D82"#$3"118"$
8&a=0L !aG1*9$"&>*!(aG!=>A9
8;13$3$713$$
"&'*!&)*&GP*9$$2$"1"4
85"16$89!c5$<$" 7$$"
"$2% 69"#$!3$5"4$
3$8"""$ " 792%8D
K/LM L/M /&G/*
4 " &G/*! 88B $% 3$ #$ 8$4 1$
871 89 816 84 $ $% "9 77
$ 1" 1$ 18"$9 $
4 "#$"#$4" 51#$19$8$ 1
$ 8 8 21" 7 "@" O$ 8
2"3 2" 8" $ 8$ $7 4 8$ "
"51#$9 3$" ; " 2"9 2%8
6D
$'(
G)
gσ
= &G?*
4iD$4"#$2"&91@G*!
D"8$2"&1*!
D$72"&1=*9
%$%18$2$ 1" "8
3 18"$ 719 81 ; "$ 2"8$
2"$&M*8$$H116U>!0@/!G(!G=@G>V9
48856$4$%1"$%;32%8"
$$4"#$$8"$;1"$%$;/((L U>!P@/!)@G(!G=V9
" 1 4 3 13 $% $ 8$ 3 $ 1$
8$ 744$"9
$>8"
%13$%18" $83 18 1"$ "7"!
#$ H 3" ; 2$1 U=!0!/@?!G(V9 88$%
18" ; 3 " j=!0!G(!/V! 8$ " 8" $ $1!
5 U=!/@?!G(V % +1$5 " U=!G(V9 8$ #$#$
"! $4$% 1"$% 8" 88"" " 8$ J 18"
@- 91$%!$4EU'V%$$8U'V9
$>$; ")1 A
H $ 71 8#$ &7 $ 9?*9 213 ;
GG/(L ! $$ 1#$! $8 28 =GO! 39 85
#$#$! $828'=O1!3GG/(L ;=>/(L UGP@G/V9$$
885" "$98168;$
1817UGPV48161a(!>P'13aa(!0=/19
!1<$82% 618"8 $82849
2M'd8"$$%"62%"")(L2$888
;2$!=@$4;$(!=(P0(!='001M'd9$$
8$" 1J"8$13" UG?V!48161
$'(
=(
a (!0G0 1 3a a (!0=/ 19 2 3 1J1 85 88#$
#$ 1 817 13 " ! 816 1
3$ #$9 71 85 1#$ 4 85
#$#$ 81#$ $ 8 $ $ 1 4$10_
UG>!G)V9
$@;=>/(L <$#$2$87$!$$3$$7$
H! $828-1>197185#$#$485
$3#$ $ 71 $ #$ 2B 8 44$1#$
U=(V9 85 1"3 H! 88" b! 88B 1 7
8 U=G@==V &7 $ 9)*9 85 $ $ $$ 5513#$
$828319
- $9?D-18#$H3$4 >9GUGPV
- $9)D$$H718"$8U==V
H8" 13$% 4 !1 86$ 738$4
$ 9 $ 4$ 2884"! "
*$3#$*1#$ 3*#$#$
H$1% 6
*$3#$*1#$ 3*#$#$
H$1% 6
$'(
=G
82%H$19$3$2$1H$1&M'd*8$8
8 >d 81 " $ 1@$ 2% 6 8 $3$" 8$ 8
2"$"$1"$UG)V98$!2<$8385#$#$
$ $3#$ H! $ 8! "4 71
1#$ 1#$@#$#$ #$ 8$ J ; 2
7$9"#$!$87783"N$%$
#$ $$ $1"$9 5% $ $ 8 18" 8 277
"#$8\92>dJ8$8583M'd
&(!(?'1*8$"4$773 48 UG)V988$
$" <$ 2$1 #$2$ 8 $ $1 81 23
$4"#$3$8"$U/@?!GG!='@=0V9
$3$ $ $1 8$ $" 8$ 8%
83"! 1 " 1 ; $ 85 513"#$
$3#$#$$4$%$P0(L 9385$3#$83
8 2<$2$1U='V$2% $1U=0V9"2$$
#$"8GG19_=>8$834$""18
$4"#$418U=P@=/V9
H 3" ; 2$1 $" 8" $ 3 3"
51#$ $ 1856 "$ % U/V9 86 " 1 $
$ 8$1 #$9 $ 1"#$ 77 2%8 "
1834 $""118 F$898$! 2$1
8341 #$"4$73\97#$"
8!83385#$#$$$3#$H971
$3#$ $1 $" - 9 88"" "#$ 81
3$8$$$%112385$3#$&7 $9G(*?19_
U?@)!G>V9 8!H#$#$"118"$
1" 8" $ 1$ " 1"#$ #$ 71 $3#$
U/!G)V9 8$! S88 1" #$ H #$#$ 86 $ $4"
#$$8"$;H$3#$8$$18"$71
/((L U=?V9"1! 71#$#$28$"! "38$
71851#$2$89$$$3#$
8 " 1 #$#$ 8361 "4" 4 1"$% 59
$'(
==
%18! 18" 85 8 =M=/ M> ; 27
MOU?!G(V9 18""!$8"""7Q"3
88""89
- $9G(D"4$$4"#$7$$%2=>
&*1&*8UG)V
$>$* ")1
1;H!"28388$385
7$9 $1 $ $$ U=)@>(V9 1"$ $
$$1%!; 7$$ #$"#$U>G@>=V9"8"
8" $ 73 $4" #$9 "#$! " 2$ $
8 8$ B $ 2 =@ 1$ $4" "#$9
118$H!$3$2$ 'd8$88
>d 81 " $ 8$ 8 2"$" $ UGG! G>! >(V9
+9 991"#$2$$%8?;G=19_81"=;>_
$U>>V92<$81$" 1 "$3""4@;@4
73882% 6U>'V92 'd"41 &a(!()/1*!
77 $ 83" 5% 89 45! $% 6 ;
8 $ $ 89 81 2 "#$ ^ 7$11
77"82 'd8$8"8
$3$95%$"1#$83"9
4 776 $ 8 #$ 77 1$ 88"" 1
$4""1$"$$9 1117 $9GG!8
$ 1$1 $3$ #$ 81 23 1$ $4"9
8!$7\83"!8 $ $1
8 $ 181 M 11 " 8$ @- 9$ #$
$'(
=>
8 $"!18";3"86$$4"#$$8"$;
18";3H118"$@- U0@P!)!
G=!>GV9 $%812% $1 &,=>*$ 1$1 &1=>* $
$%$G(19_8$ 23388"""#$ U>>V9286
+9 99U>>V$99+WU>'V!" "&,8 D, *
1"$3#$"1"&18 D *1;
#$2771959U>(!>0V$f9 $59 U>PV913$%$$8
8$ 8 $ $1 #$ 13 J 3 181 " ;
"$3"88""$UG(!G=!>>V9
- $9GGD"4$$4"7$$8U=)V
$4"#$, 3$8"$;M$%$
/((L UGG!>>V9$%8G(19_77$8$ 1$
#$#$2$8 =(19_UG(!>>V9" 11834
1"$%2" U/! >/V9"1! $%8 "7 ; " 8$
1"$9 81 #$2 8" 8361 3" 1"#$9
8361"$N"#$89 $@8;$1$"$$!
8$"3"42 'd#$"$ >dU/!>G!>>@>'V9
"$218 2$%84$1#$P_18"71"
'/U>'V?_22 =>U>'V9 17$$
;7$#$$$718U>'V98$!2882 >d
218 2$ $ 1 $4" "#$ $ "1
$4"#$U>!/!G=!>>V9
$4 "8$"4"$$ 'd >d$N"#$9
;8$368MU0!G(!G>!>PV!$771178$
884 3$4", !1" 1$7711
"88$$3" 'd9
(!G (!GG (!G=$8O1
&iO91
@G9f*
G!P
G!?
=
(!G (!GG (!G=$8O1
&iO91
@G9f*
G!P
G!?
=
$'(
='
$>$> ")& ? 0 >@
5 $ $ $$ 8 8"4X
51" +>9 11 1 7 $ 9G=! $$ " 18"
8"4X8$3#$UGG!>?V988$%11$
$37 $"#$42% 6^8$ $8$$3UGGV9
18"1$6+P#$$8$";
1" $3#$9 $$ ,> 5513#$ U>)@'(V &7 $ 9G>*9 2
$1&,>d*8$ 262% 6 2 5&>d* 71G=
4% 68$859
- $9G=D$$84X"U>?V- $9G>D$$$,>""4 >9GU'(V
118$$$7$&M, *!$3$
>d 8 4 7"$ 81 " $ 74
$2=@U)!GG!'GV9$3$3$$>d8$=d$,>d8
$ =d 81 23 $4" #$1%19 51"
18"G@%%,G@ >@k&,*UG(!'G@'=V9$4"#$1%1
#$$%$3$18(!G(!=8$%(!G0(!=8$9
718!,$$$8$1
#$9 1"$8"$$4"$8"$;M, U?@)!GG!
>?! '=V 183 4 1"$% 5 U/V9 18" 8$
4 $%#$, !3$1856"$%U'>V9
4" $ , " \ 41 18 $ $1 U/!G(V
62% 6
=@ ,>d >d
62% 6
=@ ,>d >d=@=@ ,>d,>d >d>d
$'(
=0
4"$N"#$8$18"$2$8U/@?V98$
#$#$ "! 9 55 9 U'>V f9 f$ 9 U''V " $ $3
$3$$,>d8$ =d$ =dU/!GGV$$-=d8$1"$
#$9
$>$B '4C
+'A=GG! "4 +AE! 8" $ $$ "7
% 6 88 ; 71 18"$4$9 $$ $
181 $7 $5 U+==V=d 88 8"4X ""
"7 % 6 UA>!0(!0V=@U'0@'/V9 $ 71 8#$
718"$9213;'>(L !$$1#$&l*4$
$828=U'0V9$18"$18'>(L 0/(L !$$
5513#$&m*4$ $82811U'PV97!8$18$
5$18"$!$$8#$#$&n*4$ $828'O111
U'PV9855$18"$!8""7 $9G'!1"488""
$#$1%1UG(!'/V9
- $9G'D$$n+'A=GGU'0V
3 85 l! m $ n ; 18"$ 13 83
$3$$8$4$18$1"9853$"8$
#$$89%18!99U'?V1"485
5"" 7 $ $4 $3$" $ 4$19 $ 1
+AE8""18"51"+=%AG@%0!0@k913$%
$3$ "" $" U'?@0GV 8$ 3 85 n! $ 8$ J 8$
$'(
=P
$UG(!0(@0GV9$%G(9_$4812385n77
388""$#$U0GV9
+AE $$ #$ 3 1$ #$ M! , $
, UGGV9 8! $ 18 #$2" 8$ @- 8
#$#$8361977!8$18"$2$4 "!24$1
&Ad0*"$71Ad'#$788B$$4""#$U')@0(V9
"$ %J1! 1"$ 1 "3" A=> &A>d* 31$5
1"#$U0(V9$4 38$"4"$$+AE
;"$"3$5118$$, 9
$>$- 3'C
71E $$ 18"==)9 $@ $8$
18! 1 2 #$ "11 #$ 9 3$ 1
"4 88"" $ #$ U0=V9 2%8 $ 1"1
$"$8$3$U'!0>V918"$
13! ==) $ $ $$ 1#$ " 61 $ &l@
==)*U'!0'V9$@;0?(L !$$$3#$&m@==)*4$ $8
28=G>&7 $9G0*U'!0'V9 7185$%$0?(L
8O"9218 2$$ 1$4$11
#$$4"#$2$1$% $&P9G(@=91@G;?((L *U'!
0'V9
- $9G0D$$$m@==)U'V
3 85 $3#$ ; 18"$ 13 83
$3$$8$5$$1368$$U'!0=!00V9$
$3$""8$$8U'!00V9
==)
G
>
=
'
0$%*;> K<I*,;B?-@N1 D<,O"
==)
G
>
=
'
==)
G
>
=
'
0$%*;> K<I*,;B?-@N1 D<,O"
$'(
=/
8361E"733"$Pd$73
8 8 2% 6 U'! 0P@0/V #$ $ ; 288 2$ $4"
"#$9$4$"3"1$"$$!$$;
18$8$1368$""11 "$3 $4
4$$4"#$$1J1 $9 $%6!#$
3"1$"$$$488"""#$!8"
218 $ 68$$3$$8$136U'!0PV9$ 288
8;13$37;318"$!$871
E $83 18 M 11 " =@%%=@S)9
$3 $3$ 77 83" 3 85 m ; 18"$ 13 8
<$2$12$ 1";"$$7388
2% 68<$$ 69
$>$D
18";$$8$51"8G(@&+'*P%!4
a ( $ (!P/ >Z %ZG9 $ 3 3 88"" $ 2=@!
2""1$2""1+$$1$$ 1$1918"
;3 1$17$4""8$218- !$7$\
74";5$18"$$ 1$1U0?V913$%""1"""
8$ ^ $4"1%1 3$ 8$ 1"$% ;3
5U0)V9
1"$% 8" 88"" 8 $4" #$! 8$
182$ $ 2%#$88$1;9
8$ 2%8#$ " $8 28 18" #$ 8
5% &P>O1*9 11 1 7 $ 9GP! % &=* $4;
2"$ $#$888;7186&+'*!
139 8" $ #$ 2""1 8$ " 1 $ 1
13" % 2% UP(@PGV9 586
88""$1$8"$;M!2""7"UPGV9
$"11!"$""1"$$81%O,8$2""1+7
14"$ 1$1$%18"$"4"UP=V9
$'(
=?
- $9GPD$$88@4$ 2%UPGV
$B"
$ $ 47 8$ 2" ! 8 ; 13$3
"9 " 8$ ; 8 2$ "
"51#$ #$ "$ 7Q 77 884@;@4 2419
%77"88#$77"8$18"$719
% -$ 8 1 #$ 7 $%
$ G(((L 9 18"$ "6 $ "4" $ 77"
""118F$8"2181"$%41"$%9
$ "1#$ 5#$! " 1$ 18"$
2$4 /((L 9 2 5 1 18$ @
% -$ 9 8! 31 18"$ $ ; $ 5$
871 8 $9 1 8$ 8 $ 4$
2" 8 8 $ 1$ 2"8$ 1"$% $ 8
2"3$4$%1"$%9
58; 7 8$ 88""#$8" 2"
- #$$1"$%$83411"
@- 9
2"J32$84$51#$!185 #$&$$*
1&"4$8$*2$89" 1
8"$77"4;42% 6!11"$3$$
&=@*"$%7 88869
$'(
=)
8$!J$3"#$8$18J525
#$18$$9
1"$% 4 $3 H " &M*! #$
1"$"7"!"8"$ $1&, * 54
4 $3$9 18" 8$ " +AE! E
1"$%;$$89"28%5$4!1"$%;$$
+W1! $8 $ 5 8$4 " 1 J "4#$" 11
$$#$8@- 9
$'(
>(
$-5 & 9 UGV S9,4!585 H!>!G'!&G?>)*!G=/@G>(U=V 9 +$ 5 13$! 9 4! W3 $3 4W! P!
&=((=*!'>>@'00U>V :999$<1!-99-94+X!,99 5!:$7W$!/G!&G))?*!
G(/@GG(U'V 9, !562$4"$!=((>!U0V 999+W!f9- ! 1!==!&G))P*!=0/@=P0UPV 9 9 5!!G0=@G0>!&=((=*!'(0@'G(U/V 9 4@77"!9S"3!93! :$ 7 5 $8 1 ! =G!
&=((G*!G?(0@G?GGU?V 999+W!!G'>!&=((G*!>)@'PU)V 99!!0G!&=((>*!0)?G@P(((UG(V 9 !9,$3! 51"$%!=P!&=((G*!')@0?UGGV 99X!:99f!!1&=((>*!>(@>/UG=V +9 99!!G>'!&=(((*!>@=(UG>V 995!:$71 1!/P!&G))>*!0P>@0??UG'V 94!-94@ ! 919 !5#$2 "$!>>'(UG0V 9 +$$! 511#$ "#$3 51#$! ! + =@/=)P@
(>)(@0UGPV ,9$7! 85!G0!&G)P=*!GG?/@GG??UG/V :9X!9+!9$55!W77!G=!&G))/*!)P@)?UG?V 9+!-9-!9A ! 85!+'/!&G))G*!??G@??PUG)V 999+W!!0=!&G))=*!=>@>=U=(V -9+$25!56,!=((=!,3U=GV +9$!56!G))'!U==V 94$!9-$!5 1 7 1!9+9!1 1
! &G)/0*49>89/P
$'(
>G
U=>V 2 53X 7 85 7 1 85! + &49>*D(@?/G/(@==(@/!8=)')!""89A99 4
U='V 95!!/?!&G))0*!>>>@>>?U=0V 95!9W!9<1!!0/!&G))=*!G0>@G0/U=PV 911!9!9X!915!9H$!9fW!9X1$!
!G>=!&G))0*!G>/@G'=U=/V f91$!9H$!9fW!9X1$!911! !
G>=!&=(((*!=>0@=>)U=?V S9S88!!0=!&G))=*!G0@=GU=)V 9 !9911!,9918!!G=)!&=(((*!P>@)'U>(V 9 5! 9 $5! f9 $5! 9 ! :$ 7 88 51! G?!
&G)??*!0=/@0>GU>GV 93!9 W!!?>!&G))P*!G@GPU>=V :@,9!9X 1!9!!0=!&=(('*!===G@===?U>>V +9 99!!G=)!&=(((*!)0@GG(U>'V 999+W!-99 5!:9!!G=G!&G)))*!=0>@=P=U>0V 95!f9 $5!9!!>P!&G)?)*!/G@/0U>PV f9 $5!9 $5!9$9!!0=!&G))=*!GP0@G/=U>/V 9 ! 9E!9-$!,9 !9 !!0P!&=((=*!G('>@G('/U>?V f9$ !:9+9,$ 5!:$7 18$!>(>@>('!&=(((*!'0'@
'P'U>)V 99!:9994!955!9X!!G(/!&G))?*!>G)@>=>U'(V 9 5! 9 +! 9 ! :$ 7 5 51 7 ! P=!
&=((G*!''0@'00U'GV 9 5! 9 3!9$1! 9,9 !9 X! 9 W!
!G==!&G)))*!G@G0U'=V 955!9$!9X!!/)!&G))0*!G'/@G0GU'>V 955!9X3!9-$$!9X!!GG>@GG0!&G))?*!0?0@
0)G
$'(
>=
U''V f9f$!951!f95!:9XX$!91$!9f1!955!9X!!G>=!&=(((*!G))@=(?
U'0V ,9!9$!99A!9!,9W X!!0!
&=((>*!?PG@?P)U'PV ,9!9$!99A!9!,9W X!!0!
&=((>*!?0G@?0)U'/V -9351!9-93$@,!,9!,94 X!!=?@
>(!&G)??*!0=)@0>=U'?V 9!9!9+1!93!:9-$!99A!,9!-9
351!,9W X!!/(@/G!&G))'*!=0)@=P>U')V 94!99A!9 8!,9W X! :9 9+4!,9!9
!9 5!93!!G0)!&=((>*!GP/@G/)U0(V 94!99A!,9W X!:9 9+4!,9!!
G0)!&=((>*!G?G@G)GU0GV 9S3!f9!:$7 51!GP>!&=((=*!=='@=>(U0=V 9!-9,$!9+5X!9$!9 !$!'('!&=(((*!?0P@
?0?U0>V 9!!=!&=(((*!/00@/0?U0'V -9,$!9!9$%!9! 51!G=!&=(((*!=0/0@
=0?(U00V 9, !-9,$!-97!95854!-9-$5!9$!9!
!GPG!&=((>*!=>G@='GU0PV 9, ! -9,$!9+5X!9 9 ! 9:9 X!@9S15o7! 9
!:$7W7511!/!&=(('*!0G@0/U0/V 9@8H! :9 9 $H@! 9 "H@ ! 9 $H! :9 9 9 3! :99
-!:$751!?!&=(('*!P>?@P'>U0?V :9991!99!!GP/!&=(('*!=>@=/U0)V 9 X1! 9 X1! :$ 7 5 $8 1 ! G?! &G))?*!
G'G>@G'G?UP(V 9X1!9X1!9 $5!f9f!9!9fX!9$H$X!f9
5!:$75$8 1!G)!&G))?*!0(/@0G(UPGV 9 $5!9$3$5!9X1!9fXXW!f9f!!
G/'!&=(('*!/>@?(
$'(
>>
UP=V :9991!9<3!99!!G/0!&=(('*!>0>@>0
>'
) "
>0
!(2)
()
$;/ :::::::::::::::::$><
$;$;/ ::::::::::::::><
$;$*/ ) &::::::::::::::>+
$;$>/ ) & ::::$$$>=
9G9>9@3""#$I I IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 9>)
9G9>93@3"$" 18$4"I I IIIIIIIIII 9>)
9G9>9@8$13"I I IIIIIIIIIII 9'G
$*/!5() :::::::::::::::::::$B*
$*$;/' ) &::::::::::::::B*
$*$*/' ) ::::::::::::::::::::::$B>
$*$>/"( ::::::::::::::::::$$BB
$>/ $::::::::::::::::B-
$>$;/5) )?$$@::::::::::BD
$>$*/' :::::::::::::::::::::B=
$>$>/!) 5)::::::::::::::$$-;
$>$B/" )5)%
) ::::$::::::::::::::::::::$$$-*
9>9'9@8I I IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 0=
9>9'93@$1$I I IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 900
>P
9>9'9@ 11218"2$1@$- I IIIII 9990P
9>9'9@87%8"1I I IIIIIIIIIIIIIII 9990/
$B/"::::::::::::::::::::::::$$-=
$-/5 & 9 :::::::::::$$D;
$$'#
>/
% 13$ 1"5 #$ 81 56 71 1
"1#$9 5#$ 1 F$4 $ $ "$ 8$4"
5#$ 1 " #$ 8" $% 4 83 8$ 73 $5
1"1#$9816;8$4"$3"1#$1
7"#$9 " 8$4"2$31"#$
"4;22$ ""$$$9 4$"$
$"$77$1$N$8""4"8N8$
"4"9 $ $ 58! 86 $ 37 88 $ 8$4" 5#$
1 "! $ 8" $ 87 %8"1 77$"9 77"
5#$"188$4$"9
$; UG@>V
2"32$4J188$4"5#$"$"8D
" 2$ 48$ 8 % 21 ; 8 2$ $ &3*!
74$3$21856"7"48$$
4$$$3#$$ 1$719
$;$;
2882$77"8$2$1856"7"$
;"2$81718"2"!2!85$$
"71$%"9$2$518"#$!8684$81
&d* """ " 8 5 &3*9 218 d $ 3
84#$8$4"$712$$ 21#$86$" 8$
$118&∼0A*9 " 7477$$8786$
4$ $7 $ $3 48$ ; 2
71 $59 88"" $ "8N 4 1
8" $" &8 4!1"$ 3! 816 "5 !I *
&7 $9G*
$$'#
>?
- $9GD5"1$888$4"5#$U=V
$;$* ) &
871 " ; 8 $% 1 #$ 8"
4;2659 1 "6$5181 "#$&+*86
;$7388$$518"#$&*913
$%518"; 518#$71 H
#$3$"1 "#$9""15
8" "8 5182$$$@! $$8$
77"2#$81$$ 1 4"8N$
1$84&7 $9=*9
"1! $ 4" 5" $ 87 1 " " $
"5$771183#$"2182$61719
$8361"$7#$8$4"8$4$27
1!#$$;$$$5"" 639
- $9=D871 "UGV
18
$3
3d
@
3
@ A
18
$3
3d
@
3
@ A
3)
#
8( )
"5)
& )
3)
#
8( )
"5)
& )
$$'#
>)
$;$> ) &
5618""1#$#$%;831"#$
8382<$2$ H"7$ H8$9 17816
"#$"5 $72$ H"7477"$7
$"$&8!3!$3*9 5 1181"#$84#$"
8 17 $$7 38 8886
"4;8$4"983$%85"1623"
"5 ! 84#$" 8 7 1" 1"KD
3"$"#$$" 18$4"U=@0V9
$;$>$
2 H "7 3 $ ; 71 8$
" H 7$% 1" 8$4"" 8$ 739 18"
$4"#$9"#$!$313134
8684 &d*! 8$ $ $1$ 5 84#$8$4
2"4$2@1J1H1"9$8277$8$8$
$"#$4881@#$8$411 #$"$"8N8
8<1@ $$"39
$;$>$ &)
72<$$ H"717"#$"#$#$
88 H"7!4"8N!98$ H"7$
11"877 8$7$"$$$8"4$"8
61818 9 85"16$;$$388 H"7@
"3 H"78"2$"5 !$<$$"5 9
7!8$8$$25""$%" 1#$"3
HB$"B&7 $.>9*9$73"3! H"71<1
11"877 $4$8$"$!4$731
$739$388 H"77"3
86$7389 " 1!""1!""8$4"8N
181 81 ""18 ""8N F51"#$9
$$'#
'(
77" $34"5 #$7 88 H11"
877 97#$8$"$$"1"K&*!$
5$ 277 $ 1 8 4 39 " 13$
" 118"&p +*!#$84#$$34"8N";$
$ 1 88 H "7 83"2318"
F51"#$&7 $9>93*9
$@; $ 8 3$1 &+*! 8 3 1 1"!
277 #$ 84#$ $ "4$ $3 4 "5
861;$3"5 9
$"3 H"71$! 61"18 41;
8$83$1!B$$ 1$7$%1"8$4""$
$ 111286"4$8$"$961
3$" 1""1& p *$
? @
? @
- $9>D8"5"1#$2"4$882% 67$"3
$&2$611"@1"K6"7*&*@4$4"8N7$
"3 H"7&3*U=V
!*
+
4!
!*
+
4!
+
8
2%
6&
=*
" 18$4"18" & *9
" 18$4"""1&*9
D"5
D4"5
( ! (&2?!*@
+
8
2%
6&
=*
" 18$4"18" & *9
" 18$4"""1&*9
D"5
D4"5
(
+
8
2%
6&
=*
" 18$4"18" & *9
" 18$4"""1&*9
D"5
D4"5
D"5
D4"5
( ! (&2?!*@
$$'#
'G
$;$>$')
%13$%1#$8$4J188$1$"1
85"1623"9887Q"$3""#$
$4D
• 8"4288$7%8"$7$%2d8"
$71"858"U>V!
• " $ 81 13 8Q $ "K $$ 39
8$4"341UPV!
• $ $ ""$ 7"#$ ; G>!0P H9 $ ; $ 7
$ 1 $ \ ; $ 3 4 "8N! 18 4
2$ 2$ ""$ $ $! #$2; 8361 2
218"U=@>!0V!
• 88#$ $ $ 8$" ;1 7"#$9 $ 18 3
8"" 41!B28684"8$
86 " 4 &"*9 $7 3 5 841
" 2 q 3XW #$ 18 " 8$ " $
"#$ &[G( r*9 $! $ 18 77! "5 1 $7
$"8$86848"8"
819$"7781$$186$7!
#$" 1""4G(rU=@>!0!/V9
881"58$3"$" 18$4"
$4D
• $21856"4!$ 14818 U=@>!?V!
$61377"U>!?V!
• 17 "1"$6137Q728U=@
>V!
• 5816"#$N8"U>!?@)V!
• 74"4"$4$$$3&8$!!999*!
• $ 1 18"$ 3 8$ 81 77$ 4$1 $
1"K!#$84#$$1118$7UG(V!
• $ 1$3!
$$'#
'=
• " $3$71"$816"5 #$$71
$$%$413U>!P!?V!
• %8"8$4""48$ H"7U?V!
$2""5 U>!0!GGV9
$*!5()
$*$;' ) &
213$87%8"181 ""8N8 8""
8$4" 5#$ 1 " &7 $ 9'*9 "8N "" $
;42$4$1'(4#$";$ $8818 9 $@
18$818;8$818$31"$8123
2$4 G(@'9 3! 7%" $ 611 "! 7 8 $ $
2$$$"5""$4$ 591 "$"$%
1#$8"4! ""$5181 "#$&+*86
;$7391 "$"""#$3"!#$ 7#$1
1 "#$$%177"9 518#$71
H#$31 "#$!8" ""185
&3*9 $;$8$ 77"2#$812$ 1
4"8N1$849
8@"5 $ 61 7 <$3 5$$ 77
83"" 3@$3&@*98"75
""#$1$8$"$78$4J8"9
71B8""!2"8N";8$$88D
• $<$ 88f+8$$42"4$8;
2"$2!
• $ ""$ $ $ $ 8$" ; 1 7"#$ #$
"5 $$"$!
• $61"$882"#$!
• $ ""$ 7"#$ &G>!0P 5H* $ $ 8$ 8 8@
"51!
$$'#
'>
• $6127"1"8#$1"1&489>9G
58*97$$1$%2$185 68"8$738#$
134"4$816:3@49
´13 88 " ; $ $ #$ 18 "
2"4$77"816D8!!""8#$9
- $9'D878$4"5#$1 ";$$3
$*$*' )
13$17""77$"$872"3&7 $
9'*! 8$ 81 56 18" "1#$ 18%9 17
1<$2<$2$1 "#$;$15;$$
3&7 $90*9 17""2B8@$38$1$!
8$34J151 61891 "1377$
83" " ! 816 41 18 8$
251 """ 18 "8$ 2$ 611$@$9
77""1"489W3$UG=V$$3
," $79 21 "#$ 83" $ 8@$3
1$9
'
0) &
0 !"8
IPI
λ λ λ λ K--,)
& A
3)5 !/
4"
"
!'
8
4 ) &
5
"5)
) &2
)2)
' '
0) &
0 !"8
IPI
λ λ λ λ K--,)
& A
3)5 !/
4"
"
!'
8
4 ) &
5
"5)
) &2
)2)
$$'#
''
1 "8$4J1"$$$7"#$9
""$$$"#$8"61"$888
29
1$8@$377"5#$N@$"488"
8 -9 $ $ 39 $ 4 1 "!
8168#$"""#$8"2$1" 8$"8#$
$ 738#$98$"" "$ "$8$81 1$
" 8#$ $ 1J1 8 $ 8@$3 $ $ 2%8"9
" 8$ 4" 1$ 27"1" 8#$
19
- $90D878$4"5#$1 "1$$
$*$>"(
5%$3 $"8288718$"9
$34$"8$28#$715""9
"8$7425""8N$49 $
4 ; 2$ 4$! 8$ $ Q ; 2$ " ! 7! $ "5 4 $
4""
4"
"
$71
,$8818
A1 $3
7
$A$4
!=
4""
4"
"
$71
,$8818
A1 $3
7
$A$4
!=
$$'#
'0
88 339 18$ 1 4 $ 7 " 7 4
8"$9 77! $ 4 $3 8" $ 8$ "7 ;
25"719
218$31"#$$"8$ 213$9
5% $ $ 1" 7$ 23< 2$ "$ 8"1 UG>V9 2 2$
%3 7#$ 8 '>( &1*9 1" 86 $ 77 "
2%851#$4185$%1"$%"3"$$
"$9 " " $ 8 1 $7! 8$ $ "
2"5 8 $ 3 51"5 8" ; "3$9 $!
2"58"$3;$8G(1$!8$ "4
2"5"425$9
7! 1"$% 8 " - &! 1 @?M*
" 1""$"92 1"$%11"8"" &!
3*9 8 %8"1 8"8 "5 #$ ;
$149
$>
5#$#$"1"$%&77E
&E*!8 #$ ;+ &+* 1 &** ""
$" 8$ 1"$% 5""9 $% 7716 18" 8$
"71!8187!1#$!"#$8"2$18$$3!
81 7 1$ $ $ 7% 'L9 88! 1#$
10((! "1" + + &sO=s*9 $% 87 "#$8"
2$53&ta(!G/??)1*98#$;
+ ""$$88588-,E>("#$8"2$2E
; 8 " 8 E9 8 8 #$
177$"$$8758 =((9""1
" 1""1"$$1 8 E0($!
5#$8$8"7#$;2"$""$"!8""@$9
$$'#
'P
$>$;5) )?$$@
$ $ 7$ $1$% 75 27 $% 1$% 8!
8$$ 77 8$4 88BD $ 8 $ 7$ 8$ J "7"5 &7 $ 9P*
#$81&7 $9P*$3$17<9
5 1! ""88#$@!"8
"7&*77"1$%4" $$2t$7$$1$%
$"9#$N17$4D
G&G*a=&=*
4G!=8#$"71$%G=841^ $
1!
G!= "4$7$$1$%888;1$8"8$
$%1$%&L*9
1"$%"8$<$8718#$18$8
$7$18$J33"9!2"7& *"$
$ 71 18% 8 1 8" 6 33 $1$9
2 "78D
a@X
- $9PD5"16"7"7%$8 2$7$$1$%;4$14"8$"8N1$%78633
85"16 "7 "7% "$ ; 5#$ 7
8$$4 2"$! 7$% "7"5 1 " 11 5#$
3$951$1$%2$7$77"4"$1$8
77"$2$7$28$3"79 77"51
4!"7$71X!772%$71
E
7$1
7$7$"7"5
E
7$1
7$7$"7"5
$$'#
'/
8#$ ; 7" $4 $ $4 8$ $$
2""&7 $9P*9 77"42"8$
88""8#$$719
2"32$"8N8$" 6133&X73*$$
$3 8 &4! 8 %18*! 299 ; $4 2"4$
18$7197 $9/$87%8"19
- $9/D5"1$885#$27"1"8#$1U=V
"#$ 85#$ $ "8N 4 "8N 2"4$ 8
$ #$ 7$ $1$% 4 1 $ 71!
1&*$7#$D
"'! 'Q#
3'8"3
) &2
3RB/S-λλλλ KB;=$+)
λλλλ K--,)#
8
Dg
D
D
"'! 'Q#
"'! 'Q#
3'8"33'8"3
) &2
3RB/S-λλλλ KB;=$+)
λλλλ K--,)#
8
Dg
D
D
) &2
3RB/S-λλλλ KB;=$+)
λλλλ K--,)#
8 8
Dg
D
D
Dg
D
D
$$'#
'?
7 $816 $ G!XG! G #$ $
439$4$%8"1!$$1$$185 61"8
$ ""$$$" $"8$$3"97118
8" $ 8 7 2$ 4 7 23 $ 1 $
7$$"8N97$1"$8""8$738#$138"
6 $3 8 8$ 4" 4 $ 816 #$ "
$$2!7%";00(1"$9
2$1"$8718!41
$$3$K7$18!$8"42"8$$71&7 $
9?*9 218$ 8 ; 77" "7
1$% 4" 77" $% 1%1 &$ 11* 8" $
$ 12"8$$71eatO=G9
$ 71 33! 2"4$ 1 7 $ 18
8#$ 8"#$! 4 $ "$ 8$ $ 1 18 4$ XG
&- $9?*9
- $9?D8"$35"#$172"8$$71
a7L&(!!λ!G!XG!G!*4D (!"7$4!
!"7$$3!
λ, $$2$$1$&1*!
G!"7$"8N!
XG!772%$"8N!
G!"8$$"8N&1*!
!182%8"&*9
G@
( G(( =(( >(( '(( 0(((
(!=
(!'
(!P
(!?
G K λλλλ J *
)2 %
K;I- λλλλK --,)
;K-,,)
GK*I-P
;P;K,I,-?&2) @
P; K,I-? @
?)@
G@
( G(( =((
(!=
(!'
(!P
(!?
G K λλλλ J *
K;I- λλλλK --,)
;K-,,)
GK*I-P
;K,? @
P;K,I,-?&2) @
P; K,I-? @
)
G@
( G(( =(( >(( '(( 0(((
(!=
(!'
(!P
(!?
G K λλλλ J *
)2 %
K;I- λλλλK --,)
;K-,,)
GK*I-P
;P;K,I,-?&2) @
P; K,I-? @
?)@
G@
( G(( =((
(!=
(!'
(!P
(!?
G K λλλλ J *
K;I- λλλλK --,)
;K-,,)
GK*I-P
;K,? @
P;K,I,-?&2) @
P; K,I-? @
)
$$'#
')
"177G!XG2"8$G7 R;2$
2$ 8 11! "488" $ 3u! 3" $ $ 1"5 "$ 4!
8$2<$1$35"#$$%$3%8"1&7 $9)*9
- $9)D 118$"177"77$"8N
5#$778$$83"2#$88""$"8N2"4$8$D
• "1 4 8$ #$ "8N 8
&"8N1861%"!#$$#$751"#$83$
$$1$*!
• 2<$1 $3 %8"1 $% $3 5"#$ 8$ "1
7Q8"77X2"8$$"8N!
• 83" 21 2"8$ $ "8N $ 2%8" 18
13 8" $ 8$ %8" ""
#$977!2"$%1%14$λO=&7 $9)*
"8N "4$ $ ! % $ 88""
$$$3a7L&*9""1"48-98
56%U=V9
$>$*'
2"4J118
"$9 77 " 11 6 8$ 8$4 "
71417"8$&0@G(]1*95#$181
8$92 1"5$3$U=!G'@G0V9
$81 18! 1$ $" 2182$$3
%189 $3!2$"8$P(]1!1$$"$
$%#$136!$3$151#$"1&G5$.
68#$
$35"#$
%8"
$3%8"1
$88
!X!"8$
68#$
$35"#$
%8"
$3%8"1
$88
!X!"8$
$$'#
0(
P((L * $ $ 4 819 #$ &$3 ""* "
"#$1! 8$ 8"8" 11 $3 1"#$17 &4 9=9>*9
$ 7%" ; $ %"1" $ $88 81 $ "71 8
85"8N9
"1 $ $3$ 7 8$$ "8 4 87
%8"1 8"" 7 $ 9G(9 2"5 $" $ $ 8 #$
"8;22$411"#$98";2$8$
8&%!*9$!" 184188
H $ #$9 8$ 8 " " ; 2$! $
$ 75 8 &%! *9 2$ 2$ 8 11 "488" 8 9
"H812%"$3$$#$9
771"3"!$1$"71"213#$@71;
$4$ ""9 $ "71" #$ $ ; 213
#$@7181 "1 $3$ $ 8 2" $
719
- $9G(D87%8"11$$3$$#$
713$88#$71$187"
U=!G0VD ( ) G
55
vG
PG
i
=
( −
= 4 !1$2$ $$3&*v!77$$35!"8$$$3&1*5!"8$$71&1*!$3$$#$&1*
%
""!
H
)
" $$18
% H
775$$1"#$
$88"5
13&%!*
8$"81&1$H*
A11"#$
%
""!
H
)
" $$18
% H
775$$1"#$
$88"5
13&%!*
8$"81&1$H*
A11"#$
$$'#
0G
71$43#$$418D
• "717"1!
• "8$$$3$71841"
8#$&5!5qq $$$3q $$$$3*773
" "!
• $3"8N51 6!88688"""#$
"!
• 2"8$$4J1734$$3&5qq5*9
71$"$181"$1"$!2$8
4$ $1"#$#$2$84$ "1"#$9778
8"!2$11$4$8$4#$#$H
8$99"H"7$14"71$!#$2$
6 "1"#$ &l* $$ $ 4 $8 @"" "1"#$
11UG0V971$6$4D
∆=<
−− ==
=== gG(gG( α
4! $$#$&1*
88&la=O5*4$=!=!2$11&∆*0_9$213
%8"!""4"7"#$887"$;4$9
2$ "71 $" 7 $ 9GG 81 "1 $
8"$$4J1D
- $9GGD"4"71$#$7$ "#$4
$>$>!) 5)
77" 5#$ "" 1 8 $ $ "$ 8$
"1 2"8$ 719 8161"5! 15! ;
18& " 7*
$ 2%& 87*
"8N
$$'#
0=
1$77"5$$$7$"8N$$38" "8
"8N;22$8716&$7*98"1$2
'(19
5#$ 8 $ 2 8#$ 71! $3
%8"1 299! 8 2#$ " 8#$ %@$ ; 2 2$
885168#$ 1&A 0(((*92<$14$
%8"1416 5"#$"488"8-9 UGPV$$ 3
81"1 $8#$$"8N#$"8$9
$21371!$N2"8$" 1""77$"4
+$76$8$9
$>$B" )5)% )
UG/@=(V
8$ " G)P) 4 +$ U=(V! 88 218" & *
B$8$""51#$9 5#$
; 88#$ $ 7 73 18$ $$ 2$ 8
7121$8$3$61"51#$9
8""81 $3$2""9
$>$B$
218"2$61"#$88$K88#$"
&a(%8&w** $ $ 1$" &a(%8&wdx**9 $% $K$%!
218" $ $ 18% " $ 1$ jMj 85 x
"8$!11@$!""D
TMTMT1&M*&M**&*&
*M& +=+==ωωω
4&M*!8"218"&Ω*1&M*!818%218"&Ω*9
"8""D
$$'#
0>
w
y
My
w(
w
w(
x
w
y
My
w(
w
w(
x
w
w(
x
x
M2
@M22Mω(
d
O=
( (ω ωωωω
xMTMT
xMMTMTTMT
x
*T&MT*&MT&M*1&M*M =====
=
=
=
+=+=
1$53$18"$8#$ &7 $9G=*$
$ 8 + &7 $ 9G>*9 8 #$ ! 8$ "51! $
86U@1&M*a7L&M*V98+8"42 $1 85
x&w* $1$ jM&w*j 7 $ 51 "1 7"#$ $
79
- $9G=D 11218"$8#$$"#$8UG/V
- $9G>D 11218"$8+UG/V
1$ 218" 2$ 61 "51#$ 86 $
"#$9!83"18$3218"8$
"$8618"#$189 11""!218"
""118"4$D
=
ω=ω
G *&M*&M
$864$D
=
ω=
ω
G
*&M
G
*&MG
$$'#
0'
18 ""1 "" "! 8
2$97 $9G'$ 11218"8#$
77" 18 ""19 " 86 $ 18 $#$1
"9"#$! 4$ 218" "8 7"#$$
79$ "K8"$18 1 94$
218" 1 $ "8 4@;@4 7"#$ $ 7
1$9
- $9G'D 11218"18"#$""1
8#$!218"2$$"#$18"2$"
2$ $ 86 $ 1@9 $ "#$ 8""
7 $9G=86$18"""8$1@""2%
1 9 " $88"2$""4$
869 61 "51#$ 18 8 $<$ 11
""1 18 "$% 18"9 28$ #$ "51
"" $ $4$ 18 ""1 #$ " 77" 85"16
"51#$D 51& *9 181"$8
$1@#$28"$2%" 11#$8$$
$ 869218"$"D
*&<G
*&Mω
=ω 4!816$ &-*!%8$ &(YYG*
2 " $1@4$D=z
m = 9
2$ 18 ""1 ""1 88$ $ 181 $
4$ " 7 4 1"1 77$ &S3$ ! S3$
-Im(Z
)/
Re(Z)/0
R
=*&ω
R-Im
(Z)/
Re(Z)/0
ωω
G*& =
C
-Im(Z
)/
Re(Z)/0
ωω =*&
L
-Im(Z
)/
Re(Z)/0
R
=*&ω
R
-Im(Z
)/
Re(Z)/0
R
-Im(Z
)/
Re(Z)/0
R
=*&ω
R
=*&ω
RR-Im
(Z)/
Re(Z)/0
ωω
G*& =
C
ωω
G*& =
CC
-Im(Z
)/
Re(Z)/0
ωω =*&
L
ωω =*&
L
$$'#
00
1"!I *9"$! $"8$"88""
2"9"#$!18""17$%"8
3"$$589
218"2"5!83"1
88""$#$O$"#$9$$4" #$
2$"""88#$71$$4D
7$gG
=σ "1"#$
4i!$4"2"&91@G*!
!"2"&Ω*9
2%8$7$ "1"#$"8$977!4$"8
$1$$"9
$>$B$ )
%77"8$"61"51#$^;
$%$"!112$7 $9G09
- $9G0D ;$%"1"#$&*!1"#$&3*;"&*
$1$
$ ; $% " 8" $ $ 7 $ 1"#$ $
1"#$9 871$$4188$"1
88"" 4$1#$ 2"5! 11 $4" 2"9
1 1"#$$"$%"81J1$79!
7 B 2 2" 2"59 ! 2$
11$ "1$7$ "1"#$&7* $4"$97 $
1"#$!$ 2"8$!3"$$77" 18
"4
@"
(a) (b)
"4
""7"
@"
(c)
"4
@"
(a) (b)
"4
""7"
@"
(c)
$$'#
0P
$7 $% "9 2" 41 8 1 $ 7
18$3$11"#$$8$#$9 87!7$
"1 $7 2"5 2" ; 2 2$18
8#$9 $ 8$J 77$" $ 4$ $7! "8$ $
21$7$ "1"#$$9
$ B 88"" $! " "1
2%8$7$ "1"#$944871$1
89#$1 $"1"#$!%8D
7a4!2"8$2"5&1*!$72"&1=*9
1 1"#$!2%8$7$ "1"#$D
$72"1";$856D=
G7
π= !
$7""11$#$D=
7π= 9
1 ; " $" 8$ " 85"16 $%
"9$882$$$$ 7$$8$3
9$42"4$$"4$"
"7"77$"!#$811"$89
$>$B$! & ))) )/8"
$"51#$"$"$"2181$4D
=!"&*O"O"&*!=
7 $ 9GP 8" 11218"2$"173$
8#$! $ #$88B 51 7"#$$
79$"#$"#$4$12"$
"$%$ 869811@!8$1
5$ 7"#$! 7 $% 88"" 6#$ $ 1"$9 2 4
2%"81"1" 2"91@
8$137"#$"277< 9
=@G " $$1"$94$ G=6;
$$'#
0/
$4" #$ 2"9 1 6 3 7"#$ $
85"16$%"9
- $9GPD 11218"8#$2$8, 77$";=)(L U=GV
$>$B$!5()
4!$%$1$""18"9816
1 %8"1 $ ; ! #$ $" $% "
1"#$8 $7 $ 89 87 "
" 56 9,$3 U=GV9 $!1 8 $,! $
1 ;$%"$1"#$8!$7
G1=9 87 11"8 ""! $" 7 $ 9G/! 1$2$
21" H #$ 77 83" 7 1$ $ $ 1856
N"9$%"1"$$$887%$12$8
$ $ $88 #$! 13! 218$ 1" 8 $ $
12"5$%"#$2$8#$
8$ 77" %8"9 1 2"5 8$4 %" $
#$GP11169$8"$$3"1#$&7 $9G?*
$<$$"5""21856$87$1$%"$9
8$$3! $2"5!$$7$$3$#$
18"$8$G=((L 9
D
-B
>
m m:
- !
-: ! :
ElectrodesElectrolyte
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Zr (kΩ)
Z i (k
Ω)
Grain Joint de grain
R grain R joint de grain
G=
m m: m m:
- !
-: ! :
ElectrodesElectrolyte
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Zr Ω)
Z i
Ω)
hautes fréquences Grain
basses fréquencesJoint de grain
très basses fréquences
R grain R joint de grain
G=
D
-B
>
m m: m m:
- !
-: ! :
ElectrodesElectrolyte
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Zr (kΩ)
Z i (k
Ω)
Grain Joint de grain
R grain R joint de grain
G=
m m: m m:
- !
-: ! :
ElectrodesElectrolyte
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Zr Ω)
Z i
Ω)
hautes fréquences Grain
basses fréquencesJoint de grain
très basses fréquences
R grain R joint de grain
G=
R grain
CPE grain
R joint de grain
CPE joint de grain
R grain
CPE grain
R joint de grain
CPE joint de grain
$$'#
0?
- $9G/D1812"5- $9G?D $1$
87 " ; $ $ "8 7"#$ 1#$
G=P(98 1171#$&1*!"488"8""!$$8
18"$ $ 7$ #$ 2#$ " 2$9 7
1$ "!"188218"""4
M4W=9/""3!9
$ 1$ " 8" $ $3 H 51"#$ 4@;@4
21856 %"$ &7 $ 9G?*! 83 N 241
H$%2"59"2$1856N"""$$
818"51#$;% 6 UG/!==V9 $"2$ $3M $4
8 $ 8 $ 213 $79 $3 #$ $ H
$4;2"$2$7$$3$$7%"$429
18"$$ 7$ $7711 188$#$ 5$51#$ "8
2" #$ $ $% " " 3! 288 2$
84 @" &7 %"$ $ * 2" 4
&7"$$ H*84#$1 2% 624 H
&51$ H % 6*91312% 6 """!
882% 6!$-2%8$4D
'-g
= =
4= !1312% 6""!
!$18"&*!
!188&*!
-!-a)P0(( 9
H"5
$3$1
<
H"5
$3$1
<
"5
1" H
$887%
$8813
d$$
"
$$
51$8
"5
1" H
$887%
$8813
d$$
"
$$
"5
1" H
$887%
$8813
d$$
"
$$
51$8
$$'#
0)
"! "3 H & 95@G* ; 2"$ $ $3! 7
12% 6 H"8$4D
'==-'
'==%-'%
(
=
=
++
=
4=% !712% 6 H!
(=
% !712% 6 H!
-!-a)P0(( !
!"3$ H&95@G*!
!$18"&*9
H8$$"!2 !6 8$"9188"
3$ 9G9 87 8" 8 7$! 71 2% 6
H8$J""11$9
18$",H $"&_*
$ $&8811*
&85 H=*
))!)))) ==
=
1 =
=
q(!0q(!>q(!Gq(!Gq(!Gq(!Gq(!G
3$9GD 18$ H$"8$"21856N"
$B"
58 " ; 8" 5#$ 1 F$4 8$
2"3 " 719 8$4" 5#$ 1 "
"41"558$"4J19 5#$
8$ 81 56 18" 1"#$ $ "1#$ ; 8 3
1"#$9 2<$ $ H "7 &=* 8$ 8$3 "8N 7
$$'#
P(
88B 3"9 8" 8$4" 5#$1 "
#$18$13"""%8"9
5 5#$ " #$ &77 E!
+!!I *$"8$2$5!$8$6""8";
8" 27"1" 8#$ 1 &99*! 88
218"&99 *!1$2"8$719299$
5#$"488"$$ 3#$81277$$N @$
"1 88"" 8#$ 719 $ 88"" "51#$
"1"8 9211823<7"
717"8$45#$1$49
$$'#
PG
$-5 & 9 UGV :@:9+!5#$2 "$!GP0/U=V -98!562!=((G!U>V 9$!9 !9,!9H!4J11$7!5#$41&G)))*! >00@>?=9U'V 9+|X4|!9+ ! 9!9 !5-1=P(!&G))0*!G?G@G?PU0V 9+! 9-H!$7 5 !?P@?/!&G))P*!/==@/=/UPV 99A4!94! 935H! :995!95W!A$$1!'P!&G))0*!/=>@/=)U/V +9$!562!G))'!U?V 97!$7 5 !G=/!&=(((*!=(>@=G?U)V 95X!953!:951H$!91!5-1!=?G@=?=!&G))P*!=G>@=G/UG(V 9+!9! -9 ! 9 -H! $7 5 ! GGP@GG)!&G)))*!/=G@/=PUGGV 9+!9!-9! 9-H!$7 5 !G'(!&=((G*!==0@=>(UG=V 9W!9+!!GG!&=((0*!G=(@G=0UG>V 9+!2$4"@"!=((=!UG'V ,9,9! 757!?=!&G)()*!G/=@G//UG0V 9"H!$7 5 &$8*UGPV -9!9 !9+! 9-H!5-1&8"*UG/V 9"8!9$!9-3!:9-$!911$!9fH!93!:99$#$!51!,3!+=?P??>''//UG?V 9, !56$4"$!=((>!UG)V 2$1"51"1#$!!,@,!,3U=(V :99+$!:$75 517!>(!&G)P)*!=P0/@=P/(U=GV 9,$3!56 @4"P!&=(('*
$$'#
P=
U==V9A$%!11$84"
# "
P>
2)
58"
$;/!5() 1) &:::::::::::$$$D-
$;$;/) ::::::::::::::::::::::$D-
9G9G9@ 3M@&?'@GP*_999I I I III 999I I I IIIIII 99PP
9G9G93@ 3M@&?(@=(*_9I I I IIIIIIIIIIIII 999P?
9G9G9@$$4"71839P)
$;$*/5 ::::::::::::::::D=
$;$>/55 ) :::::::::::::::$<D
$*/!5() 1() &::::::::::$$<=
$*$;/") 5() (::::::::::::+;
$*$*/ 5)5 :$$+B
$*$>/!E5 ) :::::::$$+D
$*$B/ A)::::$$$$$=;
$>/"::::::::::::$$$:::::::::::$=<
$B/5 & 9 ::::$$$::::::==
P'
$$$'(
P0
58";8""$%8"1$%2"
"7"- 92 H3";2$19 584"
#$89816%8"$"5"3"415;$
1 "9"5 5"" 4 15;$%1 " $8"
89 7! 8 85 $ "7"
33 85#$$#$288$"$%8"1$%9
$;!5() 1) &
$;$;)
"$ ; "1 8" $ 2$ 3" $ " 1
8$4"! 18 81 3 "3 2% 6 " 8$
232$18"51"#$9
4$%56+9$UGV$$3!$562%
H$1;82$31"#$!1"4#$" $$
81 2"4 288 23" "#$ $ " 1 8$4"9
4J1H""3"88$4"5#$1 "
"43$$$$8$";17"#$4$18a
=( ] $ 18 77aG( ]9 816 "5 $4D "3
2 &* >( 1! 2" "5 &* 4$ (!0 9 7 $ 9G
8"2"4$8;2"$2$4$
3#$"32% 6$ 1948$92
8 85"16 23" 1 ; $% " 58 9
816"5 " "16;N61&M@*@9
816 " 2%8" "" 1" 4 $ 3 H$1 8$
81983615"$8""1 "2882$
2"8$$"57$89711
!4J1""""$148$77"
4 " 8""119 "$ #$ #$
251 """"8$$5B#$$ 1$"1
$$$'(
PP
4 "8N9 7$ " $ 181 4 "8N
51 """ "8$ 719 &@* GG( 11 $ $
51 """"8$434"8N1834"8$
55"9
- $9GD4$8"5 7$"32% 6$
5%$3 $"8$%49816"
7#$857$""!#$B$$11)_9
"8NU=@>V948""8$4"9T"1!
8$&4*!77"8$H$1T$19!4
"$ U'@0V! 77" $ 3 $" T"3
4J1"431"#$DM@&?'@GP*_9M@&?(@
=(*_9
$;$;$ " H/G?+B/;D@T $
$ 81 18! " "1 "3 2% 6 81
8$ 56 $ 18" &M=*G@%&=>*%9 1 8 2999 81
21 8 "39 2"4$ 1 $ 71 $
8"82"$! 7#$2% 6$#$"
$77 8$ 5" $ 18" 8! 1861 %" 88"
F51"#$ 8 3$ 9 $ 7 $ 9=! 88B #$ "3
81=!P;=!/19
"32% 6&1*
&A
*
310
315
320
325
330
335
340
345
0 1 2 3 40,52
0,53
0,54
0,55
0,56
0,57
0,58
0,59
tensionpression
&
*
"32% 6&1*
&A
*
310
315
320
325
330
335
340
345
0 1 2 3 40,52
0,53
0,54
0,55
0,56
0,57
0,58
0,59
tensionpression
&
*
$$$'(
P/
- $9=D4$18$$715"";82$3M@&?'@GP9_*
7$18"8N8$77""32% 6
2 8 77 E &7 $ 9>* 71 5""
8""#$2$$$$3#$;7"&7*9
2 85 7$ H9 23 $$ 7 #$
#$"8$778$385$5"8$288
#$2"8$- 9
- $9>D77 11E""4$53&ta(!G//?)1*$$
7%'L2$71&M=*G@%&=>*%"3"4$3M@&?'@GP*_9
$ B $ 3 #$ $" 8$ 2"$! $
8 1 $4 4 3 M@ &?(@=(*_ 99 18 3
$ $%1$4$ 88 218" 5 8$
2"$9
=!) =!? *I< *ID =!0 =!'11"
18$99
"32% 6
&1*
(!?
(!?0
(!)
(!)0
G
( G0(( >((( '0(( P((( /0(( )(((
=!) =!? *I< *ID =!0 =!'11"
18$99
"32% 6
&1*
(!?
(!?0
(!)
(!)0
G
( G0(( >((( '0(( P((( /0(( )(((
(
>(((
P(((
)(((
G=(((
G0(((
>( P( )( G=(
&GGG
*
&==(
*
&>GG
*
&>>G
*&'=(
*
&'==
*
=θ &L*
"$99
&=((
*
(
>(((
P(((
)(((
G=(((
G0(((
>( P( )( G=(
&GGG
*
&==(
*
&>GG
*
&>>G
*&'=(
*
&'==
*
=θ &L*
"$99
&=((
*
&GGG
*
&==(
*
&>GG
*
&>>G
*&'=(
*
&'==
*
&GGG
*
&==(
*
&>GG
*
&>>G
*&'=(
*
&'==
*
=θ &L*
"$99
&=((
*
$$$'(
P?
(!?
G
( G((( =((( >((( '((( 0((( P((( /(((
1 1"
18$99
>!0 >IB >!> >I* >!G > "32% 6&1*
(!?
G
( G((( =((( >((( '((( 0((( P((( /(((
1 1"
18$99
>!0 >IB >!> >I* >!G > "32% 6&1*
$;$;$ " H/G?+,/*,@T $
1$"#$;18"8$3
M@ &?'@GP*_9977""32% 6 " $ $ ;$$3
2999 8"4 4J1 8 &7 $ 9'*9 $ 77$
4J1 8! "32% 6$">!'>!=1&7 $9'*9
$$13$"8$"$8"$;816
39! 8"" "! $ $1 " $77 8$ 3
857$9853$718"" 1"#$2$
$$7&7 $90*9
- $9'D4$18$$4J15""4$3M@&?(@=(9_*
7$18"8N8$77""32% 6
- $90D77 11E""4$53&ta(!G//?)1*$$
7%'L2$71&M=*G@%&=>*%"3"4$3M@&?(@=(*_9$"3
2% 6>!'1
=( '( P( ?( G(( G=(
&GGG*
&=((*
&==(*
&>GG*
&===*
&'((*
&>>G*
&'=(*
&'==*
?$ $@
*U ?O@=( '( P( ?( G(( G=(
&GGG*
&=((*
&==(*
&>GG*
&===*
&'((*
&>>G*
&'=(*
&'==*
?$ $@
*U ?O@
$$$'(
P)
$;$;$' 5 )
1$$4"77$"$4J1"8"$$
%3&'>(*8$$%$3487$ !$
7 4 18"$9 1 81 8 "1 8""1
$4"! $ 18 71 1J1 "8$ &/0( 1* 77$"
7$"98218"1$$3$4
; $5 8 #$ &7 $ 9P9*9 8" $ 11
25"$$ 51"72418"$&7 $
9P93*! "46#$ "8N 5"" 4 318H/G?+B/;D@T $
1"79$$2"$!$3$"8$
""8N9
- $9PD&* 11#$ ";>0?L 2$71M"3"$$8(!P
!$"(!08"$3M@&?(@=(9_*9 517"#$18"
8"$7 $9&3* 1125"$$ 51"724
18"$91$""487$ !$!$$ 1118"$
>((;'0(L 9$3$%3&'>(*92"8$71M/0(
18$4J1"3"4318M@D&?'@GP_9*&?(@=(_9*
$;$*5
2"4$17$18"8N&7 $9/*!8$$
71"""1"2"$8"1! 742$
4J18!1861%"9
=
>
'
0 1 2 3 4 5 6M2&gG(= Xb*
0
1
2
3
4
5
@M22&gG(
=Xb
*
(a)
=
>
'
0 1 2 3 4 5 6M2&gG(= Xb*
0
1
2
3
4
5
@M22&gG(
=Xb
*
=
>
'
0 1 2 3 4 5 6M2&gG(= Xb*
0
1
2
3
4
5 =
>
'
0 1 2 3 4 5 6M2&gG(= Xb*
0
1
2
3
4
5
@M22&gG(
=Xb
*
(a)
(
G
=
>
'
0
P
/
) GG G> G0 G/ G)
10000/T(K)
Log(
R/o
hm)
71&3?'@GP*
71&3?(@=(*18"$71@-
/((L ? @
(
G
=
>
'
0
P
/
) GG G> G0 G/ G)
10000/T(K)
Log(
R/o
hm)
71&3?'@GP*
71&3?(@=(*18"$71@-
/((L ? @
$$$'(
/(
- $9/D4$1$71M7$18"8N8$$"3
2% 6=!P1$$8(!0)
17$"32 815""8N8$$ 11
8(!=0;'92<$11$%8"129998$
16 5"#$"488"8-9 UPV6$% $8#$ 719
772%2137118$ 11(!=9G(@>;
G(@>9$718!7"#$$31$ 14
4 "8N 18$ B 4 2 "7 &* $ 4J19
1117 $9?!4"8NB42$ 18
<$#$2;4(!P9" 2 "74 2$ 1
84 742$$ 18"$719 85"16
71"88+$76$8$71"3"$(!0)'
&7 $9)*9$$"4$$$!1$$O$
18$719
- $9?D4$17$18"8N8$71M"3"$
77"84;82$3M@&?'@GP_9*
(!P
(!?
G
( =((( '((( P((( ?((( G((((
(!0) (!' (!=0
(!0) a=!(' (!=0 a=!(/
(!' aG!))
)
)E?@
(!P
(!?
G
( =((( '((( P((( ?((( G((((
(!0) (!' (!=0
(!0) a=!(' (!=0 a=!(/
(!' aG!))
)
)E?@
(!0) a=!(' (!=0 a=!(/
(!' aG!))
)
)E?@
(!P
(!?
G
( =((( '((( P((( ?((( G(((()E?@
)
(!P
(!?
G
( =((( '((( P((( ?((( G(((()E?@
)
$$$'(
/G
- $9)D 85+$76$8$71M"8";(!0)'$%'>(
18 71! "1" 8 1 "#$ !
8" 8 2"4$ 74 7 8 4 &7 $ 9G(*9
"84@;@4871$%2"177$
M8$4""8 2 !$7 $7377"11#$
U?V9 88 8$ 1#$ $% ""14$(!G?!4$4
3$%8"%8"1869
- $9G(D;1"#$ 1871M7
84
213715""$$$$3#$;7"
H &7 $ 9GG*9 $$ $ 11 8$ 743 ;
$2% 6U=!)V981"$5#$8$3
#$ 77 E 8$ "1 $$ H9 $
7 $9G=! 233"#$;G/(1@G!G)(1@G =P(1@G8$
'(
P(
( G = > '(
=(
( G = > '
T $
&*
_9 T $H
T $G
'(
P(
( G = > '(
=(
( G = > '
T $
&*
_9 T $H
T $G
$$$'(
/=
711#$!;P'(1@G8$71#$#$!713
71 $3#$ 11 "1" 8 77 E UG(V9 ! 4
$;1@5$$877E! 4J1"8";(!'
(!0) 8" $ 8$ 18 #$ $% "3" ; 8
$8"$&='*;6738&(!=0*9
$8877734"8E!$"$$
"" ""9 $ 71 4 $ 8 1! 8$ $ "$8"
7 13$$$ 18!77$"8$8"8"5
8$98"2$%$$ 1177"#$
$ 71 "3" ; (!0) &7 $ 9G>9* "46 #$ $"
! $ $% 5"" ; (!=0 &7 $ 9G>9* ; ' &7 $
9G>9 * #$ 1 $% $! 77 8 9
11 "46 8$ $ 77 %$! 85"16 " 1 34" 8$ 71
"3" $ $8 '9 $ 73 " 88 ; $$
#$#$34"$7 $9G>99 8573882
8""1"44$5#$"&E*9
71#$213"51<1$
$$791 77131#$2"5"3"
;(!=018!8$" 1"#$!#$
$%$4J19 8!$%"5!
% $ 77" 1$$ D 4J1 ; (!0) $"
1 !#$2"5;'86 3$$88$89
277%$8$715""$8(!0)'3$";
185 98$! 8" 218 #$ 8
41$9 4 234$+$ 76 $8$ &7 $
9)*!#$1"42$ 118"$4J1#$8
41$9
$$$'(
/>
- $9GGD77 11E""4$53&ta(!G/??)1*$$
7%'L8$71M5""$77"84
- $9G=D8$71M"3"$$8(!0)9"
"4$3<7g0(86=$1$G=($4&ta0G'!?>1*2$
2 2$8$=(1S9
) ?)/;@
inte
nsit
(uni
tar
bitr
aire
)
( =(( '(( P(( ?(( G((() ?)/;@
inte
nsit
(uni
tar
bitr
aire
)
( =(( '(( P(( ?(( G(((
&GGG* &==(* &>GG*&=((* &===*
>( '( 0( P( /( ?(
,I*-
,I-=
*
,IB
B
$3
$3
*U ?O@
? @
&GGG* &==(* &>GG*&=((* &===*
>( '( 0( P( /( ?(
,I*-
,I-=
*
,IB
B
$3
$3
*U ?O@
? @
>( '( 0( P( /( ?(
,I*-
,I-=
*
,IB
B
$3
$3
*U ?O@
? @
$$$'(
/'
- $9G>D 1177"#$3$$"5M5"";(!=0
&*!(!0)&*'& *91 7H8841&3*!&*!
&5*1 713&*!&7*&*9
8"8#$1$"51#$&7 $9G'*
81 $$%3$92"8$1@ 7 $1
5$7"#$4@;@4218$$ 7!#$$@4G((
;>((1A!8; "82"9 $7"#$7"$;G(((
H;''(L ! 1$8$3"8218$$ !#$ $ "8
"UG>V91"$%8178"$1$%3$
4;2"8#$UG=V9!$$1"49
181"8$1"$%$% 1"#$$8$71
&GGG*
&>GG*
&G(=*
&==(*&=((*
&GGG*
&>GG*
&G(=*
&==(*&=((*
&GGG*
&>GG*
&G(=*
&==(*&=((*
&GGG*
&>GG*
&==(*&=((*
&GGG*
&>GG*
&==(*&=((*
&GGG*
&>GG*
&==(*&=((*
&GGG*
&>GG*&==(*&=((*
&GGG*
&>GG*&==(*&=((*
&
&GGG*
&>GG*&==(*&=((*
&GGG*
&>GG*&==(*&=((*
&
&GGG*
&>GG*&==(*&=((*
&GGG*
&>GG*&==(*&=((*
&
$$$'(
/0
41 73 "8$ U'! G>V9 4$ " 7
18"$ 8"$ 1125"$8$ 5#$ 4J1 &7 $
9G0*9 $ 213 71! 2"4$ " $ $ 25"$9
2" 2417"48"$71!4849
4$$8"$$%""$4$4G!=;G!/
AU'!G'V9
- $9G'D 11#$$71M5"";'7218$$
78$$18"$''(L 91$""41 $ D$!4
GG88"$$$3%3&'>(*9 517"#$8"
$ 119
- $9G0D 51""8NM72418"$9
$77$"41 $ !$!GH;GH4GG88"!18$
$ G((1A!$$3%3&'>(*9
'!0
0
0!0
P
P!0
/
/!0
?
?!0
G= G=!0 G> G>!0 G' G'!0 G0 G0!0 GP GP!0 G/
V ,I-= W ,IB
X B
Y ,I*-
;,,,,J?Z@
LogR
()
'!0
0
0!0
P
P!0
/
/!0
?
?!0
G= G=!0 G> G>!0 G' G'!0 G0 G0!0 GP GP!0 G/
V ,I-= W ,IB
X B
Y ,I*-
;,,,,J?Z@
'!0
0
0!0
P
P!0
/
/!0
?
?!0
G= G=!0 G> G>!0 G' G'!0 G0 G0!0 GP GP!0 G/
V ,I-= W ,IB
X B
Y ,I*-
;,,,,J?Z@
LogR
()
H ?R;,- )@
/H
?R;,
-)
@
V ;,,)4
W *,,)4
Y >,,)4
B
>>
>
( 0 G( G0 =( =0 >( >0
=(
GP
G=
?
'
(
H ?R;,- )@
/H
?R;,
-)
@
V ;,,)4
W *,,)4
Y >,,)4
B
>>
>
( 0 G( G0 =( =0 >( >0
=(
GP
G=
?
'
(
$$$'(
/P
(
G
=
>
'
0
P
/
G= G' GP G? =( ==G((((O&f*
-
L &H*
: UG0V
,UG0V ,IB ,I*-
~ ,I-= B
(
G
=
>
'
0
P
/
G= G' GP G? =( ==G((((O&f*
-
L &H*
: UG0V
,UG0V ,IB ,I*-
~ ,I-= B
$ 7"#$ % 81 B 1"1
$14J1& $< *UGGV98"
$ 11 5$ UGP!G/V 4$ 7"#$ % 71
5"" 2$ 113 7" M >!P 11 2"8$! $" 11
"7"!72418"$UG0V!8""$7 $9GP9
7"#$ % " $ 1@ 5$ 7"#$ 8 ;
3$ $ 1"$ & * 8$ "8N "3" $ 73 89
2$ 1 8 4 74 $ 8 < 9
2"4$ 7"#$ % $ 71 5"" ; ' 85
3$ < "1#$ 7"9 34 1$
"#$ 4 1$$9 2$ 1 8 4
$ ; $ $$ 8$ 8$ 8$! #$ 8" 8 "#$ 8$
2""13#$&< *9
- $9GPD 18$ 517"#$%71M7
2418"$487">!P112"8$UG0V9$3$4
1 $ !$!GH;GH4GG88"!18$$ G((1A!$
$3%3&'>(*9
$;$>55 )
88"""#$813$#$1"11
$9 77! $4" #$ $8 4G(( 7 8$
18#$< $118"$71
- UG?V9 " "5 5"" ; 77" 8 1
$$$'(
//
"4#$2$73847418"71$$
8 9 1 8$ $ 1 ! 11
$7< !5"4J1$$$35$92"
88" 8 5$77 B 77$ 4$1 1
9
$4"2"5"3"8$$ 118
(!=0 ; (!P 9 8 %8"1 1J1#$ 8"" " ;
2%8 $ 8@$3 #$ 8" ; $ 18"$ >((L 9 $ ; 1@
5$$8$77 11E$71"8"$$35$8$
73#$4J15"";18"$13&7 $9G/*!#$
$$8$ 9
- $9G/D77 11E7%'L77$"4$53
&ta(!G/??)1*8$71M"8"$$84(!=0$$$3%;
18"$13&*$$$3%5$77";>((L 885"8N&3*
18 71 "" ; >((L ! 3$ 8 88 84
2" &*"$+!182"4$ 744 8
&7 $ 9G?*9 4 34" 1 8" 5#$
18"9 8$! 2$ 8$ 18 11 $ #$7
2""1" 112% 693!"$71;$%3$
8 8 1 "#$ $ 4J1 "" ;
18"$139
>( '( 0( P( /(
$3&GGG*
*U ?O@
? @
&=((* &==(*&>GG*
? @? @
>( '( 0( P( /(
$3&GGG*
*U ?O@
? @
&=((* &==(*&>GG*
? @? @
$$$'(
/?
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0,2 0,25 0,3 0,35 0,4 0,45 0,5 0,55
Zr
Y
O
&*
_9
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0,2 0,25 0,3 0,35 0,4 0,45 0,5 0,55
Zr
Y
O
&*
_9
- $9G?D888842 788$71M
5""$$3;>((L
1$ 218" 81 $ $ $ 3$
11 #$ U'!G>V9 286 8" $ 51 "
7 18"$ &7 $ 9G)*! 71 $4 $ 181 8
5"$9$" 244G;G!0A9 4$1"4"#$
1$";8715""$$35$77"!1"1
$8"$$%" "$94$ "" 11
189 344"$$719
5$77 74 !1$88<
#$ ""13#$9 181 7" 8 8"
7"#$ % 4J1 11 5$ UGP! G/V &7 $
9=(*9 1$ "#$ 7$" 8 18 "8N 1
" 18$185 &18" *9
$$$'(
/)
0
2
4
6
8
10 12 14 16 18;,,,,J?Z@
&8°?
A@
: UG0V
,UG0V
V ,I-= W ,IB Y ,I*-
0
2
4
6
8
10 12 14 16 18;,,,,J?Z@
&8°?
A@
: UG0V
,UG0V
V ,I-= W ,IB Y ,I*-
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
10 12 14 16 18;,,,,J?Z@
&?[
@
V ,I-= W ,IB Y ,I*-
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
10 12 14 16 18;,,,,J?Z@
&?[
@
V ,I-= W ,IB Y ,I*-
- $9G)D4$$ 51"71M5""$$35$&>((L *
72418"$8$77"849$""4
1 $,!$!G(5H;(!GH4GG88"!18$$ G((1A!
$$$3%3&'>(*
- $9=(D 18$ 517"#$%71M5""$
$35$72418"$8441$$
87"UG0V9$""41 $,!$!G(5H;(!GH4GG8
8"!18$$ G((1A!$$$3%3&'>(*
$*!5() 1() &
2 8$4" 17" $ $%1 " %" 8
88 ; 2%$8@"5 &7 $ 9G0*9 5 1 "1"
81234J151 6"8$18$$7
$$$'(
?(
8$ 18 #$ 2$ 2$ 3 $#$ 4 $ $3 7% UG)V9
8$! 8$4"$%377$8$ 7%3"$ 18
71 5""9 8$4" 5#$! 17 "1" $ "$
8$ 28885"1623"$" 18$4"U/V9
$ 81 18! $ 4"7 3" $ 61 "" $4$
87 %8"19 2"4$ $ 8 4 "3
2% 6 $" 7 $ 9=G $ 3 #$ 61 8" $<$ $
18139
- $9=GD4$87$"3 H"78$3
M@&?'@GP_9*8$4""4$"(!08$";=(XH9
" 118"7818$23
8$ $751 683971"5"";82$$3
18"2""111#$414&M*!
27$8$189
251 """4J1"8$"1";2$88""
7"U=(V^"7%!$$"8N7$"8$9
71""5""8$77"$$11"#$9
2"1""1"8$!873!2"8$
1%1$4739!$2$$$88B7;
3!4$" "$$82$&7 $9==*9$7$;1$#$
$ 1!4$#$#$$ 116#$
854$8197"75!16
$#$1$42$ 19
(!PP
(!P?
(!/(
(!/=
(!/'
(!/P
(!/?
( G = > ' 0G0(
G/(
G)(
=G(
=>(
=0(
=/(
=)(
?4
@
?
@
! (&2?)@
(!PP
(!P?
(!/(
(!/=
(!/'
(!/P
(!/?
( G = > ' 0G0(
G/(
G)(
=G(
=>(
=0(
=/(
=)(
?4
@
?
@
! (&2?)@
$$$'(
?G
350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 8000,65
0,7
0,75
0,8
0,85
0,9
0,95
1
7 aG(/0!=1
longueur d"onde (A)
trans
mita
nce
71$&*
350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 8000,65
0,7
0,75
0,8
0,85
0,9
0,95
1
7 aG(/0!=1
longueur d"onde (A)
trans
mita
nce
71$&*
- $9==D4$2"8$4J17
8$4" 3 M@ &?'@GP*_9! 88B #$
81$$%$'@019
$*$;") 5() (
"8N"3"$8(!'(!P487;$3
8" 1$ 88"" "51#$9 7! 4J1 ""
"3" 1J14 $4 "1"159"8$
71"8"8$1J1$"!"1";2$88516&7 $
9=>*!841" ;G(!=P]18$84(!P(!'
9138!85"162%8#$81$
4 8$4" 4 89 4$ $ 77 2% &X*
2 G(@> 8$ $ 719 734$ $ #$ 4J1
8!1861%"92"7&*28$
1 $$ 2 $43^ 4 =!G= ; =!(G9 213 "
8#$"8N4"$U=G@==V9
- $9=>D4$17 $$2
8$715"";(!P&*(!'&3*
350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 8000,65
0,7
0,75
0,8
0,85
0,9
7 a=0?!)01
longueur d"onde (A)
trans
mita
nce
71$&3*
350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 8000,65
0,7
0,75
0,8
0,85
0,9
7 a=0?!)01
longueur d"onde (A)
trans
mita
nce
71$&3*
$3
7$%1"
"8$$71
3 3
8$
81
8
3
%8$3 %8$3 %8$3
$3
7$%1"
"8$$71
3 3
8$
81
8
3
%8$3 %8$3 %8$3
$3
7$%1"
"8$$71
3 3
8$
81
8
3
%8$3 %8$3%8$3 %8$3%8$3
$$$'(
?=
2$$718E8"4$$7
H&7 $9='*971"3"$$8(!'8"#$
&GGG* &==(* #$ 8 77 2"1%1 $$ 7
H9 8$! $ " 8 34" 8$ 4J1! 8 $
18"9 774"<;""34"8$"8N
5"" $ $1J1 8 15 ; $1 " &79 7 $ 9GG*9
1 85 + &7 $ 9=0* 1 #$ 76 $8$ 8$ 8$
18 #$ $ $ "8N 5"" 7 $ ; $1 " &7 $ 9)*9
1784#$"81$#$B2"
8692"8$"1"476$8$&7 $9=0*
43$;2"8#$$719
- $9='D77 11E""$144J$M"3"$$
8(!'(!P;22$77167 $+ +&sO=s*"#$8"2$
53&ta(!G/??)1*
- $9=0D 85$+$76$8$$71M"8";(!P$4
20 30 40 50 60 70 80=s &L*
"
&$9*
&GGG* &=((* &==(* &>GG*
(!'
(!P
20 30 40 50 60 70 80=s &L*
"
&$9*
&GGG* &=((* &==(* &>GG*
(!'
(!P
$$$'(
?>
2
3
4
5
6
7
11 12 13 14 15 16 17;,,,,J?Z@
V ,I-= W ,IB
&?[
@
2
3
4
5
6
7
11 12 13 14 15 16 17;,,,,J?Z@
V ,I-= W ,IB
&?[
@
1J1 #$ 8$ "8N 3$ 4 15 ; $ $ 1 "!
1$ "#$ "" $ %3 & '>(* 4J$ 8" $ $
3$4;2"8#$92"4$$ 51
"72418"$$$85"$71
$%"$8"3&7 $9=P*983184$1$"$
"55""$$37$$35$8$$84
(!P2"8$$71 #$!$%$1$86!8$77"
%8"94$"4"8$73#$8"""5
"3"$$37$1J1 $#$$%"8"$$35$9
77 "#$ 2$ 1 18" 4J1 $ 8
5$77 &"8N $ $3 5$* $ 8 8$ 7 " 86
& 3@$3 8$ $ 15 ; $%1 "*9 "
118$ "8N8$4"" $ 8$ 738 &(!'*9$%778$4
J ; 2 1819 81 " ; 2$ 1 18"
$88$738484#$"88$73"8$
$719"1!2" 241$"48$$%4J1&[
G!P@G!/A*! $ $8"$ $% 4$ H 3" ; 2$1
""$U'!G'V9187"#$%714
7" 8 9 ,$3 UG0V $ 8 7"! 83 "1
1"1 1 1 2 %9 11 1 7 $ 9=/!
$ "" 8 9 1 8 1 8$ 8 #$2$
8N"8< UG?V9
- $9=PD4$$ 51"71M724
18"$9$""41 $,!$!G(5H;(!GH4GG88
"!18$$ G((1A!$$$3%3&'>(*
$$$'(
?'
- $9=/D 187"#$%71M487"UG0V
72418"$9$""41 $,!$!G(5H;
(!GH4GG88"!18$$ G((1A!$$$3%3
&'>(*
4$2884"8$71!2"8$8739
$ 1J1 4! "8N 8$ 7 "8$ &[0]1*
""9$!8361 $ 4J1 88$!
2 8$ 84 2$ 8361 25" $3 71 $
6#$%4925"$"8N8$J1$
8"8"51J1#$8""%8"!8$!
$474"8 "2$"8 #$4 858$4"9
"#$! 8361 1 " ; 8" $
"8N9 834"8 85$49
$*$* 5)5
5 8 $3! 816 88$% 7$
2" 71 #$ 2" "5 1$ D
84!248$1"#$9"1
$"8N3$41"5"58
2$71$187"9"$8"8"$$
2"$7"8N8$71"3"4
1 " %" $ 8@$3 79 3 8! 2$
,UG0V
: UG0V
V ,I-= W ,IB
&8O?A@
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
;,,,,J?Z@
,UG0V
: UG0V
V ,I-= W ,IB
&8O?A@
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
;,,,,J?Z@
$$$'(
?0
1 "2$8@$37%!181%17
$1 "8$4%$1184;2%"$U=>@='V9
$ 81 18! 816 "$" 277 89 "8N
5""$$824(!/0&a(!0d8$=(XH@a'!01*1
$ 181 $9 1%1 18 &[ @?0( *
$4 8 7 31 %" $1 " &7 $ 9=?*9
4$8188$8$4"717"8$9
18 74"8 738 4$
19$11!7$$ 189181
718$4""$88$7#$;$"3"$(!/09
4J1 5"" $ $ 8 G!=' &7 $ 9=?* " 61
18$$8@$3%; 2%"$9 8""1
$ 73 4 2" $ 8@$39 8$!
"#$ 8 8 8 1878$4 5"
"8N$77118$"8$%% 2"5""2884"9
- $9=?D1$71M788$
$'!01$"8"$3(!08$";=(XH
$! $ $4 " "" 77$" $ $ 8 G!=0
74'01!8 81"1"488""
8#$ "8N 8$ #$ 251 """ "8$ 719 11
1 7 $ 9=)!$ '18123$9
816 $" 8 $ 8$ " 71 41 7
"8$9 $ $ 0 1! 5 1 $
8$34@;@4371;"$U=>@
='V9 $ 7"$ ; 0 1! 2$ $ $3
-1,00E+03
-8,00E+02
-6,00E+02
-4,00E+02
-2,00E+02
0,00E+00
2,00E+02
4,00E+02
30 40 50 60 70 80 90
PL=1,24 Pa
PL=0,99
PL=0,74
\ ?'
@
) ?))@
%$1 "-1,00E+03
-8,00E+02
-6,00E+02
-4,00E+02
-2,00E+02
0,00E+00
2,00E+02
4,00E+02
30 40 50 60 70 80 90
PL=1,24 Pa
PL=0,99
PL=0,74
-1,00E+03
-8,00E+02
-6,00E+02
-4,00E+02
-2,00E+02
0,00E+00
2,00E+02
4,00E+02
30 40 50 60 70 80 90
PL=1,24 Pa
PL=0,99
PL=0,74
\ ?'
@
) ?))@
%$1 "
$$$'(
?P
&"81 $ 1%1$1 184 4 2"$ $ 8@$3*
8$ J 84#$" 8 $ 8@$3! 81 277
1 " 1 "$ 11 2 1 86 #$ "8
8$619$481 "$
"1"4838$"4J1"8!
828""887$$"$9
- $9=)D7$$4J1M8$$
84G!=0$"(!08$";=(XH8"$3
$*$>!E5 )
$"4J17"8$!2""5 (!0
4$7"#$8$=(XH!$'1!$"32% 6
=!P1$"32 #$$$8G!=094J1
77""8$5""8"9
2 8 77 E$ "8N 8$ "8 74
$$7$H&7 $9>(*9234$+76$8$!
"8"$$1@?M&1"$2- *!8"$185
18 48$"7$ &7 $ 9>G*92"8$$ 71 8$ "81$" $
8716 '!)]1!4$4 2"8$"1"$
+&7 $9>G*9
-4,00E+02
-3,00E+02
-2,00E+02
-1,00E+02
0,00E+00
1,00E+02
2,00E+02
3,00E+02
4,00E+02
5,00E+02
30 40 50 60 70 80 90
d=5 cmd=4,5 cmd=4 cm
) ?))@
%$1 "
\ ?'
@
-4,00E+02
-3,00E+02
-2,00E+02
-1,00E+02
0,00E+00
1,00E+02
2,00E+02
3,00E+02
4,00E+02
5,00E+02
30 40 50 60 70 80 90
d=5 cmd=4,5 cmd=4 cm
) ?))@
%$1 "
\ ?'
@
$$$'(
?/
- $9>(D77 11E7%'L3$;22$5
3&ta(!G/??)1*2$71M"8"$$1@?M
- $9>GD 85+$76$8$2$71M"8"$$1@?M
""#$"8N""$$ 117"#$G(
H;(!GH4GG88"$18$$7G((1A9
2131$77$"$;8185"#$!>((L;?((L 9
$3$" "8 2" UGGV! 8"$
11 5$ UGP!G/V 7"#$ % 4J1 81
271"11$2%9 1117 $
9>=! 77$ 2 % 1" 8 $ 1"1 $9
181 1 1#$" #$ 8$ 8"" 71! $ 8 $
8 4 8$ 18 8$ $ 56 71 7 "8$!
3$$"9
=s &L*>( 0( /( )(
"
&$9* $3
?;;;@
?*,,@
?**,@
?>;;@
?***@
?>>;@
=s &L*>( 0( /( )(
"
&$9* $3
?;;;@
?*,,@
?**,@
?>;;@
?***@
?>>;@
$$$'(
??
G
=
>
'
0
P
/
G( GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/
,UG0V
: UG0V
G!0]1 '!)]1
G((((O&f*
-
L&
H*
G
=
>
'
0
P
/
G( GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/
,UG0V
: UG0V
G!0]1 '!)]1
G((((O&f*
-
L&
H*
- $9>=D 18$ 115$7"#$%71M
487">!P112"8$9$""41 $,!$!G(
5H;(!GH4GG88"!18$$ G((1A!$$$3@?M
51"72418"$8""
$7 $9>>7$135$77 9""$3
$$1"151#$14"$4$85"$!8
"#$2" 2494$8$718$"8"4$G!G/
8$8161"18"$8$3$%$G!(>A8$
$49 64$85"5"#$H14
3"$$$$3#$&[GA*U'!G'V9$4J18$1!2"
24 "B G!>= ; G!G0 A $ $ 77" 5$77 9
"$%4J1$1J1 $#$8""9
" 61 $8"$ 8$ 71 8$ 1! 4 34
449U=0V$71M"3"81J15#$98$4"
5#$1 "$5#$5"#$32$84$511#$9
7!2"4$1$"#$3$";$1;2"#$3"8N
8$85"1692771 $8$
77 11 E 4 86 1$ &7 $ 9>'* $ $
1 9 234 $ + $ 76 $8$ 1 8
2"4$ 74185 861$218"&7 $9>0*9
$$$'(
?)
&*
&3*
- $9>>D4$"718"$$138$71
MG!0]1&*'!)]1&3*2"8$9$""41 $,!$!G(
5H;(!GH4GG88"!18$$ G((1A!$$$3@?M
- $9>'D77 11E3$4$53&ta(!G/??)1*$$
7%'L4&*86&3*1$218"8$71M2"8$G!0]1
G((((O&f*
&
Ob*
> = G
=
>
'
0
P
/
) G( GG G= G> G' G0
aG!G/A
aG!(>A
G((((O&f*
&
Ob*
> = G
=
>
'
0
P
/
) G( GG G= G> G' G0
aG!G/A
aG!(>A
) G( GG G= G> G' G0G((((O&f*
&Ob
* > = G
B
aG!>=A
K;I;-4
=!0
>!0
'!0
0!0
P!0
) G( GG G= G> G' G0G((((O&f*
&Ob
* > = G
B
aG!>=A
K;I;-4
=!0
>!0
'!0
0!0
P!0
20 30 40 50 60 70 80
&GGG
* M
&=((
* M
&==(
* M
&===
* M
&>GG
* M
&GGG
*
&=((
*
&GGG
*
&=((
*
* ?°@
?$ @
20 30 40 50 60 70 80
&GGG
* M
&=((
* M
&==(
* M
&===
* M
&>GG
* M
&GGG
*
&=((
*
&GGG
*
&=((
*
* ?°@
?$ @
$$$'(
)(
- $9>0D 85+$76$8$4&*86&3*1$218"8$
712"8$G!0]1M"8"$1@?M
86 "#$!$5 1$$$ $4 34"$
4$2!181""#$2%$X$7
" 1$ $ 9 2% $ X "743 $% "$
1$ 218" 4 1 1 $$9 " ! $
1" $ 181 $ 71 34"9 88B #$ " $
4J123388"""#$9"#$!
7$#$ "$"1"13#$ 4$"
3$"42"8181$9
1$$1856N""834$"51#$
1 89 " ""1" 1$ "$$ $ 71 8$
"89 H$"! 2 68$!81 "1$ $8
82% 64G(@/;218569"318"=!G?O59 11
17 $9>P9>/!88"""#$$712"4$84
8 8 2% 69 $ #$ M 3 $ 11
8 #$ $4" 8$1 #$9 8$! 7"#$ %
$1J1 $#$8$1$77$"$9$6!
""1"#$1"11$8 988B!
#$#$882% 618"!1 2%8
$9
$$$'(
)G
- $9>PD4$$ 517"#$%$71M7$ 51
882% 68$$18"$1$7%P((L 9$""4
1 $,!$1856N""";2818"51#$!G(5H;GH
4GG88"!18$$ G((1A!$$$3@?M
- $9>/D4$$ 51"$71M7$ 518
82% 68$$18"$1$7%P((L 9$""41 $,!
$1856N""";2818"51#$!G(H;GH4GG88
"!18$$ G((1A!$$$3@?M9
$*$B A)
2<$ 2$1 3 85 5$ 18"$ H ;
18"$ 139 <$ $% 8! 83 23 85
1#$! #$#$ $ $3#$9 "$ " $ 6 #$ $$
#$#$8"$$4" #$ 2%$8"$; 71
$3#$8$18"$71@- UG(!=PV9
$ 81 18! 7$ "1 "8N 8$ 3
$$#$#$971""43M@&?'@GP*_9$3
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
@/ @P @0 @' @> @= @G ( &8=O8°*
&-
°OH*
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
@/ @P @0 @' @> @= @G (0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
@/ @P @0 @' @> @= @G ( &8=O8°*
&-
°OH*
((!0GG!0==!0>>!0''!00
@/ @P @0 @' @> @= @G (
&O
* &8=O8°*
((!0GG!0==!0>>!0''!00
@/ @P @0 @' @> @= @G (
&O
*((!0GG!0==!0>>!0''!00
@/ @P @0 @' @> @= @G (((!0GG!0==!0>>!0''!00
@/ @P @0 @' @> @= @G (
&O
* &8=O8°*
$$$'(
)=
M9$<$$$1!2"3M@1$
; (!0 8$" ; >> XH 2" $ 3 M 4 (!P ; G 9 1
2"574"8N5#$39"8N
$018$5#$3!$"32 >(1$"3
2% 6P1#$$$8(!P@(!/9
18 71"1"888842 9
$ $1 1$ 4 2$ 1 2" 8" $ 3
H$1 &7 $ 9>?9* 1 $% 2$1 1$ 8 18 8$ 3
85 #$#$ $9 286 -9+$25! 85 #$#$ % 8$ $
1 => =; '_ UG(V9 1$ 1" $3
51 """!$%8"$"$86!$$ $7&7 $9>?93*9
1$8#$711"4#$2"7"B4
1$$ $%2#$ 772% 2G(@> U=G@==V
&7 $ 9>)*9,9, 9 34" $ 181 1 #$ $
4 > ; G= _ 1 U=/V9 45! 9 +$$H 9 34" $
1$ 2 8#$ #$ $ B $ $$ $3#$
U=GV9$!4$2"7"818"U=G@==!=/V
$$"8NU=GV9
&*
- $9>?D71M7882"&*
;2%$8"5&3*
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
0,50 0,60 0,70 0,80 0,90IZrY/IZr
Zr(%
at.)/
Y (%
at.)
?_1=>
'_1=>
$3#$d
$#$
$3#$
$#$$$D
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
0,50 0,60 0,70 0,80 0,90IZrY/IZr
Zr(%
at.)/
Y (%
at.)
?_1=>
'_1=>
$3#$d
$#$
$3#$
$#$$$D
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
20 30 40 50 60 70 80Distance depuis le centre (mm)
at% M
M a(!?M@ a(!0&3*
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
20 30 40 50 60 70 80Distance depuis le centre (mm)
at% MM
M a(!?M@ a(!0&3*
$$$'(
)>
- $9>)D"7&*772%&3*$8$438$71
M72"8"$3H$1
2 8 E 4J1 $ $1 43 &7 $ 9'(*
1 8" 71$3#$ #$2"88#$"$ 3M4$
(!P!8$1#$#$2"3M" ;G9$$
71!77"17Q8"$$$918
88 &7 $ 9'G* 81 7 "$ 3$ 8
E4218"$4J15""4$"$3
M 4 (!/ ; (!) 9 77! 8$ ! 8
"#$ $2$1" $$$3#$#$#$9 $%
5#$ $" " 1"5 " 18#$! 218 $
8 #$ 1 81 2 " 18#$
4$%719!5#$"4""8"85#$#$
"8N 8$4"" 4 $ " (!P $ 3 M &7 $ 9'=*! $$
"" 88 E! 8$ 88$" $
"8N&7 $9'=*91 857&7 $9'=3!!5*713
0
0,5
1
1,5
2
2,5
3
3,5
4
380 430 480 530 580 630 680 730 780
772%&%G(
@>*
$$2&1*
Ma(!P
Ma(!?
Ma(!)
Ma(!/
MaG
1,96
2
2,04
2,08
2,12
2,16
380 430 480 530 580 630 680 730 780 $$2&1*
"7
Ma(!PMa(!/Ma(!?
Ma(!)
MaG
&*
&3*
0
0,5
1
1,5
2
2,5
3
3,5
4
380 430 480 530 580 630 680 730 780
772%&%G(
@>*
$$2&1*
Ma(!P
Ma(!?
Ma(!)
Ma(!/
MaG
1,96
2
2,04
2,08
2,12
2,16
380 430 480 530 580 630 680 730 780 $$2&1*
"7
Ma(!PMa(!/Ma(!?
Ma(!)
MaG
&*
&3*
0
0,5
1
1,5
2
2,5
3
3,5
4
380 430 480 530 580 630 680 730 780
772%&%G(
@>*
$$2&1*
Ma(!P
Ma(!?
Ma(!)
Ma(!/
MaG
1,96
2
2,04
2,08
2,12
2,16
380 430 480 530 580 630 680 730 780 $$2&1*
"7
Ma(!PMa(!/Ma(!?
Ma(!)
MaG
&*
&3*
$$$'(
)'
&7 $9'=!!*1#$71$"8 11
77"#$&7 $9'=!! *8"$77%$719
$ 4$ 2 18! $$ 1#$ 2$ 8 \ J
"98"! 71"3"4$ "G!8$J%8#$"
8 $% 85"169 81 $ 8 5#$ A #$ $ 8
11858123855"#$32$84$
511#$92"71#$8$173"$
8"85HUGV92862"$"$8 859=9=
7177$1;189
- $9'(D77 11E$$ 7%'L4$53
&ta(!G/??)1*4J1M3$8$77""8"$3H$1
- $9'GD8""$71M442$;2 &0G'!0>1*
$$8$=(1S8$77""8"$3H$1
"
&$9*
G(( =(( >(( '(( 0(( P(( /(( ?(( )((132&1@G*
(!P
(!/
(!?
(!)
G
M &*
$3#$
$3#$
#$#$
1#$
"
&$9*
G(( =(( >(( '(( 0(( P(( /(( ?(( )((132&1@G*
(!P
(!/
(!?
(!)
G
M &*
$3#$
$3#$
#$#$
1#$
G(( =(( >(( '(( 0(( P(( /(( ?(( )((132&1@G*
(!P
(!/
(!?
(!)
G
M &*
$3#$
$3#$
#$#$
1#$
20 30 40 50 60 70 80
(!P
(!/
(!?
(!)
G
IZr (A)
=s &L*
"
&$99*
$3#$
$3#$O$
#$#$
1#$
20 30 40 50 60 70 80
(!P
(!/
(!?
(!)
G
IZr (A)
=s &L*
"
&$99*
$3#$
$3#$O$
#$#$
1#$
$$$'(
)0
- $9'=D 1177"#$"5M"3"4Ma(!P&*!
(!/&*G& *91 7H8841&3*!&*!&5*
1 713&*!&7*&*9Ua$3#$!#a#$#$1a1#$V
$ 81 "$! 1" #$ 2" "
841 (!P) &8$" ;=(XH* 8$ 3 M (!>G &8$" =(XH*
8$3M@924J1"46#$888$
1#$M$" ;G>!#$8$13" 85
#$#$ UG(V9 8! 8 81" &7 $ 9'>* 8
E&7 $ 9''9* 8"4 $$1#$93
77" 71 8#$ H"8 181 " 1
2" $ 71 UGV 8$ UG(V9 $ 1$ $%
&'==*&>(=*#
&GGG*&G(G*#&=((*&((=*#&G(=*#&==(*&GG=*#&>GG*&G(>*#
&===*&=GG*#
&'((*&(('*#
&=G>*#&>>G*
&'=(*&GG'*#
&0GG*&(='*#
? @
G((1
? @
G((1
?@
?@
*,,)
&GG(*1&@GGG*1
&=((*1&G=(*1&@=G=*1
&G==*1
&@G>G*1
&@>G=*1
&G'(*1
?&@ ?@
=((1
&'==*&>(=*#
&GGG*&G(G*#
&=((*&((=*#&G(=*#&==(*&GG=*#&>GG*&G(>*#
&===*&=GG*#
&'((*&(('*#
&=G>*#&>>G*
&'=(*&GG'*#
&0GG*&(='*#
0(1
5
0(1
&'==*&>(=*#
&GGG*&G(G*#&=((*&((=*#&G(=*#&==(*&GG=*#&>GG*&G(>*#
&===*&=GG*#
&'((*&(('*#
&=G>*#&>>G*
&'=(*&GG'*#
&0GG*&(='*#
? @
G((1
? @
G((1
?@
&'==*&>(=*#
&GGG*&G(G*#&=((*&((=*#&G(=*#&==(*&GG=*#&>GG*&G(>*#
&===*&=GG*#
&'((*&(('*#
&=G>*#&>>G*
&'=(*&GG'*#
&0GG*&(='*#
? @
G((1
? @
G((1
?@
G((1
?@
?@
*,,)
&GG(*1&@GGG*1
&=((*1&G=(*1&@=G=*1
&G==*1
&@G>G*1
&@>G=*1
&G'(*1
?&@ ?@
=((1
?@
*,,)
?@
*,,)
&GG(*1&@GGG*1
&=((*1&G=(*1&@=G=*1
&G==*1
&@G>G*1
&@>G=*1
&G'(*1
?&@
&GG(*1&@GGG*1
&=((*1&G=(*1&@=G=*1
&G==*1
&@G>G*1
&@>G=*1
&G'(*1
&GG(*1&@GGG*1
&=((*1&G=(*1&@=G=*1
&G==*1
&@G>G*1
&@>G=*1
&G'(*1
?&@ ?@
=((1
?@
=((1
&'==*&>(=*#
&GGG*&G(G*#
&=((*&((=*#&G(=*#&==(*&GG=*#&>GG*&G(>*#
&===*&=GG*#
&'((*&(('*#
&=G>*#&>>G*
&'=(*&GG'*#
&0GG*&(='*#
0(1
5
0(1
&'==*&>(=*#
&GGG*&G(G*#
&=((*&((=*#&G(=*#&==(*&GG=*#&>GG*&G(>*#
&===*&=GG*#
&'((*&(('*#
&=G>*#&>>G*
&'=(*&GG'*#
&0GG*&(='*#
&'==*&>(=*#
&GGG*&G(G*#
&=((*&((=*#&G(=*#&==(*&GG=*#&>GG*&G(>*#
&===*&=GG*#
&'((*&(('*#
&=G>*#&>>G*
&'=(*&GG'*#
&0GG*&(='*#
0(1
0(10(1
5
0(1
5
0(1
$$$'(
)P
2$1!"5""5""4$"(!?8"$3
M(!=$M@!4$7"#$8$0(XH$5#$
39 8 44 G!=0 ;'!0 ! #$ 88 ; 288
2%$$719""1"#$18712"4$
8$184U=?V91783$
<$"32 1"32% 6;P198;=?L
>=L$77 11E7 $9''&3!!*1"4
8"851#$8$77"8$"91$
$ ; 1@5$$ 8 77 &7 $ 9''* 4 2$ 1
84 $$$ 1 9! 85#$#$
3" 8 8 UG(V9 2% 8$N
743;$$1#$9
"#$! " 1 8 $ $4 "
2%8" 8$ 3$ " 4J1 8"
189 $ 7$ 1$ 8 4 O$ 8 8@
$39
- $9'>D8""442$;2 &0G'!0>1*
$$8$=(1S8$71M"3"4Ma(!PGM@a(!>)
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900
132&1@G*
"
&$99*
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900
132&1@G*
"
&$99*
$$$'(
)/
- $9''D77 11E""$$ 7%'L4$53
&ta(!G/??)1*8$71M"8"4Ma(!PGM@a(!>)&*Ma(!?M@a(!=
$$84G!=0&3*!=!0&*'!0&*
$>"
71;3H""5""88$4"5#$1 "
;831"#$H$1H$1"&?'@GP_9*8"
2$ 81 "7 @% 69 " $ $ "5 3
" 18$4"18281"1"381
2% 68$3718!$88"51"#$83$
9213$5"""3"$14!2%3
&'>(*$- &1@?M*9
$ 81 18! 4J1 "" "3" 15 ; $
1 " 4 3 M@9 "8N %18 ! 8" $
351 """"8$$$$$3#$;7"
H92871B484!162
8 27$ $ $ 189 88"" "#$ $4 $ 8
5"$4$" 244G!=;G!/A7
"8N9 4$$8"$;"$&GA*91"11
$ 2 % 8 8$ $5 8$
3$ < 8$ 8$ 1#$" 4 2$ 1
8""8N9N 1 2%8 743
8$288"- !8$8#$2$N8<
20 30 40 50 60 70 80
? @,I<+
? @;I*-
?@*I-
?@BI-
= &°*
"
&$99*
20 30 40 50 60 70 80
? @,I<+
? @;I*-
?@*I-
?@BI-
= &°*
"
&$99*
? @,I<+
? @;I*-
?@*I-
?@BI-
= &°*
"
&$99*
$$$'(
)?
9"8N$$35$1"4218
$5 $ 1$ "#$9 4J1 5"" ;
>((L 8$ #$ $5 "3" ; 2139 $ #$2$
3$$1"$8$1#$"4$" 24G;G!0A8$
854$5"#$#$71"8"$$379
2<$ 2$ 1 " $ $ "$ 8$4" 17"
"8N9251 """"8$181""1
88$ $ 4J19 $ 1"5 !
84 """1"8$11
81"7141"892"74=!GP;G!)P
$1$43772%2G(@>9 4$
4"$9$$718788"""#$
N"8 1$"84@;@45$77
42" 24#$3;GA86>9$ 118
82% 6"!H3";2$11811$$$
8$1#$$$#$#$H28"""3"$4
$% 3 &M M@*^ 1$ $<$ 8" 85 $3#$ 73
88977!$$#$#$7$$1!
&18* 71! 816 81
"8 8""8$4"5#$9 7$8$$48
2"$"$"2%8"8$4"8;69
$$$'(
))
$B5 & 9
UGV +9$!562!G))'!U=V 999+W!!0=!&G))=*!=>@>=U>V 9$H$X!!?G!&G))0*!=GG@=GPU'V 9SH3 !-9H!9fX!9<!9o4! ! GP'! &=((>*!G=G@G=)U0V 9-X!9SX!@ 9+$$!9+7!f9$ !9HX!:$751!?!&=(('*!P=P@P>=UPV -9!9 !9+! 9-H!5-1!&8"*U/V -98!562!=((G!U?V 91HX!f9$! 9 X! :8 :$ 7 88 5! =)! &G))(*!G>('U)V 9 4@77"! 9S3!93! :$ 7 5 $8 1 ! =G!&=((G*!G?(0@G?GGUG(V -9+$25!562,!=((=!,3UGGV 9 ,$3! 9 +! 9 $"! 9 ! 9 +! :$ 7 51!?!&=(('*!P>>@P>/UG=V :99+$!:$75 517!>(!&G)P)*!=P0/@=P/(UG>V 9$H$X!9fX!99!!G0G!&=((=*!GGG@G=GUG'V @ 99 !S@ 9:9S!9! 515!?G!&=((>*!G>'@G'=UG0V 9,$3!56 @4"P!&=(('*UGPV 9+!56,@,3!&G)?(*UG/V 95$!56,@,3!&G)/)*UG?V 9:9AXX!+9:95$!9:9+$ 7!!P!&G)?=*!G0)@G/(UG)V 9W!9+!!GG!&=((0*!G=(@G=0 U=(V 9+!-9!AGG!&=((0*!==@=P
$$$'(
G((
U=GV 9 +$$H! -9 53$! 9 +! :$ 7 5 $8 1 ! G/!&G))/*!G/'G@G/'?U==V 9 + 1! +9 ! ,9 +$! 9 :#$! 9 ! +!0/!&G))?*!=?@>)U=>V 9S9771!:$7A$$15 9!G=!&G))'*!)0>@)PGU='V 9S51! 4W!G/! &G))=*!0'/@0)PU=0V 9f9 44! 9 $5! 99 $! 9 ! 99 : ! -99 5! 999+W!!))!&G))/*!>GG@>G)U=PV S9S88!!0=!&G))=*!G0@=GU=/V ,9,!9- $!99!A99!:93!5-1!>/(!&=(((*!G/>@G/?U=?V 9+!9,$3!9+!9 $"!9 !GG!&=((0*!>(G@>(0
* +++
G(G
Q 2)
() (
4$;/ & ?0 !" @:::::::::$;,>
4$;$;/) ::::::::::::::::::::::;,>
4$;$*/5 ::::::::::::::::::::;,B
4$;$>/5 )2 &%8!":::$$$;,=
4$;$B/55 ) :::::::::::::::;;*
4$;$-/' ::::::::::::::::::::$;;-
4$;$D/F)5 :::::::::::$:::::$$;;<
4$*/) ?3'C@:::::::$::::$$;*;
4$*$;/) ::::::::::::::::::::::;*;
4$*$*/ *'*=:::::::::::$;*>
4$*$>/ ::::::::::::::::;*+
A9=9>9@3@G(_89I I I IIIIIIIIIIIII 99G=?
A9=9>93@3@>_89I I I IIIIIIIIIIIIII G>=
4$>/") 55%GHI0!"3'C$$$;>>
4$B/ %0!"JGH::::::::::::::$;>B
4$B$;/) ::::::::::::::::::::::;>-
4$B$*/5 0!"JGH::::::::::::::::$$;>D
G(=
4$-/":::::::::::::::::::::::$$;B,
4$D/5 & / 4::::::::::$$;B>
$, '(
G(>
%13$%8;$3$M11"
8$ @- 9 $% 2 $% 8"" 4^
" "&, *135&E*986$18
$4$%1"$%4M!$8$68";2"3;
"2$"3$5&, OM*97!$$"9
4$; & ?0!"@
2134J1, "3";82$31"#$
"$1@ $1 &)(@G(_ 9*! 0(11 16 >112"8$! $
1" H$% "7 @% 69 71 "8" $ 1 4!
%3 & '>(*! #$ $ &@?M* 5
& 5"D*- 9
213%8""@$""""415;$1 "9
4$;$;)
$8118!""$$48
"5 4 "3 H "7 $ 8$ "4$ 3" $
" 18$4"$61 @,&7 $A9G*9816"5
1J1#$$%$"8$ 56$5MD$"32 >(
1!$" $";(!0!8$";>>XH&a=(]!77aG(]*!$
GG(119"3!2"4$8
"$ 31 " <$#$2; $ "3 =!0 1 2% 6 &" 1
8$4"""1*9"5 1$31;4
')(A9=!01!$$ 13$8!#$218 2$5$
!34"96186 " 18$4"18"9
"32% 6"!83$1$;G!?19
8" 5! $3 "5 8
8"$5""4"3 H"7$!#$$$3"$
" 18$4"9
$, '(
G('
- $A9GD4$87$"32% 6$8$$"
(!08$";>>XH8"$3 @,&)(@G(_9*
$$"3=!012% 6!1$711$" R;299
2"$8418&7 $A9=*#$"46#$$58!8
"#$ 71 $" % 6! $88" 51"#$9
$4J1$8161823<7
" $5 "89 2$ 1"5 8 2
$3$#$ 4J$8121#$ 71
$!$673$%$%8"1869
- $A9=D4$1$717$18$"32% 68$$
"(!08$";>>XH88#$";3 @,&)(@G(_9*
4$;$*5
71 2"8$4 '0( 1 ; 0!G ]1 "" "3" 4 "3
2 >( 1 2% 6 =!0 1! $ $ 8 (!P 9
$32999&7 $A9>*"#$2$"8N88$7318
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
1,5 1,7 1,9 2,1 2,3 2,5 2,7 2,90,56
0,57
0,58
0,59
0,6
0,61
0,62
"32% 6&1*
&A*
&
*~ 8
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
1,5 1,7 1,9 2,1 2,3 2,5 2,7 2,90,56
0,57
0,58
0,59
0,6
0,61
0,62
"32% 6&1*
&A*
&
*~ 8~ 8
1
&$99* >!0 > =!0
G GG =G >G 'G 0G PG18&gG(=*
1
&$99* >!0 > =!0
G GG =G >G 'G 0G PG18&gG(=*
$, '(
G(0
1,5
1,6
1,7
1,8
1,9
2
2,1
2,2
0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000
1
18"8N&*
1,5
1,6
1,7
1,8
1,9
2
2,1
2,2
0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000
1
18"8N&*
"8N! 8$ 1 2"$ 4 18 4 8"4 2$
4J1 $@F51"#$ &$ 77$ 81 $16*9
"2$ 1"3 H"78$3$18"F51"#$9
1811"<;"""$$32$"$$
35$UGV9#$18"$3$ 1!1818
2% 61$!84#$$$ 1 4"8N#$ $
8$1$7"#$$7 $A9>961!$8
2% 64$4$$8@$3!#$1"482"$$
19"$!1 "2"5$7713!
"3 2% 6 1$ ; =!0 1 $7711 18 8$
$51"71;83$ "9
- $A9>D4$17$188$$84(!P
&a>(1=a=!01*$"(!08$";>>XH8"
$3 @,&)(@G(_9*
2 8 77 E &7 $ A9'* 213 $5
"8" $ %3 8"4 $$ 7$ &7* "9
$4J18$7!&GG(*l&=((*l$$38892
8 77 " #$ 8$ 213 "8N! 71 $ 3
51 """ 1$$ 189234 $+$ 76 $8$
&7 $A90*"#$2$"8N1848$"7$$79
185 11"8$7482=@9
$, '(
G(P
- $A9'D77 11E7%'L3$4$53
&ta(!G/??)1*$71, 8$"8$4J1
- $A90D 85+$76$8$$14$710]12"8$,
2"#$715""$%377$";2$
1 $ $$$ 1118"$=((;''(L !GH;G
H4GG88"98#$&7 $A9P9*$+&7 $
A9P93*! 213 $5@$3 1 $% 3$D 1 5$
7"#$"84@;@417218$$ 7!$
"8 3 7"#$9 181 81 $
"82"&71*"9$#$2$18$
7$7$$"98$!3"7#$1
5$7"#$7;"82"UG!>V9, $$$
8$1#$ 1118"$882% 6
"$9
*, B, D, +,
"
&$99*
=s &L*
&==(
*
&=((
*
&>GG
*&===
*
&GGG
*
&'((
*$3 $3
'0(1
=!']1
0!G]1
*, B, D, +,
"
&$99*
=s &L*
&==(
*
&=((
*
&>GG
*&===
*
&GGG
*
&'((
*$3 $3
'0(1
=!']1
0!G]1
$, '(
G(/
- $A9PD 11#$&*+&3*;>=(L $5, 0!G]12"8$
7$ 79 517"#$17"#$GHG((H
8"$ 11#$&*
51 " 71 7 24 18"$
&7 $ A9/9* $ $ 25"$! 77 $ 8" 2"
2494$!(!)'A!1J18$77""8$$5!
1$8"$$%""$8$1"$%7"&[(!/0A*U'@0V9
#$ " "B 4 2"8$ $59 8" $
1125"$$88"$71$"8$&7 $A9/93*
"46#$""1"8$718$"8" 61$8"$;
$%71#$864$197! 13#$2"8$
$ "8N 7$! 7Q 6 73! 88"" $ 2 %9
"1! 7381$1#$ 18"2"4$84
"8$ 7 34 2 $$9 $ 1"$%
17! 1$218"8"$%1@8$2"UG!>V9!
11$24"8$$5H"!$$1@34"
8$ 4J19 181 3$" ; 73 $ 8$
"8N67UPV91$7"#$%71!816"8
"1"$2"5!81271"11
$ 2 %D $ < 9 18 1$
711 4 $ "1#$14 7" "46 #$ "8 2"
" 8 $< &7 $A9?*U/V9
? @
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2 3 4 5 6
100 mV200 mV300 mV
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2 3 4 5 6
100 mV200 mV300 mV
ϕ
&-OH*
7 $5
(deg
rés)
&-OH*
$5? @200 mV100 mV300 mV
200 mV100 mV
'0
>
'0
>
M2 &gG(0 *50 10 15 20 25
@M22&gG(
0*
0
4
8
12
16
20? @
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2 3 4 5 6
100 mV200 mV300 mV
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2 3 4 5 6
100 mV200 mV300 mV
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2 3 4 5 6
100 mV200 mV300 mV
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2 3 4 5 6
100 mV200 mV300 mV
ϕ
&-OH*
7 $5
(deg
rés)
&-OH*
$5? @200 mV100 mV300 mV
200 mV100 mV
'0
>
'0
>
M2 &gG(0 *50 10 15 20 25
@M22&gG(
0*
0
4
8
12
16
20
$, '(
G(?
- $A9/D4$$ 51"&*$ 51$88"88";
2"8$&3*72418"$8$71, 91$""4
1 $ !$!$$$3%3&'>(*!$$ 1118"$
=((;''(L !$$17"#$GH;GH4GG88"
- $A9?D 18487"$ 517"#$%71
, 8$"8$72418"$
=
>
'
0
P
/
?
G> G' G0 GP G/ G? G) =( =G ==;,,,,J?Z@
450 nm2,4 µm5,1 µm]& ) 5&
&?8
OJA@
=
>
'
0
P
/
?
G> G' G0 GP G/ G? G) =( =G ==;,,,,J?Z@
450 nm2,4 µm5,1 µm]& ) 5&
&?8
OJA@
&
Ob*
G((((O&f*
'((L >((L =((L
>
'
0
P
/
?
G> G0 G/ G) =G =>
450 nm5.1 µm
2.4 µm
&
Ob*
G((((O&f*
'((L >((L =((L
>
'
0
P
/
?
G> G0 G/ G) =G =>
450 nm5.1 µm
2.4 µm
? @
&
Ob*
G((((O&f*
'((L >((L =((L
>
'
0
P
/
?
G> G0 G/ G) =G =>
450 nm5.1 µm
2.4 µm
&
Ob*
G((((O&f*
'((L >((L =((L
>
'
0
P
/
?
G> G0 G/ G) =G =>
450 nm5.1 µm
2.4 µm
? @
>
'
0
P
/
?
)
G>!0 G0!0 G/!0 G)!0 =G!0
(!'0
=!'
0!G
G((((O&f*
&O!b
9]1
@G*
? @
>
'
0
P
/
?
)
G>!0 G0!0 G/!0 G)!0 =G!0
(!'0
=!'
0!G
G((((O&f*
&O!b
9]1
@G*
? @
$, '(
G()
4$;$>5 )2 &%8!"
% $% 83" 8$ 5" 18" ! 1
7"#$ &-*! $ $ $ $ 8$" & 8$"* U?@)V9
"5 "" "" $ $3 %3 $ 14
4$"32% 6=!01$"32 >(1!$$8
(!P 9 7%" ; GG( 119 816 "#$
"5 $8$0($?(S8$" 1-$$(!08$";
>> XH 8$ " 1 92"8$ 71! "1" 8 8716 !
24G]14$8"'(194"8N8$"8$
>!/9G(@= 19S@G91@G 8$ 1 >!G'9G(@= 19S@G91@G &0( S*
=!09G(@=19S@G91@G &?(S*8$ 1-94"8N$8"$1
;1-917 4"8N $%"5
""1-"$$7#$2$88$88#$""7"59
7!8;8$4"39"5 7"#$1
N3#$2$"5 8$"9
2 8 E &7 $ A9)* 1 #$ 213
"8N$ $$ 7$ "9 $;1@5$$!8$ 73
8$71""1 ! 7#$ $8"$9 $
84$2" 868$18#$7477$
1! 973" 87743
8$J84#$"8$";F51"$8 8"9
2 71 &7 $ A9G(* "46 #$ $ 18 #$! $%
8"1$86!#$#$"8N$"9$
""1 1"#$ 4J1 1 ; 39 2<$1
1$8#$4$8 11"488"8-9UG(V81"1
"8#$$592"7&7 $A9GG9*4=!=?;=!(?$
1 $ 43 7 "8N 77 2%
&7 $ A9GG93*! 2 G(@>! 7 6 51"#$ 4J19
1$4""$8$"51"#$
UGGV9 2"8$ "8N 3$ 4 1$ 8#$ $ 1J1
$ #$ 1$" 8 871" 9 73 "
+ 842$77"2"719
$, '(
GG(
- $A9)D77 11E$$7%'L77$"4$5
3&ta(!G/??)1*7$816"#$"5 8$71,
- $A9G(D71, 7$"5 &-$ *
-&0(S* -&?(S*
% at.
,
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
-&0(S* -&?(S*
% at.
,
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(
-&0(S*
-&?(S*
=s &L*
"
&$99*
$3
&GGG
*
&=((
*
&==(
*
&===
*&>GG
*
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(
-&0(S*
-&?(S*
=s &L*
"
&$99*
$3
&GGG
*
&=((
*
&==(
*
&===
*&>GG
*
$, '(
GGG
- $A9GGD"7&*772%&3*71, $1$43
7$816"#$"5
" "#$ $ 213 71 "8" $
%3! $ $ 11 18"$ 4 =(( ; 0((L ! 8" $ $
3$ 4 ; 2"9 181 "#$ 2$ 1"$
73"8$O$18" UPV98""$
1125"$&7 $A9G=*1#$2" 2471"3"
1-4$841G!=GG!'0A8$8$0(?(S9 4$
$8"$ ; $ 4J1 5"" 1 &(!)= A*9$ #$
1 56! 2" 24 71 8$ "4" #$ "
"$U'@0V91J1!"$58$4""1-2$1=
$ $8"$ ; $5 "8" 1 9 $ $ $
8 85 8""! "" 1" #$ 1"1 1 $ 2
%" 8< 561 &7 $A9?*9
1J1 8$ $% "3" 1 - &7 $ A9G>*9 88"" "#$ "
7$"81$$71!77"34"1-
18$3$5 1 9 6"8$88$1
"7
'/0 0G0 000 0)0 $$2&1*
-&?(S*
-&0(S*
=!(0
=!G0
=!=0
&*
$$2&1*
-&?(S*
-&0(S*
(
'
=
P
G(
?
772%&gG(
@>*
'/0 0G0 000 0)0
&3*
"7
'/0 0G0 000 0)0 $$2&1*
-&?(S*
-&0(S*
=!(0
=!G0
=!=0
&*
"7
'/0 0G0 000 0)0 $$2&1*
-&?(S*
-&0(S*
=!(0
=!G0
=!=0
&*
'/0 0G0 000 0)0 $$2&1*
-&?(S*
-&0(S*
=!(0
=!G0
=!=0
&*
$$2&1*
-&?(S*
-&0(S*
(
'
=
P
G(
?
772%&gG(
@>*
'/0 0G0 000 0)0
&3*
$$2&1*
-&?(S*
-&0(S*
(
'
=
P
G(
?
772%&gG(
@>*
'/0 0G0 000 0)0
&3*
-&?(S*
-&0(S*
(
'
=
P
G(
?
772%&gG(
@>*
'/0 0G0 000 0)0
&3*
$, '(
GG=
>
>!0
'
'!0
0
0!0
P
P!0
/
/!0
G> G>!0 G' G'!0 G0 G0!0 GP GP!0 G/ G/!0 G?
-&0(S* -&?(S*
G((((O&f*
&-LOH*
,U/V
: U/V
>
>!0
'
'!0
0
0!0
P
P!0
/
/!0
G> G>!0 G' G'!0 G0 G0!0 GP GP!0 G/ G/!0 G?
-&0(S*-&0(S* -&?(S*-&?(S*
G((((O&f*
&-LOH*
,U/V
: U/V
-!#$"8$"4$12""13#$&< *$ 1!#$
$8$"8$"4"9
- $A9G=D4$$ 51"72418"$$
816"#$"5 8$71, 91$77$"487$
,D$!$$ 1118"$>((;?((L !$$$3%3&
'>(*!G((1A218$8$ 7$ 117"#$G(H;(!GH
8GG88"
- $A9G>D 187"#$%71, "3"1-4$
87"14>!P112"8$91$1"487$,D$!
$$ 1118"$>((;?((L !$$$3%3&'>(*!G((1A
218$8$ 7$ 117"#$G(H;(!GH8GG8
8"
4$;$B55 )
1$$ 4J1 7$ $88"" $97
74 $ ! $% 71 5"" 1 - &0( ?(S* $ $
>!0
'!0
0!0
P!0
/!0
?!0
)!0
G' G0 GP G/ G? G) =( =G ==G((((O&f*
&Ob
*
-&0(S* -&?(S*
>!0
'!0
0!0
P!0
/!0
?!0
)!0
G' G0 GP G/ G? G) =( =G ==G((((O&f*
&Ob
*
-&0(S*-&0(S* -&?(S*-&?(S*
$, '(
GG>
$3 5$77" ; 18"$ >((L 9 GG(11 "3
2 2% 6841>(1=!018$$8
(!P;2"$2928E21371"8"$
$375$8"4$$7$"&7 $A9G'*9
8$73 $;1@5$$8778$"8N""$$3
5$$$ 8$189$!8&=((*778$
#$28"$%8$4J177$"$$379
" + 34" 7 18"$ $ $3!
1$877"2"7192" 88"8
5$77 74 % 9
184J1288$3"85 118"$$8@
$39%18 8 $"8N"3" 4 8$?(S "
7 $A9G09
- $A9G'D77 11E7%'L""4$53
&ta(!G///?)1*8$"5, "3"1-$$37$$31$
;>((L 885"8N
- $A9G0D4J1, "8"$$35$74$8$
?(S
$37 $3
5$
,
(
G(
=(
>(
'(
0(
P(
/(
_9
$37 $3
5$
,
(
G(
=(
>(
'(
0(
P(
/(
_9
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(
=s &L*
"
&$9*
$37
$3>((L
$3
$3
&GGG*
&=((*
&==(* &>GG*&===*
-&0(S*
-&0(S*-&?(S*
-&?(S*
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(
=s &L*
"
&$9*
$37
$3>((L
$3
$3
&GGG*
&=((*
&==(* &>GG*&===*
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(
=s &L*
"
&$9*
$37
$3>((L
$3
$3
&GGG*
&=((*
&==(* &>GG*&===*
-&0(S*
-&0(S*-&?(S*
-&?(S*
$, '(
GG'
=!0
>!0
'!0
0!0
P!0
/!0
G=!0 G>!0 G'!0 G0!0 GP!0 G/!0G((((O&f*
&-LOH*
,U/V
: U/V
-?(S-0(S
=!0
>!0
'!0
0!0
P!0
/!0
G=!0 G>!0 G'!0 G0!0 GP!0 G/!0G((((O&f*
&-LOH*
,U/V
: U/V
-?(S-?(S-0(S-0(S
" "#$ 4J1 "8" $ %3
1"$!$$ 1118"$=((;0((L 7"#$G(
H;GH4GG88"$18$$7G((1A9
$3$4; 2"34"118$ $ 71,
UG=V9187"#$%71&7 $A9GP*!816"8
"1" $! 4 2$8 7" >!P112"8$ U/V!
88B#$ < N 1"1$ 2%9
1811;$718$4""$$371- 9
" 71 &7 $ A9G/* 8$ 73#$8$ $%"8" $ $3
7$1J1 $#$8$$%""1 92"4$"
$ 51 " 4 18"$ $ $ 1"1 51#$1
4"$4$85"$92" 244$G!'0A!
4$ $8"$ $% " "$ U'@0V9 " $ 1J1
$ #$ 8$ 71 "8" $ $3 7! 1 " $ 8$ 7 "8$
24=((14J15""18"$9$!5 1
1$$ 84#$" 8 18"$ $ 8@$3 17 88""
"#$71$3133""7#$8$233
88""$9
- $A9GPD 1125"$7"#$%8$71, "8"1
-$$35$91$1"487$,D$!$$ 11
18"$=((;0((L !$$$3%3&'>(*!4G((1A218$
8$ 7$ 117"#$G(H;GH8GG88"
$, '(
GG0
'!(
0!(
P!(
/!(
G=!0 G>!0 G'!0 G0!0 GP!0
-?(S-0(S
G((((O&f*
&
Ob*
aG!0'A
aG!')A
'!(
0!(
P!(
/!(
G=!0 G>!0 G'!0 G0!0 GP!0
-?(S-?(S-0(S-0(S
G((((O&f*
&
Ob*
aG!0'A
aG!')A
- $A9G/D4$$ 51"72418"$8$71
, 5""$$35$1-91$1"487$,D$
!$$ 1118"$=((;0((L !$$$3%3&'>(*!G((
1A218$8$ 7$ 117"#$G(H;GHGG88
"9
4$;$-'
$2"$!4J1""2"#$8"$%
1 "9 $ 4 4$ #$ $4 "1" 17 2"
$5M9"#$!45"4J1, 41
7"8$!$$4"2%8"188$1
71988""7"71UG>V81"1$
8138@$3#$$$%$'@019
816 34 ; $4 277 8 4 8$ $
01$ 2"4J19"5 3$
88#$$"(!08$";=(XH!"32% 6"1$
;=!01"32 "<$"8$3$ 1184(!0
;=;2"$2918134"8$$55""$
8$ 73 8 4 71 ; "$ UG'@G0V^
18 1%1 7 3 &7 $ A9G?*9 "
81 8 24 56 "8N 7 "8$9
18 " 74" 8 73 8 4! $ "$ $
" 83 $ 1 89
18 2% 4 ; 2$ 8$ 7 8 #$ 1 1#$
$, '(
GGP
1$7118UG'V9$71M!""1"#$8
81G!=9! "$1$ $18$ $#$ H$1
2$19"5""48$8"$$" ;G!=
9 3$ 1 ; 34" 4 M^ 4$
1%1 18 $4 %" 2% 34
$ $ 8@$9 $ $ 8 4 G!= ! 2" 1%1
11$1&7 $A9G?*9 28#$$8$"4$
27$9
- $A9G?D4$$71, 788$
$"(!08$";=(XH8"$3$01
77" "$" " ; ' 0 19 11
743 8$ 23 2$ 3 51 """ "8$9 11
1 7 $ A9G)! $5 "3" 8$ $ ' 1 8"
4$ 18 9 $ ' 1! 2"4$
71$%""$UG'V^ 4$18
1%173"#$22" 9715""8$
$0177$"11$1$%1%1
9 4" 8$ " "8N 41 7
"8$9
8$15&11*
&
*
-1,50E+03
-1,00E+03
-5,00E+02
0,00E+00
5,00E+02
1,00E+03
30 40 50 60 70 80 90
2Pa1,5Pa1,2Pa0,5
8$15&11*
&
*
-1,50E+03
-1,00E+03
-5,00E+02
0,00E+00
5,00E+02
1,00E+03
30 40 50 60 70 80 90
2Pa1,5Pa1,2Pa0,5
$, '(
GG/
- $A9G)D7$8$$84G!=$"(!0
8$";=(XH88#$";3$71,
71M5""$ 8 4818"$8
" 61 9 4$ 2884"! $53 23 71
419$!71, ""4$8
4 7"$ ; 11 2" ! 7 2$
184J19
4$;$DF)5
712"8$ = ; P]1 5"" $ 2 %3
"- &1@?M!*4$"(!/8$";=(XH!
"32 2% 687'(=!01$$8(!/@
(!?$019 $28E 74
$$7$"&7 $A9=(*92$+&7 $A9=G*$76
$8$$4J1=]12"8$"8"$$18"$185
1848$"7$9
- $A9=(D77 11E""4$53&ta(!G/??)1*$$
7%'L$71, =]12"8$"8"$$1@?M
8$15&11*
&
*
-1,60E+03
-1,40E+03
-1,20E+03
-1,00E+03
-8,00E+02
-6,00E+02
-4,00E+02
-2,00E+02
0,00E+0030 45 60 75 90
50 mm40 mm
8$15&11*
&
*
8$15&11*
&
*
-1,60E+03
-1,40E+03
-1,20E+03
-1,00E+03
-8,00E+02
-6,00E+02
-4,00E+02
-2,00E+02
0,00E+0030 45 60 75 90
50 mm40 mm
-1,60E+03
-1,40E+03
-1,20E+03
-1,00E+03
-8,00E+02
-6,00E+02
-4,00E+02
-2,00E+02
0,00E+0030 45 60 75 90
50 mm40 mm
"
&$9*
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(=s &L*
&GGG*
&=((*&==(*
&>GG*
&===*
"
&$9*
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(=s &L*
&GGG*
&=((*&==(*
&>GG*
&===*
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(=s &L*
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(=s &L*
&GGG*
&=((*&==(*
&>GG*
&===*
$, '(
GG?
- $A9=GD 85$+$76$8$$71, =]12"8$"8"$$
1
$8118!""#$7177$"$
!$$118"$>((;?((L 8$$1$
1" ; $9 "4$ $ 51 " $ 11
25"$34"7$139%18"$
"8N = ]1 2"8$ "8" $ " 7 $ A9==9 2"
24!3$;87 $A9==!G!'>A$81!8$
1$ 71 86 ! 8$ 3 $% $ G!G@G!= A $
;$619 4$!1J1868$$!$8"$$%"
"$U'@0V9 1117 $A9=>!$2%
N"8< !118$$71, ""8$
8$ 73 18"$! 1 ; 213 71 M 8$ #$
$#$ ""8 9
- $A9==D4$$ 51"7$131$$71
, =]12"8$5""$9$""41 $,!$!$$
8 18"$>((;?((L !4$18$$ 7G((1A!$1
7"#$G(H;(!GH8GG88"
=!(
=!0
>!(
>!0
'!(
'!0
0!(
G( GG G= G> G' G0
G = > '
aG!'>A
a(!)/A
aG!=GA
aG!GGA
&
Ob*
G((((O&f*
=!(
=!0
>!(
>!0
'!(
'!0
0!(
G( GG G= G> G' G0=!(
=!0
>!(
>!0
'!(
'!0
0!(
G( GG G= G> G' G0
G = > '
G G = = > > ' '
aG!'>A
a(!)/A
aG!=GA
aG!GGA
&
Ob*
G((((O&f*
$, '(
GG)
>!0
'!(
'!0
0!(
0!0
P!(
P!0
/!(
/!0
G( GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/ G?
G = > '
G((((O&f*
,U/V
:,U/V
&-LOH*
>!0
'!(
'!0
0!(
0!0
P!(
P!0
/!(
/!0
G( GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/ G?
G = > '
G G = = > > ' '
G((((O&f*
,U/V
:,U/V
&-LOH*
- $A9=>D 187"#$%$71, =]12"8$"8"$
42$87">!P112"8$U/V9$""41 $,!$!
$$8 18"$>((;?((L !4$18$$ 7G((1A!$1
7"#$G(H;(!GH8GG88"
7 $ A9=' "46 #$ 1$ "#$ 7$" 8 $3
& $ 8$%* 8 189 77! 2" 24 86'
1$ 4$G!=G A!G!(' A (!// A 8$ $3 841 !
1@?M%39 77"$38$%
";$72"2"#$17"9"1!
8$ 213 $3! $ N" 8 < &7 $
A9=0*9 $ #$ 2"8$ $ 71! 181 34" #$
27$2"8$1"48A9G9=" 1"""
&$58$"88$"4" 241*9
- $A9='D4$$ 51"$71, =]12"8$7
2418"$$$$39$""41 $,!$!$
$8 18"$>((;?((L !4$18$$ 7G((1A!$1
7"#$G(H;(!GH8GG88"
%31&@?M*
G!0
=!(
=!0
>!(
>!0
'!(
'!0
0!(
0!0
P!(
P!0
G( GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/G((((O&f*
&
Ob*
%31&@?M*
%31&@?M*
G!0
=!(
=!0
>!(
>!0
'!(
'!0
0!(
0!0
P!(
P!0
G( GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/G((((O&f*
&
Ob*
G!0
=!(
=!0
>!(
>!0
'!(
'!0
0!(
0!0
P!(
P!0
G( GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/G((((O&f*
&
Ob*
$, '(
G=(
- $A9=0D 18$ 517"#$%$71, =]12"8$
4$2$87">!P11U/V9$""41 $,!$!$$
8 18"$>((;?((L !4$18$$ 7G((1A!$1
7"#$G(H;(!GH8GG88"
4J10!)]12"8$"8"$""$77"
8 8 2% 69 11 1 7 $ A9=P! 181
1"$ 8$1 #$ $ 1 8 8 2% 6 "$" ;
18"$'((L !#$28$48$18"$P((L 9$6
18"$! 2"4$ "4 4 882% 6
1 #$2 4 88 $4" "#$9 8! 8
77&GO'*!53$1" 11+$W#$<$7
8" $4" "#$ 2 8 3$9 77" 8 84
\1 77$" 2<$ $3 %8"1 4 $ 16 "#$
"#$4!3$$, 8$$18"$4173!
7! 2$ 11 $ "1 18 "#$ 8$ 4
9 $$38$" 1842$1#$3"51#$$
4J1, 9"#$28""$8$
882% 6;18"$9
acier inoxydableLSMcermet (Ni-8YSZ)
3,5
4
4,5
5
5,5
6
6,5
7
7,5
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
,U/V
:,U/V
G((((O&f*
Log(
F°/H
z)
acier inoxydableLSMcermet (Ni-8YSZ)
acier inoxydableLSMcermet (Ni-8YSZ)
3,5
4
4,5
5
5,5
6
6,5
7
7,5
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
,U/V
:,U/V
G((((O&f*
Log(
F°/H
z)
$, '(
G=G
(!((!0G!(G!0=!(=!0>!(>!0'!('!0
@/ @P @0 @' @> @= @G ( &=O°*
&
Ob*
&*
&3*
(!((!0G!(G!0=!(=!0>!(>!0'!('!0
@/ @P @0 @' @> @= @G ( &=O°*
&
Ob*
&*
&3*
- $A9=PD4$"7882% 68$71,
0!)]12"8$"8"$8$18"$'((L&*P((L &3*9$""4
1 $,!4$18$$ 7G((1A!$$17"#$G(H
;GH8GG88"
4$*) ?3'C@
13 5! $ $ 18" ==)!
8$181M11"8$@- 9 2#$
"=(((!#$99UGPV1"4$388""
$2%"488"$$4$8$$
1"$&*UG/V9
4$*$;)
$5""8@8$4"31"#$&@*
$2$1856"42 @% 697$$23"1
8" $ 2$ 85"16 25"" 8$ 5#$ 39 3
8$4""4$"(!08$";0(XH!$01$"3
2 >(1$$8(!009"32% 64(;G/!0
1!$;$84(!00;(!/?>92"4$$
82$$ H"7&% 6*$3"$
61 8"5&7 $A9=/*9 118$ H!
88""7"71811"481
019
$, '(
G==
- $A9=/D4$8$37
$"3 H"7$
3@G(_898$4""$$"(!08$";>>XH!
$01$"32 >(1!8123$8
(!0=9"32% 6$@$8$"3(
;01$ 118"4$(!0=;(!P9$8&7 $
A9=?9* &7 $ A9=?93* 4 ; = 1 2% 6 "46 #$
61 @O 8" $ 85"16 23" $ " 1 8$4"
%8"1 8" 8$ 2"$9 81 ! "$
88""7""8NUG>V!'19
- $A9=?D4$8&*&3*$3@7$"32% 6$
&
*
(!0
(!P
(!/
(!?
( 0 G( G00((
00(
P((
P0(
/((
/0(
8
"32% 6&1*
&A*
&
*
(!0
(!P
(!/
(!?
( 0 G( G00((
00(
P((
P0(
/((
/0(
8
"32% 6&1*
&A*
(!0
(!P
(!/
(!?
( 0 G( G00((
00(
P((
P0(
/((
/0(
8
"32% 6&1*
&A*
&
*
"32% 6&1*
? @
(!0=
(!0'
(!0P
(!0?
(!P
(!P=
( (!0 G G!0 = =!0 > >!0 ' '!0 0
&A
*
G0(
=((
=0(
>((
>0(
'((
'0(
( (!0 G G!0 = =!0 > >!0 ' '!0 0"32% 6&1*
? @
&
*
"32% 6&1*
? @
(!0=
(!0'
(!0P
(!0?
(!P
(!P=
( (!0 G G!0 = =!0 > >!0 ' '!0 0
&A
*
G0(
=((
=0(
>((
>0(
'((
'0(
( (!0 G G!0 = =!0 > >!0 ' '!0 0"32% 6&1*
? @
$, '(
G=>
4$*$* *'*=
$ "$18"8@8$4"! 7$1 2"";
88#$$5#$38$318$5"948$4"
8$188$3#$8$4#$
841'0192"$37%";(!=08$";=(XH!
4$11#$2832184 ""$$"8$3$3
" $$974"8N5#$""1!2"
3$$%$G4$ ""$$$"#$8"2$
"$2" "149
"5""4"32 >(12% 6G(
1!8$$8(!/@(!?92"7%";(!=08$";=(XH
8$ 34(!);G!G$$8$92
&7 $A9=)*$51#$71"3"4$"G!G$
3 86 $ 18 &=G!)G(!'* 85 $ E
&==)*9
- $A9=)D71E72"$35
2 8E$ 71 18 $5" #$ #$ $@
185 ; 18"$ 13 &7 $ A9>(*9 $ 771
"4$1&$3*9 347"821 +$
76$8$$$1@?M&7 $A9>G*!"#$2$185
4$UG?V92"8$$71!"1";87 $A9>G!=]19
$$ "" 1" $ 7 18"$ 4 $
7716E2 @ "#$8" 2$ 513 5$ 18"$fG=((
!$$ 11'((;/((L 4$8=0L 8$$5"8"$
2 %3987734"8$$ '0L &=s*3$";
(G(=(>('(0(P(/(?(
(!?0 (!) (!)0 G G!(0 G!G G!G0&*
_9
==!/G=!0 =G!)G(!0=>!0G)!0
(G(=(>('(0(P(/(?(
(!?0 (!) (!)0 G G!(0 G!G G!G0&*
_9
==!/G=!0 =G!)G(!0=>!0G)!0
$, '(
G='
$$$39$'((L !71 $<$185
858$8==)88B'(('0(L &7 $A9>=*9771
8 S55 ""4 1"$3#$=G> &m@==)*
UGP@G/!=(V$ 11 ";0((!00(P((L 9 8!18$
$ 73 " $$! $ 771 1"
1#$ &l@==)* 8$ J 77$"9 $ 4$ 2 $$!
83 $ #$ 85 3$ 3 8 ==)! 1 2 8
83 2771 8 $$ 8$ 5$ 18"$ &l $ m*9
"3 85 $ 87 $ =>G= " 8$ $
18"$$8"$;P=0L 9
- $A9>(D77 11E7%'L3$;22$5
3&ta(!G/??)1*2$4J1E185"8"$$$31@?M
- $A9>GD34+$76$8$$E318"8"$$
1
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(
=s &L*=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(
=s &L*
$, '(
G=0
400
500
600
700
15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
? $$@
) ?O"
@
*/F ?O@
$3$3&=>*
400
500
600
700
15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
? $$@
) ?O"
@
*/F ?O@
$3$3&=>*
- $A9>=D77 11E""$E18"$$487
$-$9&771658E2@1"7 $+ +&sOs*"#$8"
2$5$42$5135$18"$fG=((*
1$"#$""$!;84J1"8"$$
1@?M!4$18$$ 7G((1A$$ 11
7"#$G(H;GH4GG88"9118"$4
>((;?((L 9 8"$4"#$74$$4$$
$ $4 34 $ 76 $8$9 7 8 8 2% 6
8" 2 $ $ 3 3" $$ $ E9 77!
1 $ #$ $$ "3 1$ "$$ UG)@=(V9 $
3$4;2""8#$^181
1 ; $ $5 , M9 8" $ $
"#$4 2 G(@GG-9 7 #$ 1"1 $ N
$ 2 % U=(V9 2"4$ " $ 51 "
7 18"$ &7 $ A9>>* 74 2$ 1"1 51#$1
4"! 8 8" 2" 24$ 18"9 $ 8
$37 $A9>>3439 773$"8$8161$;
$85"16!8$$!;$$lm#$
$8$1$2" 2492$$86'
71 $ 4J1 &7 $ A9>'*94$ 2" 24
8$855$18"$G!=0@G!>A869 4$
$, '(
G=P
4G!=A$4"899UGPV8$715$18"$
17764$(!)=A9@8H9U=(V9
- $A9>>D 51"$E718"$$139
$""41 $,!$!$1@?M!$$ 1118"$
>((;?((L !4$18$$ 7G((1A!$$17"#$G(
H;GH8GG88"
- $A9>'D77 11E$$7%'L4$53
&ta(!G/??)1*86'1$218"$71E"8"$1@?M
76 $8$ $5"8" $182$84$%3$
2"3 &7 $ A9>09* ; $ 8 $8$ 4 8" 8 86 '
1$ &7 $ A9>093*9 288 8 "#$
71 2" 185 &6 18* ; $ " " &1 18*9
8!7128""25"$5$19
181 4@;@4 51#$ 743 8$ 218 11
>( '( 0( P( /( ?(=s &L*
"
&$9*
: LaMox : YSZ : NiO : Ni
>( '( 0( P( /( ?(=s &L*
"
&$9*
: LaMox : YSZ : NiO : Ni
>!(
>!0
'!(
'!0
0!(
0!0
P!(
P!0
/!(
) G( GG G= G> G'
pass1pass2pass3pass4
Mm $$ l $$
aG!PPA
aG!0=A
aG!/0A
aG!=0A aG!>=A
aG!/=A
aG!')A
G((((O&f*
&Ob
*
>!(
>!0
'!(
'!0
0!(
0!0
P!(
P!0
/!(
) G( GG G= G> G'
pass1pass2pass3pass4
Mm $$ l $$
aG!PPA
aG!0=A
aG!/0A
aG!=0A aG!>=A
aG!/=A
aG!')A
>!(
>!0
'!(
'!0
0!(
0!0
P!(
P!0
/!(
) G( GG G= G> G'
pass1pass2pass3pass4
Mm $$ l $$
aG!PPA
aG!0=A
aG!/0A
aG!=0A aG!>=A
aG!/=A
aG!')A
G((((O&f*
&Ob
*
$, '(
G=/
"@- !83615"1"$%2"
2"$87387$9
- $A9>0D34+$76$8$$E7$131$
218"D3$2"3&*86'1$&3*
1$ "#$ $ 77" 8 8 2% 6 &G(@/ ;
21856*""$2"5"8"$19$23!$5$77 ;
P((L $1>(1$8$5#$882% 6""8$
2$81$;2"#$39"$3$8$18"$
'((LP((L $77"882% 68""7 $
A9>P95$3$4$$ 51"8$5#$18"$
"$" 7 #$ E 8" 8 $ $4" 8$1 #$ $
1882% 6 %8"9 118$ , ! 8
77$&GO'*$ 1125"$!#$ $8"
2$8$4""#$!281"4988B#$E
8$"7#$, $77"882% 634"9
34849@8H9U=(V#$1"
#$ $4" 1 #$ 8$ 8 2% 6 $8"$ ;
G(@G> 8$ 85 5$ 18"$ $ E &m*9 77" 181
8$J84#$"8$%77^81$$%8"1114
&M4W*!#$81"14$18"#$!$7
733$2"98$J$8181
$51!77"$1"$%17&87"*9!
4J18$"74@;@42% 69
? @ ? @? @ ? @
$, '(
G=?
- $A9>PD4$"7882% 68$71==)
"8"$18$$18"$'((L&*P((L &3*9$""41 $,!
$1@?M!4$18$$ 7G((1A!$$17"#$G(
H;GH8GG88"
4$*$>
85$3#$&m*$E8688""$2%
$8"$ ; $$ 1#$ &l* UG)! =GV9 8$! 7$ "4
71lp m218 2$5 1$4$11U=GV#$
8"<$3 ; 25" ""1 $ F$ 8 &"@
"*9 $$ 5$ 18"$ 8$ J 3" ; 213
$3$2$8$58$&!,!*UG)!=GV$2$8$
1368$SUGP!==@=>V!$+ U=>V$$AUGP!=>V9$$ 4!$
$3$$82$159$!$3G(_89$
>_89$"8$77$4J19
4$*$>$ " /G;,T $
$56"5!816%8"1$%$4D
8$ 3@! '1 2" 7%";G8$
3!012"4(!G0;(!=09213
715""4$"32% 6G(1$"32 >(1
$;$824(!/9
2"8$ 714 (!) G!0 ]1 86 = 5$ "8N! 4 $
" 7"$ ; G( _ 1$ $ 8716 "" 8
(
G
=
>
'
0
P
/
@/ @P @0 @' @> @= @G (
&*
(b)
&O
*
&8=O8°*
(
G
=
>
'
0
P
/
@/ @P @0 @' @> @= @G (
&*
(b)
&O
*
&8=O8°*
$, '(
G=)
18#$9%182<$1"%8"14 16
5"#$8""$7 $A9>/$$1 $$200(@??(
1977!2$1$1$43&7 $A9>?*#$#$
8#$ $ 71 2"4$ 8 7Q 19 ! 16 $"
818$<$1"%8"18$$18194
"8N$ 142"8"$3D(!'0]195@G8$a(!G0!
(!'/0]195@G8$a(!=(!/0]195@G8$a(!=092"4$"4
$"5 3$";1$882% 6#$
2" 8" $ 3 $ 1! #$ "$ 2181 $%
3$ 1$$%18$4"U='V92&3$A9G*
1#$88O85(!=8$2134J1!8885
$3&(!G?*9$$5"3"4$"(!=08"$
3 ! 88O& d* 24 (!)?! 4 G! 88 4" 8$
E3";2$1&=@%%=)*9
- $A9>/D%181$E8"7 $$28$71
5""4a(!G0
- $A9>?D1$1$43$E8"5""4a(!G0
00 P( P0 /( /0 ?((!/?
(!?
(!?=
(!?'
(!?P
(!??
(!)
(!)=
$$ 2 &gG(1*
1
X5=aP!PgG(@'a))>!/)
7"%8"1
00 P( P0 /( /0 ?((!/?
(!?
(!?=
(!?'
(!?P
(!??
(!)
(!)=
$$ 2 &gG(1*
1
X5=aP!PgG(@'a))>!/)
7"%8"177"%8"1"%8"1
>0 '( '0 0( 00 P( P0 /( /0 ?((!00
(!P
(!P0
(!/
(!/0
(!?
(!?0
(!)
(!)0
1
$$2&gG(1*>0 '( '0 0( 00 P( P0 /( /0 ?(
(!00
(!P
(!P0
(!/
(!/0
(!?
(!?0
(!)
(!)0
1
$$2&gG(1*
$, '(
G>(
&* (!G0 (!= (!=0
8$&]1* (!) (!)0 G!0
&_9* =>!?? G?!G) G>!'?
&_9* '!)' >!PG =!)/
&_9* '!'> )!/? GP!()
&_9* PP!/0 P?!'= P/!'P
3$A9GD8$18717
234 $ + $ 76 $8$ $ 18" 8" 3
18! "8" $ $ 1 @?M! 8#$ 2$ 71 @4$% UG?V
"#$2$1"$185&7 $A9>)*9713$2"3185
&7 $A9'(*91$77$"85$880(L
'((00(L 9"3$34"6'((L &7 $A9'(*9$@;
'0(L $$1< $ 71 71 m $ ==) &$3#$* 4 $
858#$287"9 "$4$%9, 9
U=GV!#$#$#$2$$858"$%$3$8
7"$;G0_1#$9
- $A9>)D 85$+$76$8$$E8""3"4a(!=0
$, '(
G>G
- $A9'(D77 11E$E8"3$4$7 $+
+&sO=s*"#$8"2$53&ta(!G/??)1*"3"4a(!=0"8"$$
1486$;77"18"$8>5$
""#$""$!$$ 1118"$
=((L ; ?((L 4 $ 8 =0L $ 1 >( 1$ 8$ 5#$
18"$4"1$218"9218$$ 7
G((1A$$17"#$4G(H;GH4GG81$
8"9" 8"8#$&7 $A9'G*!11
8$$71!$$3$4;$534"9"$
71718"$!8""$ 1125"$7$
13 1$ &7 $ A9'=*! #$ #$ 181 $ $
8 5"$9 2" 24 4 G!0 ; (!?= A 7 $ 13
92184818$J8""8
7 #$ 2" 24 88 1$" $ 81 $ ; $
85"16$8 2$ 118"$81$9
$!734$"$2$73
$ 7 #$ 71 "9 "1! 2" 24
1$" 24 (!?= A 86 0 9 4$ " 61 7"$ $%
""$8$3$ 71m@==)UGP!=(V9
G? >? 0? /?
'(('0(0((
00(
D==)
=s &L*
"
&$9*
G? >? 0? /?
'(('0(0((
00(
D==)
=s &L*
"
&$9*
$, '(
G>=
- $A9'GD8"$8#$1$218"$E8"5""
4a(!=0& ";'((L @L>*9 517"#$8"$7 $9
- $A9'=D4$"718"$$135$77
8""$ 1125"$8$E8"8$4""4a(!=091$
""41 $,!$!$1@?M!4$ 1118"$
=((;?((L $17"#$G(H;GH!$18$ 7G((1A
4$*$>$ " />GT $
$4$%"5""4$3@>_89!#$8
; $ $ 1#$ '!PG_ 9 18 81 3
$$m$E85UG)!=GV94J15""$$
"32 >(12% 6G01!$;$8$
$"$G!G09#$;18"43
@G(_89&'18$3@018$*92"88#$"
G/GPG0G'G>G=GGG()G((((O&f*
G
= >'
0
=
>
'
0
P
/
&b
* aG!0A
a(!?=A
G/GPG0G'G>G=GGG()G((((O&f*
G
= >'
0
=
>
'
0
P
/
&b
* aG!0A
a(!?=A
G
(
=
>
'
( G = > 'M2&gG(0Ob*
M22&gG(
0 Ob*
2
3
456
G
(
=
>
'
( G = > 'M2&gG(0Ob*
M22&gG(
0 Ob*
2
3
456
$, '(
G>>
;3(!G08$";G((XHG1 $8$";G(XH
8$ 3 @9 8 $ 3$ A9= #$ "$1 88$% "$
2 71! 88B #$ 71 8$4"" 4 $$ &
8$"* 8" $ 88 &d*O (!)P #$ 85 $ 88 4" G $
E9 86 " 2$ 1$ 218" $ 1
53$ &$ ! 4 $ 7"#$ 4 G( H ; G H $ 11
18"$ >(( ; ?((L *! 88B #$ $$ 71 &7 $ A9'>* 3$
28$==)!1#$22 $$$=P&75: (G@
(/'@(G?=*9
-"#$&XH*
+
( 'G!=' P!)? 0G!/? (!)>
G(( >'!0) P!0' 0?!)/ (!P)
3$A9=D 18""11"#$7177"#$8$@
- $A9'>D77 11E$71E8"77"#$
8$$3@$$7%'L3$4$53
&ta(!G/??)1*
4$>") 55%GHI0!"3'C
$4" #$ 71 " 8 71$ $4D & 2$
1 861"#$*D
!"8$2"&1*!
"!"2"&b*!
!$7"@"&1=*
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(
&G(>
*
&GG(
*
&((P
*
&=((
*
M
&GGG
*
M
&=((
*
&GG
G*&GGP
*
M
&==(
*
&=G>
*
&G()
*
M
&>GG
*
(XH
G((XH
=s &L*
"
&$9*
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?(
&G(>
*
&GG(
*
&((P
*
&=((
*
M
&GGG
*
M
&=((
*
&GG
G*&GGP
*
M
&==(
*
&=G>
*
&G()
*
M
&>GG
*
(XH
G((XH
=s &L*
"
&$9*
U>Vg
i
"
=
$, '(
G>'
$ 18 88"" $ 2 % 5#$ 18"! $
8" $ 11 25"$ $ 88 " &"* $
2"8$! #$ 8 $ 88 &GOig*! 7 18"$ 77$"
&7 $A9''*9$$8""1$!2182$"#$31$$
""1"4#$;""#$4J197 $A9''
""4"55""8186'
5$77 9$4$%1"$%&, !E*7788""$
2=@$8"$;$1"$4&M*U=0@=PV988B#$
1814"7"8$, E3";2$1!73 8$
"8""88"$%859$$E3"!
" 8 1 $<$ $8"$ ; $ 4J19
181 $ $ 4J1 E 1" 4
$88"19 %8 83 84 $ 181 77" 71
14@;@41"$%179
- $A9''D 1125"$$ 51$88&O*724
18"$8$21318"5""819"""
""41 $,!$$19
4$B %0!"/GH
231 18"$ 2$ - " 218
$4$%"8"$4"#$$8"$;M91
$%! , $ 89 1<$ 8361 $ , ! 7
$! " 7#$1"$2831$"$$9$
73 8 8 2% 6! = 71 =>! B
2882$$4""#$U=/@=?V#$8$"3$5$1$@
M
,
=@%%=)
==)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
) GG G> G0 G/
&
O!b
9]1
@G*
G((((O&f*
M
,
=@%%=)
==)
M
,
=@%%=)
==)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
) GG G> G0 G/
&
O!b
9]1
@G*
G((((O&f*
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
) GG G> G0 G/
&
O!b
9]1
@G*
G((((O&f*
$, '(
G>0
$ $9 $ 4 " 8$ "3
56 2$ " 3$5 18" 2$ $5 , 2$ 36
8 77$ M $ N" #$ U=)@>(V9 $5 2M J
$7711 "8 8$ 3 8" , 1! 8 8 8$ 8 "
88""$2%9
4$B$;)
81 "5 "" 15 13 $" 2$
"8$G]15#$18"9$5, 5""4$"
(!08$";>>XH9GG(11"32 2% 6
841>(=!01$$8(!P9712M"3"
8$$!$""5 $"32 #$9$
816%8"1#$""17""32% 6#$=!P14$
8 4 #$ $ " 1 $% $ (!P 9 $$
181 "#$ $ 13 $% 85 7
9 2 "8 $$ 7$ M , 9
""#$"58""569,$3U/V9
"183$5!8""8#$&7 $A9'0*!1
"4 "8 5#$1$59 $ 181 $ 71 "
$91"113$4;M8 #$2
8< 8$$, 9 8!88B#$2$"8$
M8188$4388""$$, 9
"#$!$7 $88"824 7;$1$5
M9
$, '(
G>P
- $A9'0D 11218"8$3$5M@, 98 "$;
>=(L 4$18$$ 7>((1A9 517"#$""8"$
11U/V
4$B$*5 0!"/GH
$8118!8$"3$5!4J1, "8"
$$392""5 (!/8$";=(XH!
01"32 2% 6'(1=!01841!
$$84(!//;(!/'$$$"8N92"8$$5
, 4 G!) ; 0!) ]19$! 71M 8$4"" $ 213@,
4$01!$"88#$"$3(!08$";=(XH
"3 2 2% 6 841 '( =!P 18$ $ 8
(!/0 9 "8$ 71 "" (!' (!?P ]19 2"8$
3$518=!/PP!/P]18$$88&, OM*4=;G09
2 8 E 3$5 &7 $ A9'P* "46 8" $%
$ $$ 7$ " H9 234 $+ $
76 $8$ &7 $ A9'/* 1 $185 18 $ $ $3 8$%
&*9 $5 , 8" $ 8 $8$ M 8$N
! 7 @, , @M " 19 185 M
288$3"88""$$59
' >
=
%8"1$%
d"$"18"18""18""1
M ,
M2Ob
0
1
2
3
4
0 1 2 3 4
@M22O
b
' >
=
%8"1$%%8"1$%
d"$"18"18""18""1
M ,
M2Ob
0
1
2
3
4
0 1 2 3 4
@M22O
b
$, '(
G>/
- $A9'PD77 11E""$$7%'L4$5
3&ta(!G/??)1*8$3$518"2$"8$0]1, (!=]1M
- $A9'/D34+$76$8$2$7118"G!)]12"8$,
G!G?]1M"8"$
1$ 218" 77$" $ 4 $1 1"#$
U>GV$!$$ 117"#$GH;G(1H4GG88"
218$ $ 7 =(( 1A9 18"$ 4 >(( ; P((L 9
8" $ 11 #$ &7 $ A9'?* 1 $ 3$
"8218$$ 8$7"#$$8"$;G('H92
"8 $ 3$59 1 H "#$ "8
2" &7 $ A9')* 1 "4 #$ 77"
"8 $, M 77 ; "9 %18! 3$ 5#$
1$5343$2"518"2$"8$']1,
(!?P]12M!$$$"2$"8$0!)]18$,
(!?P ]1 2M9 $ 7 77$" 5#$ 3$! "$
$"$7$3$59
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?( )(&GGG
* ,
&=((
* ,
&==(
* ,
&>GG
* ,
&===
* ,
&'((
* ,
&GGG
* M
&=((
* M
&==(
* M
&>GG
* M
&===
* M
&'((
* M
=s &L*
"
&$9*
=( >( '( 0( P( /( ?( )(&GGG
* ,
&=((
* ,
&==(
* ,
&>GG
* ,
&===
* ,
&'((
* ,
&GGG
* M
&=((
* M
&==(
* M
&>GG
* M
&===
* M
&'((
* M
=s &L*
"
&$9*
$, '(
G>?
- $A9'?D 11218" "$2"518"2$"8$']1,
(!?P]1M!8$$18"$0G(L 9 517"#$8"$
119U>GV
- $A9')D8" 11#$3$2"8$213
3$5, @M! ";'=(L 9 517"#$8"$ 119U>GV
2"4$ " " 3$5 $ 11 25"$
&7 $ A90(* 7 #$ 1"1 $ 51#$1 4"! 4
77$8"72" 249$2"8$
, $1#7$8"$;2M!2" 24$3$5
$$%$G!>A#$24$#$G!('A 2"8$
, $%78$18#$2M982"4$"
0
'
=
G
(
>
M2OgG(Pb
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 80
1
2
3
4
5
@M22OgG(
P b
-1
3$5
"
@=
(
=
'
P
( = ' P ?HJR;,-[
0'
>
=
/HJR;,
- [
0
'
=
G
(
>
M2OgG(Pb
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 80
1
2
3
4
5
@M22OgG(
P b
-1
0
'
=
G
(
>
M2OgG(Pb
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 80
1
2
3
4
5
@M22OgG(
P b
-1
3$5
"
@=
(
=
'
P
( = ' P ?HJR;,-[
0'
>
=
/HJR;,
- [
'
>
'
>=
'
>=
'
>=
'
>
=
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14Z2/*106
0
2
4
6
8
-Z22
/*10
6
'
>
'
>=
'
>=
'
>=
'
>
=
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14Z2/*106
0
2
4
6
8
-Z22
/*10
6
$, '(
G>)
72"8$ 3$5! 28832"3$181
$2137192$ 12"8$, 84#$$$ 1
"9 77#$2"8$, 7%#$2"8$
M 17"9 34 8 4"7" 18
"518"2$"8$, M841'(!?P]1
$0!)(!']192"5&'O(!?P]1*86$"8$18#$
2"5&0!)O(!']1*!3#$2"8$, 8$739
13 #$ $5 M 8$ 27$ #$ , 9 2"4$ $
51 $4" 7 24 18"$ &7 $ A90G*
71 27$ $5M$ 88""$9$#$
2"8$, !3$571"2$71M8$"8&(!?P]1*
1 $9 & 4$% 8 $ 2 "51#$ 3$5
1" 8 +51 $ ! A! 7 23< 2$ 56
$8"4$8$2"=((P*9
- $A90(D 51"72418"$8$213
3$5, @MU>GV
G = > ' 0
0
0!0
P
P!0
/
/!0
GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/
&?J[@
10000/T(K-1)
Ea=1,27
Ea=1,29
Ea=1,04
Ea=1,26
Ea=1,34
'O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P0!)O(!'0!)O(!' '!(O(!' '!(O(!'
, OM G = > ' 0
0
0!0
P
P!0
/
/!0
GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/
&?J[@
10000/T(K-1)
Ea=1,27
Ea=1,29
Ea=1,04
Ea=1,26
Ea=1,34
G = > ' 0
0
0!0
P
P!0
/
/!0
GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/
&?J[@
10000/T(K-1)
Ea=1,27
Ea=1,29
Ea=1,04
Ea=1,26
Ea=1,34
'O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P0!)O(!'0!)O(!' '!(O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P0!)O(!'0!)O(!' '!(O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P0!)O(!'0!)O(!' '!(O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P0!)O(!'0!)O(!' '!(O(!' '!(O(!'
, OM
$, '(
G'(
- $A90GD 51$4"3$5, @M72418"$
U>GV
7"8$8""14J13$5!<$$%
"8$$1$"#$;$<$#$2;18"$2?((L !
11$1$59 $ 2388""$
2 % 6 2"#$3 &8$ 2"4$ $3$5*9 !
"$ 8"1 "5 "" $ 2 8 $3 $
51#$1$81"$118"$2$
@- 9
4$-"
8 $ 181 M! 4$ 231
18"$ 71 - ! "" "" 711 8 8$4"
5#$"4;831"#$$1" H$% @
% 69213 4J1"" 5""$$3 %3
&'>(*!14"- &@?M!*9
$ 23! $ 3 "$1 G(_ 9 ,$1 18"
8$ 56 $ , 9 61 8" $ 25"" $ " 1
'O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' 0!)O(!' '!(O(!' '!(O(!'
, OM
@/
@P!0
@P
@0!0
@0
@'!0
@'
@>!0
@>G( GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/ G?
aG!=P0A
aG!=)>AaG!=/'A
aG!=P=A
a(!))PA
G((((O&f@G*
&iO91
@G* 'O(!?P
G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' 0!)O(!' '!(O(!' '!(O(!'
, OM 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' 0!)O(!' '!(O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' 0!)O(!' '!(O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' 0!)O(!' '!(O(!' '!(O(!'
'O(!?P 'O(!?P G!)O(!?P G!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!?P 0!)O(!' 0!)O(!' '!(O(!' '!(O(!'
, OM
@/
@P!0
@P
@0!0
@0
@'!0
@'
@>!0
@>G( GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/ G?
aG!=P0A
aG!=)>AaG!=/'A
aG!=P=A
a(!))PA
G((((O&f@G*
&iO91
@G*
@/
@P!0
@P
@0!0
@0
@'!0
@'
@>!0
@>G( GG G= G> G' G0 GP G/ G?
aG!=P0A
aG!=)>AaG!=/'A
aG!=P=A
a(!))PA
G((((O&f@G*
&iO91
@G*
$, '(
G'G
8$4"8""$9"1$"381
2% 6! =!0 1! 8$ 23 2$ 18" 8! $88"
F51"#$!""7"81829213"8N8"
$$7$"$185 18!743;2184"
$59$$$3$8$%!25"$71$$88
392$2$$$8$"8$N#$2$2$8-
812$ 1 !1!$%! 71""8"
$351 """"8$189$#$12"3!
$ $ 3$ 4 ; 2" 34" 8 #$
1"1 1 $ 2 % 8 < 9
" "#$ 7$" 8 2" 24
3$$1J12 $#$"$!44$" 61
$8"$918"283$73882% 68$
$18"$418"$71@- 9
$$135&$4$1"$*!""""$519
2$ 88"" 7" 71 8 81 1
"481!8410'18$3
&@*9 3 8" 8 85"16 25"" #$ 2"
88#$" 8$" ;=(XH9$! 8$4" "4 3&@*
"463!#$$$8$"$98"1
8"8$2318$==)!71185$
$$ $3#$ $ E ; 8 '((L 9 234 $ + $ 76
$8$ "#$ 2$185 18! $4 4$9 5"
4J1$3@?M!4861$"#$!
8791$"#$711218$13
$$4"#$71""1"485lp m
$% $ 0?(L 91"1 $ N" 8 2"
24 $ 1J1 $ #$ "$9 $ #$
18"$ 1$! E 2 8 3 $ 73 8 8
2% 6#$ $8$"4$ 4$ "4 8
82% 693855$18"$83$3$
$8$8$9"8N5""43@G(_89185
86 $ $ $@; '((L !1 $ $1 3 8
188$$562$E$3#$185"92$+
$, '(
G'=
1#$76$8$184$%91$"#$3
86$%1$! "$ $5 4 $
81 5$77 9 "8N 8$4"" ; 8 3 @ > _ 89
$41J11819
7!182""7"4$4$%1"$%"46
#$8688""$#$2%$8"$9
8$!, 283$73882% 692<$2$
7 $5 M $88" "4 "39 2"3 2$ "
3$5 , OM 81 5#$ 1$5 1 $
185 $8$8$, ; 6 8$M92"$ 887
1"1" $2%$3$5, OM
$$ 9
$, '(
G'>
4$D5 & / 4
UGV 9+!9!-9! 9-H!$7 5 !GGP@GG)!
&G)))*!/=G@/=P
U=V :99+$!:$75 517!>(!&G)P)*!=P0/@=P/(
U>V 9"8!9$! 9 -3! :9 -$!911$!9fH! 9 3! :99
$#$!51"1#$!,3!+=?P??>''//
U'V M95$!9 !9$ !:9f!!G'?!&=((=*!0P/@0/>
U0V ,99 5!-99-94+X!!?>!&G))P*!G/@=/
UPV 9$H$X!9fX!99!!G0G!&=((=*!GGG@G=G
U/V 9,$3!56 @4"P!&=(('*
U?V 9+! 9-H!$7 5 !?P@?/!&G))P*!/==@/=/
U)V :@:9+!5#$2 "$!"8N88$4"5#$!GP0/
UG(V-9!9 !9+! 9-H!8"5-1
UGGV9H! !P?!&=((G*!>)G@'((
UG=V 9 ,$3! 9 +! 9 $"! 9 ! 9 +! :$ 7
51!?!&=(('*!P>>@P>/
UG>V9+!-9!A!GG!&=((0*!==@=P
UG'V9S9771!:$7A$$15 !G=!&G))'*!)0>@)PG
UG0V9S51! 4W!G/!&G))=*!0'/@
0)P
UGPV9!-9,$!9+5X!9$%!9 !$!'('!&=(((*!?0P@
?0?
UG/V9!!=!&=(((*!/00@/0?
UG?V9+!56!&G))G*!
UG)V9, !562$4"$!&=((>*!
U=(V9@8H! :9 9 $H@! 9 "H@ ! 9 H! :9 9 9 3! :99
-!:$751!?!&=(('*!P>?@P'>
U=GV9, !-9,$!-97!95854!-9-$5!9$!9!
!GPG!&=((>*!=>G@='G
U==V :99 !99!9 3H!94@! 9+$#$! :$ 7
51!GP/!&=((=*!?(@?0
U=>V 99H$!9@8H!99 5$!A9A9f5! 9A9 8! 9H!
:99-!51!')!&=(('*!>0G/@>0='
U='V9!56!&=((G*!
$, '(
G''
U=0VA9A9f5!-99+9#$!9X!!G/'!&=(('*!G>0@G')
U=PV9:9X!:99f!&1=((>*!>G@>/
U=/V+9 9!!G=)!&=(((*!)0@GG(
U=?V 9 4@77"! 9 S"3! 9 3! :$ 7 $8 1 ! =G!
&=((G*!G?(0@G?GG
U=)V995!:$71 1!/P!&G))>*!0P>@0??
U>(V-99#$!994!!G((!&G))/*!=)@>?
U>GV 9+51!9 $"!9,$3!9 !9+!9+$8:$
7W$&=((0*
%"
%
G'0
"&
4J18$4J 18"11" @-
""""88$4"5#$1 "31"#$8"2$
81 "7 @% 697 277$ $ N $ 8$ 5""!
$1"5 7"1"#$1 $ 8 $ , $"9 81 "7
81232$718!1861%"!4
48$"4"9$5#$1"$"$"!$48"1
" ; "1 "8N $ ; 56 4J1
8!51 6"8$%18!7Q;8$4$
56 4J1 41 7 "8$ &G( ]1*9 213
88"" "#$ $5 "" "" 8 88 218"
1118"$@- &<$#$?((L *!8$1$71!1$
$77"882% 6""77$"9
8168"$!4J1M""5"";8
3 1"#$ H$1 H$1 "!
8"31"788#$$88"8$5$$
5"$4$$$39$23!$"2"54$#$1
3H$1""""3"97183"7!
77 2" 8" "" " 7 4 $$
"8N"32% 6!84
9213 71$ $$$3#$; 7" H!
$ 11 8$ $ 2 %9 28 71!
8"!B48412827$$$189
88"" "#$"8N 4 "$ 8" $
33"51#$";$3"$ 51#$9$
2%N"81"$8$4J18$4
8$8$@ $&< *484#$$ 19
"$ $ #$ ; 73" 2" "7" $5
1 8 5#$ 8$4" 5#$ 1 " "49
%
G'P
" 1""""8$5"$$#$#$H8@
8$4"2$3H$1"2$3H$19 85
H $83 277 3 88"" 1"#$ "#$
1 18"$ 2$ @- 9 $ $ "$ 4
8"18!85$3#$$3$
$5H#$#$ 1$%"9$ 718" 8$7
1$$!"$4 "77
E28H8"8$7716185"4J19$!
" 8$$4 2"$ 56 85 #$#$ $
$ 1J1 8 55 #$ $ "" 8$ 23 85
$3#$9
$%8$181M""""$51
88$4"5#$1 ""492 " "
&,8 *$135&E*9, "3";8
2$$3"$1@ $1!213718"$$7$
"$185 4118$$38$%!#$
7434$2884J19$#$18$4"&-
$ *!5"$3713$2%
1<1 N"8 < 988"" "#$2"4$8
418$7882% 6!18"$17
1$ "$$ 8$ $ 18"$ 4 P((L 9 5 1 8$
28#$;2$18"$#$2"@- 9
4J1E" 1""5""8@8$4"2$
3 5 &$ 5 "* 2$ 3 1369 816
"#$ 5#$ 3 " ; 23 $ 18" 3 18
&==)* "" "1"9 +$ 2"3! 4J1 E 185
8$ $ 18"$ $8"$ ; '((L 9 284$% 76 $8$
"4$ 4 $ 185 $8$! 1 5" $3 71
$<$ %9 1$ "#$ 1 "4 71
8#$4""318"$44""5$18"$9 8!
18" 2 8 3 51#$1 $ 73 8 8 2% 69
2$2$35"813855$18"$$
E$3$"&(!?(!=*==)#$8$$2%9
%
G'/
6 8 "$ " ; "3 $ " 3$5
, OM 7 8 "3 $ , 1$ "$$! <$ $
36877$M&1"$31$"$$*92"
"" $ 81 "1" 8$ 5#$ 1$59
2"7 $3O, OM " 3 $ 51#$ 25" 5#$
$5 39 " "#$ 1 "4 $ 181
41 18% ; 8" $ 3$59 13 #$ 2"8$
27$888""$#$8$N $4"888
"8$ , OM9 28871 18"5 $ 1"1
$ 2$ " 3$5 "3" 8 8$4" 5#$ 1 " 7
23< 2$ 56 $ 3 251 51 #$ &
+51! $ 8"4$ =((P* 2 " 4
- 9 3$ 4" 8 56 4J1 3$5 , OM
"1 2"8$ M $77 8$ $ $ 36 4@;@4 $ 1$
"$$8$, !$783""71$88"""#$
9
#'
4$ 1$ 18"$ 71 G((( ; /((L 8 ;13$3;%&- *! ""$ 2"8$$$$#$8$1"9%!8$4"5#$1 " "4 $ 56 4J1 2"8$ 183 4#$&∼0@G(]1*9
86$8$87%8"1 5#$"1 F$4 8$ 2"$! $ 8" "$ 1"$ "7" - ! H 3" ; 2$1 &M*9 $! $ %8 1$$$%8;181D" "&, *13 5 &E*9 213 1$ 8$ 5#$ 18" 4 "$9 7! $ "$ 8"1 1" $ 56 2$"3$5, OM9'/%8$4" "4! "! 8 ; 13$3 ; % ! H"!" "!135!88218"9
% % %
33"
51<8317%-$ &- *58 18$9 5 5 18$ 71G((( /((L ! 5 5 118$ .- 5 9 24 18 5 5X 7 5 $ $ 9 5 %! 5 4 1 8$ 8W7$ 5#$ 7 3 5 W5 183 5X W5 588&∼0@G(]1*9
7875%81471871575$!W81$3$51775- !53 M &M*9 5! W 8 1 $ 3$ W W 1 W55 5$47% 5M/((L D,8 &, *5$1$1%&E*9!W87$55753 D, OM9Z %48$ !!%-$ !3M!,8 !5$13$1%! 18%1888
![TÉLÉVISION FRANÇAISE Approuvé par: MANITOBA LÉVISION FRANÇAISE ... TN-0044 Août 2011 Approuvé par: P. Aubé, ... Microsoft PowerPoint - TN-0044_TVF_MB.ppt [Mode de compatibilité]](https://img.pdfslide.fr/doc/110x75/5aae41287f8b9a5d0a8be1b0/tlvision-franaise-approuv-par-manitoba-franaise-tn-0044-aot-2011-approuv.jpg)
