Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1 3 9
2 0 1 5 2 0 1 4
2015 " ,
. .
©
3
5 :'
5
:
6 �
:
,2016- 2015
17
28
35 :'
35
43 �
48
4
. - . , - . ; , ; . ,
.
5
2015 2014 ,139
:'
,4.3% (2015 2014 )
.
- ," "
.1" "
. 2014
,
.
,
.
2015
.
,
,
,2014
.2015
,
.
,
.(64 25)
, 2%-
.
0.4%- :
- .
, ;2015
1
, .
2015 .
, ,
,0.2%- .
.
,
,
,2015
0.15- 2015
.0.10 �
(2015 2014 )
2.2 , 3.5
.
�
,2014 � 2014
. 2015
,
" , 10- " .
2014 �
" �
.2014
17-
2015 .2015-
( 2014- 1/12)
. ,
- ( )
, "
,
,
� .
� ,2016- 2015-
.
-
6
: �
�
-
,
.
� �
, ,
-
�
.
�
- .
"
,OECD-
0.6 0.4-
.
�
, -
.
.
, 58%- 48%-
3.5% 2.0%-
.
. ,
,
,( )
, .
,
)
(
, .(2013 , )
, ,
.
,
.
.
�
Mankiw, Romer and .
,Hall and Jones (1999) ,Weil (1992)
( )
,
Solow -
.1
1
.
Johansen et al.-
,(2012)
;( )
:
� Johansen et al. (2012)
1
, ) Klenow and . (
.Bils and Klenow (2000)- Rodriguez-Clare (1997)
.
:
;
,
;
.
.
7
2015 2014 ,139
2010- .2
16- :
.3 10-
.1970-
4
40%-
, .70-
,
,
.
" Gordon (2014) :
" 2
," .2013 ,136 '
, - 3
Barro and Lee . 9- .(2013)
" 4
' ,".2013 ,136
0.2-
.
,
.
,( )
. �
,
.
.
.(' , , )
.
,
-
.
,
,
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
1 , OECD ,1970 -2010
1970 2010
:Johansson et al. (2012) , .
-
8
.
,
.
, ,
.
60- Islam et al. (2014)
,2010 1970
, ( )
.
- , .
: 5Firt Principal Component
- ,
, ,
500
, .
:
.
)
,(
.
Hanushek and Woessmann (2012)
.
12-
-
) 2003 1964 15 9
.(
,(100 500 ) "
. � First Principal Component 5
.
.
50 .(100- )
( )
1960
100) :2000-
( "
, .
,
,
.6
,
.
Bouis, Duval and Murtin (2011)
( ) 40-
.2005 1970
Hanushek and Woessmann
(2012)
, .
" 100 )
( -
,90%-
.8,7Hanushek and Woessmann
Hanushek and- ,
,Woessmann
Hanushek and Woessmann 6
, . , . " . ( - )
. : 7
10 ,Hanushek and Woessmann (2012) 0.2 " . Hanushek and ) Bouis, Duval .(1+0.002)40-1=8.3%- (Woessmann ,and Murtin (2011)
. 9.0% 8
, . � 56% �
9
2015 2014 ,139
) ,
) (
10%- -
.( 5%-
,
.
, )
('
- )
.(
.
.
, 2
.2011 , "
.OECD- ,7.3% ,
2014 2011
. 0.5%- ,18% �
,
.
3 .
OECD-
.( , ) ,
:
, , .1
. OECD-
,
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
2 " , OECD ,2011
:Education at a Glance (2014)
"
-
10
' '
"R² = 0.8872
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
3 , , OECD ,2011
) PPP(
-OECD
.
" ) PPP(
:Education at a Glance (2014)
'
'
"
R² = 0.8454
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
.
" ) PPP(
) PPP(
-OECD
'
'
"R² = 0.7295
0
4,000
8,000
12,000
16,000
20,000
24,000
28,000
. -
" ) PPP(
) PPP(
-OECD
11
2015 2014 ,139
.
. ,2011- ,
.2
.
: -
,
)
, ,
.(Balassa-Samuelson �
.3
. ,
,
.
,2011- ,
"
."
.OECD-
.
.(OECD- 22 )
(39%)
- , .(44%)
,
,
.
.
4 .
.
.OECD-
.
.
.
0
10
20
30
40
4 , ,
OECD ,2012
:Education at a Glance (2014)
-
12
5 . -
Hanushek and .
,Woessmann (2012)
,( ) OECD-
4.7
.5.0- , ,
Bouis, - (2012) Hanushek and Woessmann
Duval and Murtin (2011)
0.6-
27%-
, )
,
.(
"
:9(5 ,2012 )
.
"
.15 " 9
,
.10
-
. ,
( )
. ,
Hanushek .
(2006)
,
. ,
.
,Hanushek (2006)-
Dolton and Marcenaro-Gutierrez (2011) .
10
. , , �
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
5 - ) 1964 2003 (
" )2012(
"
:Hanushek and Woessmann (2012), PISA (2012)
13
2015 2014 ,139
,
,
- .
Holmlund et al. (2010) ,
Fredriksson (2013) .
.42 24
Jackson et al. (2015) ,
10% "
( 12 )
.7.25%-
.
- .
,
. -
,Times Higher Education
400
,(30%) 13
,(30%) ,(30%)
, 6 .12 ,11(7.5%) - (2.5%)
,OECD-
( ) 200
.( )
,
.39 20
:
� - 11
. "
QS , 12
Times .(Quacquarelli Symonds) Higher Education
.
:
�
200 i
.
1 �
0 i j
.
Times- j �
Higher Education World University Rankings
.2014/15
�
Times Higher Education World : .j
2014/15- 2013/14 University Rankings
.
.(2012) i 39 20 �
.OECD- :
,
200
,( )
)
,(
" .(39 20)
. 200
(39 20 )
" ,( )
Islam et al.- .
. (2014)
(2014/15) ,
,( ) 200
.
200
,
, -
.200-
,
ij
jjji
Pop
StudScoreINDiM
200
1
**200
iM 200
jINDi
jScore
jStud
iPop
-
14
� 15-
)
,
.13(1 ;16- 10
, ) 2011/12
.( 200
,2010/11 ,
. 200
,
,
( 200 ) 400 100
.39 20
.
,
,( ) �
-
13
, 200 8 ,15- � . 200 � ,
.
�
.
.
,( )
,
.
,
-
,
.
2012/3 ,
. 60%-
, (2007)
16- , ,
)
,
.(
:
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
6 Times
Higher Education1,2015-2014
) * ( 20 39
200
1 -200 .
: Times Higher Education Ranking 2014-2015 ,OECD , , Wikipedia .
15
2015 2014 ,139
,
.14
"
15
.16
�
�
,
, . -
,
.
,58%- 48%-
3.5% 2.0%-
.
39% 1996-
,2012- 48%-
.
,
(1) :
(2) ;
,(2014) 1-' 14
. 15
" " 48% ,2012- � " 4 , 3
. ,(2013) 1-' 16
" :."
(3) ;1730%
16
.(2007 , )
/
,
.
.
,
10
, "
) 9% 6%-
.(
:
" ,(2013) '
."2059 2013
.30 7 ' ,87
" ,(2007) ' ' , ' ,'
:
. ."
," " ,(2009) ' '
.30 7 ' ,87
Barro, R. and J.W. Lee (2013), "A New Data Set of
Educational Attainment in the World, 1950-2010".
J 104, pp. 184-
198.
Bils, M. and P. Klenow (2000), "Does Schooling
Cause Growth?". The American Economic Review
90(5), pp. 1160-1183.
Bouis, R., R. Duval and F. Murtin (2011), The Policy
and Institutional Drivers of Economic Growth
,(2009) 17
.10%- � " :
," ,136 '
.2013
-
16
Across OECD and non-OECD Economies. OECD
Economics Department Working Papers No. 283.
Dolton, P. and O. Marcenaro-Gutierrez (2011), "If
You Pay Peanuts do You Get Monkeys? A Cross
Country Comparison of Teacher Pay and Pupil
Performance", 26, Issue 65, pp.
5-55.
Fredriksson, P., B. Ockert and H. Oosterbeek (2013),
"Long Term Effects of Class Size", T
128(1), pp. 249-285.
Gordon, R. (2014), The Demise of U.S. Economic
Growth: Restatement, Rebuttal, and Reflections.
Department of Economics, Northwestern University,
Manuscript.
Hall, R. and C. Jones (1999), "Why Do Some
Countries Produce So Much More Output Per
Worker Than Others ",
114(1), pp. 83-116.
Hanushek, E. (2006), "School Resources", in
Hanushek, E. and F. Welch (Eds.)
2006 (2), Chapter 14.
Hanushek, E. A. and L. Woessmann (2012), "Do
Better Schools Lead to More Growth? Cognitive
Skills, Economic Outcomes, and Causation",
17, pp. 267-321.
Holmlund, H., S. McNally and M. Viarengo (2010),
"Does Money Matter for Schools?",
29, pp. 1154-1164.
Islam, R., J. Ang and J. Madsen (2014), "Quality-
Adjusted Human Capital and Productivity Growth".
52 (2), pp. 757-777.
Jackson, K., R. Johnson and C. Persico (2015),
The Effects of school Spending on Educational
and Economic Outcomes: Evidence from School
Finance Reforms. NBER Working Paper No. 20847.
Johansson, A., Y. Guillemette, F. Murtin, D. Turner,
G. Nicoletti, C. de la Maisonneuve, P. Bagnoli, G.
Bousquet and F. Spinelli (2012), Long-Term Growth
Scenarios. OECD Economics Department Working
Paper No. 1000.
Klenow, P. and A. Rodriguez-Clare (1997), "The
Neoclassical Revival in Growth Economics: Has it
Gone Too Far?" in Bernanke, B. and J. Rotemberg
(Eds.). NBER Macroeconomics Annual 1997,
Volume 12. MIT Press.
Mankiw, G., D. Romer and D. Weil (1992), "A
Contribution to the Empirics of Economic Growth
", 107(2), pp.
407-437.
17
2015 2014 ,139
: ,2016- 2015
� 2015
,
.
� 2.8 2.5 � 2015-
.
�
.
:
. -
� � 2016-
,
3.3- �
3.5- 2020 2017 ,
. ,
� �
� ,
- 2016- " 10-
.2020- 14
2020
.
�
,
,
.
� , ,
, 2.5
, ,
.
�
,
,
,
.
� ,
. 70-
� ,
,
,
.
�
,
.
, -
. - ,
.1
2014- 2013
.
2015- ,
2015- ,
2014 2013 .
,
, .
,
, ,
.
.
,
�
� (2- 1 )
,
.(3 )
-
18
, ,
.
,
, ,
,
. ,
-
.
. ,2015
2015
1/12 ,
.12014
2015
� 2016 �
, 1
. ,
.
39.5
45.3
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
65
.OECD :
1 , OECD ,2014
30.8
43.2
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
: OECD.1 �2014.
2 , OECD ,2012 1
19
2015 2014 ,139
.
,
, 2015-
, .2
,
.
.
�
" - " ,
. � " 4.3
2.6 12-
2.8- 2.5 ,
) .(4 )
� (
2
.2015 ,138 '
http://www.boi.org.il/he/NewsAndPublications/RegularPublications/DocLib3/RecentEconomicDevelopments/develop138h.pdf
,
� 2016
,
.
31.034.2
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
3
, OECD ,2013 1
.OECD : 1 �2014.
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
4 -12 ,
: ," .
-
20
.2
,
, .
. " 8-
,
,
� - �
.
-
,OECD
,3
- .
,
�
�
.
,OECD
)
.(3 1
, ,
, -
. -
,
,(2014) 3
http://www.boi.org.il/he/ .' ,NewsAndPublications/RegularPublications/DocLib3/20% 20% 20% /BankIsraelAnnualReport
chap-8-2013.pdf/2013
,4
� �
.
, -
.
-
: , -
,
.
,
.
,
.5
,
� ,
,(2015) 4
(3-' ) 40-
.2012 2010- 2001 1999
http://www.boi.org.il/he/NewsAndPublications/RegularPublications/DocLib3/20% 20% 20% /BankIsraelAnnualReportchap-8-2013.pdf/2013
' 5
. ' '
,136
http://www.boi.org.il/he/NewsAndPublications/RegularPublications/DocLib3/RecentEconomicDevelopments/develop136h.pdf
. ,(2013) 1-'
http://www.boi.org.il/he/NewsAndPublications/RegularPublications/DocLib3/20% 20% 20% /BankIsraelAnnualReportchap-5.pdf/2012
21
2015 2014 ,139
;
;
.
,
,6 ,
, .7
, -
.
,
. -
, " 2.5-
; " 2015- "
( ) .8
)
, " (
( ) .
( )
, "
( ) .
.
"
,
, "
: " : 6
."2012
http://www.boi.org.il/he/Pages/Search.aspx?k=%D7%9E%D7%A2%D7%A0%D7%A7%20%D7%A2%D7%91%D7%95%D7%93%D7%94&s=Hebrew 7
. .2013- 8
-
.OECD
,
.9
� �
.10 " 8-
,
1.3 .
500 "
.2018- ,2017- 500 ,2016-
"
,
0.5 ,
.2017- 0.5 2016- "
6-
.2018- 7.5- 2016- "
.
,
.
,
,
.
,
.
" 9
154 ' , ,(2015) .158
http://www.boi.org.il/he/NewsAndPublications/RegularPublications/DocLib3/20% 20% 20% /BankIsraelAnnualReportchap-6.pdf/2014
10
, ,
.
-
22
,
.
,
.
,
,
,
.
,
.
2016 .3
2016
.2013
1.9)
(2016- 2015- ,2014 2012
) 50
(
, .(2014 67.1)
, 2.66 2015
.11 " 8.4
, 2016-
, 2015
2015
" 8.6- 2016 .2014
, .(1 )
. 11
" 3.75 , ,2014 6- ) , ( " 2 ) 2014 2013 ,2015 10
.(7.10.2014-
,2016-
.12
,
,
,
.
,
, .
, - ,
,
, .
,
.
.
.13
,2001 ,
, 2- ,
.
,
,
.
,
.
- ;
,
.14
� 12
. 2- � 2015 2016 (2014) 13
.' , , 14
.
23
2015 2014 ,139
,
,2015-
,2016-
.
,2014-
.2016-
,
.
�
,
,
)
15(
�
15
.
.16 " 10 2016-
" 6-
. 2
2016
6.5- . " 16-
"
( )
.17
�
�
:
16
. , ) , .2002 ,(2003) 3-' ,
. " 6.5 17
, .
. ,
2016 :1
( " )
1( , ) 2014 319.3
21 3.8
3(1-2) 2015- 315.5
(%)
4 2.66
( " )
52(3*4) 2015 8.4
622015- 0.0
7(3+5+6) 323.9
8(4*7) 2016 8.6
932016- 4.5
10(7+8+9) 2016- 337.5
. 2013 1
2015- ,2015 - 2
. .2014
.2015- 2016- .2015 3
. :
-
24
.
,
,
.
.
)
,
.(
"
" � "
, ,18
.19
,
,
.20 -
,
( )
,
,
.
,
18
. , 19
" " ,
. ,(2015) 2-' 20
http://www.boi.org.il/he/NewsAndPublications/RegularPublications/DocLib3/20% 20% 20% /BankIsraelAnnualReportchap-6.pdf/2014
. ,
,
. ,
, - 2008
,
- , .2013
,
.21
.
� -
�
, "
.
-
.
2020 2015 .4
, -
,
-
.
,
.
2016-
� 22 3
.
21
: " ,(2012) ' , "
. ,8 2016 22
.22.6.2015-
25
2015 2014 ,139
, 5
" � ) 2014
2- .("
6 . 2019- 1.5- 2016-
,( )
62-
, � 2020
, .
. ,
7 5
,
. 2020
2017- 3.5-
.
.2020- 71-
,
� ,
�
� .23
,
�
10- , ,
) 2020 2017 24 "
,(25
,2020 0.5 0.3-
.
: 23
" ,(2015) ' ' , , : "
. , ,"
http://www.boi.org.il/he/Research/DocLib/dp1502.pdf.2016- , , 24
25
" ,(2013) ' 31 ' ,87 ,"
,68
http://www.boi.org.il/he/Research/DocLib/dp1412h.pdf
" ,(2014) ' ' . , ,"
http://www.boi.org.il/he/Research/DocLib/dp1412h.pdf
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
5
,2014 2020
: .
6
,2014 2020
: .
55
57
59
61
63
65
67
69
71
73
75
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
-
26
7 5
2.5- .
. ,
, 66-
,
.
2020 2017
,2016- . " 4.5-
.26
1.2-
.(7 )
,
.27 ,
:
,
.
)
.(2
,
26
, ,
. 2015 27
, " 1.3- ,2014- .( )
.2020 2015-
37
38
39
40
41
42
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
7
,2014 2020
: .
, .28
. ,
2-
) 2020 2016
,(5
�
.
� ,
. �
,
.
28
, - . . ,
:
" ,(2015) ' ' , , : "
. , ,"
27
2015 2014 ,139
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
3 4 2
8 ,
2014 2020
: .
,
.
,6- 5
. 2.5-
, ,
,
)
.(
,
.
.
OECD-
. - ,
,
, 4
, .(8 )
, 2
) 4
- (8
. 75
-
28
2015201420151,2
2014IIIIIIIVIIVI
2.82.81.60.86.52.13.42.3
"2.72.61.80.07.52.64.12.2
4.11.86.05.47.97.55.95.2
-0.44.21.5-9.9-5.720.92.23.1
-2.8-12.0-5.3-7.09.0-6.5-3.0-4.5
2.1-2.5-4.4-3.512.8-2.90.30.03 1.29.2-21.12.210.4-3.8-1.3-4.0
3 0.8-2.28.6-17.66.12.4-1.7-1.3
4 2.6-2.42.210.64.514.04.25.25
1.0-7.1-3.718.4-9.517.00.52.35 6.530.38.67.2-9.221.67.98.5
4.23.76.65.66.90.84.44.2
3.94.36.16.25.9-0.53.94.4
3.33.05.24.03.48.85.04.6
. 1
. :
. - 5
. - 3
. , 4
2014
2015 2014 , :1-'
. 2
( , , , )
2
29
2015 2014 ,139
1*
0.30.30.40.30.30.41.82.63
1.4-0.2-1.62.6-0.51.53.26.13
( ) -1.10.51.4-0.21.53.44.82.13
-2.00.00.90.5-2.11.51.91.23
- -1.2-0.22.2-0.1-0.80.13.33.23
- 0.50.7-6.05.90.10.50.43.43
6.7-1.00.4-3.61.20.2-7.4-19.43
-15.513.7-5.18.65.2-9.31.7-7.93
-6.642.9-13.5-24.161.4-20.014.517.932,1
( ) " 9954,1436,364123
0.230.220.240.240.230.263
0.250.250.260.290.280.263
0.230.210.240.220.210.2734
0.180.190.210.200.200.223
0.190.210.190.210.220.233
. , :
. . ( " ) 2
. 1
: . * ,(1) ; - ,(2) ; - ,(3)
. - ,(12) ; -
. 4
. 3
20142015
2015 2014 , :2-' ( , )
-
30
I/20152015
( )IIIIIIIVI1*
3,801.51.30.60.30.5-0.1-0.11.53 3,596.21.20.40.21.10.20.21.93
1,301.31.20.31.42.10.80.84.53 2,296.41.20.6-0.30.5-0.3-0.30.53
( ) 296.8-0.1-0.8-2.00.30.60.6-2.03
( ) 35.4-0.3-1.7-1.74.6-3.3-3.3-1.33
) (108,368.10.5-1.4-0.51.5-0.6-0.6-0.23
94,899.30.4-1.5-0.21.7-0.7-0.70.23
( )32,731.40.4-1.51.13.3-0.7-0.72.33
205.43.84.32.1-8.6-4.3-4.3-5.93 206.0-0.7-1.11.9-0.8-2.4-1.0-3.91
89.5-0.6-6.08.10.8-0.84.31.63( " ) 76.50.42.70.89.55.212.819.63
( )2 0.70.30.60.21.11.12.43
0.80.30.80.41.31.52.43 0.40.40.90.51.21.52.43
2 9,276.50.30.50.60.01.00.81.83 8,954.60.80.30.60.40.71.01.93
9,437.20.10.60.9-0.21.10.81.93 1.00.30.7-1.912
64.264.364.264.263.83 60.460.460.260.660.43 5.96.16.25.65.43
3 23.119.616.721.221.63
: . * ,(2) ; - ,(3)
. - ,(12) ; - ,(1) ; -
, - . : ; , ; ,
, ; " , ; , .
.( ) 3
. 1
. . 2
2015 2014 , :3-'
( , )
( , )
2014
31
2015 2014 ,139
201512014IIIIIIIVI*
-1.80.5-0.8-1.5-5.31.43 -2.7-0.1-1.6-2.3-6.70.23
2
-1.30.6-0.9-1.0-1.30.10.4-0.53 -6.90.4-5.0-4.1-6.90.02.8-0.53
5.60.24.13.25.60.1-2.4-0.13 -29.9-0.3-4.4-6.2-19.00.7-7.71.03
13.9-1.2-0.24.93.78.55.03 12.0-1.41.12.53.811.64.73
:11.5-11.4-20.08.06.011.30.43 " -0.30.110.6-0.71.210.53.43
1.90.62.90.06.33.12.63 3.05.95.83.84.61
:3.3-1.77.38.24.213 -2.82.6-0.2-1.6-0.51
3.73.96.36.16.26.05.43
2015 2014 , :4-'
20142015
2014
. , :
: . * ; - ,(1) ; - ,(2) ; - ,(3)
. - ,(12)
. 2
. 1
. 3
-
32
20152,12014IIIIIIIVI
2*
4
4.41.4-0.3-0.50.2-6.9-3.5-4.23
:9.03.51.02.23.0-11.5-1.91.13
4.91.1-4.8-1.33.9-15.7-4.9-11.73
2.30.70.8-1.5-2.4-1.5-3.9-3.93
1.4-0.5-4.10.40.8-1.60.2-6.03
:1.5-0.8-3.52.0-0.4-2.5-0.7-5.83
: -1.5-6.8-3.4-2.76.28.59.2-4.23
98,52325,60324,58624,24924,08523,7143 93,14823,63523,18123,75522,57822,0203
/ 5,3751,9691,4054941,5071,6943 / 13,2534,6824,3961,5252,6492,8853
2( " ) -8,573-961-1,845-498-5,269-3,46132 :6,7383,2141,4992,056-304,2003
29,5552,8641,8811,9162,8949683
2 "11,9074,2875,5121,7173924,53132 , 86,10185,56286,81986,18386,10184,969-1.4-0.732,5( ) -35.6-29.6-29.0-31.4-34.3-37.33
. 1
. :
. , , 4
. 2
. 3
. 5
2015 2014 , , :5-' ( )
: . * ; - ,(2) ; - ,(3)
. - ,(12) ; - ,(1)
( ) 3
2014
33
2015 2014 ,139
* 0.3-0.20.0-0.9-0.70.3-1.2-1.03
0.20.10.0-0.4-0.40.2-0.3-1.031 0.40.30.60.40.80.43.03.43
2 -0.72.4-1.9-0.84.46.510.114.833 1.31.01.2-1.8-1.50.73.73.53
1.61.11.3-2.2-2.70.33.01.734 0.30.40.41.00.30.12.43.83
2 0.20.20.20.20.20.10.21.032 5- " -0.4-0.3-0.2-0.3-0.6-0.7-0.4-0.23
2,5 -0.2-4.4-3.5-0.7-0.1-1.1-8.3-23.83
-0.3-0.1-0.2-0.5-1.0-1.0-0.6-0.53
. 4
. :
38 28 ( ) 3
. ,
. 1
. 6
. 2
. . Credit Default Swap (CDS) 5
6 12-
, , , , :6-'
: . * ; - ,(2) ; - ,(3)
. - ,(12) ; - ,(1)
2015 2014 ,
( )
20142015
-
34
20152016
20132014 "3.43.43.53.8
1 1.41.82.42.4
5.04.64.34.7
3.53.43.74.7 2.13.33.34.3
3.13.33.24.1 5.53.73.55.5
4.63.45.35.7
( ) - 2-0.9-7.5-39.612.9
-1.2-4.0-14.1-1.0
( ) 1.41.40.41.43( ) 0.40.30.71.9
0.20.20.00.0( ) 7.97.36.96.6
.2015 ,World Economic Outlook (IMF) :
( , )
:7-'
. World Economic Outlook- 1
.
. , " 96.25 2014- (U.K. Brent, Dubai, West Texas) 2
. 65.65 2016 , 58.14 2015
. LIBOR- - ; LIBOR- - 3
35
2015 2014 ,139
:'
�
.2008
.2014 ,
�
,
.
�
,
,
.
,
.
.1
.2008-
2008 :
,( ) 1.7%
. 2014 11.5%-
6%
,2007 , .1(1 )
, ( ) 60%-
.80%- 2012
� 2007-
�
.22007-
. 1
35%- , 2
� 2007 .2005- 2000 30%- � 80%- 20% ) . ( ,
.
,2010 ; ) �
.(2011
)
, (
, .3
.4
, )
, ,(
,
.
, -
/ :
. /
.
. 6%
,
.
.
- /
.
3
.Card and Ransom (2011) Scholtz et al. - Martin and Whitehouse, 2008
.(2006).2-' , ,(2011) 4
-
36
,
.
65%-
( " 9,000- 2,000 )
) 5
.5(
.2
, ,
�
.
, .
,2008
.6
5
2001- .( 55) 60- 22 ;2006 75%- ,2006- 72%- ,2007- .2012 . ,56%- 60% ,
. ( ) 6
,( )
.
,
, .
.
:
) .
.(1 ) (
, ,
2007- 1
. 0
5-
.7(2012- 2007 )
,
,
. ,
10%
,
.
5 7
. ,
.
: :1 ( , )
"
1.1.20080.830.830.832.5
1.1.20091.661.661.685
1.1.20102.52.52.57.5
1.1.20113.333.333.3410
1.1.20124.164.164.1812.5
1.1.201355515
1.1.201465.5617.5
37
2015 2014 ,139
.2012- 2000
, ,
.
,
2001 ,
) 2006-
.(2001
2012 2007
,2006 2001
:
0 1
.8
, ,2012 2001
.
,
, , 8
,
.
.
2006- 2001
,2012- 2007
,
, :
)
,(
.9
,
.
, ,
.
�
.
,
,
.
, ,
(2012 2007)
� ,(2006 2001)
�
" 4,000- )
.(2007
,
.
4,000- ,
. , "
.
,
.
,
. 9
, . ,
.( 4 )
* -100.
: .
1 64-25 ,
2001 2006 -2007 2012
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
- 2001
- 2007
0 1 2 3 4 5
-
38
,
, .
. ,
,
.
, .
,
5%- .
, 2008
.
.
,2001
,2007
,2 .10
,
, , ,
.
.
.3
2007-
,11(3 )
� 10
36% � .2012- 2007 40% 2006- 2001
. ,23%- 21%- 11
,( ) 2007 , .
2001 , :2 12007-
2001-
2007-
2001-
2007-
)(
0.520.510.40.43
( ) 36.3436.9933.2834.24
1989 0.290.280.240.21
%) (0.720.760.620.65
( " ) 64.2468.1945.3246.09
11.1311.399.9310.34
/ /0.260.290.40.42
3 0 0.290.30.30.31
18 4 0.890.860.780.9
30 1 0.140.140.380.36
100 30 0.230.220.310.3
1,000 100 0.40.410.230.25
1,000- 0.230.230.080.09
(55 ) 60 22 , " 9,000- 2,000 1
) " 2,000 5 , .2007 .(
39
2015 2014 ,139
.2006- 2001 � �
2012- 2007
7.5%- 2007-
,2007-
2001 4.5%-
.2006-
,121%
.(1 ) 4.16% � 2012
: 4 .
-
.
.-5.25 t 12
12012 2007- 2006 2001 : :3 ( ) :
2007
2012-t
2001
2006-t
-7.612-13.73**-2.958-4.27**
-20.79-26.24**-19.569-18.28**
3 0 -2.081-4.51**-2.939-4.87**
8 4 -3.14-7.97**-2.971-5.6**
1988 -7.466-13.22**-5.662-7.75**
( " ) -5.341-71.8**-4.976-51.87**
( " ) 0.03162.44**0.0346.04**
" 48- -8.524-9.53**-9.554-8.34**
6.23810.32**3.0513.801**
1.6586.79**1.6835.05**
10.02157.4**9.22342.31**
0.0076.68**0.0064.9**
133.06124.29**149.85420.59** 88,61267,756
R squared0.180.13
.2 1
,2007- ,2007- , , , : , * , * , * , * ,2007- , * , * ,2007- , 50 30 , 30 15 , 15 ,25 19 ,18 9
** .2001 2007 2006 2001 .2012- 2007 .1%
-
40
2012- 2007
,
, , .3
2012 2007
,2007 2002 2005 2000
.13
)
,( -
.
,
.
2006 2001 , 13
. 2012 2007 2000 2000 : 2007- 2007 , ,
.
,
. ,
/
,
.14
2001 �
,2009 2007- 2003
� 14
. � , .
. 35 30
1 - - :4
2012 2007- 2006 2001-
-7.61-2.96-4.65
2005 2000 -7.61-2.51-5.10
2007 2002 -7.61-3.12-4.49
-7.41-2.51-4.90
-5.38-1.11-4.27
-9.9-5.43-4.47
" 9,000- 4,000 -4.31-0.79-3.52
" 7,000- 2,000 -7.48-3.58-3.90
" 6,000- 3,500 -5.55-2.14-3.41
" 6,000- 3,000 -6.28-2.68-3.60
-7.52-3.07-4.45
23 -7.17-2.42-4.75
57 : 52 -7.49-2.44-5.05
26 21 -7.62-2.99-4.63
22009 2007- 2003 2001 -4.75-3.03-1.72
. ;3 1
.(1%- ) 3.09 t . 2
41
2015 2014 ,139
� (1 )
.15
� �
.2007-
,
,2012- 2007 ,2003 "
.
,
)
) .(
(
.
.
,
.
, . ,
,
�
. �
,
.
, .
15
2003- ,2006- 2001 .2009 2007 2009 ,2009 2003 ,
.
.
" " ,
:
,
.
, 8%- 4%
, .
,
.16
.
.4
� �
;4.5% 4%-
.2012 4.16% �
�
�
.
,
.
.
- 16
� . � , , . ,
.
-
42
,
�
.1780%- 50%
,2014 ,2007-
, 11%-
.2007
,
,
.
,
�
�
.
.
,
,
,
. 18
:
. ,(2011)
" ,(2010) '
,84 ,"
.123-87 '
" ,(2011) '
.119-90 ' ,(1/2) 58 ,"
;(1998) Poterba and Krueger ,Fuchs 17
.(2009) Melguizo and Paramo-Gonzales (2014) . ,
. 18
,(2011) .2-' ,
,(2014) ' '
, ,
.2014.08
Card D. and M. Ransom (2011), "Pension Plan
Charactersitics and Framing Effects in Employee
Savings Behavior",
93(1), pp. 228�243.
Fuchs V.R., A.B. Krueger and J.M. Poterba (1998),
"Economists' Views about Parameters, Values
and Policies: Survey Results in Labor and Public
Economics", 36(3),
pp. 1387�1423.
Martin, J., Whitehouse, E., 2008. Reforming
Retirement-Income Systems: Lessons from the
Recent Experiences of OECD Countries. Working
Papers, 66. OECD Social, Employment and
Migration.
Gonzales-Paramo, M. and Melguizo (2009), "Who
Bears Social-Security Taxes? A Meta-Analysis
Approach", Instituto de Estudios Fiscales, 20/09.
Scholz, J., Ananth Seshadri, K., Khitatrakun,
S., 2006. Are Americans Saving �Optimally' for
Retirement? . 114, 602-
643.
43
2015 2014 ,139
�
� (1994 )
.
�
.
�
,
.
.
.1
, , 2013- 2010
28
2013- .1
,2
.
.
.
,
, .
.
, ,
.
,
,
.
� 2012- 2011 , 11,000 2010 1
) 1,000- � 2013 , 8,000 .( , ,
. - , 2
.
) .3
;(4
�
;
.
,2009
, :
.
( ) , 10
.5 1,500
, 7.9
.
.6
5.8%-
4 ,
, .72008 2000
2009 :
.
" : 13 9 ' 3
" , ,(2011 ) ." , , : " , 4
,(2014) . " " .144 142 '
- 2015 " " 5
. 18,000 Assessment of the Effectiveness of Scrapping" 6
Schemes for Vehicles � Economic, Environmental andSafety Impacts" (March 2010), HIS.
Monitoring CO2 emissions from new passenger" 7
cars in the EU: summary of data for 2012", European Environment Agency, Page 7.
-
44
***
.8
.
,
. 3
,
,
,
. ,
.2
2010
-
20 .
,
1994
,
.9 70%-
� 2010
�
.10
,
.
( )
,(2008 ) " " (1 : 8
" (2 ; " " " ,(2011 ) " : " ,
." , , EMEP/EEA emission inventory guidebook, 2013, page 9
33. " 10
24- 22 15 ' ,(2011 ) " .28
.
-
.
,
,
.
" 3,300-
,
.12 ,11 " 200-
� " 100 �
.13 " 3,000
,14 28-
.1994 60,000-
.3
, :
) ,
.15(
. �
,
.
" 11
.24 23 ' ,(2011 ) " ) " 7,000- 12
40- ( . 1993- , " 300- 750-
. . " 13
, ,1994- 1993. " 3,000
.(2 ) , " 87 14
' ,' 15
" ,(2014) ' , , ," -
.
45
2015 2014 ,139
.
.
,
.
"
,162013 2009
,1994
.
.
1994 �
� 1994
.(1 )
.
,
.17
,( )
� 16
, , : .(" " ") . ,(9%) .(4.5%) 21,765 , 31,839 , � (68%) " . : .( ) :7 , ," " , "
. , � 17
� ( , , ) . " 60%- American Association of State Highway and : Transportation Officials" (2010), Highway Safety Manual.
.
.181 �
� ( / )
.2
,
,
(' ) .
. , 18
. � 29 25 � (10%)
.(15%)
0.5 -0.1 -0.4 -0.4 -0.2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
1 1
,
2009 2013
1 1994.: .
, :1 2013 ,
1994 : 1994 :
24-1523.5%21.9%
69-2570.9%74.5%
70+5.2%3.6%
. :
-
46
)
.19(
,
. ( )
,
.
.
,20
.
.
, :
.(2 )
,
.
(2013 2011)
.
:24.14 ,2014 , " 19
, , , (' ) .
20
. , . , . ,
.
21(3 )
.(2 )
.22
" 1,015
, .
( " ) 21
. ,2012.
22
.
, :3 (2012 ) "
6.10
1.53
0.12
.2 ,72 ' ,2012 " :
.
, :2 2013 ,
1994 : 1994 :
-38.6%33.6%
61.4%66.4%
. :
4.4
0.9
6.0
2.1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
2
: ,
2011 2013
1994 1994
: .
47
2015 2014 ,139
, .4 -
, -
.1994
30%-
.
( ) 4
. 23
1993
,70%-
.
:
.
1995-
" 1,000- �
.
.4
�
� 1994
,2013 2010
.13 23
.
,
.
,
.
,
�
� ( )
" "
.
2012 , " 3,000- )
.(2013
,
.
�
.24" "
.25
,
. ,
24
. 40 " 200 , 25
. "
1 :4
( )
- 2
-
39,5172,92712,444
412,5663,86516,430
515,5544,78420,339
618,4855,68524,170
. 2% 1
,(2011 ) " " : 2
." "
" " :
, : " , ,(2011 )
. " ,
-
48
.
,
" , .
,
.(2%)
,
"
.
, "
,
.1
, "
. ,
"
. "
-
.
.
, " "
.(Break-Even Inflation Rate) BEIR
,
.
(FOMC- ) 1
2014 , , , Fed- . Federal Reserve, Minutes of the Open) .(Market Committee, December 16-17, 2014 (ECB- ) , " . ECB-
.(ECB, Economic Bulletin, March 2015) 2%-
,
.26
.
,
,
) 26
,( . , )
.(
.2014
,(3% 1%) 2014
.-0.2% �
:
, ,
.
.
,
.
,
.
,
.
,
,
.
49
2015 2014 ,139
,(Zero-Coupon Inflation Swaps) ISwaps
( )
(Swap Rate- )
.2
,
,(five-year, five-year forward)
.
,
.
1
BEIR- , " ,
)
Barclays (2014), "Global Inflation- 2
Linked Products: A User's Guide"
- BEIR- .(
, ISwaps
)
.(70% � " ,50%
,2014
, " . "
, .
� .2%-
, �
BEIR- .(2%) ECB-
� 2%- ,2014
.
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
% "
BEIR
Iswap
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
%
BEIR
Iswap
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
%
BEIR
Iswap
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
%
BEIR
: � . " � . -BEIR -BEIR ,
" . " -.Fed
1 :BEIR ISwaps , , , 2007 2015
-
50
,
.
,
.
.3
:
"
.
"
ISwaps- .BEIR-
�
. , "
.
" ,
" , ,
.
.
: "
" .
� "
" .
.BEIR- , "
2000-
, (1%- )
,
, 3
Kerkhof (2005), "Inflation . Derivatives Explained: Markets, Products and Pricing",Lehman Brothers.
.4 ,2008-
"
"
- ISwaps-
.5BEIR
:ISwaps-
,
.
,
.ISwaps-
BEIR- 1
ISwaps- . ISwaps-
,BEIR-
.6 " ,1
.
Fleckentstein et 4
al. (2014), "The TIPS-Treasury Bond Puzzle", . Grishchenko and Huang (2012), "Inflation Risk Premium: Evidence from the TIPS Market",
.Federal Reserve Working Paper Haubrich et al. (2012), "Inflation 5
Expectations, Real Rates, and Risk Premia: Evidence.from Inflation Swaps",
6
. " .ISwaps-
ISwaps- BEIR- :1
BEIRISwaps
-
ISwaps- -
. (-) .
51
2015 2014 ,139
"
BEIR- "
,ISwaps-
.
,
, " BEIR- ISwaps-
,7
"
.(2 )
,2008 � 2
,Lehman Brothers
.2011
, .
, " ,
2014 .
,
.
BEIR- ISwaps- 7 , ,
.6 .
�
. "
2015
.
,
"
.
: " (bid-ask spread)
.
" , "
.(3 ) "
)
, " (bid-ask spread-
. BEIR-
,
,
. BEIR-
-0.4
-0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
2 : ISwap -BEIR spot) (" , , , 2005 2015
"
: . -BEIR -BEIR , " .-BEIR " -Fed.
-
52
,
.
,
.
.
,
,
.
, , ,
.
, "
, .(1 )
"
,
. 8
,ECB- ,
,2% 2015
) 1.6%- � ISwaps-
9(
,
,
.
, ,
.
2015 Fed- 8
Fed- ,2014 Board of) Governors of the Federal Reserve, Monetary Policy
.(Report, February 2015, pp. 12-13 9
) ECB- .(1
.
0.00
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
3 : )bid-ask spread ( : " , ,
2008 2015
"
"
: .
53
2015 2014 ,139
- .
,
, .
.
"
,
.
,
, .
.
