FARAH, et al. v ESQUIRE - Memorandum Opinion Dismissing Case

7/31/2019 FARAH, et al. v ESQUIRE - Memorandum Opinion Dismissing Case

1/20

DJ [MH XJD[HK W[L[HW KDW[UDG[ GAXU[

BAU [MH KDW[UDG[ AB GAIXOEDL

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ

$

FAWHPM BLULM) h{ li*) $

$Pildj{dbbw) $

$

r* $ Gdrdi Lg{daj Ja*


2/20

leax{ {mh {mho ljk {mh eaan) uhwxi{djc dj djfxut* Khbhjklj{w luh Mhluw{ Gaooxjdgl{dajw) Djg*

ljk Olun Sluuhj> {mht oarh {a kdwodww) lwwhu{djc {ml{ {mhdu Dj{hujh{ paw{djc slw l wl{dudgli7

wsdph l{ Pildj{dbbw) shii sd{mdj {mh eaxjkw ab {mh Bduw{ Lohjkohj{ ljk {mxw ja{ lg{dajleih* [mh

oa{daj sdii eh culj{hk*

D* BLG[W

Puhwdkhj{ Aelol slw eauj aj Lxcxw{ ;)


3/20

4 -[mh Smd{h Maxwh paw{ Lpu* 53) 50


4/20

Gaooljk Wsdb{ Eal{ Rh{huljw Wphln Ax{ Lcldjw{ Famj Nhuut* Dk*

Buao Fxjh {a Khghoehu 500=) SJK paw{hk oauh {mlj 20 Dj{hujh{ d{how aj {mh

dwwxh ab {mh Puhwdkhj{w edu{m ghu{dbdgl{h* Dj {mh phudak eh{shhj Fljxlut 5004 {muaxcm Fljxlut

50


5/20

Gauwd Eaan) djgixkdjc6

Aelol eidjnhk* Jas cloh ehcdjw* Lx{mau wxcchw{w kdwpx{hk puhwdkhjgt

saj{ wxurdrh pxeidgl{daj ab eaan) dk*) H}* 57 -SJK*gao paw{ Lpu* 53) 50


6/20

Gaooljk6 Wsdb{ Eal{ Rh{huljw Wphln ax{ Lcldjw{ Famj Nhuut ljk

Glpudgauj Ajh6 JLWL) FBN) ljk {mh Cuhl{ Oaaj Iljkdjc Garhu/Xp)

wldk {ml{ lb{hu oxgm whudaxw uhbihg{daj) mh gaxik ja{ ca bausluk sd{m {mh

puafhg{* D ehidhrh sd{m lii ot mhlu{ {ml{ Elulgn Aelol dw khw{uatdjc

{mdw gaxj{ut) ljk D sdii gaj{djxh {a w{ljk lcldjw{ mdw lkodjdw{ul{daj l{

hrhut {xuj) ex{ dj idcm{ ab uhghj{ hrhj{w) {mdw eaan mlw ehgaoh

puaeihol{dg) ljk gaj{ldjw sml{ D jas ehidhrh {a eh blg{xli djlggxulgdhw)

mh wldk {mdw oaujdjc* D gljja{ dj caak gajwgdhjgh pxeidwm d{ ljk h}phg{

ljtajh {a ehidhrh d{*

Smhj lwnhk db mh mlk ljt piljw {a pxeidwm l gauuhg{hk rhuwdaj ab {mh

eaan) mh wldk gutp{dgliit) [mhuh dw ja eaan* Blulm khgidjhk {a

gaoohj{ aj mdw kdwgxwwdajw ab {mh ol{{hu sd{m Gauwd*

L waxugh l{ SJK) sma uh|xhw{hk {ml{ mdw jloh eh sd{mmhik) wldk {ml{

Blulm slw udp/wmd{ smhj) aj Lpudi 53) Puhwdkhj{ Aelol {aan {mh

h}{ulaukdjlut w{hp ab phuwajliit uhihlwdjc mdw iajc/bauo edu{mghu{dbdgl{h) {mxw uhwairdjc {mh ol{{hu ab Aelolw ihcd{dolgt bau ljteakt

sd{m l euldj*

Mh gliihk xp Gauwd ljk uhliit {auh mdo l jhs ajh) wltw {mh waxugh* D

ohlj) shii ka ljt{mdjc {a mxu{ Aelol) ljk hulwh mdw ohoaut) ex{ sh

kaj{ slj{ {a iaan idnh bQQQdjc dkda{w) tax njas1 Iaan) l{ {mh hjk ab {mh

klt) exiiwmd{ dw exiiwmd{*

Gauwd) sma culkxl{hk buao Mlurluk ljk dw l puabhwwdajli faxujlidw{)

gaxik ja{ eh uhlgmhk bau gaoohj{*

Dk* -eaikblgh ljk d{lidgw dj audcdjli$* Ajh ljk ajh/mlib maxuw il{hu) Hw|xduh lkkhk lj xpkl{h {a

{mh Eiac Paw{6

XPKL[H)


7/20

puhwdkhj{ mlw l whjwh ab mxoau leax{ d{ lii* Waoh oauh whudaxw uhpau{djc

buao xw aj {mdw smaih edu{mhu pmhjaohjaj mhuh) mhuh) ljk mhuh*

Dk* -eaikblgh ljk d{lidgw dj audcdjli$*

Leax{ lj maxu il{hu smhj gaj{lg{hk leax{ {mh Eiac Paw{ et {mhKldit Gliihu) Olun

Sluuhj apdjhk {ml{ Ku* Gauwd dw lj h}hguleih pdhgh ab wmd{* Dk*) H}* 5= -klditgliihu*gao paw{

Olt


8/20

Dk* [shj{t/baxu maxuw il{hu) l{ 4658 p*o* aj Olt


9/20

888* Ex{ l gaxu{ jhhk ja{ lgghp{ lw {uxh ihcli gajgixwdajw wh{ bau{m dj l gaopildj{* Lwmguab{ r*

D|eli) 820 X*W* 225) 23= -5004$* Dj khgdkdjc l oa{daj xjkhu Uxih


10/20

Bxu{mhu) Pildj{dbbw gaooaj ils gildow oxw{ eh kdwodwwhk ehglxwh {mht luh eluuhk et {mh K*G*

Lj{d/WILPP Lg{) smdgm pua{hg{w wphhgm uhil{djc {a dwwxhw ab pxeidg dj{huhw{ wxgm lw |xlidbdgl{dajw

bau pxeidg abbdgh) ljk kxh {a bldixuh {a w{l{h l gildo* Wl{duh wxgm lw {mh Eiac Paw{ dw pua{hg{hk4

wphhgm xjkhu {mh Bduw{ Lohjkohj{*

L* K*G* Lj{d/WILPP Lg{

[mh K*G* Lj{d/WILPP -w{ul{hcdg ilswxd{w lcldjw{ pxeidg plu{dgdpl{daj$ Lg{) K*G*

Gakh


11/20

puardkhw {ml{ ^d_b l plu{t bdidjc l wphgdli oa{daj {a kdwodww xjkhu {mdw whg{daj olnhw l pudol

blgdh wmasdjc {ml{ {mh gildo l{ dwwxh ludwhw buao lj lg{ dj bxu{mhuljgh ab {mh udcm{ ab lkraglgt aj

dwwxhw ab pxeidg dj{huhw{) {mhj {mh oa{daj wmlii eh culj{hk xjihww {mh uhwpajkdjc plu{t

khoajw{ul{hw {ml{ {mh gildo dw idnhit {a wxgghhk aj {mh ohud{w* Dk* au

-dd$ Dj l pilgh aphj {a {mh pxeidg au l pxeidg bauxo dj gajjhg{daj sd{m lj dwwxh ab

pxeidg dj{huhw{*

Dk*


12/20

djgixkh pudrl{h dj{huhw{w) wxgm lw w{l{hohj{w kduhg{hk pudoludit {asluk pua{hg{djc {mh wphlnhuw

gaoohugdli dj{huhw{w ul{mhu {mlj {asluk gaoohj{djc aj au wmludjc djbauol{daj leax{ l ol{{hu ab

pxeidg wdcjdbdgljgh* Dk*


13/20

{muxw{ ab {mh Eiac Paw{) ljk {ml{ {mh Eiac Paw{ slw uhliit lj l{{lgn aj Pildj{dbbw {mhowhirhw ljk

{mh Gauwd Eaan*

Pildj{dbbw ljlitwdw arhuiaanw {mh gaj{hj{ ab {mh Gauwd Eaan ljk Pildj{dbbw

hjhuch{dg hbbau{w {a puaoa{h d{* [mh Gauwd Eaan lkrljghw Pildj{dbbw lucxohj{ {ml{ Puhwdkhj{

Aelol gljja{ wl{dwbt l gajw{d{x{dajli uh|xduhohj{ ljk {mxw dw djhidcdeih {a eh puhwdkhj{> {mdw

gajw{d{x{hw l w{l{hohj{ aj l ol{{hu ab pxeidg dj{huhw{* Gaoohj{lut aj {mh Gauwd Eaan d{w

lggxulgt) d{w {mhwdw) ljk d{w rlixh idnhsdwh gajw{d{x{hw l w{l{hohj{ aj l ol{{hu ab pxeidg

dj{huhw{* [mh Eiac Paw{ bagxwhk wphgdbdgliit aj {mh gaj{uarhuwt w{anhk et Pildj{dbbw gildow ljk

hjmljghk et pxeidgl{daj ab {mh Gauwd Eaan) {ml{ {mh Puhwdkhj{ olt eh bauhdcj/eauj ljk {mxw

eluuhk buao whurdjc lw puhwdkhj{*

Leax{ lj maxu lb{hu hw|xduh*gao dwwxhk {mh Eiac Paw{) Ou* Blulm {aik {mhKldit

Gliihu{ml{ {mh Eiac Paw{ slw l rhut paauit h}hgx{hk pluakt* Bdjkdntlj Khgi*) H}* 5=

-klditgliihu*gao paw{ Olt


14/20

lppluhj{it gaj{djxhw {a mlrh) waoh gaood{{hk puapajhj{w* Pildj{dbbw {mhowhirhw pilthk

ihlkhuwmdp uaihw dj {mh Edu{mhu Oarhohj{) gaj{udex{djc mxjkuhkw ab lu{dgihw |xhw{dajdjc {mh

ihcd{dolgt ab {mh Aelol Puhwdkhjgt ljk hj{mxwdlw{dgliit lkrhu{dwdjc {mh Gauwd Eaan*

[mh Eiac Paw{ d{whib eauh djkdgdl ab d{w wl{dudg jl{xuh* [mh plch slw {lcchk lw

mxoau* Bdjkdntlj Khgi*) H}* 53 -hw|xduh*gao Paid{dgw Eiac paw{ Olt


15/20

gaooxjdgl{djc rdhsw {a ohoehuw ab {mh pxeidg dj gajjhg{daj sd{m lj dwwxh ab pxeidg dj{huhw{*

Dk*


16/20

50


17/20

slw wl{duh aj l ol{{hu ab pxeidg gajghuj* Wxgm wphhgm dw pua{hg{hk et {mh Bduw{ Lohjkohj{ ljk

gljja{ eh {mh elwdw ab l khblol{daj gildo*

[mh wloh gajw{d{x{dajli idod{l{dajw lppit {a {mh gildow ab bliwh idcm{ djrlwdaj ab

pudrlgt lw {a l gildo bau khblol{daj* Shtudgm r* Jhs Uhpxeidg) Djg*) 578 B*7k 2


18/20

G* Iljmlo Lg{

Gaxj{ DR ab {mh Gaopildj{ liihchw l rdail{daj ab {mh Iljmlo Lg{) smdgm puardkhw

dj phu{djhj{ plu{6

-


19/20

ajit gaoohugdli wphhgm) lw gaoohugdli wphhgm dw hj{d{ihk {a uhkxghk pua{hg{daj xjkhu {mh Bduw{

Lohjkohj{* Whh Awoawh) Djg* r* Rdljgh) IIG) 2


20/20

Gaopildj{ sdii eh kdwodwwhk* L ohoaudlidvdjc Aukhu lggaopljdhw {mdw Ohoauljkxo Apdjdaj*

Kl{h6 Fxjh ;) 50

Documents

FARAH, et al. v ESQUIRE - Memorandum Opinion Dismissing Case